Penn State 42, Michigan 13 Comment Count

Ace


A matchup problem. [Patrick Barron]

Michigan has weaknesses that playoff teams lack. Tonight, those weaknesses were brutally exposed by a Penn State squad that sure looked like a playoff team themselves.

This game looked all but over in the opening five minutes. On the second play from scrimmage, future Heisman winner Saquon Barkley shifted over to quarterback, ran a read option with quarterback Trace McSorley acting as the running back, and gutted Michigan for a 69-yard touchdown. The Wolverines, on the other hand, went backwards on their opening possession, then watched as Barkley finished off a four-play, 78-yard drive with a 15-yard touchdown off a speed option pitch. Michigan, again, had negative yardage on the following drive.

A miscommunication between McSorley and tight end Mike Gesicki resulted in a David Long interception that briefly gave the Wolverines new life. After marching down to the PSU three, it took four cracks for Karan Higdon to finally break the plane. Quinn Nordin, getting booed by a crowd that never forgets a slight, missed the extra point. Michigan's counterpunch brought the defense to life; Khaleke Hudson nearly picked off a screen pass in the end zone.

Also a matchup problem. [Eric Upchurch]

The teams traded punts until a flurry of action at the end of the half. First, an unlikely connection from John O'Korn to Kekoa Crawford set up a six-yard Ty Isaac touchdown to bring Michigan within a point. Then McSorley threw Penn State down the field in the blink of an eye before finishing the drive on a three-yard keeper.

While the Wolverines went into the half down only 21-13, the numbers were foreboding. PSU amassed 302 total yards in the first half, more than Michigan had allowed in a full game this season. The safeties, steady to this point, were exploited in space by Barkley and McSorley. The offense mustered only 141 yards on five fewer plays, still hampered by poor blocking and a lack of trust in the passing game.

Given all that, it probably shouldn't have surprised too many people when Penn State blew the game wide open in the second half. Issues new and old appeared on PSU's first possession of the half. Tyree Kinnel got dusted one-on-one by DaeSean Hamilton on a slant for 26 yards; Barkley dropped a big gain after easily beating Mike McCray on a wheel route; McSorley seemingly juked half the defense to find the end zone on a beautifully designed inverted veer that had Barkley motion before the snap, drawing much of the defense's attention. Just like that, PSU took a commanding 28-13 lead.


Once again, John O'Korn couldn't generate much in the passing game. [Upchurch]

From then on, it was a merciless beating. On offense, O'Korn was improved from last week's woeful outing but still only managed 5.9 yards per attempt. Any hopes of a comeback were dashed when cornerback Christian Campbell beat Karan Higdon around the edge and ripped the ball away from O'Korn. They were really dashed when Barkley toasted McCray in man coverage for a juggling 48-yard touchdown two plays later; McCray had no hope of keeping pace, yet the normally unassailable Don Brown kept allowing that matchup to play out. 

It was academic from there. McSorley added another rushing touchdown with 7:53 to play. Michigan's final possession ended in appropriately inept fashion. Facing fourth-and-nine, the coaches pulled right tackle Juwann Bushell-Beattly, who allowed consistent pressure, to insert Nolan Ulizio as an apparent pass-protection specialist. Before they could snap the ball, O'Korn took a delay of game. After the penalty, redshirt freshman backup Shaka Toney ran right around Mason Cole to sack O'Korn for the coup de gras.

Michigan can only fix so much this season. With the schedule letting up considerably over the next few week, they're likely to try some new patches, potentially including one fans have wanted for weeks. Quarterback Brandon Peters was warming up on the sideline before O'Korn ultimately took the field for M's last drive. Given how that drive played out, that was probably for the best. Now that the conference title is essentially out of reach and a top-ten defense isn't facing M's O-line, it's time to see what Peters has got. While that won't solve everything, it could be the spark this offense desperately needs.

Many of tonight's other issues will be taken care of for this year, at least, by not having to face Joe Moorhead and this Nittany Lions offense again.

They want Bama. They can have them.

Comments

Loid

October 23rd, 2017 at 7:39 AM ^

This is quite simply about the best post I have ever read on this blog, save some of Brian's gems.  Look around the country and the offenses being employed, and this is SPOT ON.  College football at some point boils down to coaching, and having guys who know what system works, and the ability to implement it.  I fear that we are being passed by in the sense that what works at the pro level doesn;t necessarily translate to the college level.  We regularly get scorched by mobile QB's, and it appears they can do so even to our lauded defenses.  Harbaugh is still the man, but needs to steal a page from Franklin's and as much as I hate to say it, Kelly's playbook and get assistants in who can light it up at this level.  Head coaches steer the ship, but its quality assistants who aim the guns and sink the enemy, for lack of a better analogy..............

