USA 2022: Midfield Comment Count

Brian

Previously: Attackers.

NUMBER TEN: HOPE YOU LIKE KIDS WAIT THAT CAME OUT WRONG

Defining different central midfield slots is slightly silly since most players suited for the center of the field are at least somewhat flexible, but in an effort to organize our thoughts we'll do it anyway. So: the USA hasn't had a Central Attacking Midfielder or Number Ten or Trequartista or Guy Who Tries To Be Messi of much note pretty much ever. (Clint Dempsey was always a striker.) There were some promising folks over the last two cycles but for whatever reason Benny Feilhaber and Sacha Kljestan existed on the fringes of the national team.

American 10s in MLS include those rapidly aging guys, a couple more even fringier members of the pool, and File Not Found. Inserting Pulisic here is an obvious option and may be the way it ends up, or the US could just roll out a couple box to box types like they did when Michael Bradley and Jermaine Jones were freed to run by the insertion of Kyle Beckerman behind them. I bet one dollar that's this cycle's solution, with a really fast right back who overlaps and frees Pulisic to tuck inside.

But a speculative name or five here anyway, all of whom are absurdly young. Maybe one of these guys will get good enough fast enough to be relevant. All ages are as of 2022, so... yeah.

Andrew Carleton (22), Atlanta United. Carleton has been a next big thing for a couple years now but he's stuck behind a boatload of expensive South Americans in Atlanta and only gets scattered matches for them. Intra-MLS loans aren't really a thing so Carleton's in a bit of a tough spot.

Richie Ledezma (21), RSL. Ledezma is trialing with Dutch powerhouse PSV and turns 18 in September so wouldn't have a full limbo year if he does go. Ledezma is getting semi-regular minutes in the USL already.

Josh Pynadath (20), Ajax. Pynadath had a couple of years with Real Madrid's academy and is now at Ajax—his mom's job got moved to Holland. He plays on both wings for Ajax but a dual-footed guy with the kind of ball skills Pynadath has is a natural candidate to move inside. He could realistically play anywhere across the attacking midfield level of a 4-2-3-1, but he's 16 so he could also be a potato you never hear about again.

Giovanni Reyna (19), NYCFC. Yes, that Reyna. He'll hook up with a European club as soon as his EU passport goes through and from there will hope to bust into a starting lineup. Realistic best case scenario is another Pulisic type rise where he plays a bunch for a big team and gets integrated the year before the WC.

Gianluca Busio (19), Sporting KC. Youngest MLS signing since Freddy Adu, and it's appropriate to mention Adu in a section in which the oldest guy is 18. Can get an Italian passport so could be another quick move across the Atlantic.

By 2021 everyone except Carleton should be pushing to break through at a high(ish) profile Euro club. There's no better example of the academy effect than the next gen of potential 10s; previously American 10s have been limited in numbers and opportunity since MLS tends to target foreign players at that spot. USL opportunities for teenagers have the potential to break out a number of skilled attackers both here and abroad.

This has been the most crootin' section of this post.

[After the JUMP: still fairly crootin sections.]

NUMBER EIGHT: LET'S TRY THIS AGAIN OKAY

Another reason that this cycle probably isn't going to have a pure 10 is that there could be a (relative) embarrassment of riches in the box-to-box category.

Weston McKennie (23), Schalke. 24 appearances at age 19 for the second-best team in the Bundesliga instantly shoots McKennie to the top of the depth chart at some spot or another. There's ongoing debate about whether he should be a pure holding midfield or become a bit more adventurous; that'll depend more on the people around him than McKennie himself, probably. Since the US produces bulldog defensive midfielders with some regularity and McKennie can do stuff like this...

...I assume he'll be the next gen box-to-box guy.

