Spring Football Bits Has Been Herbertized Comment Count

Seth April 6th, 2018 at 1:25 PM


true center. [Patrick Barron]

Congratulations everybody on breathing through two Final Fours. Meanwhile the football guys are doing football-like things while we wait for scraps to fashion into hope dolls for next season.

We should, then, step back for a moment here and try to enforce some kind of context. Spring football is an oasis of football practice with not the full team, months before the season, and mostly filtered down from coaches to media. Whatever the depth chart is by the end of it won’t be the depth chart in fall. Our feeble efforts to discern things about the team next September are hampered by a general lack of information and the coaches’ preference to keep everybody motivated. Like Harbaugh talked for several minutes on his Attack Each Day podcast this week on the offensive line and managed to name every single guy on it.

Anyway most of this is going to be about quarterback and the offensive line because that’s what we worry about the most and what we got the most about.


What we want to hear: No matter what, things won’t be as bad as last year.

What we’re hearing: Quarterback play should be improved if only because the floor right now is Brandon Peters plus an offseason of maturity. From several reports, regression is not a thing to worry about but challengers are. Depending on your source, McCaffrey is either neck and neck with Peters or slightly ahead. Having watched the Amazon special I think we can interpret that as competition will go into fall and neither young candidate should be counted out. It would be highly stupid to make a prediction right now.

Also Shea has really good ball placement.

What it means: Shea does appear to be the leader even though somebody seems to have shut off the hype valve. We’re going to have to wait until the NCAA committee on whatever reviews the case because Ole Miss is fighting it. My understanding of the Traitorous Losers (nice mascot)’s case is they told all these players there wouldn’t be significant sanctions because they honestly believed they had done nothing wrong because they had done nothing wrong. That defense would be facially ridiculous except hi, this the NCAA, have we met? An encouraging sign is that the NCAA has asked for more information:

Attorney Thomas Mars, who represents Patterson and several other erstwhile Ole Miss players, said the NCAA's request for more information is not uncommon and that he expects Patterson and Michigan will be able to respond in the next few days. Mars said there's no specific timetable for when they expect a final answer, but it's clear "the NCAA isn't dragging their feet on the waiver request and won't take any more time than is necessary."

"I'm encouraged by this particular request," Mars said. "From my perspective, the questions Shea's case manager asked are the right ones to be asking."

My completely unscientific guess is 69.314159% Patterson is cleared this year, and 51.3341% Michigan is fine at quarterback regardless.

[After THE JUMP: a lot to unpack about the offensive line, and who the coaches think is their best player on defense will surprise you and not surprise you]

Offensive Line


[Bryan Fuller]

What we want to hear: The inside has taken a leap, and a man has emerged on the outside.

What we’re hearing: Cesar Ruiz is happening. Baumgardner, with apologies to Kugler:

The Daily:

“He understands football very well,” Warriner said. “But he is very powerful, plays with a good base, loves football, quick feet for a center, too. He kinda has the whole package.”

Ruiz has it.

“I have two starting centers in the National Football League, both started as rookies,” Warriner said, referring to Minnesota Vikings center Pat Elflein and Green Bay Packers center Corey Linsley.  “He has that kind of ability some day to get to that point. Not yet, I mean he’s just a young kid. But if he keeps going, I know what they look like. … He can be the quarterback of the O-Line.”

Added Runyan Jr.: “He’s one of the most athletic centers I’ve ever seen. He’s big, strong, powerful. I’m looking forward to what he can do, even though he’s only a sophomore, so that’s really really exciting to see his development.”

Warinner is having them do more live practice against the defense as opposed to working on technique against equipment—given Michigan’s defensive line and the things they can do to screw with protections I think that’s a good idea. Bredeson and Runyan told 247’s Isaiah Hole that they’ve got a better attitude this year:

Now, with a focus on revamping the line, those players are developing something of a "swagger," left guard Ben Bredeson said on Tuesday, adding: "Everybody's got a little bit of an attitude. I think we've been playing – definitely a lot better than I've seen in the past. So we're making a lot of improvements as an offense in general."

Michigan fourth-year offensive tackle Jon Runyan Jr. agrees

“Coach Warinner – he brings in a new, refreshing energy,” Runyan said. “We like working with him. He's tweaking a little bit of our techniques. Pass pro has been going really well. Everything's meshing with him and looking forward to what these next seven spring ball practices will be with him and how much further we improve.

