further adventures in Jed York being unsuited for his position
|1 day 17 hours ago||Yep - this is a frequent discussion in my house||
My oldest son has a merit based full tuition + scholarship to Alabama (Engineering for CS). The debate there is debt free at graduation, versus one to two nice new cars worth of debt graduating from NC State Engineering. He wants the flexibility to pursue less mainstream or startup options, so is choosing the no debt route. There are better intellectual and cultural fits for him, but he is using reasonable objective logic.
My middle son wants to go to Michigan, or another top engineering school. The discussion is maybe by co-oping or an ROTC scholarship (like I did) that is doable. Right now, Georgia Tech is the higher likely candidate because it is $40K less across four years, and has a better co-op program and semester abroad program for engineers.
As much as Michigan tops every search criteria every time we look - out of state tuition really makes that choice very, very hard to pursue.
|3 days 12 hours ago||Maybe make Bo's "dress"||
Maize or Blue ...
|3 days 12 hours ago||Needs some work||
JH needs Khakis to make this google-safe
|5 days 17 hours ago||Irregardless||
It is the name of a long standing cafe in Raliegh that specializes in vegetarian dishes, and live music.
|1 week 1 day ago||To be fair||
there are five OT eye glazers
|1 week 1 day ago||Do we really need another post||
on the same interview that was covered in several posts last week?
|1 week 2 days ago||I thought your Wife / Avatar||
was more double jigger shaped, or like a 2 cones day shape ... or did that not pass Google regs?
|1 week 2 days ago||Get you nautical terminology correct swabby||
that would be a head ye are referrin' to.
|1 week 2 days ago||Those quick release pins||
for the facemask can be a pain in the ass to re-attach with mud an grit in them too.
At least now I know the reason for them.
|1 week 2 days ago||Visors are a pain in the ass||
not one JV game goes by and some player isn't asking me to remove his visor from his helmet quick before he has to get back into the game.
(This from a volunteer equipment manager's point of view.)
|1 week 2 days ago||That lasts a day or two||
Then you get no smiles -- unless they totally think no one is looking -- until they come off.
|1 week 3 days ago||They way Jim didn't address the Michigan job||
until the 49er season was over was straight out of Bo's Lasting Lessons (Section I, Chapter 3, last page).
|2 weeks 10 hours ago||Brian - I don't always agree||
with the extreme nature in which you say things or the opinions, conclusions and actions you formulate, but I really appreciate the this blog, and the effort you take to articulate clearly what you think is going on or has gone on.
I thought Failure was damning enough without the last three paragraphs, but hey, this is a fan-point-of-view-blog editorial, so why not.
Keep it up and Go Blue man!
|2 weeks 17 hours ago||You are right||
"the Process" is not covered enough in Brian's editorial
|2 weeks 1 day ago||That's why||
the khakis are pleated
|3 weeks 1 day ago||In Wake County NC||
we only pass every other bond just to let the school board know we won't put up with their shenanigans too.
It has become so bad the best teachers are leaving in droves - especially science and math.
|4 weeks 21 hours ago||Is it dusty in here||
it seems to be dusty in here.
Great story, and sounds like a really great young man.
|4 weeks 2 days ago||I think my son read it in AP Government||
because he's pretty adamant about not making his bed or putting his clothes away.
|4 weeks 2 days ago||No fair||
You and buckeyejonross are arguing with reason ...
Don't you get that people around here just want to feel better.
It doesn't matter what has transpired the last four years as Brady Hoke and staff somehow managed to get to 85 after signing a few over each year. And even then by the time fall practice came around they had a few schollies to give to key walk-ons.
Clearly Michigan has done this ethically, and Ohio State is as slippery as Ole' Miss or Les Miles at LSU .... /s
|4 weeks 3 days ago||Well Barbasol was||
advertising to it's target Buckeye audience right?
|4 weeks 3 days ago||Yeah, that one was like||
WTF, LOL, ewww, weird .... and you are left with undesireable images stuck in your mind + Loctite
|4 weeks 3 days ago||It's OK||
I set up Wolverine Devotee's mgoblog twitter feed thing, only to find out I had read 80% of the posts before twitter notified me that they were posted. I keep telling my wife this is a good addiction - just think of the alternative addictions a husband can have ...
|5 weeks 5 hours ago||Eh - I went with a corona typewriter||
and roomed with a guy with an Apple II after Freshman year so I never had to type a paper on a typewriter again.
