- Member for
- 8 years 8 weeks
- View recent blog entries
|1 week 5 days ago||sports reporters||
I sat in on way too many of these things when I was an undergrad writing sports for the Daily. It was at least as comical IRL as it comes across in print. With that backdrop, it makes it really easy to hold onto a burning disdain for the jackasses at the Freep for what they did in Stretchgate.
Very glad I went into an entirely different field. Most of my friends who pursued journalism careers don't seem super happy about it.
Also very glad for Brian and his team's commitment to excellence and to not giving up their intellectual curiosity.
|1 week 6 days ago||don't let the facts get in the way dragonchild||
Because McDoom, Crawford, Onwenu, Bredeson and Asiasi are LoLing at the premise of your post. They've all worked themselves right into the two deep.
And that isn't counting Long or LHill, one or both of whom will be playing (though more likely for reasons along the line of your depth-only conjecture).
|1 week 6 days ago||1974||
If you're going to come at me son, come correct.
King was an '04 recruit. He was a veteran player in '06, not a freshman. He was all-conference that year.
Lloyd absolultely did not "back off" ,,, he sat back and stopped working. PSU sent King a letter every single day. We did nothing. They turned the tide in no small part by "showing him the love." He was very clear on this point. His words, and the words of those close to him.
But go on taking shots at posts where you admit you don't have depth of knowledge. I do, and that's why I posted it ... because it really, truly cost us deeply. Worse than RoJo, even.
(FYI, I wasn't referring to the next year's bowl, either. I'm talking '06 Wolverines versus '06 Gators. If we have King on that team, we win. Matchup very much in our favor.)
|1 week 6 days ago||misses that really cost us||
I'm with you EastCoast on losing sleep over Mikey Weber.
That being said, the one I will truly never get over was Justin King. He was in the bag, but then Lloyd & Co got lazy and PSU didn't. Incredibly costly mistake. You put him on the '06 team, and we win in Columbus and are in the NC game.
Go back and look at the PSU-O$U game that season ... King was the only CB in the B1G who put the clamps on Ginn, who in turn put up over 100 yards and a TD in the Game ... and, crucially, tore into us at critical moments (e.g, that bomb early on into the red zone).
Morgan Trent was a good soldier* ... but you put King on that D and we would have been something else. And I think we would have matched up against UF in the NC game way better than O$U did.
(* Pete Carroll showed in the Rose Bowl just how important that isn't)
|2 weeks 3 days ago||Thank you Brian||
The proactive decision to spend your money on the PFF data just made one of the best things on the internet even better. For no apparent reason other than your love of Michigan and this board community. This is akin to a couple of years back when Chick Fil A scrapped their already-tasty grilled sandwich for an even better grilled sandwich. I cannot stay away from her siren's song.
You, sir, are a noble beast.
(And you finally got your head right on Stibling! LoL)
|5 weeks 1 day ago||Staee||
This could very well help them a lot, as Redfield is one of ND's leading tacklers. He's a hitter from the S spot. That will likely matter when Groucho runs LJ Scott between the tackles again and again and again....
|8 weeks 3 days ago||PSA:||
LaMarr Woodley kills people
|21 weeks 7 hours ago||can Maryland hold him?||
Urb flipped a stud Maryland LB from the Terps post-Durkin last year, right?
O$U has traditionally had a much stronger presence in MD than we have. As has PSU. Hopefully Harbaugh can change that. But at this point, if he flips away from the Terps I would say the money is on an outcome we would not like.
|21 weeks 3 days ago||skeletons||
Well he does have them, but he owns up to them. No need to worry about a bomb that has already gone off.
|24 weeks 3 days ago||Cobo||
One of the most electric basketball games I ever saw was played at Cobo: Chris Webber's DCDS Yellowjackets (reignng Class B state champs) against Jalen Rose's Detroit Southwestern Prospectors (reigning Class A state champs).
It was in the heat of the recruiting cycle. Magic showed up courtside to show the love. Game was fantastic.
|24 weeks 6 days ago||Gateway||
I don't think we ever managed to land any recruit of significance from Gateway. Terry Smith sent Justin King to PSU and then we never got any of the others either.
I might have forgotten someone, but I'm pretty sure that's right.
|24 weeks 6 days ago||So Brian, I'll take the bait...||
You are "kind of in the Clark camp" over Stribling about as consistently as I'm kind of in the Michigan camp over Notre Dame.
But let me ask you this: to what end do you think the Coaches are working when they have so publicly and consistently stated throughout basically the entirety of Spring ball that Stribling is The Guy?
Is it your view that there is some nuanced, player-specific psychology going on (e.g., Strib is soft and needs to be built up; Clark needs the challenge of being called out as the backup)? Or do you have some other theory?
Seems pretty inconsistent with Mr Relentless Meritocracy's general approach to name one guy a starter if in fact the other guy is even remotely close to being The Guy, no?
|24 weeks 6 days ago||LoL @ mgoblog's ongoing Clark-fest||
Listen to Sam Webb's interview of Harbaugh: Stribling a lock to be the starter opposite JD Lewis
But keep on banging that drum, Brian & Co....