Darlington Nagbe (31), Atlanta United. The great divide in US soccer fandom, post-Landon, is about Nagbe. On the one side are people like me, who appreciate Nagbe's ability to break pressure and superb ability to maintain possession. On the other side... I can't even, man. I mean, if you want to complain that he has no idea what to do once he breaks pressure and gets to the final third, I hear that. But he's superlative at a really important skill and if deployed correctly he spends his time in the green bit of the the devastatingly accurate Nagbe Heat Map:

Atlanta has focused on the green bit. Nagbe has been unleashed as a full-time box-to-box midfielder in Atlanta and is one of just three US starters for the best team in MLS. Atlanta's point production has fallen off considerably after he was sidelined with an injury. He'll be pushing it age-wise by the time the next World Cup rolls around. He would need to have four guys ahead of him on the field—ie, there would have to be a #10 or two strikers—to be maximally effective, and that seems unlikely given the player pool. But until there's someone else in the pool with anything approximating his skills, he stays on the list.

Tyler Adams (23), NYRB. Adams is widely expected to move to RB Leipzig in the near future. Leipzig is also owned by Red Bull and just hired former NYRB coach Jesse Marsch as an assistant with an eye towards possibly making him the head coach in the near future. Adams thus has a clear path to extensive playing time with a Bundesliga club that finished second in the league two years ago and missed qualifying for the Champion's League by two points a year ago.

Adams could be either another wide-ranging midfielder or end up at right back, where he's played on and off for the last couple years. Both of those spots are fairly crowded but the added flexibility Adams provides will help him make rosters.

Keaton Parks (24), Benfica. Parks got a little time late in Portuguese power Benfica's season and before that was playing the second tier—Portugal has B teams playing just one league down—where he scored seven goals in 29 appearances. He was recently extended to 2022 and might could break through into one of Portugal's big three.

Parks has a weird skillset because he went from 5'6" to 6'4" over a brief period of time but probably slots in best as a midfielder who sits fairly deep when the opposition has the ball and breaks pressure with long diagonals and then runs into the box late, but he is reputedly Not Good on defense right now and needs to develop some bite. Nonetheless Benfica is talking to him about all three levels in central midfield but is focusing on him as a 6. I'm still slotting him in further up the field; see above about fine midfield gradations. Meanwhile ask again later about Parks, hopefully after a breakthrough year.

OTHERS: Cristian Roldan (27) had a cup of coffee with the national team and could re-emerge but is suddenly in tough with the teenage breakthrough horde likely to improve faster than him. Ditto Sebastian Lletget (29), who had a couple promising caps last year and then immediately got injured. Emerson Hyndman (26) can't get a game with Bournemouth and just got loaned to Wigan in the English second tier. Gedion Zelalem (25) missed nine months with an ACL tear and has a contract that expires next year, making this put-up-or-shut-up time at Arsenal. Luca de la Torre (24) has been on the first-team bench at Fulham for a year and got into five games last season but has a tougher road to the first team after Fulham got promoted. Loan time?

NUMBER SIX: A MERCIFUL LACK OF COMPLANING ABOUT MICHAEL BRADLEY

McKinnie is an option here. If it's not him things might be a bit prosaic relative to TEEN AT SCHALKE(!) and TEEN AT DORTMUND(!).

Chris Durkin (22), DC United. Durkin broke through to DCU's starting lineup in April and hasn't been able to make them not suck but even in his first start his ability on the ball stood out. Since his coach praises his physicality and says that one thing he has to work on is not getting super-aggressive to stomp out every play, that sounds like a defensive midfielder in the making.

Kellyn Acosta (26), FC Dallas. Acosta is aging out of Next Big Thing status and settling in as a high-end MLS player with a lot of versatility. Like a number of people in this post he's had injury setbacks lately, hernia surgery in his case, and is returning to full health. The hernia issue caused a series of groin strains that apparently took a rumored Euro move off the table; hopefully a fully healthy Acosta gets back to that level. Like Adams, Acosta has some experience at outside back—on the left in his case—and it's nice to have a couple of flexible guys on a tournament roster.

Wil Trapp (29), Columbus Crew. Trapp made the last version of this post but stayed on the fringe through the 2018 cycle as his ability to ping long-range passes didn't overcome his slight frame and relative lack of athleticism. Trapp fits best on a side that has a lot of possession and likes intricate passing; the US was not that. And probably won't be that. His best shot is if the US does hire Berhalter, his current coach in Columbus, and tries to implement a version of his current system.