As for the OPs point - whether we realize it or not and even if we have acted in inclusive ways, at least some students from a poor background probably do feel outcast - especially in first year or so. I read enough angst about rich out of state students that I wonder if some do act boorish. I also agree this is somewhat a responsibility of the students to make sure other students feel included.
That said - some of the best times my Freshman and Sophomore years in Couzens were when people just walked down the hall knocking on doors and getting an impromptu group up for dinner, or to go to a party, or traying or something.
|5 weeks 19 hours ago||Couzens was great for Engineers||
who wanted to live on Central Campus, but have convenient access to a short bus ride to North Campus for classes.
|5 weeks 1 day ago||Launching eggs||
out of the window of the triple room in the Couzens Penthouse. Someone made the launcher from a cup and surgical tubing and we could fire the eggs over to the parking lot at Alice Lloyd.
One dude got pissed and came over pounding on the door. Told security we had no idea how he got egged, and besides you couldn't get one over there from here anyway.
We had an annual Penthouse toga party back then too. Oh those bathrooms were awful the next morning.
|5 weeks 1 day ago||For some reason the first paragraph||
of the Prior's release sounds a heck of a lot like this:
when I read it. /S
That said, it does sound like the chapter is owning up to what they have done, and are trying to make restitution responsibly at least.
Still: what were they thinking? ....
|5 weeks 2 days ago||Read my post above||
I disagree. This is insignifcant, and sensationally blown way out of proportion.
|5 weeks 2 days ago||Seattle's DBs hold or interfere on every play||
(So do Michigan State's) They are clearly violating of the rules (at the very least the intent), pushing the boundary, and daring the refs to call it. In their mind (and many TV talking heads' minds), they are just "playing the game".
How much does pass interference alter the score of the game over air pressure being 16% below tolerance? Is anyone talking about how Seattle's secondary cheats?
Anybody check any other teams' footballs at halftime? How many have been altered in some way? (I am guessing someone ought to check Peyton Manning's game footballs.) Does the entire nation think just New England pushed the boundary on these minor rules?
New England had one turnover in the game: an interception in the 1st half when the balls were deflated, no fumbles in either the deflated half or the inflated half, and twice as many (4 vs 2) touchdowns in the inflated half.
This issue was silly the moment it came out.
|5 weeks 3 days ago||ESPN has done nothing wrong||
You see it depends on how you prepare your Mock Drafts - apparently if you prepare them to the right tackiness in a certain way, they may appear retroactively modified as conditions change.
[Edit:] /s some sarcasm meters are not amused this morning ...
|5 weeks 3 days ago||Yeah||
Swim lanes man ...
|5 weeks 6 days ago||Tater's breaking into||
the bottle of maize 100 proof stuff again. But I like what he's thinking.
|5 weeks 6 days ago||Maybe the suit is hyperbolized||
by using the UNC case as the primary example. That said the UNC case is an extreme example of the reality that in many cases kids who are below the curve academically are brought in and given significant mandatory and voluntary sport expectations and are advised in some way to pursue degree paths with less rigor in order to stay academically elligible.
The NCAA at the very least allows this environment to exist.
|5 weeks 6 days ago||These kids did have academic advisors steering them||
into these classes when their GPAs dipped too low. I am guessing that is their angle.
That said, I completely agree with the athlete's do shoulder a most of the accountability - they knew what they were doing.
|5 weeks 6 days ago||This is like a coaching search in a way||
"Well, Michigan contacted my client about there coahing job. Where were we on negotiating that new contract?"