Clark has intriguing ability ... but Stribling has stepped up and claimed the job. Emphatically.
|32 weeks 5 days ago||oh Scruffy||
If you're going to take the time to talk down to me, you might want to first go back and do a careful read of both Brian's piece (including what he stated up front as this piece's intent, i.e., the context in which it was to be read) and then also my specific comments (which most assuredly did NOT question Brian's prerogative to write "what he thinks"). To clarify, he said he was laying forth his view of the order in which specific players were most likely to be starters at the 27 listed positions.
To your questions:
1) yes, I am suggesting the Brian improve his occasional heavy categorization of the non-star players ... yes, I think he should change what he thinks. More precisley, I think he should change HOW he thinks. He would be well served to let his opinions flow more fluidly with incremental data on players as it arrives. He has an observable bias in some (NOT all) cases among the lesser players to establish a point of view and then cling to it, many times against futher evidence, and some times (like here with Stribling) against reason. It can make for entertaining writing and perhaps he feels it is a useful tool in conveying to the average reader a sense of his expertise (which is, in fact, very deep), but I've seen it get off the rails from time to time. He sometimes crystalizes his view, and then it just flows downstream from that point. For example, it is not remotely reasonable to expect at this juncture that either of those two freshmen are in the same likelihood category as Stribling (a very seasoned player who is, at the very least, demonstrably competent ... even with some notable flaws). As others noted in response to your post, he often does this in the context of expectations from the recruiting cycle. I would also note he has some tendency to do this (in either + or - ways, from player to player) within season and season-to-season. It is noticable within UFRs, when he selectively highlights (positively or negatively) certain guys.
To be clear, I'm not saying it is impossible for Hill and/or Long to pass Stribling up next year. I'm saying that Brian has no rational basis for making that claim at this point, given what he described as the point of this exercise. His view on this one point is countervaling to both logic and data. When coupled with my observations of some of his tendencies over the years, I highlighted it as one example of how Brian sometimes allows his bias to influence his judgment.
2) going back to the first part of this post, I am pretty sure this was NOT a dumb place for my "tirade." It's exactly the place. Brian was laying out his view on specific guys' likelihood of STARTING. To your rhetorical questions about Harbaugh's grand sense of player development and future seasons, of course JH is smart enough to see the need in '17 and beyond. But that is NOT what Brian was getting at. Or, if it is the case that he did allow that consideration into his thinknig in the Strib vs Hill/Long instance in particular ... well, then Brian got himself derailed from his own mission, didn't he? And that would only further my point of his negative bias on Stribling influencing his subjective output around a set of objective facts.
Look, I recognize the entirety of my post is an in-the-weeds observation. And it is very much the gnat on the ass of the elephant. This blog (and this board) are spectacular elements of the overall 'M' sports community. That being said, I do think it's fair to have a discussion on "the little stuff." I'd be shocked if Brian disagrees with that view. And I'm not even making an entitled bellyache of "I want Brian to deliver me a better product" ... what I'm saying is that in his quest to be great (which he inherently does have, and it's observable in his passion and fire to do all things well on this site), he would futher his own cause with a little introspection on this point.
|32 weeks 6 days ago||biases||
Love Brian's work overall, but one of the longstanding bones to pick is how his biases or partially-formed theses (extrapolated from mixed and/or limited data) sometime crystalize into truisms. Sometimes that is falling in love with a player, other times that is relegating a player to undeserved also-ran status.
Example here: the laughable thought that Channing Stribling ought to be grouped with Vert Hill (or even David Long) in likelihood of PT as a 2016 CB. Utterly preposterous. While I'm a huge fan of Hill's long-term potential, it is complete nonsense to expect a PSL kid to come in and make plays like we often see from Stribling. See: undercutting Florida WR on a well thrown, well run deep square-in during the bowl game for the PBU.
Sure Stribling has some whiffs (some very frustrating), but he can and will play. A lot, actually ... and while he may not beat out Clark for the #2 CB spot, there is a near 100% chance he would be next man up if Clark was injured. He is a far steadier pair of trusted hands out on that CB island than either of the incoming freshmen, regardless of their respective ceilings. We have, for example, significant evidence that Stribling has made tons of progress as an open field tackler, especially when he's isolated against the run (an important element of the CB trade that few freshmen -- particularly the "pure cover corner" variety -- can perform sufficiently). We have ZERO basis for an informed opinion on that matter for either Long or Hill.
The prevalence of subtle biases among the non-stars in Brian's work is not new. Nor is it entirely bad. It gives us something to debate. And, unlike various other 'M' website personas, he isn't so threatened by it as to freak out in response. But it is a weakness that I have noticed creeping in through certain recountings and subjective analyses (UFR, etc) over the years.
|34 weeks 4 days ago||Two things||
1) I love you for doing this. If I could go hang with my 'M' boys one of these Friday evenings over beers, I would insist we geek out on it name by name for hours.
