Member for

15 years 7 months
Points
11499.00

Recent Comments

Date Title Body
“Have you ever written a…

“Have you ever written a manifesto? If so, how many pages is it?”

At this point, NBA and NCAA…

At this point, NBA and NCAA basketball may as well be different sports from a coaching standpoint. They're played entirely differently, the players, particularly as shooters, are on an entirely different level, the role of coaches is entirely different (much much less roster management in the NBA). As a result, they require almost entirely different coaching skill-sets.

McDermott just signed a…

McDermott just signed a contract extension that presumably has a large buyout. He's going to retire at Creighton.

I think the lesson of both…

I think the lesson of both Stackhouse and Howard are that NBA coaching and NCAA coaching may as well be different sports. Those guys were both regarded as very solid assistants well on their way to head coaching positions, but they just fell apart in running college programs (where there's much more emphasis on roster management than with NBA coaching, which is about very specific strategic choices about how to defend the pick and roll and how to manage minutes and egos over a longer season).

Are there any good options…

Are there any good options for that left, though, with Cousins and Wilson off the board? Maybe they sign a journeyman and have JJ as the starter in waiting.

As a Packers fan, strongly do not want JJ to go to the Vikings with that receiving corps.

Except that they apparently…

Except that they apparently first met at summer camp, where they hated each other. Which is even funnier and more touching, in a way.

From college GA to NFL…

From college GA to NFL position coach in 2 years seems like a rocket ship trajectory. Very promising hire.

Highly important post. Thanks

Highly important post. Thanks

Normalize shoving your boss…

Normalize shoving your boss when he's wrong!

The NCAA's treatment of…

The NCAA's treatment of Aaliya's situation is even more messed up when you consider Argentinian inflation. Given that the rate of inflation for the Argentine peso was 185% in 2023, and is estimated to be 250% this year, if the NCAA is asking for this repayment in dollars, they're demanding he repay vastly more money than he received, in order to participate in a sport where players are now regularly being paid significant amounts of money by entities so close to the team that there is no meaningful distinction between athletic department and NIL collective.

Leonard went from dc to…

Leonard went from dc to analyst because he shived Paul Chryst and no head coach wanted to hire him. 

Universities are notorious…

Universities are notorious for doing this (waiting until someone has an offer in hand before making retention offers) with current faculty who are being interviewed for jobs elsewhere. 

This argument would be more…

This argument would be more valid even two weeks ago. But with deBoer and Fisch in new jobs, the two candidates who could reasonably be considered potentially worth paying the price of short-term losses to the program (in terms of players, coaches and likely Herbert) in the long term, and plausible hires are off the board. In part, that's why he's the only contender (I think he would have likely been the hire even if deBoer and Fisch were "available").

Yeah, but his injury history…

Yeah, but his injury history has to be part of the calculation. The floor could be another acl and out of the league after his rookie deal because he can’t stay healthy. 
 

Also, he’s not great on the move and seemed to have trouble reading M’s defense (though that is true of every qb M played this year). 

Our national championship…

Our national championship winning head coach back to lead our national championship winning team. 

I'll take that.

Plus, the University of…

Plus, the University of Arizona has a massive budget shortfall that probably prevents them from matching any offer Fisch would receive. 

https://kjzz.org/content/1867904/university-arizonas-budget-crisis-just-got-more-controversial-tucson#:~:text=It%20wasn't%20too%20long,he%20attributed%20to%20financial%20miscalculation.

Exactly, no longer a lateral…

Exactly, no longer a lateral move (if it ever was, which I don't agree with given Washington's history) now that Washington's in the Big Ten and Arizona's in the Big 12.

Only Brian was ... asked to…

Only Brian was ... asked to not do whatever it was he was doing any more. Kirk is still coaching Iowa.

I don’t know if it’s THE…

I don’t know if it’s THE moment, but a moment that things totally changed for me was in the immediate aftermath of the 2021 OSU game, suddenly realizing that “we get to watch this team in more games that matter this year!” It was like a surprise gift that I hadn’t realized was coming. 

Yes, it’s that exact moment…

Yes, it’s that exact moment when I finally stopped doubting we were going to win

If Harbaugh leaves and we…

If Harbaugh leaves and we don't hire Moore, he's 100% gone to be head coach somewhere else. 

Hoke also had head coaching…

Hoke also had head coaching experience! He had been coach of the year in separate conferences!!! DeBoer has run a program, and has succeeded everywhere he's been, but one that receives far less national attention than Michigan and receives, at best, the 3rd (arguably 4th) most attention in its local market. His recruiting classes have been in the low 20s. 

