2011 Opponents: Northwestern

Submitted by Tim on August 26th, 2011 at 6:42 PM

This is a personnel-oriented look at the season's opponents. The game-week previews will be more matchup based. Last year's stats are presented with projected starters in bold and departed players in italics.

The Offense

Northwestern Offense 2010
Category Raw Rank
Yards Per Game 391.08 48
Points Per Game 26.38 63
Yards Per Play 5.40 70
Yards Per Pass 7.94 29
Pass Efficiency 144.37 29
Yards Per Rush 3.64 91
Playcall Distribution 1.45 Rush:Pass

Northwestern's offense was a one-man show last season, with quarterback Dan Persa accounting for 61% of the Wildcats' total yardage... despite missing three games (Denard accounted for 67% of Michigan's yardage; Persa was accounting for 76% for the Cats before he went down). If Northwestern is going to have success this year, they need to find other playmakers in the backfield to spread the ball around a bit more, especially with Persa coming off a serious injury.

Adjusting for sacks, NU called a pass for every 1.35 rushes, and if Persa is to be kept healthy, he's going to have to either pass or rush less. He's unlikely to have the same escapability as last year.


We're really tying the Dan Persa theme together here, as he was probably the player in the Big Ten that was most important to his team - yes, even moreso than Denard Robinson to Michigan. Coming of an Achilles injury is not easy to do, especially after just 10 months. That could mean some serious reps for backup Evan Watkins, who started the final three games for Northwestern last year - all losses.

Northwestern QBs 2010
Name Comp Att % Yds Yds/Att TD Int
Dan Persa 222 302 73.51 2581 8.55 15 4
Evan Watkins 36 70 52.43 378 5.40 2 5
Kain Colter 3 9 33.33 38 4.22 0 1
Northwestern QBs Rushing 2010
Name Att Yds Yds/Att TD
Dan Persa 164 519 3.16 9
Kain Colter 29 143 4.93 2
Evan Watkins 23 61 2.65 2

Grade: 3.5/5. This grade is assuming non-full health for Dan Persa (Phil Steele give him that vote of confidence, naming Persa the league's 1st-Team selection at QB). His importance to Northwestern was magnified by exactly how bad his backups were in comparison. Since he's likely to be less of a rushing threat this year, it takes him down a notch. The experience from last year - unsuccessful though it may have been - is a positive going forward for the backups. If Persa was healthy, this would likely be a 5/5.

Running Back

Despite their general ineffectiveness, a ton of different Northwestern backs got some experience last year. Mike Trumpy got by far the most run (second-most used back, Arby Fields, was by far the least effective), so I'm guessing he'll start again this year. There are three returning backs with significant experience.

Northwestern RBs 2010
Name Att Yds Yds/Att TD
Mike Trumpy 116 530 4.57 4
Adonis Smith 41 196 4.78 0
Arby Fields 62 178 2.87 1
Jacob Schmidt 49 161 3.29 4
Stephen Simmons 41 154 3.76 0
Scott Concannon 5 21 4.20 0
Northwestern RBs Receiving 2009
Name Rec Yds Yds/Rec TD
Mike Trumpy 20 182 9.10 0
Jacob Schmidt 14 114 8.14 0
Arby Fields 4 27 6.75 0
Stephen Simmons 2 9 4.50 0

Grade: 3/5. Having this much talent returning is a bright sign for Northwestern, even if they didn't have a lot of success on the ground last year. Trumpy was just a freshman last year and Fields just a sophomore, so it's reasonable to expect those guys to improve.


Jeremy Ebert was the Big Ten's most oft-deployed receiver, and turned that into the highest yardage total in the league as well. His #2, Sidney Stewart (younger brother of former Michigan DB Charles) is out the door, but plenty of Wildcats got game experience. Demetrius Fields should take over the #2 role, with Charles Brown stepping into a starting role. Drake Dunsmore got plenty of work (at "superback" in the NU offense) last year, but other than him, don't expect a ton out of tight ends.

