Preview: 2016 Orange Bowl Comment Count

Brian

10324460 (1)Essentials

WHAT Michigan vs
Florida State
WHERE The Orange Bowl,
Miami, FL
WHEN 8 Eastern
December 30th, 2016
THE LINE M -7
TELEVISION ESPN
TICKETS From $184
WEATHER clear, 60-ish
 
Many numbers herein courtesy Pro Football Focus.

Overview

Michigan and FSU are both vying to prove to the world that they are the top five team they were purported to be before the season, so the Orange Bowl has some stakes. You know the picture above, and you know that it came after Michigan beat a very good Alabama team in this game. Playoff or not, there will be a flaming spear in the field tomorrow and that means quite a bit.

Not that I have to tell anyone who's playing under Jim Harbaugh that.

Run Offense vs FSU

lostfound_17915996_8col

Tupou 2.0?

FSU has a good-but-not great defense prone to breakdowns. S&P+ has them 18th in the country overall; they're 31st against the run. FSU is relatively good at preventing "successful" plays and bad at preventing big ones. They rank 103rd in S&P+'s explosiveness metric, though the raw numbers are more positive. They're middle of the pack in the ACC at 20+ yard runs ceded.

A whole season picture may be excessively harsh, however. FSU was bombed in back to back games by Louisville and South Florida early in the season; since they've crushed various bad ground games and suffered the likes of North Carolina and NC State to squeeze out four yards a pop. Michigan's rush offense is 42nd in S&P+, not in the same class as UL (1st nationally) or USF (8th), and they can expect a struggle.

DT Derrick Nnadi drives the bus for FSU; his PFF +24 as a rush defender came in just 480 snaps. That's about 50% better than any of Michigan's diverse and sundry interior DL on a per-snap basis. FSU's production falls off after that, with a couple of guys around +10 and then some other folks who have scraped above zero. Brian Burns, a five-star recruit rushed to the starting lineup, is the weak point. This is because he is a 220 pound WDE.

The rest of the defense has been decidedly meh, especially with starting safeties Derwin James and Ermon Lane ruled out. LB Josh Sweat has been up and down, offsetting a solid run grade with dismal pass rush; fellow starting LBs Matthew Thomas and Ro'Derrick Hoskins are almost perfectly average. The secondary is poor in rush D, and with some young or inexperienced players trying to fill Lane's shoes there's a decent chance a run that reaches the third level finds air.

Getting there is rather the trick for a Michigan rushing offense that's scuffled late in the year. Michigan has two good OL in Mason Cole and Erik Magnuson; the remainder of the line has been sketchy at best. While FSU presents a couple weaknesses OSU didn't have, Nnadi is about as good as Iowa's Jaleel Johnson, and Johnson dominated his matchup on the interior.

Michigan will move the ball in fits and starts; expect some big plays and some second and thirteens.

KEY MATCHUP: BEN BREDESON versus A MONTH OF PRACTICE TIME. Best bet for Michigan is for Bredeson to get radically better a la a few players from last year's bowl game. Nobody else has the kind of upward mobility he does, and if Michigan doesn't get a better performance out of their OL than they did against OSU it's going to be a lot of grunting for little product.

[Hit THE JUMP for oh man this OL versus Michigan's DL]

Pass Offense vs FSU

demarcus-walker

Walker is coming for you

Absurd person DeMarcus Walker has 15 sacks on the year, a +40 PFF grade, and a fringe first round NFL draft grade. At a burly 6'4", 280, he's a strongside end that brings an incredible amount of pass rush and is hopefully a preview of what Rashan Gary will be next year. As far as this year goes, you're going to find out what it looks like when Taco Charlton goes up against Michigan's tackles in practice. Projection: not well for the tackles.

Nnadi and Burns are also impact rushers, though Burns's sack numbers (10) appear to exceed his current ability. He's +6.5 as a rusher to PFF and doesn't have the same kind of ancillary hit/pressure numbers that Walker or the various Michigan DL do. He looks to be feasting off of sacks Walker is forcing but not collecting.

Add it up and this is the #3 team in adjusted sack rate. Michigan's not bad at protecting—27th—and Wilton Speight has proven that he's got a knack for buying time in the pocket. It is still reasonable to expect Walker and company to disrupt a number of drives.

When Michigan can protect Speight they should have a good time. FSU is a bottom-tier ACC team when it comes to surrendering long passes—they're about Wake Forest's equal at 20+ and 30+; they're 95th in the PFF explosiveness metric. That was with Lane, a freshman converted WR who wasn't good but was significantly better than FSU's alternatives.