Repeating a general offensive theme, they’re also simplifying their pass protections.

"We've simplified the offense a little bit more. There's not as much thinking when you're (at the line), you make a call and you go," Runyan added. "We've tweaked techniques and stuff's a bit more comfortable.

As I mentioned Harbaugh went into detail on the OL in his podcast. Stuff from that: Cesar Ruiz has separated himself, he and Ben Bredeson are the two best offensive linemen. Runyan and JBB having good springs. Hudson and Filiaga both growing rapidly, and poised to separate themselves. Onwenu another guy who’s poised to do that. Stueber, Honigford, Vastardis, Robinson, Other Speight all in a position to compete. Jack Harbs: “They look different” and the staff is seeing the results of Ben Herbert’s weight work, mentioning Spanellis as a good example. If you’re checking off at home, yes, that’s the entire offensive line group except Ulizio.

The insider chatter is all very positive, so much so that I wonder if they’re being asked to blow smoke at us. One thing got repeated enough that I think there’s something to it is Juwann Bushell-Beatty has made it, and will likely have one of the tackle jobs.

What it means: The Ruiz stuff is both in line with what we saw last year (displacing Onwenu at guard) and his recruiting profile (he got to play center at a high level, which is rare for a HS lineman) so I believe it.

So…Warinner uber alles? I’m not sure—everything is so on the nose that I’m cynical about it. Picking through all of this here’s my best guess at the actual shape of the line (and again, this is just me spitballing and should not be exchanged for any good or service or currency):

  • LT: They want to pick a left tackle first and then find a right side, and they don’t want it to be JBB, who’s the current leader. Runyan might be the next best player but he’s not a left tackle, so they’re hoping that Hudson or Filiaga make a jump, and neither yet has. Since Hudson is way more raw I think he’s our better hope.
  • LG: Bredeson is upper classman skrong now, not sure on his pass pro but I bet he benefits from simplified protections.
  • C: Happening.
  • RG: Onwenu is battling for the job. I bet he gets there but they’re not going to give it to him, especially if Runyan isn’t needed at a tackle spot. Competition is stronger inside than out, and Onwenu has the most tentative hold on his job.
    • RT: Wide open, but I think the coaches prefer to have JBB here where his mauling run blocking can mitigate strongside DEs and his pass pro doesn’t have to be perfect. Runyan, Hudson and Filiaga are the likely options.

Runyan’s athleticism is reportedly excellent so with him it might be a matter of matching the other guys’ strength. I choose to read the fact that they made him available as evidence he’s likely to be among the best five when things sort themselves out.

Wide Receivers


Freshmen receivers always look awkward. [Fuller]

What we want to hear: Big jump in understanding routes, cutting down on freshman mistakes, sophomores emerging.

What we’re hearing: According to Harbaugh, DPJ is their best receiver, Oliver Martin has made a big move up the depth chart, Tarik Black is back ($). Occasionally we get another reminder that Nico Collins is going to be really good, which I take to mean he made another Santana guitar solo catch, but it might also mean he’s a year away from fully formed threat.

Names we haven’t heard recently are those of the upperclassmen: Kekoa Crawford, Eddie McDoom, Grant Perry, Nate Schoenle.

Also via Josh Metellus via Rivals ($) there’s a new name we haven’t heard before:

“It’s a great competition between those guys,” he exclaimed. “They’re a lot more aggressive, and are more disciplined when it comes to catching the ball. They’re more mature now. One of them — [redshirt freshman] Jake McCurry — has really shown a lot of improvement from last season. He’s the one standing out to me right now.”


What it means: The 2017 haul is an all-timer, and if they are on track that means we’re due for the sophomore leap to start becoming apparent right about now. I think it’s happening. The DPJ > Black bit is probably because Black is coming back from injury somewhat, but also highly encouraging about DPJ.

My general receiver take is talent is evident and accessible early, but getting all the subtleties of routes down takes years. The great receivers are talented bomb threats as freshmen, progressively stop screwing up over their sophomore years, and become unstoppable as juniors. So last year was a bummer for Crawford et al., but expected for the guys a year behind them.