Northwestern Receivers 2010
Name Rec Yds Yds/Rec TD
Jeremy Ebert 62 953 15.37 8
Sidney Stewart 40 454 11.35 0
Drake Dunsmore (TE) 40 381 9.53 5
Demetrius Fields 25 291 11.64 2
Charles Brown 16 198 12.38 0
Rashad Lawrence 12 178 14.83 0
Tony Jones 11 157 14.27 1
Venric Mark 5 43 8.60 0
Josh Rooks (TE) 5 24 4.80 1
Brendan Barber 2 17 8.50 0
Aaron Nagel (TE) 1 6 6.00 0
Northwestern Receivers Rushing 2009
Name Att Yds Yds/Att TD
Venric Mark 8 63 7.88 0
Jeremy Ebert 5 21 4.20 0
Charles Brown 1 3 3.00 0

Grade: 3/5. Losing the #2 receiver probably hurts, but Northwestern spread the ball around plenty last season, so the players that will be expected to step up aren't exactly green. With the Big Ten's most-prolific receiver in the fold (though Phil Steele only projects him to the All-Conference second team), the young guys should be more than capable of picking up the slack. The one question mark is a lack of serious downfield threats - partially a product of a screen-heavy NU offense.

Offensive Line

The Wildcats only lose right guard Keegan Grant from last year's starting lineup, but that may not be such a good thing, given how awful the front line was last year. NU gave up more sacks than any team in the conference, and they were in the "Minnesota-Indiana" cohort of rushing futility. NU should start three seniors this year, with Al Netter on the left side, Ben Burkett at center, and Doug Bartles taking over the RG position. Junior returning starters Brian Mulroe and Patrick Ward will play left guard and right tackle, respectively.

Grade: 3/5. The big hope for Northwestern fans here has to be that a line with very little personnel turnover will be able to build the chemistry to develop into a stronger unit. It really couldn't be a whole lot worse, as I shudder to think how terrible the line's performance could have been without Persa the whole year.

The Defense

Northwestern Defense 2009
Category Raw Rank
Yards Per Game 426.15 97
Points Per Game 29.00 77
Yards Per Play 5.94 94
Pass Yards Per Game 241.15 95
Pass Efficiency 128.98 61
Yards Per Pass 6.73 t-45
Sacks Per Game 1.23 104
Rush Yards Per Game 185.00 92
Yards Per Rush 5.15 110

So, oddly, despite Pat Fitzgerald's reputation as a hard-nosed defensive specialist and all that entails, the Wildcats' defense was pretty bad. It was probably around the same league as Michigan and Minnesota in several areas.

So, what is Northwestern going to do to improve that? Getting to the passer and stopping the run were the two major weaknesses of the D, so stepping it up along the defensive front and linebackers is of the utmost importance.

Defensive Line

The Wildcats' defensive line - weak though it may have been last year - returns three of four starters, and should have an opportunity for improvement. Vince Browne and Kevin Watt return for their senior seasons as bookends, and classmate Jack DiNardo will plug the middle. The only replacement is at the other defensive tackle spot, where Brian Arnfelt will replace Corbin Bryant. Northwestern also has a few players - most notably DEs Quentin Williams and Tyler Scott - who have a bit of experience and will play a role in the rotation.

Northwestern Defensive Line 2010
Name Tack TFL Sack
Vince Browne 58 15.5 7
Jack DiNardo 33 7 0.5
Kevin Watt 29 5.5 0
Corbin Bryant 25 8.5 1
Quentin Williams 18 3 0
Brian Arnfelt 14 1.5 0
Tyler Scott 12 3 0
Niko Mafuli 4 0 0
Davon Custis 2 0 0
Anthony Battle 1 0 0
Will Hampton 1 0 0

Grade: 3/5. It's hard to look past how bad Northwestern's run defense and sacking were last year when evaluating this unit. They should improve with three returning starters, but they have a long way to go to get out of the depths.


The Wildcats' top two tacklers from the linebacker position are out the door in Nate Williams and Quentin Davie, so there's some reshuffling to be done at the position. Bryce McNaul is the lone returning starter on the weakside. Junior David Nwabuisi is expected to fill the middle, while senior Ben Johnson will play the strongside. Sophomore Damien Proby is the only other player with significant experience anywhere other than special teams. Roderick Goodlow is coming off a mid-career redshirt thanks to a knee injury last year, as well.