Would he do better at Michigan? Probably. But every head coaching hire is a risk! There's one hire that won't alienate large portions of players and alumni, something that we've seen in very recent memory is a real possibility and can crater the program. If there wasn't an obvious candidate that had been on an upward trajectory for years within the program, by all means, open it up, even if that means you have to blow everything up that's been built over the last 3 years. But that's not the case we're in. Maybe Sherrone is David Shaw, which, in and of itself, is not the worst outcome, and we see plateauing at some level below winning the fucking national championship. Maybe he's Kirby Smart or Lincoln Riley. Regardless, don't break what's working.

C'mon people, put some…

C'mon people, put some thought and research into your arguments. Fickell had an entire season as interim head coach and posted one of the two losing seasons in the last 50 years of OSU football (other was Cooper's first year). If Sherrone had been in over his head the way Fickell was, we wouldn't be having this conversation.

Maintaining Stanford at an…

Maintaining Stanford at an elite level is degrees of magnitude harder than maintaining Michigan at an elite level. 

Hiring anyone is a gamble…

Hiring anyone is a gamble. But hiring Moore would be a gamble that didn’t immediately piss off the most important stakeholders the program needs in order to be successful. The players clearly respect and follow him. They clearly regard him as a leader. And they put in a lot of work. 
 

Should Harbaugh leave, this is an unprecedented situation. It’s literally a national championship team (damn, that feels good to write) that was coached, at least on game day, for more than 1/4 of the games, including half of the biggest games, by someone who would be the leading candidate for the job. I can’t imagine hiring someone else and it not causing a huge amount of disappointment and anger among the players. 

It’s crazy. People are…

It’s crazy. People are treating it like Hoke went straight from coaching Michigan’s d-line to head coach of Michigan.  Hoke had years of head coaching experience.  He’s like the case study for why head coaching experience shouldn't be regarded as a prerequisite. 

Is someone as likely to come…

Is someone as likely to come in as “bull in a china shop”/“I need to clean this place out” as Rich Rod did? No, almost certainly not. Would almost every player on the team for the past three years and tons of program alums be incredibly upset that the guy they felt had earned his shot by leading the team against Penn State and Ohio State got passed over? Absolutely. Particularly if it’s the guy coaching the team Michigan just beat for the national championship? 

That’s the kind of thing that takes an amazingly talented leader/manager of people to overcome. It has such a higher chance of failure in the immediate term than hiring Sherrone. If you do something like that, you have to believe you have a best coach in a generation type figure, because otherwise, you’ve just destroyed the commitment of whole classes of players and former players. 

Lincoln Riley at Oklahoma

Lincoln Riley at Oklahoma

Rich Rod was the hottest…

Rich Rod was the hottest coaching candidate in the country, with tons of coaching experience, with tons of demonstrated ability.  The turmoil his hiring created, certainly not entirely all his making, cratered the program for a decade.  
 

And do you really think turning away from a guy who was in charge for 2 of the biggest 4 wins of a national championship year isn’t going to create huge rifts within the program? 

Pete Carroll is 72. 

Pete Carroll is 72. 

Bag of shrooms next to a…

Bag of shrooms next to a logging truck for Eugene.

Don't try Houston in the…

Don't try Houston in the summer, unless you're on some kind of health regimen where you need to experience numerous transitions between incredible heat and humidity and frigid air conditioning in rapid succession.

Sure, if that’s what…

Sure, if that’s what Harbaugh actually means by the Bear Hug. Absolutely. But he’ll never say that.

(my secret suspicion is that Harbaugh has a meh relationship with Warde, like he has with almost everyone who’s ever been above him on some org chart, but that Warde and Bacon have some mutual antipathy). 

Yeah, it's hard to know what…

Yeah, it's hard to know what would constitute "the bear hug" that the AD could give Harbaugh that doesn't already exist/isn't on offer, unless it's code for some weird power play/secret demand that Warde be let go. 

This is a good point. It's…

This is a good point. It's hard to think of a"big program to big program" coaching move in the last decade that's been an unalloyed success on the level of making the playoffs. Very small sample size, to be sure. Basically those guys above (ymmv on Cincy-Wisconsin) and Jimbo.  

There's really no way of…

There's really no way of knowing whether any coach that you could possibly hire will work out. Rich Rod looked like an out of this world hire, and the outcome was a smoking crater. (I guess astroids are out of this world).

I think this is right. You…

I think this is right. You run a real search, but it's ok if Moore is the leading candidate.

I think this is why you don…

I think this is why you don't immediately name him head coach, but you run a search where Sherrone is the first interview, it's a very rigorous interview, and you ask him to lay out how he would manage the programmatic aspects of the job.