"Hello, 247 sports, please put out there that I have schedule a visit with Michigan"
"Honey, there is something for you at the front door ..."
|6 weeks 18 hours ago||Maybe I have a more cynical view of the world||
more in line with this ESPN Commentary: Sadly, cheating is nothing new
I forgot the America's Cup cheating scandal as well.
So, I guess to answer the original OP's question: I am sadly not outraged by common place cheating - especially for so petty an advantage if any. I don't even think this infraction is a big deal, and do think New England is being excessively singled out (albeit of their own making).
|6 weeks 19 hours ago||OK - so go and tell every||
offensive lineman to stop cheating - no more holding
and every defensive back to stop cheating - no more pass interference and defensive holding, etc.
Then there is no rubbin' in racin', fouling in basketball, etc.
The point: this is a whole lot to do about nothing - it is what happens every day in sport.
|6 weeks 22 hours ago||You forgot opportunity cost||
how much revenue are they losing from the rooms on that hallway while they do the repairs?
|6 weeks 1 day ago||So interfering with a receiver||
isn't breaking the rules?
If you listen to the Mike and Mike segment down on the page, it appears the balls were checked at half time and must've been re-inflated by the refs checking them.
So - DB interferes with receiver - which is a rule violation - and the ref doesn't flag it. Game goes on.
Balls get checked at half time, are found to be 2 lbs under - which is a rule violation - and the ref re-inflates the balls and sends them back out no in game "flag".
Both are rule violations done to get a slight advantage - what is the difference?
|6 weeks 1 day ago||The [SEC] Bag Man giveth||
Thus the Bag Man tooketh away?
|6 weeks 1 day ago||Isn't this technicaly META||
rather than OT.
Get it straight OP. IDB!
|6 weeks 1 day ago||I haven't read that they checked the Colts balls||
if they had any left after the game ...
|6 weeks 1 day ago||Like I already said||
here: Just before the half, the refs didn't call three pass interferences, defensive holds, etc, resulting in the Pats having to kick a field goal. The refs set, threw, exchanged, ect. the Pats footballs all day. They didn't question the inflation without prompting from the Colts, and apparently even then didn't intervene during the game.
What is so different between not calling an interference call that impacts the score of a game, and not calling illegal ball inflation during the progress of a game? Why would one be acceptable to question and fine afterward, and the other not?
Both were non-calls by referees during the game for intentional acts that were outside the rules.
Also: did they measure the Colts footballs too? What is the pressure loss expectation for a football during a professional game in inclement weather?
|6 weeks 1 day ago||My view is this||
Just before the half, the refs didn't call three pass interferences, defensive holds, etc, resulting in the Pats having to kick a field goal. The refs set, threw, exchanged, ect. the Pats footballs all day. They didn't question the inflation without prompting from the Colts, and apparently even then didn't intervene during the game.
What is so different between not calling an interference call that impacts the score of a game, and not calling illegal ball inflation during the progress of a game? Why would one be acceptable to question and fine afterward, and the other not? Both were non-calls by referees during the game for intentional acts that were outside the rules.
|6 weeks 1 day ago||How do we know their's weren't too?||
I read somewhere that Payton Manning does this - it's not just a Pats trick.
|6 weeks 2 days ago||The part about not worrying about the next job||
Do your current job to the best of your ability and the next job will come along. I think Jim followed that one to the letter - all through December.
|6 weeks 3 days ago||Do they sell those||
at Bivouac just in case? Would imagine a Northeasterner will have cold weather gear just the same.
|6 weeks 3 days ago||Nope||
BALLSGATE or BALLSGHAZI depending on your political affiliation - but since there were multiple deflated balls involved, the description must be plural.
|6 weeks 3 days ago||Or the NBA||
Or the NBA
|6 weeks 3 days ago||Except I apparently don't know||
what pass interference is anymore.
|7 weeks 3 days ago||Yes but||
can he give his son cream cheese with is bagel?
|7 weeks 5 days ago||Yeah - the poor kid was born in Columbus||
but dad made sure he was sporting the right colors lickety split.
