2016 Recruiting: Ahmir Mitchell Comment Count

Brian July 11th, 2016 at 11:46 AM

Previously: Last year's profiles. S Josh Metellus, S Khaleke Hudson, CB David Long, CB Lavert Hill, LB Elysee Mbem-Bosse, LB Devin Bush Jr., LB Devin Gil, LB Josh Uche, DE Ron Johnson, DT Michael Dwumfour, DT Rashan Gary, DE Carlo Kemp, OL Ben Bredeson, OL Michael Onwenu, OL Stephen Spanellis, TE Nick Eubanks, TE Sean McKeon, TE Devin Asiasi, WR Eddie McDoom, WR Nate Johnson, WR Kekoa Crawford, WR Chris Evans, WR Brad Hawkins.

Egg Harbor, NJ – 6'3", 205


Scout 4*, #131 overall
#21 WR
Rivals 4*, #139 overall
#26 WR, #4 NJ
ESPN 4*, #216 overall 
#33 WR, #7 NJ
24/7 4*, #324 overall
#17 ATH, #8 NJ
Other Suitors OSU, MSU, ND, FSU
YMRMFSPA Greg Mathews or
Jonas Mouton
Previously On MGoBlog Hello post from Ace.
Notes Twitter. Early enrollee.


Junior year:

Senior half-season:

Like Chris Evans, Ahmir Mitchell might not actually be a wide receiver. He is one now and so here he goes, but all you have to do is look at the 2017 safety depth chart—Tyree Kinnel, a Khaleke Hudson who really needs to be taking over for Peppers at SAM, a couple question marks, and tumbleweeds—and then plug available safety-shaped objects in that hole. Meanwhile, Mitchell's stock as a wide receiver has been on a steady slide over the past year and a half. His rankings dropped from top 100, near top 50 in some cases, to outside of the top 100; 247's dramatic revision of his ranking saw him barely hold on to four-star status. 

Mitchell is a safety-shaped object, and an intimidating one. Hypothetically. This post won't talk about that much because nobody evaluated him as a defensive player past brief mentions that his athleticism could lend itself to a switch. Don't rule out linebacker, either.

Let's start with the good bits. Mitchell's a grown-ass man already. His high school coach says he has an "NFL body right now and you can say he comes from special genetics"; Nick Baumgardner noted that Mitchell "looks nothing like a prospect who should still be in high school" after Michigan's trip to IMG this spring. ESPN's evaluation leads with Mitchell's impressive physical package:

Thickly built and sturdy with good height ... Moves and looks like a tall tailback. Displays power as a runner and top end speed is very competitive. May not be a jet or overly fluid speed guy, but he can accelerate on a straight-line.

Mitchell attended various Rivals camps:

every wide receiver at Sunday's camp was tall and fast, but even in a physically impressive crowd like that, Mitchell stood out. With that physique, it should be no surprise that the 6-foot-2, 197-pound Mitchell has a powerful stride and he pops in and out of his breaks. Defensive backs that try to press him are going to lose either the strength or the quickness battle, but Mitchell even exploits off coverage with his ability to create separation in his routes and by using his body to shield defenders from the football.

Reports about Mitchell's speed vary. Some say it's "good for his size". 247:

…very impressive specimen and will arrive ready to play … Runs well for a young man his size (4.67 laser-timed 40-yard dash), Mitchell is a physical football player, catches the ball well and is another that could project at other positions including safety.

Rivals repeatedly praised his ability to move to the moon: "athleticism jumps off the page": "athleticism and potential is off the charts"; "one of the best athletes in the country"; "athleticism, explosiveness, strength and speed make Mitchell one of the top wide receivers in the country"; "very explosive." Meanwhile ESPN praises his "imposing get off," which arises from a combination of strength and speed—Mitchell can blow through most attempts to press him.

