The only hatchet job I read was this post. Generally, when you spend three times as long arguing someone's point as the person made making it, you made a mess of it. Here are the two things I said.
1. The title of my post was "Dorsey deserves second chance..." Give him a second chance, but he has to earn a clean slate. Breaking into homes with specialized tools and stealing TVs and computers is a serious crime. We all did stupid things as teenagers. None of us broke into someone's home with specialized equipment and stole things worth thousands of dollars. Your equation of the two is painfully, painfully stupid.
2. If you're going to censor Birkett, censor him for making a joke. Don't act as though the joke had no basis in truth.
I wasn't "uninformed." You disagreed with me. You did a poor job arguing it, and thanks to the Internet will bask in the adulation of those with like-minded sentiment. Congrats.
This is generally one of the best sites to go to for Michigan information. I'm sorry to see Brian's standards have slipped.
Recent Comments