Hail to the Victors: The Story, The Stories, and The Sponsors Comment Count

Seth

Somewhere in Ohio right now is a printer watching helplessly as thousands of beaming Denards drain their most expensive ink pots. They are Buckeyes, and acted like total Buckeyes at times, probably because to a Buckeye a few months of going to bed with this image on your mind is excruciating:

HTTV2012cover

You are not a Buckeye, and therefore to you it is beautiful. It is Hail to the Victors 2012. It's 8 1/2 inches wide, 10 3/4 inches tall (a good bit larger than HTTVs of yesteryear), and 128 pages long. It is a production of MGoBlog. MGoBlog staffers wrote it, edited it, produced it, published it, and took most of the photos in it. Our regular apparel partner, Underground Printing, is the one distributing it. More importantly, MGoBlog readers supported it through an astoundingly generous response to our KickStarter campaign. There are no ads in it (this time), just a sponsor page at the end to recognize the folks most responsible for this book existing longer than the company that used to publish it.

You can have it. It's $12.50 plus shipping (I think that's $3.00 EDIT: S&H is $4.99 and tax is $1.05, so $18.54 total to get it mailed) and will be put in mailboxes starting June 30. There are plenty to go around. Consume!

Here's how it happened: By about last August last year, frustrated that the old publishers still hadn't paid us or the rest of the contributors for the 2011 book, I approached Brian with the concept of taking HTTV indie. I've been in the publishing business and Brian never lost the contacts that made HTTV a flagship series since 2007. We figured how many copies we sold in years previous, what it would cost to produce it ourselves, and whether we could, at minimum, afford to cover our expenses plus pay back last year's contributors for last year. That concept became deadly serious when it turned out the reason the old publisher wasn't paying anybody was because they were folding.

The Kickstarter was Brian's idea. It took some time for us to come up with a number, finally settling on $20,000, a little less than half of our projected expenses ($44k – which turned out to be close enough), figuring if we have enough to cover up-front expenses we can sell enough to make up the rest; if we raised less, oh well it wasn't going to happen. The kickstart was finally posted in late March. This is when the thing went from omigod I hope our wives are cool with five-figure debt, to omigod you guys! You guys, who committed to your copies so fast if I didn't know better I'd think Mattison was telling you it'll make you a Baltimore Raven. In a day we met our funding goal. In two days we'd doubled it. In a week we had broken even on the whole thing. In the end you did this:

httvkickstarter …!

I'll save you the details of what came next, except to say captioning is like trying to write the great American novel using Twitter, and there was a point when we realized every article was 25% too short because our page size had changed. Also there are two typos that will haunt me forever, and a few Easter eggs for longtime MGoReaders to find.

Here's what you bought yourself, by which I mean here's a preview of what we put in this actual physical book which you can own and put on the coffee table or bathroom rack or read on planes and other places cheap Internet cannot travel:

SECTIONS:

  • LETTER FROM THE EDITOR by Brian Cook. Non-randomly selected words/phrases from the last sentence of each paragraph: Real Talk, fergodsakes, millennium, dysfunctional, song.
  • THE TEAM, THE TEAM, THE TEAM, by Brian. A 30-page, position-by-position look at the 133rd Michigan Football squad, with depth charts, last year's stats, predictions, and a few record books that might be rewritten this year.
  • RECRUITS TO KNOW, by Brian. Doesn't include some of the guys who made it into the position previews. Ojemudia's laser eyes are tame when compared to those of RJS. It was short on space so if you don't like anything from Ringer to Houma, that was me.
  • THE ENEMY, THE ENEMY, THE ENEMY, by Jerry Hinnen of CBS Sports, and MGoBlog's Ace Anbender (Notre Dame) and Heiko Yang (Ohio State). This is a 24-page, team-by-team preview of the 2012 schedule, with extra pages devoted to rivals (not you, Minnesota) and other big games (not you, Illinois). For OSU I enlisted editing assistance from Ramzy Nasrallah of Eleven Warriors, who set us straight on a few things and was ignored on others. Unfortunately Brian's intro page had to be cut from this so maybe we'll post that later.

those who stood FEATURES:

