Unverified Voracity Dorfs It A Bit Comment Count

Brian

32985513666_f10234a435_z

photo does not fit with theme of bullet [Patrick Barron]

Pretty grim. Mark Titus on the state of Big Ten basketball:

We’re only four years removed from the Big Ten’s incredible 2012–13 campaign, when six different teams cracked the top 10 of the AP poll and the regular-season title came down to the final shot on the final day of conference play. A Big Ten national title seemed imminent then, if not in the 2013 tournament then certainly in the immediate years to come. Now, coming off a tourney in which the league’s champion got blasted in the Sweet 16 and its best team lost to a no. 15 seed, the Big Ten could fare even worse in 2016–17; its only hope of remaining in title contention by the end of the tournament’s opening weekend could hinge on Purdue, a team that blew a 14-point lead with five minutes to play against Arkansas–Little Rock in the first round of the 2016 tournament.

It's not great, Bob. Simultaneous collapses by OSU, MSU, Indiana, and (to a slightly lesser extent) Michigan have sapped the top of the conference. A few years ago there were 6 or 7 teams as good as any of the top end contenders this year and one to three teams who were legitimately elite.

Injuries play a role, but Matta seems to have hit a wall; Izzo and Beilein are 62 and 64, respectively, and may be slowing down as they near the end of their careers. Crean may be gone after this year.

Donnal departure is already agreed to, apparently. It's not like it's a huge surprise but Mark Donnal taking a grad transfer next year has migrated past "open secret" and reached "fait accompli":

Donnal is not being offered a fifth year at Michigan.

"There have been a lot of ups and downs," he said. "I really think my career here shaped me as a better person. Now I'm moving on."

Michigan has three recruits coming in and Donnal is the third senior. Without attrition they'd be full next year, but attrition is always a possibility. [CORRECTION: Michigan still has an open slot.]

Today in Big Ten refs. How did Iowa-Indiana go last night?

God, shucks, there were a lot of those, huh? 57 (!!) total in this game, with four Indiana players fouling out — something that likely cost a thin Indiana team this contest, ultimately.

Both sides of this game have reps on my twitter feed and both sides were incredulous at what they were watching. An explanation is not forthcoming.

Seriously, MLive asked after the Minnesota debacle and got this response from the league:

MLive requested a comment or clarification regarding the technical. Via a Minnesota spokesman, the Big Ten stated that the technical was a judgment call and, thus, the night's head official, Rob Riley, would not be made available for comment.

"We question the judgment of your officials."
"The judgment of our officials is not in question, the end."

This is gaslighting, right? Did I do that correctly? I'm not good with words and stuff.

The last unicorn. Indiana RB coach Deland McCullough is off to USC. With that move, Indiana has now lost the entirety of Kevin Wilson's braintrust. Almost everybody moved up. Greg Frey ended up at Michigan, McCullough at USC, Wilson himself ended up as OSU's OC, etc., etc.

Indiana responded by bringing in Mike Debord. While that's going to be bad for anyone who liked #chaosteam—and as a fan of a Big Ten team that managed not to lose to them—it's going to be great for anyone who wants to see what happens when you put a sloth in a NASCAR race. Let's gooooooo (not very fast). 

The nation's foremost water-carrier. Tony Barnhart has always been a reliable mouthpiece for any rich guy involved in college athletics but this takes the cake. He writes an article about the spate of post-Signing Day coaching moves, which are cynically delayed until players are locked in to a LOI. He lists several examples, and then:

I did some calling around and the feedback I got essentially was this: “If this bothers you, then you’re being pretty naïve. Coaches leaving, or being asked to leave, right after signing day is just a fact of life in college football.”

Who did he talk to? Mack Brown and Rick Neuheisel. Both those guys—shock—think it's no big deal. This is like asking the head of Big Ten officials whether he sucks at his job. It's the full Greenstein right here.