Perry Kitchen (30), LA Galaxy. Kitchen is the most conventional defensive midfielder in the 2022 pool, a guy who goes and busts up plays and then lays it off so the attacking guys can go to work. A brief sojourn in Europe saw him named captain at Scottish club Hearts but now he's back in MLS, slotting in at a D-mid slot the Galaxy desperately needed to fill. He's not going to be the sexiest pick—he'd be this cycle's Beckerman, albeit with more speed—but sometimes you just need a Beckerman.

OTHERS: Marky Delgado (27) stood out as one of the poorer USA field players during the most recent U20WC but is apparently doing well in Toronto? Russell Canouse (26) is yet another DC United midfielder in the picture but if the best the US can do is a bunch of starters at a not-even-good MLS team, that seems bad. Also Durkin's time has come at the expense of an injured Canouse so it's unlikely they'll coexist. And yes, Michael Bradley (34) will be old and will cause many annoying internet arguments but his legendary fitness and professionalism might allow him to continue on as a relatively static and crafty #6.

Comments

jackfl33

July 18th, 2018 at 1:17 PM ^

I am on the opposite side of the Nagbe debate. It's not that he is a bad player, he just doesn't fit with how the US needs a midfielder to play.

My main complaint is that he is neither great in the final third nor does he tackle and recover balls. With the relative lack of midfield possession the US will enjoy, his biggest strengths are minimized and his weaknesses are magnified. Thus you get situations like in Trinidad where Nagbe spends the entire game lost in the wilderness while Bradley is sprinting his ass off.

mgobaran

July 18th, 2018 at 1:20 PM ^

A couple more midfielders on the rise:

#10 Nick Taitague (19 right now) is in Schalke's system. Might break in to the Bundesliga as soon as this season.

#10 Indiana Vassilev (17) is with Aston Villa. 

#8 Kyle Scott (20) is in Chelsea's system, and played in an FA cup game. He recently went on loan to Telstar.

ScooterTooter

July 18th, 2018 at 1:24 PM ^

Suggestion: Why not create an offshoot of MGoBlog for this type of stuff? Could link to it on a side bar. 

I say this as a soccer fan (probably more than the average MGoBlog reader): You are an interesting writer, even if its a subject I dislike or don't really care about (never thought I'd spend more than 3 minutes reading about Ann Arbor politics!) and I wouldn't mind reading more USMNT takes. But I wonder if it wouldn't be more organized to give the subject its own space as it doesn't really pertain to Michigan athletics. 

UMmasotta

July 18th, 2018 at 1:58 PM ^

I fully support this.

 

Not that my support means anything, but I agree that Brian's writing style is unique not only to Michigan sports, but most topics in general. As a fan of soccer, I would love to have a similar reference for the USMNT (or USWNT, for that matter).

 

The only issue is that the USMNT schedule would likely result in long periods where the hypothetical blog would have no new content, then lots of content in a short period. I'd be fine with that though.

amedema

July 18th, 2018 at 1:25 PM ^

A couple of small things: 

1) Marsch isn't getting a sniff of the RB Leipzig job anytime soon. Nagelsmann is taking over in 2019. He could potentially get a chance at the RB Salzburg job. Marco Rose hasn't been there very long, but managers don't seem to last long there. 

2) What the hell kind of weird Pokemon remix is that with Parks's video? 

3) Acosta started as a RB for FC Dallas.

stephenrjking

July 18th, 2018 at 1:27 PM ^

The surge of youth on this list suggests to me that the USA is going to have to qualify for Qatar with a set of players that might be significantly different from the best available players when the WC actually comes around. And that might leave them in a tactically poor situation, where players who can play efficiently in a better way are stuck in an older system adapted for the previous generation. 

Reyna, for example, could peter out. But his passing in that video was terrific, and he could easily develop into a solid deep-lying playmaker, making the passes that Bradley never could. But there's no way the team will be ready to adjust to that kind of style after qualification is over.