  • TULIPS, REAL ESTATE … SEASON TICKETS, by Michael Elkon of Braves & Birds looks at Michigan's rising ticket prices and donation demands versus a home spate that sees every directional MAC school more often than Wisconsin or Penn State, and poses the obvious: where does the bubble burst?
  • SOME OF PART OF THE OTHER SIDE OF THE STORY, SORT OF, by Craig Ross is a response to John Bacon's Three and Out and the closest we'll probably ever come to a Lloyd-angle view of those events.
  • THOSE WHO STOOD, by Seth Fisher, is my saccharine retelling of the careers of Team 132's most prominent seniors while assessing their ultimate place in Michigan history.
  • CONFIDENCE MAN, by Chris Brown of Smart Football and Grantland takes us into the mind of a Mattison to discover how, over the course of one season, he managed to turn Michigan's defense into a Michigan defense (TM), by focusing on playing Michigan's defense.
  • PREDICTING PERFORMACE by The Mathlete of MGoBlog uses the best predictors known to stats to guess at the performance of M's 2012 offense, defense, and overall difficulty of the entire schedule.
  • FOURTH DOWN AND NOWHERE TO GO by jamiemac of Just Cover Blog is a discussion on the astounding level of play Michigan got last year on its 3rd and 4th and short situations, how this was secretly just as important as turnovers in how the season went, and whether it's repeatable for 2012.
  • HARRY WHO AND '32 by Greg Dooley of MVictors takes us back to Gerald Ford's sophomore season, a time when the NCAA made as much sense as the Big Ten's postseason priorities, and an athletic little quarterback named Harry Newman led the Wolverines to a National Championship.
  • THE HUMAN HURRICANE: FIELDING YOST is a long excerpt from John Kryk's next book. The book is on the Point-a-Minute dynasty; the article is the part about how Yost got to be the man who made it.

ETC:

  • HAIL TO THE ROUNDTABLE between Cook, Fisher, Ross, and Dooley discusses the current staff, the defensive turnaround, breakout players, Hokeisms, fusion cuisine, and 2012 predictions.
  • COMIC SECTION: CHARLIE'S FIRST MICHIGAN GAME by Six Zero of The Blockhams

Plus the roster that was sent to print before I could confirm Gardner's # change was the real deal, and a cover and back cover and section images designed by MonuMental, and a table of contents that I wrote and sent off before I realized we could add 4 more pages and thus which erroneously says the Sponsors Page is on the inside back cover when it's actually just the last right-side page of the book. And the Sponsor Page. About that…

SPONSORS:

bending overbackwards

Upchurch | Because they bent over backwards, get it?

The following appear in the back of the book (not on the inside back cover like it says in the table of contents) for going far beyond a pre-order and a t-shirt during the HTTV Kickstarter. If you know any of these folk you should walk up to them at a socially awkward moment and sing Muppets in celebration of them (don't do this):

Temptation Level:

816 Hill ~Class of 2002 Jonathan Giroux Ken Mickey
Andy and Ken Anbender David Glasser Mike Curtis Agency-
Farm Bureau Insurance
Zac Barry John Granger Milty
Alexander Bash Nikki Guglielmo Edward Mitchell
Joe Beaulieu Jason G Heitman Mike O’Byrne
Jeff Becker Kirk Hemmen Paul
Scott Bishop Greg Henchel Pharker
Jonathan Borman Steve Higgs Jeffrey M. Raab, LSA ‘96
Brooks Drew Hill Walt and Connie Reebel
Ben Davis and Peter F. Holland Josh Rockey
Christie Brown Tom Hoover Joshua Ruland
Cory S. Brown Kyle Hubbard Safran Family
David Callahan Nathan Isenberg Brad Schafer
Brian W. Callahan William and Claire L. David Schenk III
Carey Family Johnson Brian Shull
Scott Childers Captain Cory Kastl/
Cadet Garrett Kastl
Damian P. Silver
Michael Cromwell Andrew Kim Frederick Cogswell
Jerry Current Matt Kramer Simmons IV
Matt Duane Donald J. Kunz Malcolm T. Simpson
Eric Dunn Adam Lanseur Bo Snyder
Chris Eagle Kevin “ILL” Legel Hariharan Sundram
Joseph Eichhorn Matt Lenhoff Ben Swihart
Epic Win Apparel Mark Liinamaa Jeff Taepke
A. Espinoza-Diaz, CoE ‘98 The Linn Family Jeff Timberlake
Joseph Fix Lud, LSA ‘05 Jason Tolbert
Dana S. Fletcher Kelly Lytle Trueblueintexas
Will Fluharty Greg Macklem Bill Weiner
Alan M. French Evan Makela Eric M Wilfong
Crew Gary Bob Manza Rahul Yaratha
anonymous Nicholas Marshall  