Annual targeting revamp. Via Get the Picture, the NCAA is going to tweak targeting again:

As targeting ejections have doubled over three years, the NCAA Football Rules Committee is looking at changing the replay standards so a targeting ejection only occurs if the penalty is confirmed. Currently, if replay doesn’t have enough evidence to confirm targeting but can’t rule it’s not targeting, the call on the field stands and the player gets ejected.

There could be three different outcomes to targeting reviews:

  1. Confirmed: ejection, 15 yards.
  2. Stands: no ejection, 15 yards.
  3. Overturned: no penalty.

I'm not sure how many targeting penalties fall into that gray area in the middle, but we're about to find out. I guess a way to get calls like that Penn State targeting ejection less wrong is good?

Good ol' boys. It's still 1975 in Louisiana:

After FSU and Baylor and Tennessee you'd think these kinds of wink-wink nudge-nudge events would be frowned upon. There are clear costs that have resulted in far worse things than the occasional drunken escapade on a stolen moped.

Indiana parallels. In depth piece on Indiana basketball finding its footing in a world where it's no longer the 1970s at the Crimson Quarry:

The factors that made Indiana a great job 30 years ago simply don’t hold as much water today. We live in a world that is now smaller due to cheaper travel, social media, national AAU programs and circuits, prep schools. Indiana is far less cordoned off than it once was, and college basketball in the state and nationally is far deeper than it was in the peak of the Bob Knight era. Bloomington isn’t an NBA market like Los Angeles. Indianapolis is known for quality, not necessarily quantity, in producing top-level recruits that power programs to titles.

The comparisons between Indiana basketball and Michigan football over the past 40 or so years aren't dead on but there are some parallel tracks:

  • Bo and Bob Knight are both cantankerous program legends who cast a long shadow for anyone who follows.
  • Immediate successors are assistants promoted to the head job. Gary Moeller is the hand-picked successor; Mike Davis is an interim after Knight goes off the rails late who eventually gets the head job. Both have decent teams that aren't good enough to keep people from yelling for their heads and don't last.
  • Controversial outsiders Rich Rodriguez and Kelvin Sampson are brought in, have short, tumultuous reigns featuring NCAA trouble. (Sampson's are much worse, resulting in a five-year show cause penalty.) Both last just three years.
  • Dorfy-looking head coaches with somewhat questionable credentials are next. Major difference here is that Crean inherited a disaster zone and Hoke inherited Denard Robinson, so Hoke's tenure looks like a man careening downhill on moguls he doesn't know how to ski and Crean had an upward trajectory until recently. Still: dorfy.

It's rough when you've done things one way for a million years and then have to adapt.

Etc.: More croot profiles: J'Marick Woods, Kwity Paye, Luiji Vilain, Deron Irving-Bey, Ambry Thomas. Nevermind on Michael Johnson, who took a WR job at Oregon because he is terribly unqualified. What if Michigan never returned to the Big Ten?

Comments

bronxblue

February 22nd, 2017 at 1:04 PM ^

I despise grown men paid millions of dollars basically lying to college kids they are CATEGORICALLY against paying money for their services on the football field being self righteous with the "life is hard kids, and don't be naive" about recruiting bait-and-switches. These same guys freak out about the idea of Harbaugh recruiting harder than them with camps because of their family time, yet see nothing hypocritical of seducing young athletes to their schools with false claims of family and trust and then booting a guy or leaving the minute a kid can't look around anymore.

Gulogulo37

February 22nd, 2017 at 5:11 PM ^

Of course he didn't hand him actual keys. I'm sure Brian knows that. Just that there's a lot of heinous stuff players sometimes get away with. The idea that players would get off easy on legal issues isn't some crazy idea at all. It's often real and with horrifying consequences.