One advantage, though: The later World Cup time will allow MLS to complete a full season just before things kick off, which may help a young guy or two emerge over the course of a year and solidify their spot. In contrast, European league will be just kicking off. Kind of the opposite of the current (normal) arrangement.

mgobaran

July 18th, 2018 at 1:42 PM ^

Not a worry, imo. McKennie, Adams, and Parks have already played a handful of games for the US. McKennie and Adams have locked down first team slots imo. All we need to do is add a 6 to that list, and Will Trapp has played fine enough since Sarachan moved on from Bradley. If we want to play with a 10, it will be Pulisic unless one of the youngsters absolutely blows up, and they should be able to do that in the next 1.5 years. 

stephenrjking

July 18th, 2018 at 1:56 PM ^

Barring a revelatory run at CM for Pulisic, I'm sure he'll be acceptable, but that idea doesn't move the needle much for me. It is, to me, a plus when a guy can play at the position for which they are naturally gifted and trained, maximizing the talent they have. Kludging a guy in can fill a position, but it significantly reduces potential if the guy's skills are really honed for use elsewhere.

I have some relatively uneducated opinions about tactical usage that are so bereft of actual evidence that I'm just not even going to bring them up here. 

mgobaran

July 18th, 2018 at 2:22 PM ^

Dortmund Wingers are tasked with CAM-like responsibilities, or at least they were with under Klopp/Tuchel. Pulisic was a CAM his whole life until we was moved to the wings at Dortmund out of necessity. Last season was a mess, and we will see how Favre utilizes him (looks like traditional RM spot in a 4-4-2).

Pulisic is our best #10 and our best RM/LM/RW/LW until further notice. I'd like to keep him at RM because that means we developed a 10 worth moving him. But he more valuable to us centrally. He was a #10 for us during WCQ and was very successful. Playing him at his more natural CAM position for the USMNT while he plays professionally as a RM isn't miscasting him as badly as Klinsmann trying to force Bradley into a #10 or #6 role. 

 

Again, if we operate without a 10, we are still more than sufficient with our current #6/#8 crop. And that current group is good enough, young enough to play the entire 2022 WC cycle, and most of them should make it to 2026.

MichiganTeacher

July 18th, 2018 at 1:33 PM ^

If this group develops enough so that Pulisic can stay on the wing, that would be a very good sign. 

I have never seen Reyna play, but if he is anything like his dad, then a big non-sarcastic DO NOT WANT. His dad was the most overrated player in US history and basically gave away the Ghana game in 06.

Long cycle. But I think McKennie will be a major factor. A couple more emerging like him, and we could have a cycle that will help ease the pain of the Klinsmann dark ages.

stephenrjking

July 18th, 2018 at 1:48 PM ^

One bad play makes up for an entire career? I'm not a huge Claudio Reyna fan but he was pretty good in 2002. His club career was decent but unspectacular and he often played roles that didn't use his modest creative abilities. 

It's not like there were a ton of better players floating around for USA soccer in 98 and 02 to get attention. 

Yinka Double Dare

July 18th, 2018 at 4:02 PM ^

He was nearly 33 and sprained his knee on that play. He was outstanding at the 2002 World Cup. Really, the main problem he had was staying healthy, dude was constantly injured. Hell, even in the 2002 World Cup he missed the first match with an injury. 

Crash

July 18th, 2018 at 1:54 PM ^

I hope for the sake of 2026, they don't bother with older guys like Nagbe (sorry Brian) and Bradley.  I would be satisfied with this next 8 years of US soccer treating Qatar as an opportunity for more touches for a team that is trying to gel and be ready for something serious in 2026.  In my years of playing soccer, one thing that was always true was that good consistent coaching of mostly the same group of players made a HUGE difference on the field.

