OT: Damon Knox not returning for a 6th year
MSU will lose some depth at the DL position as one of their potential 6th year seniors will not be returning in 2016. Mcdowell will still be good but this should help our OL in that game. The big announcement will be whether Ed Davis will come back.
This is pretty important. State graduated 3 starting DL players this year, and two others were kicked off the team this spring. Knox would have probably started, especially since they don't have any veterans at DT.
State still has a lot of bodies and some talented players on DL, but most of them are very young. DL minus McDowell could be an issue for State next year,
MSU is graduating a couple players, and Knox potentially would have been a starter. But they are returning a potential All-American, and DL may be their deepest position as they have recruited well there the last couple years. And Knox wasn't a starter last year.
I don't think potentially losing Ed Davis will be a big deal to them either. Their LBs were solid last year, and they return almost all of them. The guy I think they quietly may need is actually Brandon Clemons. Their OL does not have much proven depth, and the way they were rotating guys this spring makes me believe they don't know what they have at OL. They lost 3 starters on OL including quite possibly the best OT in school history (without steroids).
Aren't Spartan fans always the ones claiming that recruiting means nothing, and MSU 2*'s are better than any 4* in the nation, once they have a spring practice with Coach D.
I kid, I kid.
But for them to be relient on RS Fr and Tr Fr is ominous, no matter the ranking.
I mean shoot, look at us with Gary. I'd say 30% of the board thinks it's best to slowly bring Gary into the rotation, as he shouldn't just take a starting job away from an experienced player.
State will be in trouble against the IU's, ND's, OSU's. Any team that runs tempo will expose their lack of experience on the defensive front. Their returning LB's will have a ton of responsibility, and will have to cover up the mistakes made by their young DL.
May have some growing pains, but it will be easier to adjust with a disruptive player like McDowell who requires so much attention. And with the number of 4-star DL they have recruited in the last 3 years, I am guessing at least a couple of them will be players.
I think people are overrating the some of the losses here. Calhoun was a player. But Joel Heath and Lawrence Thomas were not All-Big Ten players. It's possible they may not have as much dropoff at those positions especially considering they are replacing them with 4-star players that MSU was not able to pull as frequently in the past.
And yet Heath and Thomas played many of the minutes and all this 4* talent you speak of did not.
These 4* players were redshirting or not on the roster last year. I'm sure people were saying the same things about Joel Heath and Lawrence Thomas 2 years ago. Heath was a lightly recruited player, and Thomas was a player MSU was moving to his 3rd position (previously LB & FB). The pool of players MSU is working with this year is potentially better based on recruiting rankings.
They're not just losing their three starters. They've lost three besides though. Even if they're good, they'll be thin.
Which means very few people know how they will perform. It took Thomas (a five star talent to some) four years and three positions to consistently find the field. Maybe these freshman will be ready, or maybe they will need another year or two of coaching up.
Thomas and Heath were both 2-year starters. It took them 2-3 years to figure it out, not four.
We don't know how they will perform, and that was part of the point I was making. The probability is better for them now than it was back then because they are working with better rated recruits along with McDowell returning. There is a chance that it will be a liability for them, but I am guessing it won't be.
You are underestimating their losses. They have lost three potential starters/heavy rotation guys in a month.
On average, you are going to lose 2 contributors on the DL every year. The same thing happens every year: people tend to overrate upperclassmen and underestimate recruits and unproven underclassmen. Joel Heath and Lawrence Thomas were solid players, but they weren't All-Big Ten level players. Those kind of players are replaceable. Shilique Calhoun is a loss, but I think their backup Cooper showed some flashes last year.
The thing for me is that they have recruited well at DL; it is arguably the best position they have recruited in the last 3 years, and probability says a couple of those 4-stars will be players. I don't even think MSU is in the top 3 in terms of DL losses in the Big Ten East Division. Look at the players PSU, OSU, and Maryland are losing.
I think their OL is the bigger concern for MSU.
You just negated your own point. Typically you lose 2 on the DL---they've lost 6
Lose 2 starting DL. I am not talking about players deep on the depth chart. They lost 3 starting DL, and the other 3 had very little impact, if any, on the field. And they are returning their best DL.
Damon Knox was not a starter, and it would have taken him 6 years to potentially become one. I think that says something about his talent level. MSU had a similar player a couple years ago in Tyler Hoover. Hoover as a 6th year was OK but nothing special. People are acting like Knox was some kind of stud.
If you go over to RCMB even they're admitting this is big.
MSU graduated 3 starters, and their two best returning interior lineman were kicked off the team in this past month. Knox was going to be a starter and they have no depth on the interior now. All of theirs DL contributors minus McDowell are going to be freshman, RS or true. Considering MSU has made their mark based on developing young players and letting them sit, this is going to be a new thing for them. Definitely a big deal.
I find that the type of brahs that post on rcmb are pretty much always wrong. If they're saying this is a big deal it probably isn't.
Sent from MGoBlog HD for iPhone & iPad
They also lost Evans who was looking like a an All Big Ten type DT. Their D-line is seriously lacking experienced depth right now.
