TUEBOR is Latin for "Pothole!" because you can't sue us if we warn you

The best players in Michigan play for Michigan, but who were the best players from Michigan to play for Michigan?


This week: We're looking to build the best possible team out of guys who grew up and played their high school ball in Michigan. Since we've covered a lot of these guys' Michigan careers already, I figured this could instead be a celebration of the programs they came from, and Michigan high school football in general. Special thanks to michigan-football.com, a highly valuable resource.

Rules: Only players recruited since 1990-on. Reasons are 1) Until the late '80s Michigan was a very regional recruiter. Quick chart of Michigan rosters (via Bentley) by state of origin, walk-ons included:


Moeller was the first coach since helmets were a thing to field a team that wasn't made up mostly of Michiganders and Ohioans. Reason 2) My database goes back to 1990. Reason 3: I was 10 that year, and kid memories aren't of much use. This gives us a pool of 171 players to choose from whose careers most of us are somewhat familiar with.


Quarterback: Devin Gardner, Inkster

via AA News

Right off the bat this is a tough one, and a decision I'm personally going to get flak for because the other good candidate reads this blog. Drew, at your best you were the better player, and I promise to buy you a beer next time you're in Ann Arbor. However I'm sticking by the guy who should never have to buy a beer in the State of Michigan again. Also: 33 starts to your eight.

In high school Gardner played for UofD as a sophomore but was forced to sit out for off-field issues for five games. He transferred to Inkster, following coach Greg Carter from recently closed Saint Martin de Porres, and exploded, leading them to two straight state finals. While Devin was at Michigan Inkster was also closed, its students dispersed to four other school districts.

Backup: Drew Henson, Brighton
The rest of the field: Shane Morris, Steven Threet, Nick Sheridan, Alex Malzone, Craig Randall

[After THE JUMP: The greatest player in Michigan high school history]

four horsemen by mark wilkinson

The horses will ride once more



Brian: We only have seven weeks until the season so it's got to be wall to wall.

Ace: Let the torches light the way. Try to avoid the pitchforks.

Seth: So, uh, maybe we just do an All Big Ten thing this year? I know the people won't like it.


BiSB: Like, we jointly draft together? The hell good would that do?

Seth: Brian would finally win?

BiSB: /waves tiny "Venric Mark" flag

Brian: Kemoko Turay is out of the league so what's the point of even Draftageddoning

Ace: It’s 2018, most things are terrible, let’s do this like normal people, I guess.


The one. [Patrick Barron]

Seth: Duh.

Ace: So, uh, yeah, it’s Trace McSorley.

Brian: Is it though?

Seth: He is. Penn State.

BiSB: Yes.

Brian: Okay but what happens with Moorhead gone and Barkley gone and surely at some point he's not going to hit 95% of balls downfield?

Ace: We said that when Godwin left.

Brian: It could happen this time!

Ace: Some of us more than others sorry I took him in ’geddon last year. He’s a slightly poor man’s version of Baker Mayfield and that’ll do in this conference.

Brian: Fine.

Seth: There's always a momentum that carries over. McSorley can still run the same RPO offense this year that negates his bad pass protection and keeps things open.

Ace: I mean, who’s next? Are we unbroken enough to fully jump on the Shea train?

[After THE JUMP: Lewerke for Heisman, Higdon vs Weber]

Previously: Attackers.


Defining different central midfield slots is slightly silly since most players suited for the center of the field are at least somewhat flexible, but in an effort to organize our thoughts we'll do it anyway. So: the USA hasn't had a Central Attacking Midfielder or Number Ten or Trequartista or Guy Who Tries To Be Messi of much note pretty much ever. (Clint Dempsey was always a striker.) There were some promising folks over the last two cycles but for whatever reason Benny Feilhaber and Sacha Kljestan existed on the fringes of the national team.

American 10s in MLS include those rapidly aging guys, a couple more even fringier members of the pool, and File Not Found. Inserting Pulisic here is an obvious option and may be the way it ends up, or the US could just roll out a couple box to box types like they did when Michael Bradley and Jermaine Jones were freed to run by the insertion of Kyle Beckerman behind them. I bet one dollar that's this cycle's solution, with a really fast right back who overlaps and frees Pulisic to tuck inside.

But a speculative name or five here anyway, all of whom are absurdly young. Maybe one of these guys will get good enough fast enough to be relevant. All ages are as of 2022, so... yeah.

Andrew Carleton (22), Atlanta United. Carleton has been a next big thing for a couple years now but he's stuck behind a boatload of expensive South Americans in Atlanta and only gets scattered matches for them. Intra-MLS loans aren't really a thing so Carleton's in a bit of a tough spot.

Richie Ledezma (21), RSL. Ledezma is trialing with Dutch powerhouse PSV and turns 18 in September so wouldn't have a full limbo year if he does go. Ledezma is getting semi-regular minutes in the USL already.

Josh Pynadath (20), Ajax. Pynadath had a couple of years with Real Madrid's academy and is now at Ajax—his mom's job got moved to Holland. He plays on both wings for Ajax but a dual-footed guy with the kind of ball skills Pynadath has is a natural candidate to move inside. He could realistically play anywhere across the attacking midfield level of a 4-2-3-1, but he's 16 so he could also be a potato you never hear about again.

Giovanni Reyna (19), NYCFC. Yes, that Reyna. He'll hook up with a European club as soon as his EU passport goes through and from there will hope to bust into a starting lineup. Realistic best case scenario is another Pulisic type rise where he plays a bunch for a big team and gets integrated the year before the WC.

Gianluca Busio (19), Sporting KC. Youngest MLS signing since Freddy Adu, and it's appropriate to mention Adu in a section in which the oldest guy is 18. Can get an Italian passport so could be another quick move across the Atlantic.

By 2021 everyone except Carleton should be pushing to break through at a high(ish) profile Euro club. There's no better example of the academy effect than the next gen of potential 10s; previously American 10s have been limited in numbers and opportunity since MLS tends to target foreign players at that spot. USL opportunities for teenagers have the potential to break out a number of skilled attackers both here and abroad.

This has been the most crootin' section of this post.

[After the JUMP: still fairly crootin sections.]

Warde Manuel seals up John Beilein.

Which non-aquatic mammal will fill the spot that was being held for DJ Carton? That and much more in this mailbag.

Josh Sargent is my beautiful perfect son and I will fight you if you say otherwise. 

Previously, we looked at maximizing Zavier Simpson in next year’s offense, focusing primarily on how he operated within the pick-and-roll game. As the screener, Teske is a critical component to what could be the primary schematic theme for the team in the fall.