2013 Recruiting: Shane Morris Comment Count

Brian August 7th, 2013 at 8:26 AM

Previously: CB Reon Dawson, CB Channing Stribling, S Delano Hill, S Dymonte Thomas, CB Ross Douglas, CB Jourdan Lewis, LB Ben Gedeon, LB Mike McCray, DE Taco Charlton,DT Maurice Hurst Jr., DT Henry Poggi, OL Patrick Kugler, OL David Dawson, OL Logan Tuley-Tillman, OL Kyle Bosch, OL Chris Fox, OL Dan Samuelson, TE Jake Butt, TE Khalid Hill, HB Wyatt Shallman, WR Da'Mario Jones, WR Csont'e York, WR Jaron Dukes, RB Derrick Green.

My editor ate DeVeon Smith, so this is out of order. No need for panic.

Warren, MI – 6'3, 200


Scout 5*, #40 overall
#3 QB, #1 MI
Rivals 4*, #81 overall
#4 pro-style QB, #2 MI
ESPN 4*, #127 overall
#8 pocket passer, #3 MI
24/7 4*, #81 overall
#4 pro-style QB, #2 MI
Other Suitors Alabama, MSU, Syracuse
YMRMFSPA Shorter, nicer Ryan Mallett or A Better Son/Daughter: Quarterback Edition
Previously On MGoBlog Hello post is like over two years ago. Ace scouts De La Salle against Pioneer. Presented without comment. Ace interviews him.
Notes Under Armour AA.


Junior highlights:

Single game highlights from Stephen Nesbitt in Morris's senior opener:

Morris is kind of the reason these posts exist. When he committed over two years ago he hadn't been rated by any recruiting service, and while Ace has diligently tracked his progress in post after post (MGoBlog has 14 pages of posts tagged "shane morris"), nowhere do we have a unified dossier of what kind of player he might be. This endeavors to be it.

When not acting as Michigan's de facto recruiting coordinator or posing for ridiculous student ID photos, Morris moonlights as a tall left-handed QB with a monster arm and accuracy issues. These issues were compounded by a senior-year bout of mono that caused him to miss a large portion of his senior year. His junior year was unimpressive statistically on a poor De La Salle team, reputedly because he got no protection and no one on his team could catch.

So his lofty rankings were a result of camp after camp, as Morris seemingly took in every 7-on-7 on offer with the travelling MaxEx team you may be familiar with as the summer home of Dennis Norfleet, Csont'e York, and Khalid Hill. A scouting sampler from those outings:

  • 247 at the Ohio E11 regional camp: "Morris is at seemingly every event he can get to, eager to prove himself. On Friday he did just. He can put loads of velocity on the ball without digging deep, he showed great accuracy throughout the day and he has a smooth and natural composure in the pocket."
  • Scout at IMG/Madden: "He is the prototypical gunslinger. He has a quick delivery and a strong arm. He doesn't need to set his feet to generate velocity on his throws and can whip the ball from several arm angles. Like most gunslingers, Morris isn't afraid to take chances with the ball. Most of the time that works to his advantage, but at times he takes unnecessary chances throwing into traffic."
  • Rivals at an NLA event in Pittsburgh when it was really coming down: "Morris continued to throw darts despite the slick conditions. He was not throwing 100 miles per hour on every pass as he will do in camp settings, but he would let one rip if he needed to fit it into a tight window. For most of the day he varied his speed and trajectory appropriately and threw a number of great passes."
  • 247 at SMSB: "Morris dropped jaws with his impeccable footwork and ultra-quick release. Morris is so smooth and sound in his mechanics and can effortlessly fire the ball down field with just a quick flick of his wrist. Morris has also bulked up to over 200 pounds of solid muscle."
  • Rivals at SMSB: "clearly stood out as the top player at his position. The Rivals100 prospect is really in control of his game right now, and his passes are coming out of his hand beautifully with velocity and accuracy. He was told by Michigan quarterbacks coach Al Borges, who was working the event, to throttle it back some on day one, but overall Morris varied his speeds well during the event."
  • Ace: "The first thing that stands out about Morris is his arm strength—the ball explodes out of his hand with seemingly little effort. When he's on, it's a sight to behold. The problem—and ultimately why he dropped in the rankings—is that he's yet to show consistency; he still needs work reading defenses and relies too heavily on his arm strength to fit the ball into windows that sometimes aren't there."

In literally every superlatives article I have come across, Morris is the guy designated "Strongest Arm" or "Howitzer" or "Hosiest Hose For Hosing" or "Most Likely To Bomb Berlin With Only His Arm," usually with an accompanying note stating "this was an easy choice." Sometimes they tell you that he can throw harder than everybody ever, like this eval from the Elite 11:

There shouldn't be much question of who has the strongest arm any more. Including the college players acting as counselors, the strongest arm at the Elite 11 Finals belongs to Morris. When push comes to shove, Morris has a laser-like focus on the left side of the field. That's a habit he'll need to outgrow.