Steve333

October 22nd, 2017 at 1:23 AM ^

Psu Got beat down by Michigan last year (year3 for Franklin) and it has been the springboard to where they are now. I trust Coach Harbaugh- now in year three, with more returners next year for year 4. Inexperience at wr, and qb, and more inexperience at defense- that changes next year. They got exposed tonight. It happens. Sometimes it’s good to get one of those to measure yourself and adjust. Let’s see how this team reacts. Would have rather the game been closer tonight, but psu is for real. Onward Maize and Blue- we’ve got Rutgers next week. Let’s improve

chunkums

October 22nd, 2017 at 1:23 AM ^

8.5 wins was the Vegas expectation for a season when return fewer starters than anyone else in the NCAA. At the moment, that looks dead on. This game sucked, but this is kind of the expected outcome for an 8-4 team against a playoff team.

jaysvw

October 22nd, 2017 at 1:38 AM ^

Anyone who watched Michigan's preceeding games with any shred of objectivity could see this coming.  I feel like I'm watching the same shitty movie i've seen so many times since 2007.  Michigan shows obvious signs of problems, but somehow comes into mid October 5-1 or 6-0 and people just drink the kool-aid.  The first decent conference opponent we run into, we shit the bed and it's all down hill from there.  I thought we got off the ride with JH, but here we go again.  

bighouse22

October 22nd, 2017 at 9:06 AM ^

Continuity is the key.  As more recruiting classes come in the team will improve.  This team is an 8 win squad consistent with the Vegas line early in the year.  We were all encouraged by the Florida win and the start, but the team is the youngest in the country and they are not up to the level of PSU or even OSU. 

8 wins with a team as young as this one, probably means good things to come. 

Key position questions moving forward are QB, RB and Oline.  If that gets sorted out, the future is bright.

Tedbossman

October 22nd, 2017 at 1:57 AM ^

Barkley is the best college RB I’ve seen. Outstanding pro prospect. Top 3 pick. Their OC is phenomenal. Next UT head coach. Pull it together and bring it back to ‘em.

uminks

October 22nd, 2017 at 2:03 AM ^

2017 - 17, 2016 - 14,  2015 - 18, 2014 -27. Overall they never had top 10 recruiting classes but I guess their coaches are good at getting good players.  UM: 2017 - 5, 2016 - 6, 2015 - 40, 2014 - 18. This down season may hurt recruiting a bit but we should be in the 10-20 ranked class and then if we improve next year we should have another top 10 class.

BBQJeff

October 22nd, 2017 at 2:07 AM ^

This is not a good football team.   

A lot of this season's problems fall on the coaching staff.  

The meme coming into the season was that if they can survive the first half of their schedule and endure growing pains, this young and inexperienced team will improve as the season progresses.    I haven't seen any improvement so far this season.   That is disconcerting enough.   A bigger indictment on this coaching staff is the alarming number of players who haven't shown any improvement from last year and some who have showed clear regression.   Where is the player development?

Thus far I give this coaching staff a failing grade so far for the season.   Having said that, to suggest that this staff is a failure and that they are done is flat-out absurd.    Currently there are no better options for this program than Harbaugh.   He's been somewhat nauseatingly deified by our fan-base and some of the media since the day he accepted this job.   With his pedigree and hype we all hoped that he'd be as good as Urban Meyer.   I don't think he is.   But he's a heck of a lot better than RR or Hoke.  Maybe he's no better than Lloyd Carr.   After the last 2 coaches, I'd be OK settling with the next Lloyd Carr.   Optimal?  No.   Tolerable?  Yes.   Look at MSU.   They were a horrendous 3-9 and had a horrific offseason shedding a ton of young talent.  Yet, here they sit with 1 loss and wil llikely finish with a better record than us.   This is what Dantonio does.   Hopefully, Harbaugh can at least be as good as Dantonio.  

it's critical that this team wins at least one more and becomes Bowl eligible.   Those extra 4 weeks of practice will be sorely needed.      

There are no gimmes the rest of the way for this team.   

BBQJeff

October 22nd, 2017 at 9:49 AM ^

Speight regressed.

Evams regressed.

Bunting regressed.

Cole looks like he may have regressed a little bit.

McDoom is contributing less than a year ago.

Crawford is attrocious.

Wheatley is a ghost.

Khalid Hill has regressed.

O'Korn, Higdon, Isaac and the rest of the O-line don't look any better than they did a year ago.

While still flawed Gentry, McKeon, Poggi and possibly Perry all look to be ahead of where they were a year ago.   

