Wisconsin 24, Michigan 10 Comment Count

Ace


A somber scene as Brandon Peters was down on the field. [Patrick Barron]

Michigan led undefeated Wisconsin, 10-7, in the third quarter at Camp Randall Stadium. Then Murphy's Law struck.

First, Wisconsin quarterback Alex Hornibrook shook off a shaky start to thread two inch-perfect throws to A.J. Taylor. The first victimized freshman Jaylen Kelly-Powell, who was on the field replacing injured starting corner Lavert Hill. The second was a touchdown up the seam to give the Badgers a 14-10 lead. Adding to the frustration, the drive only stayed alive due to a third-down pass interference call on Tyree Kinnel despite Hornibrook's throw hardly looking catchable.

Then disaster really struck. Facing third down on Michigan's ensuing possession, Brandon Peters took a hard hit from Andrew Van Ginkel, who stunted up the middle unblocked. Peters, who'd shaken off some huge hits in his last couple games, stayed down. As the team gathered around him, Peters took a cart off the field. According to MLive's Mike Mulholland, he was wheelchaired to the locker room, then transported to the hospital via ambulance. In postgame, Jim Harbaugh confirmed Peters has a head injury; he's expected to rejoin the team for the plane ride home.

That took the wind out of Michigan's sails. Wisconsin struck quickly, with a one-handed catch by Danny Davis setting up a 32-yard end-around touchdown for Kendric Pryor at the end of the third quarter. John O'Korn took over for Peters, and the offense never threatened to score. UW's Rafael Gaglianone eventually tagged on a field goal to provide the final margin.


A.J. Taylor's touchdown catch stood as the winning score. [Bryan Fuller]

Before it all fell apart, Michigan hadn't just scraped out a lead, but missed some opportunities to really put the Badgers on their heels. Wisconsin struck first when Nick Nelson picked up a punt off the bounce and worked his way past some poor coverage for a 50-yard touchdown. Peters had a chance to tie it up on the next series, but underthrew an open Zach Gentry, allowing Natrell Jamerson to recover for a pass breakup.

On Michigan's next drive, an apparent touchdown from Peters to Donovan Peoples-Jones was ruled incomplete, and despite replay showing that DPJ's left foot touched inbounds a fraction of a second before his right landed out, the call stood. On the very next play, Peters fumbled while scrambling for the end zone, and Michigan came up completely empty.

The young quarterback bounced back, though. Peters finally connected on a deep ball to Peoples-Jones, getting Michigan out to midfield, then made consecutive sharp throws to Chris Evans and Sean McKeon to set up a one-yard Ben Mason touchdown plunge. That knotted the score at seven heading into halftime.

After Devin Bush picked off Hornibrook to give the offense great field position, Quinn Nordin snapped his cold streak with a 39-yard field goal to give Michigan a short-lived 10-7 lead. Instead of compounding his prior error, Hornibrook morphed into Aaron Rodgers, and everything went terribly wrong in a hurry.

All other concerns at the moment are secondary to the health of Peters. If he can't recover in time to take on Ohio State next week, the odds stack even higher against Michigan unless Wilton Speight can make a remarkable comeback from his fractured vertebrae. As it stands, optimism for The Game is going to be hard to come by.

Comments

Def go blue

November 19th, 2017 at 12:08 AM ^

Don’t care what anyone says. He has the resources, he’s paid the money, he needs to do better. Can handle losing but fight for gods sake. Where is that? Where is the improvement? Why do they regress in the second half? Again, stop with the damn war story podcasts with dear old dad and earn your money.

thevetdoc1

November 19th, 2017 at 3:48 AM ^

Jim is recruiting QBs like Beilein recruits centers. They have the right measurements, take 3 years to coach up, then are OK and considered a success. The eternal search for Kevin Pittsnogle must end, we must recruit athletes. How many Mark Donnals and Speights have there been?

Charles Martel

November 19th, 2017 at 9:10 AM ^

All this griping about coaching has been adequately proven to be misguided thinking by later posts in this thread, but here's my two cents: I don't know who I would want to even consider to replace Harbaugh and his staff as a whole.  Yes, Drevno should be on the hot seat, and perhaps less is more if you eliminate him from OC responsibilities and put him simply as OL coach.  Otherwise, this team is severely plagued by injuries and no senior leadership on the OL or QB.  I know this is so anti- 21st century college football, but this program and this staff need time to sort this out.  We'd be foolish to scrap it and repeat the past 10 years all over again.  Although, John Bacon would have more writing material......