They are going to likely need one of their true freshman to make the rotation.
was entirely expected, correct?
Msu people thought their 6th years would be coming back but maybe that was just Davis.
Knox practiced and was listed as a starter through the Spring. The Mlive Sparty promoters (Griffith) and the Spartan program has acted like a 6th year was inevitable.
It's almost like Dantonio is shoving an agenda at the NCAA to see if he can get away with it.
But then they didn't even apply. Maybe Davis decided it wasn't worth waiting to see what happened? Maybe he got a job offer and decided to take the opportunity.
He never actually applied for a 6th year.
6 years and I still don't know the name.
6 years of college down the drain
Could possibly return for 7th, 8th, or 9th year, or as many as needed to graduate.
A lot of people go to college for 7 years...
They're called doctors
Shut up, Richard
Fucking Stanford Robotics
or Van Wilder
Were you calling from a walkie talkie
Sent from MGoBlog HD for iPhone & iPad
Did I hear a "niner" in there?
....or lawyers.
They usually require 8 years.
"OT: Sparty DL you've never heard of not returning for 6th Year" or "I scoured the interwebs for negative Sparty info and all I found was this lousy nugget about Damon someone".
Or "My name's Sopwith and I did my best to act like an assclown."
no, I've considered your input, and I think my suggestions are better. I mean, why would Thadmattasagoblin have named his post "My names's Sopwith....?" Amirite?
I feel bad for the kid, but it's a hard Knox life!
(Disclaimer: I posted this 3 weeks ago, but the thread had over 300 comments, and this got buried. I got into a good discussion with Kevin Holt regarding this topic though)
I decided to do a little more digging into the details during each players redshirt years.
Damon Knox: 2011- His first year on campus. Took the typical true freshman redshirt year, and earned scout team defensive player of the week twice during the season. No mention of injury. 2012: His RS Freshman year: He played the first 2 games of the season. Mention of injury, but no details made public. Graduated in December 2015, and is working on a graduate degree now. 2013-2015 Played role in at least 8 games in each of the 3 seasons as a RS So, RS Jr, and RS Sr. The media mentions 4 missed games in 2014 for a back injury, but since he played in 8 games that season, missing those 4 games means nothing.
Damon Knox: 6th year verdict DENIED
Ed Davis:2011: First year on campus. Took the typical true freshman redshirt year, and earned scout team player of the week twice. No mention of injury. 2012 RS Fr year: Played in all 13 games. 2013 RS So year: Played in all 14 games. 2014 RS Jr year: Started in 12 games. 2015 RS Sr year: Missed entire season with ACL injury. This injury is significant enough to warrant a 6th year, IF and only IF during his True Fr RS year, he was ALSO incapacitated with a significant injury. This does NOT appear to be the case. He is expected to graduate this Spring, and then must enroll into a graduate program. Missing only 1 year to a season ending injury is not enough to qualify for a 6th year!
Ed Davis: 6th year verdict DENIED
Brandon Clemons: 2011: First year on campus; took the typical true freshman RS year. 2012: RS Fr year: Missed "majority" of season with a foot injury. Named scout team player of the week once. 2013-2015 RS So - RS Sr years: Saw action in at least 6 games every year. Graduated in December 2015, and must enroll into graduate program. Unless he was injured his entire first year on campus (2011), then he also does not qualify for the 6th year of eligbility.
Brandon Clemons: 6th year verdict DENIED
What's interesting is that only 1 of the 3 (Damon Knox) is currently enrolled in a graduate program. Davis isn't because he still hasn't graduated yet. Clemons could be and it not be on his bio.
The HOPE that MSU is holding on to is the example set forth by Tyler Hoover. His situation was very different from the 3 above. Here's the breakdown:
2008 True Fr year: Granted a MEDICAL RS after missing 10 games due to a shoulder injury. Appeared in 2 games, but the Medical RS is key here. 2009 RS Fr and 2010 RS So: Played in all 13 games both seasons. 2011 RS Jr year: Only played 1 (1!) game, and missed the entire season (games AND practices) with a rib injury. 2012 RS RS Jr and 2013 RS RS Sr: Played in 8 games minimum both seasons.
The key to Hoover getting the 6th year was two things:
1) His true Fr year was cut out by a Medical RS
2) Missed another year due to a serious injury after only playing in 1 game. 1 game is crucial here because the rule states that if you played in 2 or more games, then you are not eligible for the 6th year. All 3 that applied for the 6th year either took a Voluntary RS season healthy, or played in 2 games during a RS year.
With all of the critical and valid data you have logically presented here, I can only assume the NCAA will grant a sixth year to all three of them and a seventh if MSU asks rudely enough.
Shoutout received
So now they don't have any competent defensive backs, and roughly one defensive lineman, but they still have a Bullough, I suppose..
will keep squirting them out in perpetuity.
Isnt that the normal time it takes a Sparty to graduate and move up into a more lucrative paper route?
Hehe. Good one.
Sent from MGoBlog HD for iPhone & iPad
Who do they have besides McDowell on the line? I know Calhoun was a force who graduated.
Hopefully our offensive line will be humming like a machine by this game.