Hawaiian War Chant Level (they gave more, and thus get quotes):

Arthur: Harbaugh, you owe my brother $25.00.
Jeff Baiocchi: Go Blue!
Michael A Barton: F--- the bigger boat! Get more ice and rye, a lot of rye, Drapers coming over.
Matt Candler: Go Blue!
Dahman Law: Dahman Law, unabashedly supporting the legal and blogging interests of Wolverines all across enemy territory, and soon in Michigan. Check us out at dahmanlaw.com.
Jonathan Gaines: “Dad, is it weird that I pity Sparty more than I hate Ohio?”-teenage daughter after 2011 Big Ten Football Championship game. -WFBlue
Michael Hacker: Hacker Bros. BBQ. You can’t drink all day if you don’t start in the morning.
Don Hubbard: Go Blue!
Scott Jacobs: S. Jacobs LSA ‘92
Bob Kennedy: Go Blue!
Jerome Lim: Go Blue!
Jamie MacMillian: JustCoverBlog.Com, providing college and pro football commentary, breakdowns and analysis since 2009. Your 2012 football season wont
be the same without us on your reading list
Jonathan McDonald: I firmly believe this publication will equip Michigan fans with an unprecedented decided schematic advantage. Go Blue!
JP: JP Gaztambide... Puerto Rico en la casa. VAMOS BLUE!!!
Steve Reynolds: Keep that UM fandom growing, Angela!!

Some additional names need to be mentioned here. Courtney Fathers of CorkBoards, our art monkey who held out hope of actually sleeping in the month of May way longer than we thought she would. Eric Upchurch, who provided most of the photographs for the book, and who blew most of what we paid him on special equipment he believes can capture the entirety of a Denard smile without the glare. To other contributing photographers in order of appearance: Drew Hoover of Bama's student newspaper, the Crimson White, Communications Specialist 1st Class Chad McNeeley of the U.S. Air Force, the University of Notre Dame Athletics Department, Shotgun Spratling of Neon Tommy, Daryl Quintaig of Illinois student newspaper The Daily Illini, Mark Boomgaard of Spartannation.com, Derek Tam of NU Intel, "Proud Buckeye" James D. DeCamp, and the University of Michigan Bentley Library. And a special thank you to the players, coaches, staff and fans of 133 Michigan football teams for remaining steadfastly worthy of so much ink.

We're going to try again next year, probably with another Kickstarter, wholesale distribution, interior ads, and I expect 1,000% more Devin Gardner.

Comments

Bigasshammm

June 19th, 2012 at 10:20 AM ^

This book gets me through the summer every year. I almost wish it were printed earlier but understand why it isn't.
Nothing is better than a cigar and beer in the backyard with HTTV.

Is it being printed by Hess Printing or The Press of Ohio in Brimfield/Kent?

MGoRock

June 19th, 2012 at 10:37 AM ^

A name mention on the site as well as in the mag?  Talk about exceeding expectations!  This will be my fifth year receiving HTTV and I have never been more excited.  Thanks for the detailed description, Seth!  Proud to be part of this community.

M-Wolverine

June 19th, 2012 at 10:39 AM ^

That's what she said.

You had it printed in Ohio? You know there's going to be pee in the ink.

I'm really curious about the Easter Eggs.  Sounds like a future thread.

It'll be fun to see how much less gloomy this year's edition is. Parts of last year's had me wanting to slit my wrists. Craig Ross, I'm looking at you. (Though I am curious how Ross tells the "other side of the story"...as a guy who was firmly in the Rich camp, I'm curious to see if Lloyd talked to him or not.  And leave it for the magazine...that argument doesn't need to be relived in this thread).  Now, I don't expect sugar and kittens, but reality...but there HAS to be a different feel for the future of the program than the crossroads we were at last year.

Not a correction or complaint, just a question that goes into the thought process of authoring something- Why "Those who Stood" rather than "Those who Stayed" or something along those lines? I see added meaning, but just curious what the development process is mentally that makes one choose those words.

And you better not have jinxed Devin Gardner....