Tight End

What we want to hear: Did you say Gentry looks like an NFL guy? Something nice about the blocking. Wheatley’s surgery went well?

What we’re hearing: Yep. Harbaugh said Gentry is looking much stronger after winter weights. He hasn’t said they’re going to run more offense through the TE seam, or that they’re doing more option routes for him like they did for Butt, though. Also brought up McKeon, whom they love. But nobody said anything about blocking.

Oh, and Moore so far looks like a home run hire.

What it means: Michigan will at least have a pair and perhaps three (insiders still keep saying don’t forget to mention Eubanks) really good receiving options, and given Harbaugh and the rest of the depth chart I could see the offense using on a lot of two- and three-TE sets this year to take advantage of that. I really wish Wheats wasn’t hurt though because one of the things that made those sets so effective at Stanford and San Fran under Harbaugh was OT-sized behemoths who could give you a six-OL look while still flooding the field with viable receivers.


What we want to hear: “Ben Mason” and violent words. Any name besides Ben Mason.

What we’re hearing: More Ben Mason with the blood code on.

What it means: I should probably start keeping a list of Murderface Metaphors. So far:

  • Hammer. “Giving him an opportunity to smash more people is always a good idea.” –JayHarbs
  • Hammerhead. “He’s just going to go get it. He’s our go get it guy. He’s that hammerhead that every team has. He’s just going to run into a wall if you tell him to.” –Devin Bush Jr.
  • An Intense Guy. –Chris Evans, coach of football
  • Meathead. “He likes benching and eating raw meat,” Kugler said, drawing laughs. “He’s the biggest meathead on our team.
  • Ol’ Murderface. –MGoBlog
  • Object in Motion and Pleased by That. “He is the type of person that goes from point A to point B with every ounce of energy he has and enjoys the physical aspect of arriving.” –Don Brown
  • Wrecking Ball. “That’s Ben Mason — he’s a wrecking ball,” Higdon said, smiling. “I knew what I was getting into when I was running behind him. He’s going to knock out the first guy he sees and I’m going to trust it and run behind him.”

Also they really should find another fullback, though I bet that doesn’t happen until VanSumeren arrives.

Running Back

What we want to hear: Kareem Walker I guess?

What we’re hearing: Everything but. From insiders, Higdon is either just ahead or well ahead of Evans for RB#1, but Evans is building on his excellent Ohio State game and will of course be a big part of the offense. Behind them Harbaugh brought up a surprise name: Tru Wilson, along with O’Maury Samuels. Nothing about Walker, but given how obsessed the reporting pool always seems to be about Walker I don’t know what to make of that.

What it means: Tru has seen the field in spring and late games before and he doesn’t look half bad, so I’m not going to read much into this except they want to keep these guys motivated now that the depth chart is becoming apparent.

The Defense


Khaleke doing crazy stuff, Kwity comin on. [Patrick Barron]

This part can be short because it’s mostly returning starters and the arrows are all either up or injured.

What we want to hear: All good things.

What we’re hearing: All good things, including this is Don Brown’s fastest group ever($). Mone is a leader, Dwumfour hype continues unabashed, Harbaugh brought up Josh Uche as more than just a pass rusher so yeah let’s just have a Stauskas reference added to my Poole-ish Uche crush, Jim!

Harbaugh also said that their arguably best defensive player is…Devin Bush Jr

Fast fast fast fast! Ready to separate himself…already separated himself but ready to separate into greatness.

They’ve been hype on him for years. More from Harbaugh: Josh Ross inserting himself as a MLB and WLB, Aubrey is “such a talented player” and “is putting it together,” Khaleke Hudson has been an absolute stud, David Long having the best spring of the corners. Defense has great leadership in Rashan Gary and Tyree Kinnel.

The Greg Mattison presser confirmed a lot of things we’d already been hearing. Dwumfour has a Hurstian first step. They love Kemp, Lawrence Marshall has turned his career around and is on a Godin track now, and Kwity Paye came back super strong and ready to give Chase Winovich a breather; the new thing is he can sub for Gary too.

What it means: The defense is going to be good you guys. Ross is probably up with Gil in the WLB sweepstakes, and they’re still trying to access peak Solomon, which he’s not there yet but it’s there.