2) on the specific rankings you are a clueless idiot and wrong many, many times over ... but this is still freaking awesome
|34 weeks 6 days ago||I'm thinking Shantee Orr 2.0||
I'm thinking Shantee Orr 2.0 might be the better comparison. Unblockable speed off the snap.
|35 weeks 2 days ago||No. Wisconsin hates us.||
No. Wisconsin hates us. Iowa hates us. PSU hates us. And Illinois really, really hates us.
Of course, the lunatic fringe at each of them individually assumes we count them as a rival.
|35 weeks 2 days ago||The dad||
Now that we've learned the dad's name is Swen Swenson, the pendulum has swung again and I'm officially pissed at Harbaugh. He passed on that kind of awesomeness? Jim just doesn't get it.
|35 weeks 5 days ago||Glad to hear you are going to||
Glad to hear you are going to do more of this, Brian.
It would be that much more interesting if you could get some of your fellow bloggers following other programs to do the same thing.
I mostly care about what the 'M' related sites are able to deliver on our guys. But if there is systematic outsized suckiness at one of the services that is analytically observable, that would be worth seeing.
|35 weeks 5 days ago||Please do more of this. I||
Please do more of this. I think they are fair game.
|36 weeks 5 days ago||Posible, but Trieu saw him||
Posible, but Trieu saw him live and said much the same thing.
There were plenty of reports in SE MI that Trishton is a terrific athlete, and a natural at WR.
And he was a monster in high school hoops last year too.
Even though he made many of those plays in a league not traditionaly characterized as elite for either basketball or football, the kid is at the very least seriously athletic.
Sometimes you miss some. And other times you don't worry yourself too much about kids coming out of the 248 area code ... the track record of them fulfilling the hype is pretty spotty, to say the least.
|36 weeks 5 days ago||I think everyone on this||
I think everyone on this board can agree that Bert sucks. That truth spans all generations and time periods of the game.
|36 weeks 5 days ago||B1G guarantees its schollies||
B1G guarantees its schollies are for four years.
Easy picking to market itself as the high ground option relative to the S(ee) E(verybody) C(heats).
|37 weeks 2 days ago||Gary||
In addition to the challenges mentioned in the prior post in comparting OL and DL, the Kalis comparison is not fitting because it was widely observed in his Army All-Star week that he was far from dominant. Looked pretty ordinary, actually. Clearly not a 5*.
In contrast, last week at the UA Gary looked like a terror, a man amongst boys. He has it all: size, unrelenting motor, excellent and diverse technique and freakish speed for his size.
I think he is far and away the best DL prospect I have seen. Ever.
|37 weeks 2 days ago||also||
I don't know of any precedents as impact players because all the hype seems to be about QBs (Russell Wilson, Rudock, et al), but are there any whispers of a graduate transfer in at LB?
As I recall, Josh Furman went that route to OkSt on the way out of U-M.
|37 weeks 2 days ago||LB options||
Didn't Chase Winovich move back to LB? Or, if he hasn't yet, wouldn't that plausibly be on the table at this point?
|37 weeks 5 days ago||DA, not Manningham||
I loved Mario, but the better former M player comparison for Chesson is Derrick Alexander. At least in terms of his physical gifts and playing style. Lanky-tall with tons of straight line speed and a bit more wiggle than people expect of him. Not elite hands, but developing into very good. Is a consistent threat to take the top off the D, but also can make plays at the mid-level, including an ability to either juke for or fight for YAC.
Chesson is still growing a lot as a wideout ... this is a guy who is still getting coached up. I think we see a VERY interesting player in him next fall. I was one of the few who was fairly bullish on him coming into the season (loved his work ethic combined with the speed/length combo), but I didn't expect him to come this far, this fast.
Chesson already blocks immeasurably better than either Manningham or DA ever did. I wouldn't take him in a footrace over DA, but he does so many other things at least as well or better.
And there is an even greater separation off the field. As Drake Johnson noted that Jehu stands out on the team for "having his sh!t together" ... well, that was quite the opposite of Mario and Derrick, who would have done well for themselves to be a little more responsible in life. DA, in particular, is one guy who is awfully glad that the internet was only a pipe dream during his college years.
|42 weeks 3 days ago||No doubt about the Stadium's cultural importance||
I married into a big SEC family (mostly Bama and UGa), and one of my wife's great aunts was a HUGE Bama booster. Gifts to players, the whole nine yards.
When she came up to Ann Arbor for our wedding, the ONLY thing she absolutely had to do before heading back south was see the Stadium. She could not care less for a single thing north of the Mason-Dixon line (her words), but she had to see Michigan Stadium.
PS - for those who haven't been to PSU's contraption of a home field, yes they can get 100k+ in there, but it looks like they hired McGuyver to put it together rather than an architect. So I could see how some visiting Nits would want to see it. Ours CRUSHES theirs in every way.
|42 weeks 4 days ago||Anyone is a downgrade?? LoL||
So, how did the very best D-Coord in all of CFB do on his final exam this year?
LoL ... methinks our 2016 DL roster alone will attract a number of HIGHLY qualified candidates for his seat. All of that back plus Mone and maybe plus Rashan Gary. Is there a 'licking chops' emoticon around here?