This is the upside. Morris has a huge arm and a ton of great tools for a quarterback. ESPN's evaluation loves every part of him save one, which we'll get to later. I'll skip the stuff about the arm strength and just note the QB stuff:

He possesses terrific feet, pocket movement, awareness and can buy time with good overall athleticism for the position. …  He works through progressions nicely, can check down and work from the first option to the next. … He rarely takes his eyes down within the pocket and scans the field under pressure and will plant and throw in face of the rush. He side-steps and resets with balance and is ready to get the ball out even under duress…. He shows a consistent and quick stroke over-the-top, which is tough to find with lefties, and can beat the rush with his release consistently. He shows good ability changing ball speeds and displays touch and timing on fade and corner routes. That may be best trait Morris possesses.

Wow, huh?  

Well, the downside is that most evaluations come with a caution about consistency. ESPN flat-out states that Morris's completion percentage is "nowhere near where it should be given his tools and this is an area in need of significant improvement." Scout's eval is another example:

Scout.com Player Evaluation:


Arm Strength / Pocket Awareness / Poise and Leadership


Accuracy / Consistency / Decision-making

A better than advertised athlete who does a good job of escaping the rush and can make plays with his feet and throw on the run. … Downfield passes do not hang up and he has great placement on his deep balls. Great leader with a lot of intangibles. Sometimes trusts his arm and throws into traffic. - Allen Trieu

Y mas:

Morris had an up-and-down day, but when he hit his stride he made some incredible throws. He regularly displayed his ability to go vertical and make the big throw down the field. He also made some excellent throws underneath and into tight windows. He has a cannon for an arm and showed the ability to thread the needle at times. He battled some inconsistency and his accuracy was on and off, but still had numerous flashes of why he was so sought after.

Morris is a bit of a slow starter. A lot of evaluations say "started rough, but then warmed up," whether it's on day two of an event or just later in a competition day.

He had a stronger, more consistent day on Sunday than he did on Saturday. He has great arm strength and throws a tight spiral to all levels. He showed the ability to utilize touch and lay balls over the defense in the middle of the field. It was evident that Morris was missing some upper-tier wide receivers at the event as he was let down at times by the inability of his receivers to win well-placed balls.

…That tendency can be seen in that Pioneer game above: Morris tosses an ugly interception on his first throw of the season, misses a few guys, has another couple passes broken up, and then heats up even though his receivers generally do their best impression of Michigan State 2012.

Morris's evident upside was enough for the sites to rank him highly out of the gate, and after he was excellent at the Opening—which came right on the heels of the 7 on 7 just mentioned in which he had a he had a poor first day before leading his team to the Championship Game—he was proclaimed a five star by most sites.  Then he went to the Elite 11.

On the Elite Eleven. The once-prestigious quarterback camp has descended into reality-TV farce. Now crammed full with 25 prospects—most local camps will have half of that and give a large number of reps to the few true D-I prospects—the competition consists of around eight throws per day, frustrating scouts in attendance:

With trips to the beach for a Navy-Seal style bootcamp workout at 4 A.M. and chalk talk sessions behind closed doors, the final television product for ESPN should look spectacular when it airs in early August, but the on-field action was limited. … Ranking players off of 30 throws at a shorts and t-shirt event after having seen these players for over a year is for entertainment purposes only. Don't expect players to jump up in down in the actual Scout rankings after 30 throws.

You can see the inconsistency in the rankings: Scout named Morris the #1 guy there ("capable of making throws that only a few in his class can hope to match"), Rivals said he was #4 ("at the top because of his high ceiling"), as did 247 ("could at times approach the college counselors in terms of driving the ball down the field"), but the camp coaches left him off the "Elite 11" list that is the only semblance of the old camp.

I don't care. Both Scout and Rivals ranked all 25 QBs, placing the #1 and #2 "Elite 11" guys in their bottom five. One of those guys ended up at Fresno State and had one other offer from Mississippi State; the other is headed to Nebraska to be Taylor Martinez 2.0. People call him "Johnny Tebow" because he is a horse who can't throw. Those rankings are so intentionally bad that they may as well not exist. End Dilferrant.

Wait, more Dilferrant! AND we're talking about eight throws a day for a guy who clearly takes a little time to get in a rhythm anyway.

Anyway. Camp season wound down, Morris had a pretty damn good opening game against Pioneer. Ace:

The rough start for Morris stemmed from a combination of rushing his throws and trying to force the action too much…. throws either led receivers right into big hits or were overly ambitious tosses into small windows. …

Then Morris started to roll, reminding everyone why he was so highly touted in the first place. He showed improved touch on short and intermediate routes, as well as the ability to make an accurate throw across his body (see 3:10 mark above). He also toned down the happy feet; at 4:06, he steps up and makes an impressive throw while facing heavy pressure.