April 6th, 2018 at 1:30 PM ^

When you say,

Shea does appear to be the leader even though somebody seems to have shut off the hype valve.

do you mean the hype valve was shut off by on-field performance or the eligibility uncertainty?

Wallaby Court

April 6th, 2018 at 1:41 PM ^

I understood that passage to mean that breathless Shea Patterson reporting has diminished. Neither Patterson's ability nor eligibility have changed. Reporting has shifted away from Patterson and the other quarterbacks to other position groups. Thus, the hype faucet only delivers a trickle.

Wallaby Court

April 6th, 2018 at 2:44 PM ^

Think about it. Reporters are out in the middle of nowhere with some quarterback they barely know. They look around them, what do they see? Nothing but other position groups. “Oh, there’s plenty else for me to report, what am I gonna do, hype Patterson?”


April 6th, 2018 at 1:43 PM ^

Like I got a ton of unsolicited "Wow that guy" stuff last week and none this week. No way to know if that's the program telling people to stop hyping a guy who might not be eligible, or he didn't rip off any more 75-yard runs, or anything. 


April 6th, 2018 at 2:06 PM ^

I am thinking it means that Harbaugh et al wants the competeition to remain high, and is trying to make sure that the QB compeition stays intense. Endless hype about one guy may not actually impact the players much, but he probably wants the players to believe that the depth chart changes day-to-day (with this being the offseason, afterall)  based on performance.


April 6th, 2018 at 1:55 PM ^

seeing if the QB can stay upright and not have to flee for his life while delivering a ball >15 yards down the field.  Something that looks like a competent passing game, please.


April 6th, 2018 at 2:01 PM ^

If the interior OL, WR, and TE take a step forward, I am actually not as worried as I probably should be about the QB. If we have Shea and we can get even average tackle play, then the ceiling on our season gets that much higher.

Mr Miggle

April 6th, 2018 at 2:05 PM ^

Ole Miss is appealing their NCAA penalties. That's why they are denying the charges Patterson and the other transfers made. They aren't asking for leniency where coming clean might help their case.

I'd guess their appeal is a real long shot and the NCAA isn't about to give them the benefit of doubt in a factual dispute. Giving Michigan another opportunity to submit evidence supports that.

Also "nose...picking"?


April 6th, 2018 at 2:17 PM ^



Any update on Luiji’s [Vilain] status?

“Well, they say he’s getting better all the time, and Luiji does not miss one treatment, does not miss one workout, his grades are doing really well. I’m really excited about when he comes back. This is going to be interesting once he finally is cleared.”

What is he able to get out of spring practice without being able to go full?

“Yeah, he’s doing a lot of lifting, a lot of upper-body lifting and things like that. He hasn’t been able to do much with the running yet. It’s not quite cleared yet, but he will be pretty soon, I think.”

CRISPed in the DIAG

April 6th, 2018 at 2:12 PM ^

RE: Peters - what would represent regression? I'm not sure what to make of the bowl game. And before that we saw progress until he got vaporized at Camp Randall. Shit, I'd take a game manager this season and ride that to 10-2 in a heartbeat.

Watching From Afar

April 6th, 2018 at 3:00 PM ^

I've thought about the bowl game a ton and come to the following opinion:

Harbaugh never asked Peters to go win games. He was there to eliminate the JOK mistakes, ride the running game and defense, and take a shot or two here and there.

Against Wisconsin he did everything right up until the fumble (which never should have happened because DPJ WAS IN BOUNDS DAMNIT). That game, running wasn't working but Peters was keeping Michigan above water even while getting crushed. That concussion, I think, shook him up going into the SCAR game behind that OL who had 2 back ups in (Spanellis and Runyan played a lot).

Against SCAR, everything was going to plan until the Higdon fumble that kept SCAR in it. Then the McKeon fumble completely obliterated the idea of Peters doing what he normally did, just ride the defense to a W. Overall he was doing ok up until that point. The first drive out of half time was great and he was making good throws.

Speed up to the bad INT thrown in the endzone, freshman mistake. The second INT was all play calling. It was 3rd an 1 around the 40 IIRC and instead of run for the first down and then no huddle, Michigan tried to pass and Peters took a 9 yard sack. 4th and 10, the CBs sat on out routes because there was little time and they knew the ball was going to the sideline. Peters had 1 throw, no other options, and the CB undercut the out.