Charles Martel

November 19th, 2017 at 9:10 AM ^

All this griping about coaching has been adequately proven to be misguided thinking by later posts in this thread, but here's my two cents: I don't know who I would want to even consider to replace Harbaugh and his staff as a whole.  Yes, Drevno should be on the hot seat, and perhaps less is more if you eliminate him from OC responsibilities and put him simply as OL coach.  Otherwise, this team is severely plagued by injuries and no senior leadership on the OL or QB.  I know this is so anti- 21st century college football, but this program and this staff need time to sort this out.  We'd be foolish to scrap it and repeat the past 10 years all over again.  Although, John Bacon would have more writing material......

rkjjeep

November 19th, 2017 at 9:14 AM ^

Lots of reasons and angles on the M loss........but I think most will agree that Wisonsin was exposed as a playoff pretender.  Does the big ten really want to send a team that will get shredded?  

Amaznbluedoc

November 19th, 2017 at 9:47 AM ^

This thread is lit up and it’s difficult to read much of the angst. On the one hand there is the camp that we’re a young team, developing, and predicted to go 8-4. The other side argues that teams like wisky, 3 years into a new system and with an offense which apart from a couple of seniors is equally young and yet they somehow are able to perform (I could throw GA in there as well). There are merits to both sides and the situation is infinitely more complex than expressing blind loyalty or firing Harbaugh. Neither of those approaches are valid and given the challenges with a diminishing number of quality kids playing ball, scholarship and other logistical issues, injuries, and the changing landscape one has to accept reality. It is fair to hold Harbaugh and his coaches accountable and if they are unable to be successful, Harbaugh needs to retool (I'd love to hear reporters ask these questions) Sure, I would love to win the B10 and maybe the NC, but when I look back where we were for the past 7 years (losing to garbage Rutgers, MD, etc) and watching the stands empty out in the 4th quarter as opposed to where we are today, I am cautiously optimistic. Whatever our record, I’m much happier being associated with this program than the filth down in Columbus or E. Lansing. Go Blue!

Bertello NC

November 19th, 2017 at 9:54 AM ^

I wouldn’t want any other coach coaching our team than Harbaugh. But I would agree with some here in the idea that offensively we need to make a few changes. Even with young players you can install and design more creative and dynamic plays. Were trying to pound our opponents into submission and while we’ve done that to some mediocre and bad teams, we do not have the OL and may never have the OL in this day in age of recruiting and parity to ever be able to line up and just pound people. Not enough explosiveness right now. Idk probably when we have a fully healthy roster we will be. Offensive staff needs to be realigned or tweaked and better plays and or play calling need to happen. On a positive note Peters made some nice throws including nice touch on the bomb to dpj and the fade in the EZ. Should have put more air under the throw to McDooom and threw it more to the back corner pylon and let Eddie run under it.

Glennsta

November 20th, 2017 at 1:30 PM ^

It goes back to OL play.  When your starting QB gets his neck broken on a play where a guy comes in unblocked, when you can't run the ball in a rainstorm.against Sparty, when you let a guy get a running shot at blasting Peters into a head injury you will lose games against decent teams.  And not many teams have good seasons having started 3 different QB's. 

Yes, a lot of guys are young but it's hard to establish an identity offensively when you have young WR's and RB's who don't have time to make plays because the OL is getting overpowered. Add in an understandably gun-shy JOK in the middle of it and you have a rough season.

I think the OL will improve next year but I'm still concerned that there is no apparent direction to the QB position.

BBQJeff

November 19th, 2017 at 10:23 AM ^

That is obvious.   The degree of ineptitude on offense is astounding.   The thing is though, this offense, as bad as it is, did show some signs of improvement this year.   The run blocking improved for sure as did the output from our backs.  The D has been strong all year with only a bad outing against a really good Penn State squad.  We lost a ton of starters to the NFL.  A drop-off from last year was pretty much a given.   

Fact is, Harbaugh isn't Urban Meyer.   A down year for OSU is 2 regular season losses.  Having said that, calling for him to be fired after an 8-4 season with this much youth, inexperience and decimated by injuries is insane.   Last year, MSU went 3-9 and had in attrrocious offseason.   Yet, here they are sitting at 8-3 with only Rutgers left and they return just about their entire team next year.   Let's hope that this year is a perfect storm of circumstances that produced a down year and that the translation for "down year" under Harbaugh is 8-4 with a team returning hardly any starters and is decimated by injuries.   Hopefully next year this team is a contender (I'm growing impatient with "next year" too).  A copule of years ago Nebraska fired their head coach after a 9-3 season because that wasn't good enough.   They've been garbage ever since.   Harbaugh is it.   We have no Plan-B and there aren't any better coaches available anyway.  