CalifExile

February 22nd, 2017 at 1:23 PM ^

The worst targeting call I remember is Bolden getting called for it after a MSU OL pushed/threw him on top of a downed player. I don't blame the refs for calling it when they saw a guy fly on top of a defenseless player but the replay guys should be taken out back.

gbdub

February 22nd, 2017 at 6:03 PM ^

Didn't McDowell get ejected for lowering his head and late hitting the QB with the top of his helmet? Leading with the crown of the helmet is an ejection regardless of where you hit the guy. Or was McDowell ejected more than once?

AlwaysBlue

February 22nd, 2017 at 1:25 PM ^

We just with a presidential election where 3 of the 4 final primary contenders were near 70 or older. I don't think Beilein and Izzo have slowed down but I do think Izzo's brand of ball may be past it's expiration date.

matty blue

February 22nd, 2017 at 1:40 PM ^

i would also add that not only was mike davis not handpicked, he was only made the interim after a player revolt requesting that he get the job...when the players are asking that you be hired, that's a pretty good sign that discipline is not exactly high on your list of priorities.  knight never would have picked him, and if i recall correctly he was pretty dismissive of davis on several occasions.  i'm guessing bobby would have chosen pat knight to take over, proving for the 10,000th time that letting someone pick his successor is a bad idea.

davis was also pretty clearly overmatched (despite making the national title game in his second season) and got canned for being resoundingly mediocre, while moeller was relatively successful (if disappointing) as bo's successor.  i dont' recall too many calls for his head pre-excalibur.

Everyone Murders

February 22nd, 2017 at 1:32 PM ^

Brian notes

Gary Moeller is the hand-picked successor; Mike Davis is an interim after Knight goes off the rails late who eventually gets the head job. Both have decent teams that aren't good enough to keep people from yelling for their heads and don't last.

My memory is different.  I think Moeller was doing pretty well at Michigan when he was fired.  He had won three B1G championships, and won the B1G Coach of the Year twice.  He won four out of five bowl games, including the Rose Bowl.  He ended with a 44-13-3 overall record (and a 30-8-2 B1G record).  His worst years were 8-4, which were not great and came at the end of his tenure.   But still, I don't recall people calling for his head one bit.

What did Moeller in was the famous May 1995 incident at Excalibur in Southfield.  Moeller got drunk, created a scene in the restaurant, and got tossed in jail.  While in jail, he had a tearful rant that got released to the media.  When the audio hit the airwaves, Moeller was pretty much cooked.

The source of the domestic strife, reputedly, had to do with marital issues that were Les a matter of inches than Miles.

Oh, and why was the audio released to the press?  If memory serves, you'd have to ask the MSU grad/fan p.o. who thought it would be a good idea to release it to media outlets.  Is there a legitimate policing reason to do that?  Not that I can think of.

Link - http://articles.latimes.com/1995-05-05/sports/sp-62736_1_michigan-football-coach

 

 

Everyone Murders

February 22nd, 2017 at 2:01 PM ^

Thanks - I meant to append the following to my original:

Moeller was not reputed to be much of a drinker, so it was out of character that he'd be drunk in public and making a scene with his wife.  Underlying this, reputedly, were some marital problems.  (I also recall that he was suffering a bit of general pressure due to the consecutive 8-4 seasons, but nothing that approximates the hot seat some are recalling.)  The heavy drinking in public was, from what I've seen, a one-time incident. 

I'm not inclined to name the reputed marital interloper.  The marital strife did not result in a drunk driving incident - regardless of the cause of the dispute, Moeller did not drive an inch, much Les any number of Miles.

Joe Roberson was also pretty protective of Michigan's reputation, and in a pre-internet era the audio garnered a lot of unsympathetic attention.  It's a shame, because he was a great coach (IMO), and by most accounts a decent person.  I was happy at the time that we finally were winning bowl games and usually in the hunt for the B1G championship.

Each time I think about this, I'm always a bit surprised that Moeller was there for five full seasons.  In my memory, my sense is that it was a three year tenure! 

