Michigan Gets Florida In The Peach Bowl Comment Count

Brian December 2nd, 2018 at 4:33 PM

As it was written in the stars: Michigan and Florida will play in a semi-major bowl game after both fail to achieve their regular season goals. A baffling decision given how bored both fanbases must be of this matchup.

This edition of the Gators is in their first year under Dan Mullen and is in the awkward jerky phase when a very good coach takes over for a not so good one. Thus results like a 27-19 win over LSU and a 41-14 whooping of FSU coexist with a 38-17 loss to Mizzou and 27-16 loss to Kentucky. 

S&P+'s spreadsheets are down for updating at the moment but the overall rankings are up at Football Outsiders. Florida ranks 14th, with the #27 offense and #26 defense. S&P+ makes Michigan a 6-point favorite on a neutral field.

You may remember some of their key players: Feleipe Franks has added 1.3 YPA this year and 15 TDs without increasing his INTs; Lamical Perine and Jordan Scarlett split RB carries down the middle and both average 5.9 YPA. Onetime Michigan target Van Jefferson is their leading receiver, although like Michigan this is a situation where there are a bunch of guys in about the same range in an offense that doesn't throw a ton.

Fuller analysis later.

Comments

xgojim

December 2nd, 2018 at 5:14 PM ^

All you naysayers need to get another life or just forget M football exists until next fall.  The fact is that this is the best bowl matchup that M could have qualified for and in the best bowl that a non-Big 10 championship team could qualify for.  It is also the main lead-in game to the playoff games later in the day and will get plenty of attention, as the off-bowl games go.  It will be a great tune-up for next fall -- just forget that Florida is the opponent.  Hopefully, few players will opt out and it will be a good test.  And it is just 12 hours down I-75 when the weather is OK, so start your engines!

xgojim

December 3rd, 2018 at 4:33 PM ^

More obvious positives for M to care about this bowl:  Georgia and Florida are current hotbeds for M recruiting, equal to Michigan and Ohio but a distance away.  What a great opportunity to further expose the team to others who haven't been on-campus.  It's a little like those off-campus football camps that have been outlawed.

Bando Calrissian

December 2nd, 2018 at 5:16 PM ^

I've never been this underwhelmed about a bowl matchup. Nothing is exciting about it. I don't care what has changed about the bowl system--playing on December 29th should be what happens when you go 8-4 or 7-5. Screw this.

ryebreadboy

December 2nd, 2018 at 5:23 PM ^

Boring. Who would ever think this rematch would make for appealing football?

At least we’ll get to hear lots of talk about Jim McElwain being on our coaching staff now. Media loves an obvious narrative.

This is what happens when you come up short. We could’ve had an entertaining game against Clemson, but instead we’re in the Bullshit Bowl.

NateVolk

December 2nd, 2018 at 5:36 PM ^

It's more Michigan football. Always a plus. I think that is what every fan feels.

 

This opponent in this bowl interests me on the excitement level of a home non-conference tomato can game in September.

 

10-2 with what was one of the hardest schedules in preseason deserves better than this. I know you have to win the OSU game or the ND game. But at the same time let's not act like we're 8-4 with no quality wins like last year.

 

Players should be in a warm weather site and the fans should be watching the most marquee match up available. 

 

I don't think either request is close to be met here. And those aren't unreasonable requests.

Mongo

December 2nd, 2018 at 5:46 PM ^

Where does the team practice?  I would just stay in Ann Arbor and practice there.  It is an indoor stadium, so just treat it as a stinking away game.  I feel bad for the players ... no 10-2 team should get stuck in Atlanta for a Dec 29 bowl game.  Sorry, but that is just not right. 

Princetonwolverine

December 2nd, 2018 at 7:40 PM ^

Holy shit, people. It wasn’t too long ago we got excited to be bowl eligible. We are 10-2. Let’s make a statement of who we really are. Keep and get great recruits and beat the fuck out of the Gators.

MIdocHI

December 2nd, 2018 at 6:08 PM ^

This just shows Warde Manuel has no power. We just sit back and accept a crappy, repeat opponent and bowl. If we are such an attractive draw for a bowl, why don’t we exert some influence to get a better bowl and more intriguing opponent? The A.D. is a joke. We just meekly accept whatever scraps the bowl committee deigns to give us. 

uminks

December 2nd, 2018 at 6:13 PM ^

This is Michigan's punishment for not taking care of business and making the playoffs. We let the conference down by not defeating OSU and making the playoffs. I think UF will be much more motivated for this game then Michigan. I guess we'll see how good Harbaugh can coach to get the win. It will be rather disappointing to lose another bowl game.

jbuch002

December 2nd, 2018 at 6:24 PM ^

I don't like the match-up for a lot of reasons but .......

The one thing worth watching is to see if Harbaugh and Brown learned anything from having put their players in such an untenable position v. osu. The players were juiced for The Game and these two did nothing but put forth a stodgy game plan, straight out of the hackney drawer that was the same old shit that worked for a weak BIG overall and especially for hobbled Wisconsin, MSU and PSU - usually good teams that weren't in 2018. M got pantsed by ufm who had a lot of under-performing talent on his team, until The Game ..... so, what's new...... other than it is becoming apparent that Harbaugh may not be the elite coach we thought he was when he was signed.