Top CB Tarvarus McFadden is a quality player with a Stribling-like PFF grade; Marquez White is a little better than average, and then things get hairy. Whoever ends up playing at safety or nickel corner is going to be a middling-at-best player who has to check Jake Butt or whoever Michigan throws in the slot. Grant Perry's absence will hurt, since he had a breakout bowl game and was productive against Ohio State. In his stead Michigan will look to one of their three freshman slot types or possibly Drake Harris.

Most of Michigan's offense will come through the air; it's critical for Michigan to get Walker thinking screen or run or draw and give whoever ends up with him the requisite amount of help. Michigan will look for a healthy Wilton Speight to have the same kind of eye-opening performance Jake Rudock had a year ago. The outcome of this game largely rests on whether Speight is the flamethrower he was after the bye week or the guy who clunked around against Iowa and didn't even attempt a deep ball against OSU.

KEY MATCHUP: EVERYBODY versus WALKER. Kori the Cord Guy will be involved in some protections.

Run Defense vs FSU

ORANGE_BOWL_FLORIDA_ST-COOK_Football_37484

beep beep

This is Dalvin Cook versus the world. Cook is, in a word, ridiculous. Youtube is littered with totally rad and unwatchable Cook highlight videos; here's a relatively demure set of highlights from this year's Clemson-FSU game:

If you let this man get the edge you will be lining up for an extra point block. He carries a +22.4 rushing grade from PFF and is possibly the best back in the country.

The problem for Florida State is everyone else. No FSU regular grades out positively as a run blocker other than left tackle Roderick Johnson, who's +5. The rest of the OL ranges from –11 to 0 save Cole Minishew, who we're projecting as a starting guard amongst considerable uncertainty. Nine different Seminole OL have seen at least 150 snaps; only Johnson and Minishew are positive, or anywhere near it. Center Alec Eberle is –14; RT Rick Leonard is –12, and both of those guys have racked up those numbers in 50-60% of FSU's snaps. There are OL playing for Rutgers who would press for playing time on this line.

Compounding matters is poor peripheral blocking. FSU's outside receivers are both in the red; TE Ryan Izzo is about even, and he's been hit with a bunch of holding calls.

So this might look oddly familiar. Michigan's played some electric scatback types saddled with terrible offensive lines this year. Games against Penn State and Maryland saw Saquon Barkley and Lorenzo Harrison struggle to find anything between the tackles. Barkley got a couple chunks on short passes, and Harrison beat Mike McCray to the edge for a first down here and there. FSU will probably emulate these teams. They'll attempt to avoid Michigan's defensive tackles at all costs and hit Michigan on the edges or try to exploit their linebackers in space.

The good news for Michigan is that Don Brown is familiar with Cook and Florida State. Last year's Boston College-FSU game was a great defensive performance that was, as usual, ruined by the BC offense. FSU gained just 217 yards; Cook was held to 3.6 YPC on 15 carries. Brown won't be caught out by the things FSU tries to do, except for the usual we-had-a-month-to-prepare stuff that both teams will be armed with.

QB Deondre Francois is an athletic guy who could help balance things out for FSU but the Seminoles are loathe to put too much more on his plate. FSU's called just 45 QB runs this year. That's about 4 carries a game.  He might get Michigan for a chunk or two on a called play. He won't be JT Barrett.

Given the matchup between Michigan's DL and FSU's OL this should be an exercise in discovering how much Dalvin Cook can make by himself against an elite defense. Survey says: some. Cook's going to get stuffed a ton and end up in a very dangerous situation two or three times. Michigan needs to keep those latter events to 20 yards instead of 70.

One thing to watch out for here: Cook has fumbled six times this year, losing four.

KEY MATCHUP: MICHIGAN SAFETIES, INCLUDING JABRILL PEPPERS, versus 70 YARD COOK TOUCHDOWNS. If it comes to it, Michigan should repeat Dymonte Thomas's approach against Barkley: give up an extra ten yards to make sure you can live to fight again after a 30 yard chunk.

Pass Defense vs FSU

9641265-clelin-ferrell-deondre-francois-ncaa-football-clemson-florida-state-850x560

the past and hopefully the future

Chances are that when you turned on an FSU game this year you saw one of three things: 1) Deondre Francois getting obliterated, 2) a replay of Deondre Francois getting obliterated, or 3) a montage of various times during the game when Deondre Francois got obliterated.