Richard75

February 22nd, 2017 at 2:54 PM ^

The main reason Mich was winning bowls at that time was the opposition. Three of those wins were over Ole Miss, NC State and CSU, teams that had no business being on the same field. Michigan's talent level in Moeller's tenure was second to none—high-round NFL draftees at QB, Wheatley in the backfield, Ty Law, Morrison, Buster Stanley, Tree Jenkins, on and on and on. They never should've been in games like the Holiday Bowl.

InterM

February 22nd, 2017 at 1:38 PM ^

Agreed that the Excalibur incident did Moeller in, but two consecutive 8-4 seasons (each with three Big Ten losses) left him vulnerable to firing for bad behavior.  He was definitely on the hot seat before his episode of public intoxication --  not a good idea to give ammunition to those who were looking for an excuse to show him the door.

Rufus X

February 22nd, 2017 at 3:15 PM ^

... and as I recall it was recorded in the back of the police car.  It was several days after the actual arrest, and things were actually dying down a bit. I was a student at the time, and suddenly it was back in the news, and was playing almost unceasingly on WJR radio - then on Channel 7 evening news.

To paraphrase, it was something like "Don't you know who I am?  You guys are just arresting me because I'm the coach of the football team".  That, as they say, was that.  It would have been really tough for him to stand up in front of a football team and tell them not to expect special treatement by local law enforcement after that.

A couple of 4 loss seasons didn't help, of course, but he had a long leash at that time.  A heisman trophy winner, a very progressive update of Bo's offense to a no-huddle, and some impressive recruiting classes.  He may have survived it if for those two middling seasons, but after the audio tape it would have been tough even then.

FWIW I was around Mo a LOT in those days as a student manager. Although all the coaches would have a beer or two in the hotel bar on road trips (always staying sober), Mo never EVER had a drink in public.

EDIT:  I just read the LA times article. It says Moeller was going to continue to recieve his salary of...    $130,000.  My how times have changed.

CalifExile

February 22nd, 2017 at 1:31 PM ^

I think they're wrong about Moeller. He was 44-13-3 over 5 years. It wasn't his record that forced him out. From Bentley:

"Taking over for the legendary Bo Schembechler in 1990, Moeller guided the Wolverines to four bowl victories in his five years, including a 1993 Rose Bowl triumph over Pac-10 champion Washington. Moeller's list of accolades include directing teams to three Big Ten championships, two outright Big Ten titles, five bowl appearances ('91 Gator, '92 and '93 Rose, '94 Hall of Fame, and '94 Holiday), and five straight finishes in the nation's top 20.

"Moeller's Wolverines set a Big Ten record by winning 19 consecutive conference games between 1990-1992. By winning the Big Ten title in his first season as head coach, he joined, Bennie Oosterbaan and Fielding Yost as the only coaches to accomplish this feat in school history."

 

Ty Butterfield

February 22nd, 2017 at 1:56 PM ^

Maybe Donnal wants to leave. Still, if Wagner ends up leaving and Michigan has two open scholarships just sitting there it doesn't make sense. It is Beilein's job to have a handle on player attrition. I understand coaches may sometimes get blindsided, but I think Beilein will have some explaining to do if Wagner and Donnal both leave and he doesn't bring anyone else in.

ijohnb

February 22nd, 2017 at 3:25 PM ^

seems to have gone from something that somebody mentioned in passing as a remote unverified possibility to something that is definitely, for sure, going to happen in the course of a couple of hours.

 

Sac Fly

February 22nd, 2017 at 2:00 PM ^

Creen brought about his own demise by being a shithead. It's all a direct result of his oversigning and I couldn't be happier to see him lose games because of it.

InterM

February 22nd, 2017 at 2:11 PM ^

He interviewed a B1G bureaucrat -- can't remember if named or unnamed, head of officials, etc., and don't care enough to google it -- who assured him that the calls in the game were 100 percent correct, nothing to see here.