Moon Disaster Comment Count

Brian

1/1/2010 – Michigan 14, Mississippi State 52 – 7-6, 3-5 Big Ten

Amongst the many many things posted over the weekend that could have been posted at any time in the last three years was one odd bit of history that's apropos: a letter drafted for Nixon to read in the event that Neal Armstrong and company were to die on the moon because the lander wouldn't leave.

moon-disaster

Men in charge of things make difficult decisions and live with the consequences of their actions even if they result in reading the thing William Safire wrote for you about two men watching at their oxygen gauges count down in an airless wasteland.

Back in the summer of 2008, when we were a happy-go-lucky band of mountain yodelers with flowers in our pockets and caviar dreams, I finished up that year's preview with that picture of Don Canham staring down a thicket of microphones as Bump Elliott searched for a sandwich and Bo exuded his Bo-like confidence. I've referred to it ever since, and here it is again:

bobumpdon_thumb

Lives were not literally at stake above, but even so it's hard to imagine Nixon adopting an expression that more perfectly sums up the feeling of someone who's made a big decision and now has to watch someone else execute. At the end of that post this is what I said:

We are all Don Canham now. Rich Rodriguez comes in with a wildly successful pedigree but promises to finally tear down the culture of Bo’s program, to replace it with something uncertain. This has caused apprehension in some, joy in others, and disdain verging on hatred in a select group.

The program risks changing into something people drift away from because it has drifted from them, or, worse, something that you only wish you could drift away from. It also promises fireworks and fun and victory and a feeling that’s something other than that thing we’ve felt so much before. Other fanbases go through this every five or ten or fifteen years; for us it’s been 40.

I could welcome it, I guess, or celebrate it, or proclaim inevitable dominion over the land. But I don’t feel like it. Nor do I feel like fretting over imaginary scandals future. Like Canham, I just hope it works.

I don't think it has. A game somewhere around expectations would not have moved the needle enough for slight support for Rich Rodriguez to morph into a call for firing, but I turned the game off before the third quarter was over and when I felt remorse and turned it back on a few minutes later Mississippi State had put up another touchdown. It was not around expectations, except in the ways that it was by not being around expectations in a depressing direction. Before the season I thought 7-5 would do it but now at 7-6 with every loss a blowout and three of the wins last-drive nailbiters, Michigan's progress seems minimal at best. But for the opening week, this is the worst seven-win season imaginable.

If I'm slotting Rich Rodriguez into the picture above he's on the right, and it's time to look for the guy on the left again.

Coaching Bits

On the likelihood of a change. Still nothing definitive but everything that enters the inbox adds to the circumstantial pile of evidence suggesting we're done. If Harbaugh escapes Michigan's clutches Michigan is in a bad spot because of the "process" and how much time it's left them in the event they do not immediately transition to a new coach, but having no serious options other than Rodriguez is probably the only scenario in which we don't see a change.

As to when, Tom says he's hearing there's a team meeting tomorrow at 7 PM that was scheduled before the bowl game. If that's now be a wake we'll hear about it soon after. There are unconfirmed third hand reports about coaches saying goodbye, which could mean anything from the obvious canning of Greg Robinson to a wholesale broom.

Also, while some players have been publicly supportive, a lot of parents have jumped ship and have met with Brandon expressing frustration at goings-on on the defense. Some players may have been "lost" by the bowl debacle as well.

On recent Harbaugh panic. The Big Lead probably doesn't know shit and even if he turns out right he got lucky because he's just randomly saying things people email him without even a cursory check. However, Adam Schefter is serious business and this is foreboding:

Schefter on ESPN: "Now, there is a real feeling around the league (Harbaugh) would prefer be in the NFL."

On the other hand, "a real feeling" is far from definitive and Schefter was just reporting that Harbaugh was leaning towards Michigan with the same strength—coaching change stuff is "fluid," and by fluid people mean "batshit."