 

El Jeffe

June 19th, 2012 at 11:21 AM ^

Oh come on, man. Are you seriously angry at Rich Rod for burning Denard's redshirt and rolling the dice with Tate, Sheridan, Tha Notorious C.O.N.E, and a cool breeze? Or are you just saying "man, I wish that hadn't had to happen so I could enjoy me some more Denard?"

If the latter, I totally agree. Playing Devin as a frosh was more inexcusable, though IIRC it was because Tate was being disciplined and Denard got dinged up a bunch.

CRex

June 19th, 2012 at 11:51 AM ^

Tate was in the doghouse and Denard was just coming out for a couple plays here and there mostly.  Hindsight is 20/20, but looking back if only we'd sent in Jack Kennedy to hand the ball off twice while Denard got his breath back.  Of course at the time if we'd done that, RR would have been ripped up for not trying to win 100% of the time.  

Seth

June 19th, 2012 at 10:55 AM ^

It makes sense in the article, which leads with the story of the "Those who stay..." banner going up and how from then on whenever we needed to be reminded about what this program is about they trotted out a Dierdorf who stayed. However you can only stand so long on that edifice, and the crux of this story is about how when the City of Bo was crumbling around them this class forged a new foundation. Those Who Stayed were Team 90. Those Who Stood was Team 132.

CR

June 19th, 2012 at 11:05 PM ^

Dear M-Wolverine:

I enjoy your posts quite a bit so I apologize for my brooding piece last year. You weren't alone in your point of view.

Until this moment, I didn't know which of my articles Brian had chosen, if he had chosen either. I sent him two and I am a bit surprised by his decision but happy for the "transition" article to see the light of day. I hope it isn't too depressing---I don't think it is---but for my part the transition from Carr to Rodriguez was mystifying, especially since I was "there," if in some virtual reality, for a part of it. I tried to make sense of the strands of information I had, some different ones than those owned by John Bacon---a guy who I have known for a long time. I respect and admire John, but some pieces I had just didn't quite fit. John's source was, or so I guess, Rich Rodriguez. For my part, I had access to Rodriguez, but I never asked about the transition. However, I did attempt to defend RR with John Hilton at the Ann Arbor Observer, who seemed to desire to run a "negative" piece (or pieces) about RR due to the litigation concerning the liquidated damages clause in his WV contract. I argued with JH (great editor, BTW) that the fight had little to do with RR, that it was strictly a pissing match between West Virginia and Michigan. I won't get into it, but (admittting my minority view) I think liquidated damages clauses in the context of employement contracts are mostly horseshit. That contrarian view aside, no one should have believed that the litigation had much to do with Rich Rod, since he had cut his deal at minute one with UM. It was strictly WVA versus UM, with WVA (my view) extorting money for non-existent damages. In the end, de classe at best.

Rodriguez never knew that I took up that particular cudgel for him. He may have known that I wrote an article for Sam Webb's publication (the editing there really went south; not Sam's fault) arguing strongly that (post 2010) Michigan should not fire Rich Rod. I may have been (be?) the last Rich Rod defender, since (irony) I thought UM should live up to its contract and that "any coach" deserves at least 4 years. Plus, I concede, I loved RR's offense. The defense? Well, I liked it about as much as you liked my article last year.

But I don't really know RR. I do know Lloyd, pretty well, and I am very defensive of him. I consider him a friend. When Rick Leach attacked Carr of WTKA Ira Weintraub gave me time for a rebuttal, but LC wouldn't help me out on Leach's claim that Carr was tanking the program. He said "say what you think" in my pre-radio inquiry to him. So I did, and he never complained to me. Same sorta deal in this article. I sent a version to him based upon things I observed and was told, including some things he had mentioned to me. His response to me has been (functionally) "It's your story bro, not mine."

My apologies for the lengtth of this comment.. Glad to answer specific questions to the extent I can.  [email protected]. I am curious about the article, too, since it went to Brian at nearly 8,000 words and he was looking for half that.

As a complete aside, I have seen three coaching staffs up close. As impressive as Carr's staff was, Hoke and his group are off the charts. a truly thoughtful, savvy and gracious group of guys. I could not be more pleased or impressed. Blown away, really.

CR

 

Seth

June 20th, 2012 at 12:24 PM ^

Craig- I believe the version Brian sent me was unchanged from the one you sent him, and I made scant edits when we put it on the page. The article was fantasic. I didn't see the other one but this is one of the better articles in the book if you ask me. You still owe me coffee!