We are seeing an appalling lack of develpment on the offensive side of the ball.   When it's that widespread it's bad coaching.  

The D has been much better.   Other than McCray pretty much everyone has imrpoved from a year ago.  

los barcos

October 22nd, 2017 at 2:36 AM ^

When has Brian been right?? Honestly he prides himself on his football acumen- but between RR, hoke pooping gold and tonight. When has his predictions spotlessly worked???

Amaznbluedoc

October 22nd, 2017 at 2:42 AM ^

A couple of random observations now that I got home from state college. First, we had a good time hanging out at the bars and met some very friendly psu fans. Likewise when we moved to the tailgating in the parking lots around the stadium, folks couldn’t have been nicer and some even offered us drinks, food, etc. But interestingly all of that changed once we went inside beaver stadium. That place is a dump; think of some dumb psu engineer dropping sParty stadium on top of Ross-Ade or another crappy other venue. The place was a friggin, ADD nightmare. Music blasting every second, advertisements, and promotions galore, and stupid promo bits. When the wind would blow the stench from the pig farms around the stadium became unbearable. Speaking of pigs, the fans were relentlessly rude, constantly baiting and antagonizing M fans. A real surprise for us. As we left the stadium, there were constant f-bombs and swearing from random psu dopes, and by their attitudes, one woulld suspect they lost. It was simply awful, and M fans don’t realize how great we have it in Ann Arbor. In terms of the game itself we were outplayed by a more talented squad. What impressed me is our kids never gave up, and we saw some improvement in the offense in its ability to sustain a couple of drives. They could have done more and it seemed that penalties and dropped balls killed any mo. Okorn played reasonably well but our receivers have to get separation and the times he got sacked or flushed out was largely due to downfield coverage. The dropped balls killed us and quite frankly I only saw one or two of okorn balls sailing. The majority were catchable but our receivers just can’t hold on. The D got burned early and seemed to have trouble adjusting to the plays where they lined up Barkley in the slot. If he stayed they passed and if he came in motion, they ran but our D didn’t have any answers. Also the direct snap to Barkley was problematic. Look we won the last three in a row from these chumps and they got the best of us tonight. They can gloat all they want but psu is hardly a number two team.

Steve-a-wolverine-o

October 22nd, 2017 at 3:19 AM ^

What a craptastic thing that was. I'm surprised we even got a game column and not just the otter with a bottle of fireball. There are basically no positive takeaways unless you believe that we somehow got shit on by the refs and have earned more ref fucks up in our favor points for a future game. Don't get me wrong, I'm not really upset. I enjoyed rooting for this team and will continue to root for this team going forward. I can't wait for DPJ to get more reps and become more effective. I'd like to see us with a QB with flow and better accuracy, maybe Peters this year or or next year or maybe Speight gets back and can get into flame thrower mode. I would love if our safeties improve over the next year or two. Oh and I would like to see us not have recruiting holes on our roster. Never again for 20 years please. Also, I hope that photographer is okay. I didn't see the collision but Higdon sure was moving fast out of bounds with zero control of his trajectory.

Berkley@MainMan

October 22nd, 2017 at 4:01 AM ^

I agree with everything you said. Interesting that you mentioned, "lack of trust in the passing game." I thought O'Korn did have enough time on some of his drop-backs, but assumed he was holding onto the ball because nobody was getting open. Sounds like maybe what you meant by lack of trust, was that he could have tried some throws on some of them, but he just did not trust what he was seeing, or his recievers. I thought it was because of those kids could not gain in any seperation, but will look again, with what I think you were saying in mind. The one thing that I hope does not happen is anyone from the interior of the OLine being moved anywhere. I feel like those guys are doing good enough, and will continue to get better. I just really believe that continuity is what is best for those kids for this year, and in the long run. If we're going to put Peters in there, may as well get Runyan, or Stubes some run at R.T. I thought we played hard, and did the best we could. That offensive line whipped us. I thought it really would be the other way around. That is a good team they have. One to grow from, and our young offense gained some valuable experience. HAIL.

bighouse22

October 22nd, 2017 at 8:27 AM ^

I agree that you can't put this on O'Korn.  I thought he played smart considering.  That being said it's now time to prep Peters for next year.  O'Korn playing from this point forward does nothing to improve the team for next year.  He is a 5th year senior and has no eligibility next year.

Time to give Peters some game time action and get him in position to compete next year with Speight and McCafferty for the starting positon. 

Harbaugh soldier

October 22nd, 2017 at 11:22 AM ^

Isn't even part of team during games, During timeouts or team huddles. He's zoned out and body language is I'm done here. Think he will transfer out in December. If anything they burn McCaffrey RS and start him remainder of season - that would be most against grain thing Harbaugh could do.