This is slightly misleading. FSU is by no means a good pass-protecting line, but they're not totally horrendous. Francois got sacked 32 times this year; FSU ended up 85th in sack rate allowed.  PFF charged FSU blockers with 24 hits above and beyond those sacks and 72 hurries. Francois dropped back 450 times this year, and got some form of pressure 29% of the time. This is about NCAA average. You remember Francois getting obliterated because the FSU games you turned on were probably Louisville and Clemson. Those elite pass rushes combined for 11 sacks.

Speaking of elite pass rush, here are Michigan DL PFF grades in that department: +20, +19, +17, +13, +10, +6, –1. Matt Godin is the only Michigan DL with 150+ snaps who doesn't have an excellent grade in that department, and Ben Gedeon and Mike McCray did a bunch of damage themselves. Michigan had 48(!) sacks, 69(!) QB hits aside from those, and 169(!!!) hurries.

That is 286 pressure events on 301 passes, and now we know that PFF will hand out multiple pressure events per play. Francois will be running for his life. Like Cook, he might be fumbling as he does it. He's put it on the ground eight times this year.

When afforded opportunities to do anything else Francois has an excellent receiving corps. #1 Travis Rudolph has been omnipresent for FSU this year, and if his raw numbers aren't amazing (53 catches, 798 yards) that's mostly because FSU spreads the ball out more thoroughly than anyone in the country. Seven different players have 30+ targets; Rudolph leads with 88. His 60% catch rate and 9.1 yards per target are both excellent. Funchess-esque Auden Tate is the deep threat and even more efficient; Jesus Wilson, Nyqwan Murray, and Kermit Whitfield are all interchangeable slot types. FWIW, Tate was spotted in a no-contact jersey a few days ago and may be dinged or unavailable.

Meanwhile, Cook pops up again here as a lethal threat. 10.7 yards per target is an insane number for a running back. He's got 31 catches on the season and figures to add another half-dozen tomorrow.

Michigan matches up well against this unit. They can expect to win most of the battles on the outside without help and the two primary safeties have been excellent in coverage against slots much of the year. Meanwhile, pass rush. The chief dangers are broken plays when Francois escapes the pocket and the threat of a screen, checkdown, or wheel route to Cook.

KEY MATCHUP: LINEBACKERS IN SPACE against DALVIN COOK AGAIN. Akrum Wadley and Saquon Barkley had a ton of success on quick throws. Michigan DL will probably search out Cook and chip him coming out of the backfield, slightly blunting the pass rush in exchange for what they hope will be the neutralization of FSU's top threat.

Special Teams

FSU is undergoing a #collegekickers period here. Freshman Ricky Aguayo was yanked from the Florida game after a miss (from 49) and a block; it looks like fellow freshman Logan Tyler is set to replace him. Tyler's 1/2 on the year but that make was from 53. Aguayo is 17/24 this year  with a clear bifurcation. He's 11/11 from within 40 and 6/13 outside of 40; S&P+ has him slightly above average.

Tyler is also the punter. Typically Ruthless PFF Special Teams Grader has him –22.4 and this makes sense. Only about a quarter of his punts are returned but FSU is giving up 21 yards a pop on those 13 returns, with huge chunks ceded in multiple games. His net of 34 yards is Not Good.

FSU has gotten little from their return units aside from an 89-yard punt return TD against Charleston Southern; they have suffered the punt coverage follies described above and have been solid on kickoffs. Tyler puts two thirds of his kickoffs into the endzone.

Add it up and FSU is 125th in FEI's special teams metric, with punting both ways killing them—FEI disregards FCS games so the Noles don't get credit for that TD. Michigan is second. With Kenny Allen seemingly over his early-season slump Michigan should have a clear advantage here. How much of one depends on how many returnable punts Jabrill Peppers gets, how far away from him FSU defenders are, and if Michigan gets its hands on another punt.

KEY MATCHUP: AHHHH YOU PUT IT THROUGH THE UPRIGHTS.

Intangibles

11694385444_57bac20446_z

Cheap Thrills

Worry if...

  • Dalvin Cook runs a wheel route.
  • Dalvin Cook breaks contain on the edge.
  • Dalvin Cook DeMarcus Walker is bearing down on Speight's blindside.

Cackle with knowing glee if...

  • Francois looks like Devin Gardner about halfway through the game.
  • Speight looks like a killer after another opportunity to regather himself and absorb some Harbaugh coaching.
  • The huge gap in special teams metrics pays off.

Fear/Paranoia Level: 5 (Baseline 5; +1 for Oh God Dalvin Cook, –1 for Don Brown Kind Of Owns Him Though, +1 for Oh God DeMarcus Walker, +1 for And Some Other Dudes, –1 for Harbaugh Bowl Motivation Edge Theory, –1 for Seriously, Rutgers-Class OL, +1 for Quasi Road Game, –1 for You Can Feel The Peppers Special Teams Play Coming.)