Jringo25GOBLUE

November 19th, 2017 at 11:00 AM ^

All season long the offense has had zero identity! Play calling is horrible.. Don’t see any urgency or intensity with this offense. They just look like they are going through the motions.. What’s that attributed to????

mhweintraub613

November 19th, 2017 at 11:51 AM ^

I’m finding it hard to watch Michigan football. It seems like a team in search of leaders and lacking in pride. I️ don’t see anything close to an “enthusiasm unknown to mankind”. About the closest thing I️ saw to passion and enthusiasm was from Nordin after making his first field goal in 4 attempts.

I️ can understand the team making mistakes due to youth. And I️ can deal with a bad call here and there. I️ suppose I️ can tolerate stupid play calling.

But what troubles me and makes it hard to watch this team is the lack of passion, energy and enthusiasm that I️ see from most of the teams we have played. Even the ones we beat.

#uninspired

tybert

November 19th, 2017 at 12:17 PM ^

Unlike the MSU game, which we SHOULD have won had we not lost the TO contest 5 to 0, I didn't go into this game thinking a loss would be a failure. 

As long as Peters can be healthy and ready for the bowl game, he showed me enough to feel good about next year. 

Whether it's Drevno, etc. next year, no excuses for getting beat so easily and so often by stunts. Our own D-line should be practice enough for our O-line. 

MGOBLUE67

November 19th, 2017 at 3:28 PM ^

I also can look back to the early 2000’s when we were truly competitive. I don’t miss my season tickets given up during the RR era. I really expected a difference in year 3 with “harbaugh’s players”. Remember “wait until his players are in place”? Understood it’s year 3 however I’m starting to wonder especially after the losses snatched from the jaws of victory last year and 0 offense progression especially the O line for 10 years +. We really need to lower expectations and HOPE we can find a QB and O line. We are dead meat next week anyway. 1-5 against rivals? Team not ready to play? Outcoached? Very very disappointed with the lack of any progress, and really tired of all the excuses. This is what M football has become I’m afraid.

Bertello NC

November 19th, 2017 at 5:29 PM ^

I’m trying to put the outlook of our program into perspective and have patience with Harbaugh. If you look at Clemson, (which most would consider them at this point an elite program). It took Dabo 5 years before he was vying for conference championships and NYD bowls and 7-8 years to get to 11/12 win seasons and playoff births. Now do I believe that JH has a little bit of tunnel vision in the sense that he’s under the Bo 3 yards philosophy? Yes I do. I think he and the offensive staff need to think outside the box a little more. Not saying we need to throw out manball philosophies entirely but we need a little more diversity within the scheme IMO. And maybe with more experience and a healthy roster that will develop. I guess what I’m saying is I think we need to be patient with what’s being built here. Were comparing Michigan football to these other programs that haven’t been in hibernation like we’ve been. Bad recruiting years, unexpected attrition, injuries, all have played a roll in this seasons growth or lack there of. And I don’t want to be that person who blames officials but we have definitely been on the wrong end more than not with a lot of calls the last three years.

surfdoc37

November 20th, 2017 at 12:35 AM ^

Took Dabo awhile, but Urban and Saban won national titles in their third seasons. We expected Harbaugh to deliver similarly. And we expected him to develop QBs, on the heels of poor Devin Gardner’s regression. If we recalibrate, consider 8-4 with a successful defense of the Little Brown Jug and a 25% winning percentage versus Sparty and OSU to be OK, that allows for the odd pleasant upset surprise. Expecting 100% success vs OSU, PSU, Sparty, ND and we’ll always be cranky fans, even with seven or eight million spent on coaching salaries. QB situation though, is very troubling. Morris was a 4 star recruit and Jimmy and staff couldn’t make anything out of him. Malzone was recruited by Hoke but technically a member of Harbaugh’s first class. Another four star recruit they have coached into a holder after they couldn’t get him to transfer. Zach Gentry, yet another four star QB they did not develop at that position and instead turned into another good TE out of a group of four or five really good TEs. Meanwhile, somehow, they don’t offer a kid from Saline whose dad coached at UM for what, 15 years, and whose brother played WR for UM, and who is a starting QB as a RS freshman for a Va Tech team ranked as highly as #12 this year. As far as inexperience up front, the Wisconsin line that just handled us has no seniors on the two deep.

mgobaran

November 20th, 2017 at 8:15 AM ^

Untimely and crucial intervening of the referees and an injury to our QB took away our chance at winning this game. I thought our team played hard enough to deserve a chance.