Northwestern Linebackers 2010
Name Tack TFL Sack Int
Nate Williams 96 9.5 2 0
Quentin Davie 68 6 1.5 3
Bryce McNaul 62 5 1 0
David Nwabuisi 26 2 0 1
Ben Johnson 21 1.5 1 1
Damien Proby 20 1 1 0
Tim Riley 2 0 0 0
Will Studlein 1 0 0 0
Timmy Vernon 1 0 0 0
Bo Cisek 1 0 0 0

Grade: 2/5. The linebackers weren't blameless for the issues I pinned on the DL, so losing the two most productive players from a weak unit isn't going to solve anything for Northwestern. The depth is also lacking in a big way. Any injuries could spell more doom (than already exists) for Northwestern.

Defensive Backs

Justan Vaughn is the only departing DB for the Wildcats, so there's a good chance the performance along the back is improved this season. Senior Jeravin Matthews should slide in to take his spot, with 4-year starter Jordan Mabin on the other side. The situation is a little murkier at safety, with Brian Peters a lock to start at one position, but three reasonable options at the other spot. I'm guessing Hunter Bates will play FS, allowing the enormous Peters (6-4, 215) to play closer to the line of scrimmage. David Arnold and Jared Carpenter both have a bit of starting experience, and could slot in at safety, as well.

Northwestern Defensive Backs 2010
Name Tack TFL Int
Brian Peters (SS) 60 4 3
Jordan Mabin (CB) 63 0 1
Justan Vaughn 57 0 1
Hunter Bates (FS) 45 2 2
David Arnold 42 0.5 1
Jared Carpenter 27 1.5 0
Jeravin Matthews (CB) 15 0 0
Mike Bolden 15 1 0
Demetrius Dugar 10 0 0
Davion Fleming 5 0 0
Ricky Weina 5 0 0

Grade: 4/5. This is easily the strongest unit on Northwestern's entire team, with Phil Steele picking Peters to his 2nd-Team All-Conference defense and Mabin on the fourth team (though he was a 3rd-team performer in the Big Ten last year). There's also a few combinations that would result in four senior starters. Pass D was one of the few bright spots on NU's defense last year, and with even more experience, it could improve further in '11.

Special Teams

Stefan Demos - a recipient of the Brooks Bollinger Memorial Eighth Year Senior Award - has finally moved on, meaning that redshirt sophomore Jeff Budzien should become the new placekicker. Redshirt sophomore Brandon Williams will return for a second year as the starting punter.

Northwestern Kicking 2010
Name FGM FGA % Long XPM XPA %
Stefan Demos 16 23 69.57 47 34 38 89.47
Jeff Budzien 0 0 - - 1 1 100
Northwestern Punting 2010
Name Att Yds Yds/Att
Brandon Williams 61 2439 39.98

Grade: 2/5. Demos was never a superb kicker, so Budzien's inability to unseat him doesn't speak to any big upgrade there. In the punting department, Williams was steady last year, but not really very good. This should be an iffy unit.



August 26th, 2011 at 7:18 PM ^

The word is that Kain Colter is the second QB off the bench, not Watkins.  In the early going they're actually calling him "QB 1b" -- I think he might have the start against BC in week one.   Colter is an athlete, could be a RB or WR if his dreadful passing doesn't improve, though that's what people said about Persa prior to his breakout last season.


The NU concept of "superback" is bizzarre.  Dunsmore is more like a hulking un-tackleable slot than a TE, Nagel is basically a fullback, and Rooks is a blocking only TE.  Kind of.  Dunsmore is a beast.


Among the LBs rumor is that Ben Johnson has been passed at SAM, I think by Proby.


At safety, freshman Ibraheim Campbell looks to play alongside Peters.  He's alleged to be fast, which is not something you hear a lot when discussing the Wildcats.


Special teams: watch out for Venric Mark in the return game.  He's a tiny burner who took one to the house vs Wisconsin last year.  He may be more involved in the run game too, but that's just a guess.


August 26th, 2011 at 7:53 PM ^

NW actually has two kids on their team that I played HS football with. They were underclassman my senior year.

The RB Stephen Simmons was the real deal, breaking single-game, season, and career rushing records at my school, all before he was a senior.

Niko Mafuli who plays on the DL was the LT next to me on the Oline. I was a LG and a senior, and he was only a sophomore. Huge Samoan kid whose dad used to play for the Samoa National Rugby Team. The dad was even bigger than the Niko.

They were both HS studs, which just goes to show you how high the competition level is at a FBS school, even an average one.