M-Wolverine

June 20th, 2012 at 2:20 PM ^

If it came off as directed at you that you "ruined my day" or something, that wasn't the intent. I don't think your mood was that far off the median for the publication or the blog (though maybe a little more dark than the general fanbase, which had warmed, but wasn't in any way red hot yet).  If anything you were singled out because I felt bad for you, because rather than negative you seemed depressed by the whole happening. (For some good reasons too).  I don't know how closely you follow the minutiae of the blog, but it was a very otter moment. 

If anything it came off as that the only way to enjoy Michigan football going into the future had been cast aside, and there was no where to go but down.  I know there are people around here who don't believe that I believe this, but there are lots of reasons to defend Rich. Most off the field, but some particular cases very much on the field. I never had a real problem with the "1 more year" point of view. (Not sure at that point it would have worked in the toxic environment...but old discussions)  It was more the feeling that Hoke was the downfall of mankind; or something more important - Michigan Football!  (Not that you were particularly the one saying that)

I would be reading the article in any case (picking up my copy a week from Saturday).  I'm intrigued whether Lloyd talked to you, or was "Lloyd".  Some people see the whole situation as black and white. I see it as more Roshomon. And I'm not saying I hope you "refute" anything, or add fuel to a debate that's basically embers right now.  I'm just curious and interested in different viewpoints. 

So if I came off as seemingly singling you out, or your article, I'm sorry. I was probably thinking more about the roundtable (something I always enjoy in any format), and that would have included Seth, Brian, and anyone else feeling an emo vibe. It's ok. Most got over it. Winning does that.  And Hoke's hard to not like. I was just more glad that for the first time in a long time in coverage of the sport, by anyone, even if looking realistically at things this season could be tougher, there's at least an air of optimism going into a season (for if not right now, the future certainly looks bright).  And even when Rich was a popular choice we really didn't get that going into the season because of the glaring holes on the team that were going to cause us to struggle by Michigan standards in any case.

But thanks for your response.

CR

June 20th, 2012 at 3:00 PM ^

M-W:

    Shoot me a note in, say, three years---assuming this might have any continuing interest for you--- and I wil tell you the exact deal re: sources of information. It is complicated.

     Thanks for your note. Quite thoughtful.

Craig

 

 

 

ThatGirlLovesM

June 19th, 2012 at 5:13 PM ^

I always looked forward to Johnny's articles in HTTV especially, his writing is a nice change of pace. Guess Brian couldn't convince him to come out of hiding this year.

Even so, I can't wait to read!! I'm glad the cover has been upgraded, since HTTV inevitably ends up on my coffee table for the whole year.

Seth

June 19th, 2012 at 12:28 PM ^

I keep telling Brian we should have a Kickstarter level where the editors of HTTV will come on your camping trip and tell stories around the campfire. We'll bring our own thermarests and agree to portage up to 90 lbs.

/shines flashlight at chin, uses dramatic voice

...and do you know what happened then? They came out in a play formation, even though it was fourth down on the 25-yard line...

But they didn't run to get the two yards. No, they were going to PASS it!

And Elvis the QuarGrback stood against the rush and pumped his arm toward an underneath route. But do you think he threw it underneath? No! He didn't! He pump-faked, then threw it long to Desmond Howard. And Desmond Howard ran past two defenders, and he laid out, and he soared through the air, and he caught the ball in the end-zone!

 

ca_prophet

June 19th, 2012 at 3:48 PM ^

... and I'd probably donate a bit more to avoid advertisements within the magazine, both on principle and because Ann-Arbor-local-businesses aren't going to be interesting to me.

Not sure how much more I'd be willing to give, and not sure how many others feel the same way, but there it is.

 

Seth

June 19th, 2012 at 5:08 PM ^

The inside covers ended up being blank. They're not cheap to print on (that was a gotchya moment in the printer proceedings). So either they'll be blank again, or someone will offer so much moolah for them (ie enough to make it worth it to print there) that it'll be hard to meet it with donations.

I do plan to keep ads out of the interior of the book.

freernnur5

June 19th, 2012 at 4:12 PM ^

Can't wait to read the Smart Football article about Greg Mattison. I am reading the book and loving it, so I will probably love the Mattison article.