Soccer is like basketball and hockey from the standpoint that you don't really get time to communicate things while on offense.  You have to go by gut feel and knowing your teammates.  Also, on defense you need a concrete strategy for rotating and tackling tendencies.  This stuff takes a lot of repetition like any other activity.  We need to find the best talent we can now, and start finding lineups that gel and will be in their physical prime by 2026.  

stephenrjking

July 18th, 2018 at 1:59 PM ^

I guardedly agree, though I don't mind the idea of an old guy or two to provide some mentoring and to fill a key hole if there is one. The 2026 WC is more important, but the World Cup is never just a building exercise; it is an event that stands alone. 

But if the choice is Bradley or a guy who is very slightly less optimal than Bradley but will be around in four years, I want the guy that will be around in four years.

mgobaran

July 18th, 2018 at 2:40 PM ^

Nagbe/Bradley are exactly the type of veteran bench players that would be great for our young team, imo. If Bradley can regain his form, that is. If either can be a solidifying super-sub like Beckerman was in the 2014 cycle, that has real value.

It doesn't have to be those two though. Bradley has been brutal for Toronto. He doesn't deserve that slot unless he turns it around. Danny Williams would be an interesting name if he ever sorts his injuries out. Cristian Roldan will have a say moving forward. Alfredo Morales is entering his 3rd Bundesliga season in the past 4 years and deserves more of a look as an older guy.

I think it'd be wrong to draw a line in the sand and write off everyone over the age of 24. Those U23 players have a lot to learn still. Even when their talent outshines the olds.

L'Carpetron Do…

July 18th, 2018 at 10:18 PM ^

I'm not as versed in the fine, minute details as most of you guys but I like the way Nagbe plays.  He always seems to be making things happen.  In the few times I've seen him play I thought he was a good playmaker who could create for guys on the attack, which USA needs. And then you just need someone to finish.  

Bradley still strikes me as a weird, weird player. Years ago I got so psyched about him because of his hard-nosed style and the fact that he wasn't afraid to shoot. But, he can look so good one minute and then be stumbling around, turning the ball over with horrendous touches the next. Perplexing.

I agree with your point - I always think its a good idea to have some savvy vets around and to have a good mix of wise old guys and young talented stars. Nagbe and Bradley could be perfect for that. I kind of wish Donovan was brought along to the 14 WC just to provide some veteran leadership and like 15-20 mins/game but oh well...

nscharer57

July 19th, 2018 at 9:54 AM ^

Here is the easiest list I can think of to describe the numbers. It is similar to the baseball numbered positions for the scoring system.

skurnie

July 18th, 2018 at 2:21 PM ^

There is a lot to like about this young crop of Midfielder talent, especially with McKennie and Adams. I can see McKennie anchoring the US midfield for the next 10 years. 

I'll be interested to see Keaton Parks develop at Benfica as well. If he can break into the starting eleven, he'll have some great opportunities at Champions League matches as well. 

Whatever is happening at FC Dallas' Youth Academy needs to be captured by US Soccer and replicated. They are turning out loads of talent. 

BlueInGreenville

July 18th, 2018 at 6:22 PM ^

Love the comparison of Perry Kitchen to Beckerman.  I hope he reads this and grows some bad ass dreads for 2022.

Can't wait to see McKennie and Pulisic developing some chemistry together...

Artermis

July 18th, 2018 at 10:56 PM ^

We should keep the biggest failures from this past WC cycle from having anything to do with the next cycle.  Bradley is definitely in that group, along with Altidore, Guzan, etc.  The only leadership those guys can show the next generation is how to choke away a WC spot. 

Dough Boy

July 18th, 2018 at 11:51 PM ^

Hyndman has not been loaned out to Wigan (yet). That is a rumor at this point. He is still fighting for minutes in the preseason with Bournemouth. 

Sparty Doesn't Know

July 19th, 2018 at 6:39 PM ^

I have loved these articles.  It has been awhile since I followed the USMNT (apparently I haven't missed much), but these have given me a nice list of young guys to follow over seas.  Good stuff.

Any content coming for France 2019 for the women's side?

MiesterBoston

July 20th, 2018 at 9:42 AM ^

You know when a puppy's feet grow way faster than the rest of him and he just has these big ol' paws flopping around on the floor and it's all adorable and stuff?

That's what I see when I watch that Reyna video