If M wants to compete for Championships like Harbaugh says he does, he absolutely has to not drop a turd on the playing field like he did v. Usc last season. That loss sent a message to a lot of M fans and that was JH simply can't manage or motivate his staff sufficiently to obtain the results he claims he wants. That message lingers.

I think it is obvious that his approach to the game in 2018 grossly underutilized the talent he had on the roster to play at an elite level. Instead, he let himself and his staff get comfortable and lazy with what they thought they had - Fortress M - failing to realize how weak the BIG actually was. Whether that was from talent disparities or injuries making M wins a lot easier than they probably should have been in an up year for the BIG is immaterial.

That he and his staff failed to account for that and come up with a better game plan for osu was damning. That throughout the 2018 season, his failure to innovate in the passing game in such a way that would have allowed practice of such innovation and for a reasonable chance to keep up with air-osu in a shootout, specifically engineered by ufm to be that way, and it did -  was nothing short of incompetence. Instead, JH tried to impose his strategy on ufm and that failed. He seemed to have no back-up. People I know get fired for avoidable mistakes like that.

If his Michigan team shows up in ATL on 12/29 with the same stale game plan he won games with against bad teams, the one that cost Michigan wins against the two good teams M played, regardless of whether his team beats UF or not, it will seal his fate as an average coach and fans will have to get used to Michigan continuing it's also ran tradition in an era that demands innovative play. M fans, who support ticket and apparel sales, donors who support much more than that, and the BIG Ten who keeps getting shut out of CFP bucks by an under-performing Michigan football team WILL DEMAND IT.

Even Lloyd shocked the world with his swan-song game plan v. the Tim Tebow lead, ufm coached Gators in 2008. Henne went 23/39, 379y and 3 TDs throwing to Arrington and Manningham who torched the UF secondary. Meanwhile, M's defense kept Tebow under constant pressure - both of these things were completely unlike anything M had done that season. Jim, we're watching you.  

 

uminks

December 2nd, 2018 at 6:54 PM ^

May be Harbaugh will unleash Shea and our talented WR core and they will finally have some fun!  I hope Harbaugh opens things up rather then running every play into a stacked D LINE! It will make the game more fun to watch if he opens up the offense. But I have a feeling we'll see more RPO with a lot more run!

You Only Live Twice

December 2nd, 2018 at 10:58 PM ^

You may have some points there, although, stating that our BIG opponents were weak, is all hindsight unless you said this in the beginning of the season, when everyone was saying that we had the toughest schedule in the country.  Wisconsin, MSU and PSU all looked worse than their rankings when we played them yet you won't give Michigan credit, you just dismiss every team we beat as being awful.

 

Mongo

December 2nd, 2018 at 6:40 PM ^

Gary is out.  Honestly, any legit NFL prospect on UM’s team should skip the Peach Bowl.  Time to get the replacement players reps and get the moving-on guys ready for the NFL combine. Time to look on to 2019 for everyone.  

BlueHills

December 2nd, 2018 at 6:56 PM ^

Any New Years’ Six bowl invitation is an accomplishment, not a punishment. I’m going to watch the game and have fun. It’s healthier than dwelling on negatives.

I hope the team is excited and plays their best game of the year.

Go Blue! 

Alton

December 3rd, 2018 at 8:53 AM ^

This game, along with the 2 semifinals (Orange & Cotton), were originally scheduled for December 31.  But everybody complained the last time the semis were on a December 31 weekday, so they moved the Peach, Orange and Cotton Bowls to Saturday, December 29.

Because everybody complained.

 

MerryMarkley77

December 2nd, 2018 at 7:50 PM ^

Thanks for swimming against the tide of negativity.  Wow.  It was a disappointing season because of the OSU loss, but the negativity just sounds like bitterness at this point. I've been fighting that myself, but this entitled attitude on the part of some epitomizes the stereotype for M fans.  We've got to earn it.  I believe we will earn it with Harbaugh as coach.  I do hate the college football world these days, though, as I think the four team playoff may be creating four or five programs that have a permanent recruiting advantage and we are not in on that.  I keep thinking about the Harbaugh who beat Pete Carroll's USC teams and think he'll get the better of Meyer.  The only thing that scares me is that his teams struggled more against Oregon's spread and that's what OSU runs. Still can't believe how they shredded our defense.  Nevertheless, go blue and beat Florida!  We should not assume it will be gimme game.  Respect every opponent.

blue90

December 2nd, 2018 at 7:03 PM ^

Yeah, gotta say, pretty sick of this match-up. Florida is overrated, wish we got a better team to play, oh well. I hate how everyone (the media and announcers) thinks Harbaugh hasn't won a single "big game." Such BS, he has won a bunch of good games, just because he is 0-4 against OSU people say he sucks and hasn't won big games. Just this year, we beat Wisky, MSU, and PSU, all in a row, all ranked teams.  Yeah in hindsight they were all overrated but in the moment and at the time they were huge games to win. He also won against Wisky his first year which was a huge win and won the Orange Bowl his first year. He is a great coach and has won plenty of good games, get rid of Pep and we'll be elite.

bronxblue

December 2nd, 2018 at 7:42 PM ^

One thing I do wish they'd do is move these bigger bowls around a bit more.  Nobody is going to be excited for this game in Atlanta, but if they moved the Peach Bowl to, I don't know, the Northeast then they'd 100% get more excitement from a big part of the fanbase that doesn't live in the Sunbelt.