A big criticism of Morris last year focused on his often laser-like focus on the left side of the field; he'd stare down his top read and often force it there even if covered. While the pass fell incomplete, you can see the strides he's made in that regard at the 4:33 mark, as he looks off the coverage to the right, then moves on to his second read down the left sideline. That's a big advancement from last year and proof that Morris is picking up a lot from his myriad camp appearances.

And then he slowly unraveled with mono. When he came back it was not under ideal conditions. Tim Sullivan:

There was only one bad throw by Morris on which he was not being buried under pressure - the second interception. He unleashed the arm strength on that one, hoping velocity would make up for throwing it into coverage. On other throws, he was either crushed by a defensive lineman, a pass was straight-up dropped, or it was close enough that there's nothing to worry about.

He warmed up a little after those events, but by the an already-shaky De La Salle team had lost all hope of the playoffs and the season just kind of sputtered out.

Recruiting sites generally held Morris steady through his mono, but when he showed at the UA game his extremely erratic throwing (he was two of ten in the game) forced large moves down on most sites. Rivals mentioned he "did not look like himself" early. In 247's final update, Morris dropped from #19 to #81:

[Morris] continues to struggle with the accuracy aspect of being a passer, and this was especially evident the week of the Under Armour All-America game. With that being said, Morris still has plenty of potential and will likely start making gains in the accuracy department as he works to get more compact in his motion.

Morris took a similar plunge on Rivals for similar reasons:

It was a tough week for the five-star quarterback who never found his rhythm. Morris is coming off an upper respiratory illness that caused him to miss most of his senior season. His rust showed during practice and during the game. … No one can discount his arm strength, but he needs to become more consistent on his progressions and taking what the defense gives him.

ESPN had already started the process of moving Morris down when he got sick and went farther than any other site by the end of the year, likely influenced by the Elite 11 guys. 

Given Morris's tendency to start slow, this is not a surprise, nor will it be when you hear practice reports saying he's struggling early. Morris needs time to get revved up, and time to fix the mechanical regression he experienced due to his mono layoff. If Michigan has to turn to him this year, only bad things will happen; given a year or two—please be two—he has the potential to be anything he wants to be other than Denard Robinson.

Etc.: Not the guy who trolls Fall Out Boy on the internets. Family keeps him grounded. Here is an interview featuring the question "What was your response when U of M recruited you? Did you cry?"

Why Shorter, Nicer Ryan Mallett? Mallett was the hosingest hoser of them all as a five star out of Texas, but immediately alienated the entire team and Lloyd Carr in his single year at Michigan. After his transfer to Arkansas he displayed his talent for fitting balls into windows so tight they barely existed, throwing NFL lasers off his back foot, wearing backwards baseball caps, throwing arrogant interceptions, and occasionally lasering a five-yard pass into an incompletion. The end result was very Mallett: his completion percentage rose from 43% to 56% to 65% over three years in college and his YPA hit nearly 10 as a senior.

Morris is basically the same guy without the attitude and three inches of height. His challenges will be the same: throwing accurately, taking heat off the ball when he has to, and not thinking "I can make it!" when he patently cannot, at least not too often.

Why A Better Son/Daughter, Quarterback Edition? Sometimes when you're on, man.

Guru Reliability: Moderate. All the camps, but limited high school data and the great mono question about whether everyone is overreacting to a bad UA game that may be easily explainable.

Variance: High. Limited high school success and time, consistent questions about consistency, and that drop mean Morris has a high bust factor. On the other hand…

Ceiling: High. Guy could obviously be a top-level NFL prospect.

General Excitement Level: Moderate-plus. I believe Morris will round into a good player, but it's easy to see him being a pretty frustrating starter who whips in too many amazing interceptions. Variance is large. Borges's QB coaching skills will be under the spotlight here.

Projection: Redshirt all but impossible given the depth chart and the nonzero (even if slim) chance Gardner is out the door after one year as the starter. Will be the #2 this year, hopefully given over to backup duty only.

If Gardner goes, he's pretty much the starter by default with only Bellomy and a true freshman Wilton Speight for competition. If Gardner stays, Speight will be on a much more level playing field and that competition will have some doubt in it, plus there is a strong likelihood Michigan brings in a hotshot 2015 guy who would like to play Henne in a three-way artillery piece battle.


El Jeffe

August 7th, 2013 at 9:03 AM ^

Here's hoping that Shane's accuracy issues are some function of (1) having an, er,  substandard HS team and (2) the 7 on 7 and other camp premium on looking spectacular, with no PA game to set up downfield throws.