Harbaugh soldier

October 22nd, 2017 at 9:04 PM ^

Harbaugh repeats often players make biggest push between freshman and sophomore years. The real players who are core players, bush, Hudson, hill, long, metellus, gary, nordin all made significant jumps - Evans , crawford, McDoom all gone backwards- Peters has not even played in a real game.

DonBrownSoda

October 22nd, 2017 at 7:44 AM ^

Not sure what the TV showed but O’Korn made the right decisions. The receivers rarely got separation and JOK utilizes his two checkdowns: 1. HB/FB/TE in the flat or 2. Run.
On the couple of clean pockets John threw to the open man. He is wholly serviceable if we could pass protect. His main problem that I see is what he does when he senses pressure. A great QB will sense the pressure and adjust without taking his attention away from passing progression. JOK senses the pressure, switches his focus to escaping and panics.

DonBrownSoda

October 22nd, 2017 at 7:48 AM ^

One gripe: the officiating missed several obvious defensive holds on PSU - particular on the option sweeps by Barkley. Their WRs on the edge were frequently behind the Michigan defender holding the jersey.

Also, the blown grounding call was atrocious. Didn’t make the LOS and nobody for 20 yards.

DonBrownSoda

October 22nd, 2017 at 8:01 AM ^

State College. Man that place is a something. The stadium (as another poster put it) is basically a center of ADHD. The only time you had some blessed silence was when Michigan completes a play. They toned down the lion “rawr” but the music was horrible. As with most stadiums the older fans were fine, but the students reminded me of MSU. Trashed, f-Michigan every second and taunting constantly during the game. I took my nine year old son and he was wondering why the sun-burned drunk college student (maybe? Except in the Michigan ticket holder section) wouldn’t stop turning around after every damn play. Thankfully for the “text a problem fan” he was removed from his seat at halftime. The worst thing was the smell. The cow manure was sooo strong. Asked if this was normal the answer was a resounding yes. The stadium is an erector set. It’s loud for sure. They loveI to listen to 80s lighter music. As for leaving - we parked closest to the freeway. Mistake. We sat in the parking “lot” from 11:15-1:10am then drove 2 hours to Harrisburg. I was there in 1997 and now that my son has checked that off the B1G stadium list I will be happy to NEVER go back.

Amaznbluedoc

October 22nd, 2017 at 8:37 AM ^

Dude, where were you sitting?  Our seats were in the M alumni section and your experience of Beaver (and Butt-head) stadium was a carbon copy of mine.  Over the years we've been to every stadium in the big ten and apart from ohio and sParty we've never been subjected to so many f-bombs and taunting.  Even walking to the car, these d-bags would lean out of their decked out 80's style cars and shout f-Michigan.  From their behavior, one would think that these morons had  lost the game?  Given PSU's sordid history, I think dropping the f-ing thing would be wise?

NateVolk

October 22nd, 2017 at 8:22 AM ^

For the segment of the fan base that follows the state of Michigan's recruiting, attrition, and relative experience vs. the opponent game to game, I have a suggestion. 

If you are going to post on here with facts about why an offense loaded with veteran talent had a big night against a defense loaded with underclassmen, cut and copy it for later use.

You'll need it after every loss for the 5 games. Those mind-numbing weeks when the howling "unacceptable" crowd buries this wonderful blog with the repetitive baseless whining.

Time saving tip.

Nofx1728

October 22nd, 2017 at 8:28 AM ^

Caught the tunnel screen he may have tied the game on the first series of the second half. Could of been hard fought to the end. Instead the entire team imploded. This team has 0 playmakers who can step up and make a big play when needed.

Defense got out schemed and made 0 adjustments. Safeties, Hudson and McCray got abused.

It’s embarrassing how bad our oline is.

If Peters does not start next game I give up on the coaches. Every goal of the season is now lost. Play the freshmen so someone has experience next year. We don’t even know if Speight will be able to play again.

Amaznbluedoc

October 22nd, 2017 at 8:48 AM ^

After one of the earlier games in the year, someone said (it might have been JH, or a player), that you can't have 10 players doing their job on every play while one doesn't and expect to be successful.  That was really the theme of the game again on M's side of the ball.  Dropped passes, missed blocks on sweeps, drive killing penalties, blown coverages, and guys out of position.  Sure we would all love stud playmakers but if guys executed what they needed to do, we might not have won but the game would not have been so lopsided.

 

Icehole Woody

October 22nd, 2017 at 8:43 AM ^

O’Korn played well. Hard to win with shitty blocking, dropped passes, and the defense giving up big plays. The fundamental problem remains the OL. The coaching staff has their work cut out for them over the next couple years.