Way to go dad - and more importantly mom. Congrats and Go Blue!
|8 weeks 20 hours ago||You forgot||
the Big Ten is good now.
|8 weeks 21 hours ago||Agreed the imbalance is concerning||
But on the other side of the coin, you get a really senior team for two years every four years which may be what is required to compete for a NC against the oversigning SEC, and JUCO gap filling Big 12.
That is a hypothesis FWIW and needs analysis.
|8 weeks 1 day ago||No, no - according to the national||
pundits, Harbaugh has a total rebuilding exercise to undertake ... Michigan really sucked the last two years, so it must be true still, and thus Harbaugh has to start all over (so says the talking heads).
|8 weeks 2 days ago||no - bad luck||
especially if this is news broken by football scoop
|8 weeks 2 days ago||Did the students always sing "yooouuu suuuuck"||
all through the song, or did they start that when the band tried to play over "YOU SUCK!" at the end?
While I agree, it appears stupid or arrogant a lot of the time, the whole signing of "yooouuu suuuuck" is pretty funny / appears fun for the students.
Did this stem out of Yost?
|8 weeks 2 days ago||Maybe he was thinking about||
Spartan or Ohio Stadium ...
Then again in all seriousness - being in a very large crowd = being in a very large target. Especially if you've had any kind of security experience, how can you not think of the risk you are taking entering a large crowd environment and have the exact concern expressed?
|8 weeks 2 days ago||The funny thing is||
that kid totally disappeared from the radar locally as a D1 potential to watch.
|8 weeks 2 days ago||This is why||
the golden toilet is important. He's way down the hall in the men's room.
|8 weeks 2 days ago||I believe we had||
an OP posting several diary entries critical of conditioning under Wellman leading to a lack of flexibility and injuries.
|8 weeks 6 days ago||or two places||
if anything yesterday shows that conference champions deserve the shot.
|9 weeks 2 days ago||So Oakland is like||
Indy Car racing for the F1 circuit - where you go for your final driving years before retirement?
|9 weeks 2 days ago||He extremely competitive||
And thus wants to win the top game in his game: the Superbowl.
That said - his heart seems so back at Michigan. He's a dyed in the wool Bo deciple.
|9 weeks 4 days ago||At this stage||
He would piss a lot of people off, including former assistants and most all of the Michigan insiders. Elephant like people who have long never-forgetting memories and already prostrated themselves by "forgiving and forgetting" Harbaugh's prior criticism and openly supporting Jim as the next coach.
If he changes his mind now, there is no coming back - he'll be a black sheep like Miles or worse for the rest of his career.
I believe this thing has been somewhat orchestrated for a while by Jack. Even the Hoke and Mattison hires were Harbaugh aided to rebuild the recruiting classes in the event that at some point in the future John or Jim wished to step in when Hoke was finished. (i.e., he didn't come last time because he wisely thought he could be successful faster with the 49ers given our self inflicted recruiting holes.)
I think that time line moved up on them: they expected Hoke to turn the corner and be successful longer - gave him space and air cover. That didn't happen so the time is now.
Very unlikely Michigan would extend their necks so far unless this a commitment of honor. Everyone else say otherwise are media trolling for clicks. (Remain calm and stop feeding the trolls ...)
|9 weeks 4 days ago||Same||
here in NC.
|9 weeks 4 days ago||I saw my Buckeye neighbor yesterday||
He is excited if Harbaugh signs and shows up in Ann Arbor. He wants to go bar to the competitive war, and figures it will be good for the Big Ten.
So depends if you listen to the truck driver variety or actual Buckeye alumni maybe?
|9 weeks 5 days ago||Bartender||
I'll have what he's having!
|9 weeks 6 days ago||See that's the thing||
the big question about Hoke is whether he can motivate 4 and 5 star guys to their fullest potential. His good guy routine works well for teaching and supporting development of Mac or Mountain West talent over a 3 to 4 year curve.
So how does that work in the NFL. Maybe - given the resistance to Jim Harbaugh motivation - "good guy" works with NFL talent. Maybe - given the failure at Michigan - it doesn't.
|9 weeks 6 days ago||What amazes me is how the NFL homers totally overlook||
what Michigan means to people who went to Michigan, and especially to guys who played for Michigan. His heart is in the NFL .... bull shit!