While I can understand the points about wanting experience, this program, for reasons that are complex and multifaceted, is highly resistant to people perceived as coming in from the outside. It's not a great feature of Michigan football, but it is a real thing. Sherrone now knows how the place works and has learned about program building by being here as Harbaugh rebuilt it from 2020. He deserves honest consideration and should be the leading candidate, IMO, but shouldn't be handed the job. 

And there are a number of coaches that have stepped into elite programs as assistants to great success. It's just important to get the right one.

I don't think it's that…

I don't think it's that JayBaugh's head wasn't in the game. It was actually a brilliant coaching move to put an up man on the field, since Washington's short punts that went unfielded had been killing our field position. It's what gave us the ball on the following punt for the clinching drive on the 33 rather than the 14 or something (with Thaw fielding the short punt there).

It does probably indicate communication issues that the punt formation had changed to ... whomever was yelling at Semaj to get off the field. And I don't really think you can blame him for running off if the sideline is yelling at him to do so. Maybe you want your returner to do a count and be confident the numbers are right, but if the sideline is yelling, you have to trust they know something.

Nick Baumgardner makes this…

Nick Baumgardner makes this same point about Penix's accuracy in his (very good) film breakdown in the Athletic. Namely, that Penix's off-target rate (14%) is below the national average for starting QBs with 300 passes. Burrow, who he's being compared to, was at 6% (first in the nation) in LSU's championship season. That said, Penix only had 3 off target passes out of 38 attempts against Texas, so as we know, he's perfectly capable of being in the zone and putting a number of deep balls right on the money.

Here's Baumgardner's breakdown, which is excellent and a decided change of pace from the Athletic's very sub-par tactical analysis of college football. (The amount of attention that place gives to Ari Wasserman's vacant takes is something.) He picks M in a close game, fwiw.

football. https://theathletic.com/5181549/2024/01/06/michigan-washington-michael-penix-jj-mccarthy/

Amazing story from Kris…

Amazing story from Kris Jenkins. 
 

Michigan defensive lineman Kris Jenkins witnessed it from the trenches and had the same question as any Alabama fan watching: what is going on?

"I was kind of surprised," Jenkins said in the locker room after Michigan's 27-20 overtime win in the College Football Playoff semifinal. "I was like, what happened bro? I was genuinely, like, confused. I wasn't even trying to talk trash. I was just like -- what's going on?

"He ain't say nothing."

https://www.reddit.com/r/CFB/comments/18wy62d/michigan_dl_kris_jenkins_on_alabama_center_seth/

Mandel doesn’t understand…

Mandel doesn’t understand what’s going on on the field and, the Stallions thing reveals that he doesn’t understand the nature of the sport he’s been covering his entire career. The Stallions story is basically a Dr. Pepper commercial come to life. Crazed fan works his way into program and hatches bizarre scheme in the idea it will help his favorite team win. If Dr. Pepper can get that down to 30 seconds, I expect to see it next year. 
 

Think about that. Dr. Pepper ad guys understand the sport better than the editor in chief of the only national sports magazine that remains in existence. 

Fuck Mandel. He’s the editor…

Fuck Mandel. He’s the editor-in-chief of the Athletic’s college football side. He, more than anyone, is responsible for driving the over the top coverage of affaire d’Stallions through his editorial decisions and reporter assignments. The Athletic still has a “Stallions was at the Rose Bowl” story prominently featured in its cfb feed. And he’s not admitting he was wrong about the coverage, just that Stallions’s info isn’t the primary reason why Michigan was winning (he is sticking with the “we can’t know what advantage it gave Michigan.”)

Thanks. That’s slightly…

Thanks. That’s slightly relieving. Though he did still have to hold onto it while getting blasted. 

Say what you will about the…

Say what you will about the decision to field the punt, and the initial execution of said action, and the existential horror it causes me every time I think about it, but that was an all time great loose ball recovery by Thaw. He couldn’t just fall on it because it would have been a safety. He had to secure it, make sure he got clear of the end zone, and hold onto it while getting blasted a split second after gathering it in. 
 

Now … never do that again. My heart just can’t.

Ooof. Nussmeier. That's some…

Ooof. Nussmeier. That's some deep cut disappointment.

There was no one in position…

There was no one in position to either side of JJ to cover a fumbled snap, so they called a TO out of an abundance of caution.

 

Given the activity on the…

Given the activity on the board today, I don't think we need threads about Alabama winning the coin flip twice and a momentary boob shot on Bourbon Street driving more active threads down the queue

And Washington's game…

And Washington's game against ASU was a weak after they beat Oregon, their biggest program win since they won the Pac 12/went to the playoff in 2016. The point is that neither game is a particularly helpful point of comparison.

Man, the Big Ten was…

Man, the Big Ten was remarkably bad offensively this year. (LOL at OSU falling behind Penn State's dink-fest offense.)

 

I assume OSU's rating took a big hit with their bowl game.