Desperate need to win level: 8 (Baseline 5; +1 for This Is An Important Bowl, +1 for When Do We Ever Play FSU?, +1 for So Are We A Top Five Team Or Not, +1 for Many Farewells Will Go Well Or Badly, –1 for Lingering Bitter Hangover).

Loss will cause me to... block/mute scathing hordes of #FSUtwitter.

Win will cause me to... get blocked by all of #FSUtwitter

The strictures and conventions of sportswriting compel me to predict:

A defensive game dominated by the respective DLs that will be hard to pry apart unless 1) Cook blows up and through 75 tackles or 2) Speight looks like unkillable robot Speight again. If neither happens this will be frequent punting and a lot of quarterbacks looking for help.

Michigan should have the edge there. Both pass rushes are killer; FSU has a below-average pass pro line versus Michigan's good one. Meanwhile FSU has been shredded on punt returns and does not have Michigan's punt block chops; they're also enduring turmoil at kicker. A field position game favors Michigan. Unless it doesn't in the low-sample, high variance world of special teams, but I can only project the past into the future no matter how many times that's seemed dumb.

Finally, three opportunities for me to look stupid Sunday:

  • Speight passes for 300 yards and looks like the kind of guy who can carry a young team next year.
  • Francois is sacked 6 times.
  • Michigan, 25-18

Comments

TrueBlue2003

December 29th, 2016 at 9:17 PM ^

one of the last plays of the game!  And the argument about the run game is once again, totally irrelevant.  Sure, if we could run for a first down every play, regardless of how bad the QB is playing, we could win every game with me at QB.  They were stacking the box though!  Daring the game manager to make a play and he didn't make enough of them.  And that proves my entire point above.  Our run game isn't good enough that all we need is a game manager to win every game.  We need a guy that'll make some plays.  Speight was very good most of the year.  Not against Iowa.

beef supreme

December 30th, 2016 at 1:05 PM ^

There is no way the current iteration of speight that I saw against Iowa, Wisconsin and anyone else with a pulse defensively carries us as a young team next year. He needs to improve ALOT or I would personally rather have peters in there. If speight is just gonna bog us down I'd rather the rd frosh got his feet wet.

nappa18

December 30th, 2016 at 9:12 AM ^

You forgot about the other INT that led to TD making the score 17-14. And the fumble on the Ohio 2 that wasn't as costly as it could have been because we stuffed the faked punt and scored anyway right after that.
The pick 6 was huge, can't just make light of that.

Truth is, and yes, our run game was deficient in those games, Speight came up small in our 2 road losses. Hey, the defense gave up 12 against Iowa and really only 3 against Ohio. Have to win games like that.

Freaky Reaky

December 29th, 2016 at 7:08 PM ^

he's never looked good in a big game is because our running game has suffered. Had we been able to run the ball successfully against OSU in the fourth quarter, we could have closed out that game. Also, against Iowa I think we didn't even manage 100 yards rushing on the game. He's made some mistakes, sure, but when you need to rely that much on your passing game, you're setting yourself up for some of those mistakes.

TrueBlue2003

December 29th, 2016 at 7:26 PM ^

they stacked the box and they intentionally made it easy on him.  Their secondary was awful and he had lots of wide open deep balls that he missed.  That was on him.

Against OSU he played very good considering his health - except for the two big mistakes.  The Butt drop and two blatantly missed PIs ended three drives in OSU territory.

Freaky Reaky

December 29th, 2016 at 8:16 PM ^

But it also plays into part of my argument - if you're placing the overall success of your offense on just a handfull of deep throws (which, I agree, were open and should have been completed), you're relying on only a few, high variance plays to determine the success of the offense. I think the lack of consistency in the running game and short passing game ultimately cost us against Iowa. I think we agree completely on what stalled the offense in the OSU game.

TrueBlue2003

December 29th, 2016 at 9:19 PM ^

of the game was better, than yes, we would have won the game.  My argument is that the non-peppers run game had no reasonable expectation to be better with the stacked box, it being their strength, our mediocre run blocking, and Speight showing no ability to hit the deep ball.  The only low-hanging fruit that should have been better was Speight hitting a long TD bomb or two (not much to ask given all the opportunities), which may have then opened up the run game, or the coaches not running poorly designed Peppers read-options into the scrape exchange.