Yeah, he wants a Superbowl ring, but how much does he want to run through the tunnel, touch the banner, and beat Ohio State again?
Also, they seem to equate any NFL job with a higher stature than even the top college jobs. Nick Saban begs to differ.
|10 weeks 1 day ago||Yeah, the NFL big brother police||
forced him to say that ...
|10 weeks 1 day ago||I need to turn off the WD twitter notification plan||
And stop checking mgoblog and worry about this after Christmas.
|10 weeks 2 days ago||Sure||
I'll bet there'll be a lot of "how are you today coach", I am doing great and you, coach" water cooler discussions.
|10 weeks 4 days ago||So Harbaugh is going||
to interview the existing staff for positions via video conferencing - interesting ...
or is he addressing the team?
[I just totally made that up FWIW.]
|10 weeks 4 days ago||Hmm - this opinion piece||
seems to be written rationally. I hadn't considered this may be his last chance / he doesn't want to be like Les Miles...
|10 weeks 4 days ago||Maybe it is a false impression||
But don't most of Saban's oversigning cuts get a continued scholarship of some type (unless it is a greyshirt offer)?
To me, if a guy hasn't worked out to where he's competitive, that is a fair deal.
|10 weeks 4 days ago||I think Michigan doesn't||
take Jucos but once in a blue moon because of transfer credit issues.
That said Jucos are a an important part of the educational infrastructure for a number of reasons and someone transferring in should be respected.
Interestingly, with all the state budget cuts for education down here, NC State sent a letter to alums with college bound seniors saying they were going to start being more selective for incoming freshman classes, and accept more transfers from 2+2 programs at UNC Wilmington or Wake Tech CC, etc.
I don't see many comments disparaging that route. Most complaints I've seen in the past were about Michigan admissions making this almost impossible for football player transfers thus making our playing field tilt a little against us.
|10 weeks 5 days ago||Yep - the OSU fans||
I know are the same way - want it to be a competitive rivalry. They are all alums though - maybe a difference there.
|10 weeks 5 days ago||My neighbors who are||
B1G grads from various schools all at least are happy to see we are going after him the way we should THIS TIME ...
The last two processes were such an embarrassment - even when the first one landed a hot name coach.
|10 weeks 5 days ago||Now see, if I was an egomaniac||
I could work for egomaniacs. This is why Jimmy should come home.
|10 weeks 6 days ago||It's alright dad||
You did it! You have successfully launched your kid into the world and it is an awesome feeling.
|10 weeks 6 days ago||It's been a while since I switched companies||
But last time I did you could sign in a way that allowed for two weeks notice on one side, and a declared 1st day of work in the future on the other.
It is true that he cannot do that with an NFL team unless released from his contract by San Fran or San Fran is compensated for the remaining contract. But my understanding is an NFL contact number of years is a commitment at the NFL level. A college contract is a separate thing (a college does not have to pay the buyout for Jims final year for example).
So we'll see I guess. Our best two guts (Sam's and Brian's) are still queasy but hopeful, so that's where mine remains.
|11 weeks 11 hours ago||I don't think he's saying "shit"||
in that picture - that is definitely a "fu" mouth formation
|11 weeks 22 hours ago||No buyout if he signs w Michigan||
So now that the papers have been alledgedly delivered for his review, he can sign at anytime. They can even structure it so he can sign starting Jan 1st unless the Nines fire him earlier, etc.
And if he signs the can(attempt to) delay the official announcement until the 29th.
|11 weeks 1 day ago||Nice job||
couldn't have said it better.
These kids have four years to state their case for the NFL. Going into an unknown is a huge risk. Rather than telling them to fuck off, perhaps asking them to reconsider is the wiser, more understanding course.
|11 weeks 1 day ago||Eh - I think you're overblowing||
if true, we offered Harbaugh for realz top dollars for NFL and College coaches. If he turns down the offer, the entire fan base can comfortably be done with him, and A list coaches thinking about being plan B know we ain't kidding this time.