When Mitchell was trying to get an OSU offer at one of their camps, Bucknuts pinged someone "inside the Woody Hayes Athletic Center" for their opinion:

"I really like him as a player,” the source said. “He's big, he's strong, and he can move for a guy who's already 215 (pounds). That said, I know we're looking at him and asking if he'll grow out of wide receiver."

His physical ability lends itself to the strongest part of Mitchell's game: YAC. He is equipped with a nasty stiffarm and once he finds himself in space with the ball he's got enough wiggle to turn opposition tackle attempts into arm tackles, which he is strong enough to blow through. Touch The Banner:

…ability to run after the catch is probably his strongest attribute. He frequently uses his long wingspan and a stiff-arm to brush away smaller defenders.

Clint Brewster:

…rugged wide receiver that is at his best running after the catch. like a running back after the catch … [picks] up tough yardage with his strength and explosiveness. He’s got strong hands and the ability to out-muscle defensive backs on jump balls or in close coverage. Mitchell… size, strength, toughness, and quick-twitch make him a coveted player. …thrives catching short passes underneath, as well as smoke-screens.

ESPN calls him a "power runner" and says he "makes most of his big plays … because he is so difficult to tackle in the open field":

he makes things happen with the ball in his hands especially when he can quickly transition after the catch as he is a one-cut, slashing type of runner. He is far more elusive that he is sudden, fluid or laterally agile. He builds to top end speed and when you think he's going to get walked down, he will somehow pull away. He's as fast as he needs to be.

Son of a Coach:

He’s physically ready to play college football right now. … decent change of direction skills, but his straight line speed is the differentiator for him. His ability to accelerate and hit another gear is outstanding. …dynamic after the catch. …strength to run through tackles … really makes him great. He has a good stiff arm that compliments and his size and power. He looks very much like a running back after the catch.

There's not much question that Mitchell is an NFL athlete. There are some scattered concerns that he got too big as a senior and lost the necessary quicks to play wide receiver, but he's listed on Michigan's roster at 205. That should be fine even if he adds the usual 15-30 pounds players usually do once they hit college. Mitchell's game is never going to be separation. If he's going to stick at wide receiver and perform it's going to be as a guy who goes up and gets contested balls.

Reports about his ability to, you know, receive things are varied. Mitchell was a big-deal top 100 prospect to just about everyone when he went to that OSU camp and dropped a bunch of passes:

"The performance at Ohio State really killed him rankings-wise," Farrell said. "That was his first appearance where he was consistently dropping passes. I wasn't at Ohio State but there's video out there, and Josh Helmholdt was there, and he just had a lot of drops. That scared the heck out of some because wide receivers need to catch the ball."

"His hands are not a concern for me. They're really not," Farrell said. "I saw him at the Rivals Camp in New Jersey and he was very good."

While dropping a guy 50 spots based on one camp when he did this

…really stood out during the drill portion of camp, separating himself with explosive speed and he made a bunch of tough one-handed catches. He is a big receiver with a lot of ranginess and he can create space against most defensive backs. Mitchell was a little too quiet during the one-on-one session.

size, explosiveness, competitiveness and reliable hands were on full display on Saturday. Cornerbacks that tried to jam him at the line of scrimmage were quickly dispatched and errant passes were hauled in with ease. There was one pass that Mitchell hauled in with one hand between two defenders. He had to pin it against his body because the defender was holding onto his other arm.

…at various preceding ones is a bit of a hair trigger reaction, Mitchell didn't provide a counterpoint. He came off a reasonably productive junior year (47 catches, 872 yards) with a bunch of hype, and then his stats fell off a cliff. As of mid-November Mitchell had just 13 catches. Per MGoBlue he finished with 30; I'm guessing most of those were within five yards of the LOS. He averaged barely ten yards a catch, and his highlights have a ton of YAC in them. The half-season senior highlights above consist of a lot of handoffs on which he gains five yards and tackles made while he plays corner. While that's not necessarily Mitchell's fault—his QB manages to wobble a two-yard crossing route in that video—recruiting sites can only go on what they see, and they didn't have much data to go on after that camp.