So all in all, when he was put in situations that were ok to good, he did well. When he got screwed by bad line play, bad play calling, and incorrect reffing, he did what a RS freshman does.


April 6th, 2018 at 6:02 PM ^

Seriously, I highly recommend a rewatch. South Carolina wasn't disguising coverages. It was pretty clear what was going on. He held onto the ball forever on quick routes. He took a month to get the ball out on screens. Easy man reads in the passing game and he didn't throw the football. There was nothing positive from that position in the football game. Nothing.

Peters took the sack at the end of the game and waited too long to throw the ball on 4th and 10. Tough throw. Yes. But gave his team zero chance throwing it late. For the millionth time in that game.

At some point during the 2018 season, no matter how good the defense, the QB position is going to have make some plays. Nothing from that bowl game would tell me Peters would be that guy.



April 7th, 2018 at 8:37 AM ^

"Competitive" in this case means "defense collapsed in every game that mattered".  The defense did not win a single game for us last year.

What this defense really needs to get better at is takeaways.  We have been below average in that respect every year under Harbaugh, and far below where we need to be to compete at an elite level.


April 7th, 2018 at 11:15 PM ^

against weak and mediocre opposition. It has not gotten the job done against quality opponents, and it has fallen apart at the end of the season. Until that changes, we will be a perennial 9-3ish team and a third place division finisher at best.


April 8th, 2018 at 7:34 AM ^

"we will be a perennial 9-3ish team and a third place division finisher at best."

And that's what Michigan is and has been for the past 25 years!! Only 4 times in the past 25 years has Michigan finished with fewer than 3 losses--97, 99, 06, 11. And they have finished with at least 2 losses every year since the 97 championship year. Everyone thinks the standard is Bo in the 1970s. That 40+ years ago!! 

The defense plays high risk, high reward football. And most of the time they get the stops. Sometimes, they give up the big play at a bad time. Whatever issues they have pale in comparison to the offense.


April 8th, 2018 at 10:28 AM ^

We will CONTINUE to be a perennial 9-3ish team and a third place division finisher at best.  

The point being that Harbaugh was supposed to lift us above that "good to very good but rarely great" level, and we were supposed to be locked in as a perennial elite team starting no later than 2018.  No one being honest with themselves sees that happening.  We can't even field a quality multi-year starter at QB, our Oline is still a shambles, and we have no one even approaching an elite RB.  The standard is NOT Bo in the 70's, btw.  It's Alabama and Ohio State in the 21st century.  Or even Michigan State. 

As far as "high risk, high reward", not sure where you ginned that up from.  That would mean we're getting a lot of interceptions, but giving up a lot of big passing plays.  As you acknowledged yourself, neither has been the case for this defense.


April 8th, 2018 at 2:51 PM ^

High risk, high reward--Giving up big plays, getting off the field and otherwise having a very good defense. Might not be a lot of turnovers, but a lot of stops regardless.

At some point it isn't the parade of coaches (some of them that have had a great track record) that have come through here, but something in the program in itself. In the past 25 years that Michigan has less than 3 losses (4 times), Ohio State has done it a ridiculous 17 times. That isn't just coaching. That's something systemic in the program and school itself. Some of it is Ohio State is probably willing to win at football at all costs and Michigan just won't do that. But I'm also guessing there are other factors involved as well.


April 7th, 2018 at 10:11 PM ^

Looking at the stats, both Michigan and Penn State were identical in terms of interceptions. Both teams threw 10 of them, and picked off 10 of them.

With fumbles, it's a different story. Penn State's and Michigan's opponents both fumbled 20 times. Michigan recovered 7 of those, while Penn State recovered 15 (!) of their opportunities. If fumble recoveries are mostly random, they got lucky and we didn't.

The other part of the turnover margin is that Penn State managed to fumble only 8 times and lost only 3 of them, while Michigan fumbled 18 times and lost 11. I am going to cop out and blame that on Barkley.


April 6th, 2018 at 2:24 PM ^

I already feel it happening. A sip here, a sip there, sips all until August when I am fucking hammered on M Football Koolaid, thinking we will go undefeated and get a playoff spot.... And after that, the deluge.