Amaznbluedoc

December 29th, 2016 at 10:45 PM ^

Partially true and it's difficult at times to know what Harbaugh sees in him? Is he the best we have, does Jim see some of himself in Sp8, or are there other unforeseen factors? Perhaps, we just expect too much? Look ohio and 'bama don't have exceptional talent at qb yet they managed to get the job done this year while we did not. That's why we're playing in FL.

funkywolve

December 29th, 2016 at 11:39 PM ^

That's what I wonder.  These are the  stats for past UM QB's in their first yr of starting.

Speight:  183 out of 293 (62.5%), 2395 yds, 17 tds, 6 ints, 145.6 qbr (qbr is from espn)

Brady: 200 out of 323 (61%), 2427 yds, 14 tds, 10 ints, 133.1 qbr

Henne: 240 out of 399 (60.2%), 2743 yds, 25 tds, 12 ints, 132.6 qbr

Navarre: 186 out of 346 (53.8%), 2195 yds, 17 tds, 12 ints, 116 qbr

Greise (97 season):  175 out of 277 (63.2%), 2042 yds, 14 tds, 5 ints, 138.2 qbr

Collins:  189 out of 246 (63.9%), 2509 yds, 17 tds, 7 ints, 149.3 qbr

Grbac:  155 out of 266 (58.3%), 1911 yds, 21 tds, 10 ints, 137.2

beef supreme

December 30th, 2016 at 1:14 PM ^

Don't really see how these stats are relevant. We can beat Ucf and Rutgers with very little at qb. In every big game he struggled. And I'm not saying he didn't makes some plays against osu. But two picks and a fumble at the two. This is what qbs sign up for. Obviously harbaugh felt more confident turtling in the msu and osu game instead of continuing to press the pedal to the floor, which to me is a red flag as he is always throttle down.

funkywolve

December 30th, 2016 at 2:57 PM ^

After Michigan went up 17-7, these were their possessions:

1st and 10:  run for 4 yds

2nd and 6:  incomplete pass

3rd and 6:  screen pass to Smith for first down, called back due to Cole facemask penalty

3rd and 5:  13 yd pass to Perry

1st and 10:  run for -4 yds

2nd and 14:  pass intercepted

next possession

1st and 10:  pass for 8 yds

2nd and 2:  run for 3

1st and 10: incomplete pass

2nd and 10: run for 5

3rd and 5: incomplete pass

next possession

1st and 10:  incomplete pass

2nd and 10:  run for 0 yds

3rd and 10:  sack

Last possession of regualtion

1st and 10:  run for 2

2nd and 8: run for 4

3rd and 4: incomplete

bronxblue

December 29th, 2016 at 5:57 PM ^

Going to be a close game I guess, unless guys start checking out mentally on either side.  FSU is talented but people just assume that means they are better than UM because of it, even though UM has recruited as well and has a more experienced and talented team across the board.

uminks

December 29th, 2016 at 6:00 PM ^

Wilton. FSU is going to stop the run and Wilton will need to have a good passing game. If he chokes and throws INTs and end up losing, I bet Peters over takes him in summer camp. If Wilton has a fine game, I think he will be our starter next season.

Freaky Reaky

December 29th, 2016 at 6:58 PM ^

on the importance of the passing offense to Michigan's success in this game, I can't imagine that Harbaugh's choice for starting quarterback next season will depend solely on the outcome of this game. Especially if some of Speight's mistakes are related to a lack of protection in the pass game.

evenyoubrutus

December 29th, 2016 at 6:45 PM ^

I feel like Speight is about to have a game like Tom Brady's Orange Bowl. Yes, that is undoubtedly blind homerism on a disgusting level, however, Harbaugh said at one point in the last couple weeks that he thinks Speight could be one of the best QB's in college football next year. Has he ever been wrong when he makes predictions like that?

M and M Boys

December 29th, 2016 at 7:44 PM ^

Hey, I wanted to give everyone on MGOBLOG a heads-up!  I just received a text from a buddy of mine who has two great tickets to the Orange Bowl Game.  When he bought the tickets he didn't realize that the game is on the same day as his twice-moved Wedding Date so he can't go.

If anyone is interested and wants to go instead of him it's at Ann Arbor St. Thomas Church at 6PM.  Her name is Brenda..  She's 5'4" and about 125 pounds and is a good cook.  She'll be wearing a white dress.  

jdon

December 29th, 2016 at 9:08 PM ^

we will be up 10 to start the 4th quarter.  Then we will learn just what our team learned the last three games...

I expect us to win going away, by 24, but I would bet just about anything that we are up 10 at the begining of the 4th.

I feel it.

High expectations and imminent doom...