Mitchell's overall polish and routes are also frequently questioned. Brewster notes he's a "raw player" and "still learning from a technical standpoint"; Son of a Coach says he's "not a sharp route runner at this time". After watching his highlights I have to agree. Mitchell appeared to run three routes in high school: bubble screens, crosses, and fades—mostly the former two. The fades that should be his bread and butter don't even see him leap most of the time. He doesn't high-point the ball, and there are only a couple of catches that are contested.

As a result I don't necessarily trust a lot of the praise in Mitchell's scouting reports. Given available evidence much of it reads like "here is a trope about a big receiver". Scout:

… good hands and knows how to use his body to gain position against smaller defensive backs. He comes out of breaks well but needs to be a bit more precise in his route running. He is a tremendous competitor, and it shows when the ball is in the air. He high-points the ball, and doesn't mind going over the middle.

Former ND QB Evan Sharpley praised Mitchell's "exceptional ball skills"; BGI says the same thing. I guess this could be something he showed in camps. There's nothing in any of his highlight tapes to confirm or deny such a thing.

Mitchell enrolled early, but didn't leave much of an impression. When I saw him at Ford Field I thought he looked like a "big time athlete, very unpolished". He dropped a couple of quick passes. Meanwhile Michigan's official twitter feed tweeted out a video in which Mitchell loses a slant route to Reon Dawson because he misses his attempt to paw him away on his cut:

Despite a dearth of options that saw Shane Morris pressed into duty as a slot receiver, Mitchell wasn't targeted much in the spring game. That's not a ton of data, freshmen wide receivers are often behind, etc. Still some data, none of it pointing the right direction.

Compounding some iffy returns from Mitchell's first spring practice is an off-field incident that all the insiders have muttered about but nobody has detailed. Per Scout's Brian Dohn, Mitchell nearly decided to transfer afterwards. Some variety of suspension may be forthcoming. Whatever the issue was it was serious enough to imperil Mitchell's career at Michigan before it even started. That greatly increases the chance he ends up washing out for reasons other than his talent.

Etc.: Wearing #2. I can't decide if this is the best wolverine or the worst wolverine:


Major battle in the #WarOnRutgers:


Why Greg Mathews or Jonas Mouton? Mathews was a tall, relatively burly mid-four star guy a while back. He was reasonably fast but didn't get a ton of separation; his hands were okay, but not great. He played early largely because Michigan didn't have a lot of other options shaped like him and topped out as a 30-catch receiver as a junior and senior. Mitchell is much more of a wild card than Mathews, who seemed boring and okay from the drop. Mitchell could be anything at all.

Other comparables include Junior Hemingway, a jump-ball maestro who played at 230 pounds one year, and—if Michigan gets very lucky—former Notre Dame receiver Michael Floyd. BGI brought the latter comparison up in their film evaluation, so don't blame me for that one. Floyd ran a 4.4 40 at the NFL combine and Mitchell is unlikely to match that, but speed wasn't really Floyd's game in college.

As a safety, Mitchell's physical package is similar to Jarrod Wilson, who ran probably-generous 4.5s at Michigan's pro day at 6'1", 205… but Mitchell is already that size now. Jonas Mouton is a better fit. He entered a college a 210-pound safety and exited it a 240-pound WLB who alternated terrible plays with excellent ones for the duration of his career.

Guru Reliability: Low. Mitchell's high school is very small and their QB very limited; really no idea what he looks like in a college context. Many scouting reports seem arbitrary.

Variance: Very high. Lack of production, potential position switch, raw even at his main high school position, had early off-field incident of some variety.

Ceiling: High. NFL player lurking in there somewhere.

General Excitement Level: Moderate-minus. Washout potential is high. Pure athlete at the moment.

Projection: I'd redshirt the guy for the same reason we're all mad that neither starting safety redshirted: his ability to contribute this year is minimal and he's got a ton of upside. His early enrollment might complicate that; he would be a frustrating burned redshirt.

