Submitted by drexel on October 13th, 2008 at 7:50 PM

This Michigan team reminds me of a team on which I played my senior year of college.  The circumstances were a little different.  It was our coaches fourth year, and had already produced an undefeated regular season and a trip to the Div 3 national quarter finals.  However, the senior class that led us to that point in my sophomore year was one of the most talented group in the history of the program.  The junior class was also very good, but by the time I was a senior there were only 13 players left in my class.  Of those 13, only about half saw significant playing time.  We started 5-0 against some weak competition.  We played the eventual conference champion in week 6 and lost 33-31 after we missed a 40 yard field goal on the last play of the game.  This is where the comparison really starts.  The rest of the year we really struggled.  Everything was a grind.  We thought we had put bad moments behind us, but they obviously lingered.  I do not remember having a bad week of practice, but we just could not seem to get it going in games. Our QB was inconsistent and struggled with his confidence.  Over the last 5 games, we went 1-4.  Occasionally, I think about that season and try to figure out what happened, because we had the players to win the conference.  I think it came down to two things:

  • We never got over the missed field goal.  I think it lingered with many of our younger players, and we just could not pull ourselves out of it.  We would have good weeks of practice, but when games came around, there was just couldn't put together any consistency especially on offense.
  • We did not have many seniors on the field.  It has been my experience that seniors play with a sense of urgency that younger players sometimes lack.  When there are a good number of seniors on the field, this rubs off on everybody else. 

I think Michigan is in a similar spot right now.  They are in a grind offensively, and are struggling to find a rhythm.  Threet has been inconsistent, and at least to me, does not look like he is throwing the ball with confidence right now.  In fact, the whole offense lacks confidence right now.  There seems to be indecision from the O-Line on who to block on zone plays, Threet doesn't seem to pull the trigger quick enough, and the backs don't seem to be finding the hole.  I actually think the D has been ok.

  The point of the story is that the juniors, sophomores, and freshmen from my senior went on to win or share the next 3 conference titles.  The QB who struggled that year was Gagliardi Trophy finalist his senior year. (Div 3 Heisman)  Those underclassmen did not give up on the system, they only became more determined.  Was it bad coaching that led to that one bad season?  I don't think so.  Should those underclassmen have given up on our coach?  Obviously not.  All these things that look wrong on Saturdays are being drilled every day in practice.  They are running the zone over and over again, because its what they practice.  The coaches, who all have a track record of success, believe its what will work on Saturdays.  Eventually, it will start working.  It may not be this year.  I think the offense will probably look good in spurts the way it has most of the season.  But every time you think about the struggles of this Michigan team, you think about those young players that are getting experience, and not ever wanting to go through a Toledo loss ever again in their Michigan football career. 

I hope some people find my experience relevant.  I'd like to finish the post with a passage from Bo's Lasting Lessons.

"Hey.  You can take any coach you want - I don't care if it's Woody Hayes or Ara Parseghian or Joe Paterno, all giants - and you can pick apart their career and find that, sure, they lost some games, probably a few they shouldn't have.  Every one of those three guys won a national title, but every one of them had losing seasons, too - usually when I was on their staff, it occurs to me!  And these are some of the best coaches the game has ever seen.  What does that mean?

I'll tell you what it means: Nothing!

Everyone's got critics.  And if you're in charge, you're going to have more than the people working for you.  Well, I had 101,001 critics every Saturday, and millions more watching on TV - screaming at me to pass more, to blitz more, to go for it on fourth-and-one more from our own 40-yard line.  Let me tell you something:  I fundamentally did not give a damn what the press, the administration or the alumni thought about my coaching.  Fritz Crisler said it best. "If you're winning," he said, "you don't need them.  And if you're losing, they can't help you."

So, you block them out!"


Emil Faber

October 13th, 2008 at 8:29 PM ^

lose (really, how to deal with a loss) is very, very difficult. Learning how to win, that is, deal with a victory, is hard enough; dealing with a loss is harder because society has rigged life so we experience a loss so seldom and have less practice.

Six Zero

October 14th, 2008 at 8:25 AM ^

I don't know what it is-- I could be half asleep with a head cold and stomach cramps-- but there's something about those Bo quotes that just wake me up and make me want to go tackle something.

I love, LOVE how this site has a great habit of 'giving' me something, anything, when I seem to need it. And that's thanks to everyone, not just Brian. I can't help but wonder how hard this season would have been to endure without the welcome confines of the MGoBlog.

And yes, MMB-- I'm in Nittany country and have already quoted THEIR Toledo score several times to back off some eager swagger going into Saturday. That and I tell 'em how old they were the last time PSU won against Michigan-- that does wonders, esp. with the young punks (you realize you were 10 the last time it happened, don't you?)


October 14th, 2008 at 8:33 AM ^

I don't think this team is going to have the deep-down confidence needed to win any more suprising games this year. Those who have a "gut feeling" that we will win this weekend need to realize that that feeling is coming from years of watching competent Michigan teams take the field. This team is probably too young and inexperienced to have the moxy needed to win on Saturday. Of course I will watch and root hard for Michigan but I certainly expect to lose by quite a lot.


October 14th, 2008 at 10:52 AM ^

Great Bo quotes. His words can still motivate, even in text. And Fritz nailed it right on the head, particularly with Michigan fans: "...if you're losing, they can't help you."


They'll get this thing right. We should do our part to make that stadium a hellhole for opposing teams and a sanctuary to our own.


Sadly, I bet our team looks forward to going on the road to escape the hostile environment created by "the faithful" in Ann Arbor.


October 15th, 2008 at 2:15 PM ^

It seems to be everything you say plus a lack of the kind of talented athletes Coach Rodrigues need to win...having seem the grim reality of things as they are...I am not holding my breath for next seems 2010 should be the realistic year we should expect the new Michigan to emerge fully from the birth canal...between now and then its all the pains of labour...

Now that I think about..2010 seems to be the date that most of the MSM sports writers/talkers were giving...grrr