I'm just thinking that Gorgeous will be able to script some plays so that the D gets a heavy dose of Green and Harris, leading to some pretty hand-wavingly wide open WRs and TEs.


August 7th, 2013 at 9:34 AM ^

.. At least the kid can apparently take a hit!  I worry that he'll be Mallet v 2.0 (with kindess!) and just be totally maddening.  Borges may be earning his paycheck over the next several years if that is the case. 

I love the idea of a 3-way battle between Morris, Speight, and some Intergalactic Superstar QB from 2015.


August 7th, 2013 at 9:50 AM ^

Really excited about Morris.  As far as I'm concerned he's the heir apparent to the QB spot in 2015.  Now whether he actually gets there is a different question.  But the guy has arm strength and quick release to make literally all the throws on the field.  He's never shied from competition and has constantly worked to improve himself.  But he does have to make that mental leap to better decisions and clean up the consistancy.  As you say, Borges is really going to be under the spotlight here.  Morris is seemingly his ideal QB; let's see what he can do.  Plus, Morris is a local kid who absolutely loves UM.  I really want to see him succeed. 


August 7th, 2013 at 10:37 AM ^

Yeah, I would agree that in 2015 he will be the favorite to take over. Unless Gardner leaves after this season, which I personally feel may actually happen.

Some of Morris's throwing issues could probably be cleaned up with college experience and college coaching.

I would have liked to see how a full healthy senior HS season would have turned out. 


August 7th, 2013 at 1:38 PM ^

I would have liked to see how a full healthy senior HS season would have turned out.

Mono is pretty serious, and IIRC he was already feeling it by the time of that Pioneer game and ideally he should not have played.

Let's assume his acute period came not long after that (I was unconscious for a week my senior year of high school) -- so it makes sense that he would be back by the end of the season, and no doubt fully recovered by then (assuming his parents and doctors are not idiots), but with no real time to get back into rhythm.

So -- what I'm saying is, yes, we can discount pretty much everything from the Pioneer game onwards. That doesn't mean he'll end up in the first round of the NFL draft, but it does mean that there are no real signs to date that would indicate otherwise. The sky's the limit.

Real Tackles Wear 77

August 7th, 2013 at 9:51 AM ^

I think this is a great eval. However, given the pieces our staff has recruited to build around him (big-time playmakers at RB, WR, TE and across the OL), I fully expect Shane to reach the higher end of his potential. I see him as a 1st/2nd round pick in the 2017 draft who has a long NFL career.


August 7th, 2013 at 10:12 AM ^

The kid played tailback the beginning of his high school career.  I am not saying he is made of Dilithium, but he does have enough speed and escapability to make defensive lines pay if they pin their ears back and don't stay in their lanes.  That is a huge difference when comparing him to Mallet.


August 7th, 2013 at 10:31 AM ^

Kinda surprised by the moderate-plus excitement level. Sure, he has his issues, but they all seem to be coachable things, not innate traits. The innate stuff he's got in spades, and not only the howizter arm but leadership abilities as well. By all accounts, and the fact he sought out so much extra coaching, the kid seems very coachable and eager to get better, so I'm not too worried about fixing the accuracy and especially decision issues. Get him behind a decent line with competent receivers, and a great running game so he doesn't feel like he's got to carry the team on his shoulders and I think he'll do fine. 


August 7th, 2013 at 10:41 AM ^

I feel a lot better about morris after we got both Campbell and Harris.  He needs wideouts who can go spread the field deep for him, where he (with his insane arm strength) can hit them deep.  My guess is that in a few years we're going to have a LOT of long touchdowns.


August 7th, 2013 at 11:13 AM ^

But think of john Navarre a little bit when morris throwing style and ability is discussed. John Navarre with escapability and enhanced leadership and poise. I will take that any day.

Der Alte

August 7th, 2013 at 12:54 PM ^

John Navarre takes a throwback pass from Steve Breaston and scampers into the end zone, sparking one of the great comebacks in M football history. Well, maybe "scamper" is a little much, but John was a good football player who showed poise in the pocket and had a large-caliber artillery piece for an arm.

Remember, even when a QB at M, Tom B. wasn't much for "escapability" either. Anyway, I hope John is doing well at whatever endeavor he now pursues.


August 7th, 2013 at 11:54 AM ^

Seems only fitting that Deveon Smith's recruiting overview essentially was 'lost'.  I think many people have forgotten about him since the Green committment and are just assuming he will take a back seat to Derrick for a few years.  But if previous recruiting rankings have shown us anything, it is that being higher rated doesn't necessarily mean they will be better in college.  I think Mr. Smith will end up surprising a lot of people in his time at Michigan and sooner than we all think.