Either way this year is likely to be a learning experience for Mitchell at wide receiver, and then they'll poke around with him on defense during the bowl practices. Since I can read a depth chart and am high on the rest of this WR class and Moe Ways, I expect Mitchell to flip to defense at that point. There's another year of apprenticeship in there, and then maybe Mitchell can break through in year three or beyond as either a safety or linebacker.



July 11th, 2016 at 2:46 PM ^

Mitchell has a ton of upside and I wonder if the coaches thought they'd give him this spring to see if he had chops at receiver and then if not, they could "encourage" him to move to safety.  They never seemed super-high on Reese and seemed to like some of the other linebacker targets better.  On balance this might be one where the gamble didn;t work out, but there's nothing about it that looks indefensible.  This isn't Hoke passing on Lucien when he had open scholarships, or stopping the recruitment of Montae Nicholson.


July 11th, 2016 at 4:42 PM ^

And IF our coaches turn out to be wrong, and you have to admit Reese had some other very high-quality offers and signed with a traditionally very strong recruiting team, and IF Mitchell doesn't pan out for either disciplinary or skill reasons, then I think it would be fair to call the decision to EE one and turn the other away a bungle. Yes?

And that's all I was really saying. I'm not crazy about using precious EE slots on guys that get into trouble before spring practice even begins. I'm sure Coach feels the same way, And - maybe, just maybe - Mitchell takes this opportunity to shape up and becomes a great team leader and credits Harbaugh for the 2nd chance. I'm hopeful that's how it plays out.


July 11th, 2016 at 1:50 PM ^

A redshirt sounds right, but my guess is we will care less about burned redshirts in the future as Harbaugh establishes depth and a steady stream of guys who are ready to step in and fill departing stars' shoes.


July 11th, 2016 at 12:51 PM ^

This will be one of those situations that tells us something about the staff:  High potential raw athlete that may not be starting out at his ideal position.  If he can move past whatever problems he's had and put in the work, it'll come down to his development.  I have confidence in this staff.  Let's see what happens.


July 11th, 2016 at 1:13 PM ^

I honestly think how we close the 2017 class at WR may seal Ahmir's fate.  If we get both DPJ and Nico Collins, it will be impossible to see Mitchell at WR especially if he redshirts this year.  One of those two recruits is likely to step into an outside WR spot from day 1.


July 11th, 2016 at 1:29 PM ^

a large four star receiver who's best position might be difficult to peg, but likely is on defense. (Hopefully he would be a better fit at safety than Cam was). 


July 11th, 2016 at 2:03 PM ^

If Mitchell will see the field this year, and we don't have long to wait, given that the summer camp is in progress. And given that there was a lot of hype around signing day that Mitchell was possibly the most physically ready WR recruit, it's disappointing to read the more cautious assessments and rumors of an off-field issue. But whatever, he's a freshman, and its infinitely more important that Chesson and Darboh are 100% healthy and ready to continue their good work by the opener.  Otherwise, we may see some of Crawford early on (if he can beat out Ways and the always fragile Harris).


July 11th, 2016 at 5:09 PM ^

Hopefully ahmir gets his head on straight...the way this staff recruits, develops and competes doesn't matter if you're a 5 star or walk on...best guy for the team will play...oh and if we get DPJ and Nico that would be nice too : )

Perkis-Size Me

July 11th, 2016 at 7:37 PM ^

Somewhat depressing post to read given how excited we all got when he committed, but Mitchell has a lot of potential. Here's to Harbaugh unlocking that potential and us seeing Mitchell playing on Sundays in a few years.

Sent from MGoBlog HD for iPhone & iPad

Steve in PA

July 11th, 2016 at 10:55 PM ^

When he was on it was beautiful but it was punctuated by too many "What the..." moments.  Seeing him and all the LB's play gave me my first signature as a member here, "I still blame Hopson"  


I don't think we have to worry about players not reaching their potential because of coaching anymore.