On Brady Hoke. "Not an option."

On Plan B. The Plan B name in the event Harbaugh escapes is probably Northwestern's Pat Fitzgerald. Fitzgerald actually makes quite a bit of sense as a young guy with a spotless media profile who runs a spread offense Denard would feel at home in. He hasn't put together a monster team or anything but recovered from a shaky start in the aftermath of Randy Walker's death to go 9-4, 8-5, and 7-6. Not exactly Harbaugh and another guy who'd be leaving his alma mater for greener pastures, but Michigan is not in a great spot right now.

Comments

SmithersJoe

January 3rd, 2011 at 4:46 PM ^

I think for coaches like Gary Barnett @ NW and Ty Willingham @ Stanford, they would have been better off staying where they were. Modest success in those programs can earn you as close to lifetime employment as you can get in this business today. That's why I don't think Patterson leaves TCU, or Fitzgerald leaves NW. In some ways, in retrospect, it might have been better for everyone if RR stayed at WVU.

bronxblue

January 3rd, 2011 at 7:13 PM ^

I'm sure this has been said somewhere else in the thread (I probably missed it), but don't ever, EVER trust anything from The Big Lead when it comes to college football except their analysis after the fact (which is also usually wrong, but at least factually more sound because they are just repeating news reports).  If JH hasn't signed a contract with an NFL team or Stanford and threw his keys, passport, train passes, donkey, etc. into the Pacific Ocean, he is still a possible HC here at UM.

Eye of the Tiger

January 4th, 2011 at 12:36 AM ^

I sincerely hope there are more options in Brandon's head and rolodex than being discussed here or in the media.  Where do the known options leave us?  With Harbaugh as the increasingly shaky first choice.  With Hoke and Fitzgerald as uninspired and uninspiring second choices.  With Patterson and Petersen as unlikely but tempting possibilities,* and with Les Miles as the crazy hermit in the woods who might just turn out to be our Yoda, but is in all likelihood neither ours nor Yoda.

We need more options.  I'm particularly keen on defensive-minded coaches, as that's our main deficiency.  I'd like to see DB consider the following:

1. Kirby Smart (Alabama DC)

Their defenses are very, very good, especially, it seems, against Big 10 teams.  He could bring on a spread-oriented OC for continuity.  

2. Gary Pinkel (Missouri HC)

String of success at a traditional doormat in the Big 12, runs a spread that can be adjusted to our players, and we can pay him more than Mizzou.

3. Nick Aliotti (Oregon DC)

Yes, Oregon is ranked #26 in yards and #12 in scoring defense.  But their defense is fast, aggressive and doesn't get tired even though their offense scores so quickly (like our offense does, but theirs is both better and more consistent).  In fact, they seem to get noticeably better in the second half.  That makes me think he's good at adjusting at halftime, and can get a lot out of his players.  Could poach someone else from Chip Kelly's staff to run the offense.  

4. Jim Heacock (OSU DC)

So this would be sleeping with the enemy, but it DID work out well the last time we poached one of them, didn't it?  OSU's defense is great every year, and then seem to have a secret vat where they clone dominating middle linebackers.  We could gain access to that vat technology.  Plus this would add a much-needed shot-in-the-arm to a rivalry that wasn't even competitive the last 4 times.  

In all cases, I think Jimmy is still our #1, but I'd put all of these before Fitzgerald, personally, and probably before Hoke too (though I think he's done an excellent job this year, his overall record leaves something to be desired).  

 

*I'd be happy with Patterson or Petersen, because they've demonstrated a high level of success with second-tier recruits.  But then again, there's more than an echo of Rich Rodriguez in those narratives, i.e. highly successful coach reaches brick wall at current institution, seeks to cement legacy by returning michigan to former glory.  So I'm a little hesitant to sign on completely...we know from RR's time here that just because you had success somewhere smaller, doesn't mean that assumed upgrade in recruits will translate to success here.