This is a brash, no fucking around, move. And now that it is out there, Harbaugh has to publicly declare sooner or later. The leak may have been intentional to force some hands to be shown.
I like Hacket's game.
|11 weeks 1 day ago||Was wondering how NFL contracts affect this||
From what I have read on the 29th there are several scenarios:
1) JH quits (and owes the Niners buy out money?)
2) Another NFL team offers JH, JH accepts, and they compensate the Niners with buy out money, and a trade (Jon Gruden precedent).
3) Another NFL team(s) offer JH and he declines, in which case:
a) the Niners retain him as head coach for his final contract year - or -
b) they fire him and owe him the final year of his contract
4) JH takes the Michigan job (for which he does not owe a buy out?)
Do I have these right???
You're Jim Harbaugh - what do you do? You wait, check the NFL options, and either do 2 or 3 a or b + 4 having leveraged 2 to get the most out of Michigan. (Who in their right mind would want to coach the Jets, Browns, Phins or Raiders? Chicago I can see.)
At some point on the 29th Harbaugh and the Niner's owners will be playing high stakes poker and bluffs will be called.
|11 weeks 1 day ago||Why would the marketing guy||
be in the inner circle of a confidential coaching hire, and have that information to leak?
The only reason to loop him in, is if you have a signed deal and he needs to spin the announcement .... IT'S HAPPENING!!!!
|11 weeks 1 day ago||No, no, no||
His office is where the golden toilet will go.
|11 weeks 1 day ago||I don't||
what a stupid time to stick your head up out of the foxhole and say something as callous as he did. It's like he was asking for a package. (Which maybe he was.)
|11 weeks 1 day ago||Total control in the NFL||
Ah ha ha ha ...
|11 weeks 1 day ago||We spent every year||
But the "growing years" hoping we'd get past ND with a win. The ND game determined if we were on track for a run at the National Championship because pre-BCS you had to go undefeated.
If we made it into the conference season undefeated then there was upstart Big Ten team that year leading to The Game, which was the ticket to the Rose Bowl.
The tension was don't lose a game, and after that get to the Rose Bowl. It was still a tragic tension but the first loss took you out of an NC run - it didn't lead you to assume a disaster of season was about to unfold. (Even when Jimmy broke his arm.)
And so, we were bummed if we lost early or to the upstart team, but had or steam back for OSU. S party was a side show.
That was '83 - '87.
|11 weeks 2 days ago||Yeah - a little sharpie action||
and he is good to go!
|11 weeks 2 days ago||I agree with you||
And I think it's been Harbaugh for quite a while - maybe even before Brandon exited, at least as far back as Sam's initial Wheatley slip and everyone including Lloyd Carr saying they think Harbaugh is the guy.
Everyone is acting weird with slips around the edges because the inner circle thinks it's right that Harbaugh finish his season first and at the same time are greasing the skids for a smoother start.
Something happened in SFO before the Seattle game in SFO to cause the players to half ass it in the game and all the dysfunction to spill out onto twitter afterwards, and then it went silent and amiable again yesterday. I think the deal was penned in Seattle. (Any Kalitta charters coming back from Seattle? Even connecting somewhere else?)
All of this is e-pionion sure, but we outer circle have to let the chess match play out here.
|11 weeks 2 days ago||Not to mention||
a relative dysfunction-less 49ers set of statements. It is like a decision has been reached, so everyone can settle down.
|11 weeks 2 days ago||Will you please||
We're dying ovah heah ...
|11 weeks 3 days ago||The don't have gold toilets at the HoJo||
nor on the Gulfstream (too heavy)
Yeah - Harbaugh is a control guy - and the good NFL teams that offer up control are few and far between. I think there is a lot of NFL wonk BS out there.
It comes down to the lure of a CoFoPo championship vs a Superbowl championship.
|11 weeks 3 days ago||I think Harbaugh just found out the hard way||
that an NFL coach is just some rich guy's toy. At the end of the day, the players get paid by said rich guy, so they effectively report to the rich guy, so does the GM, which means the coach has very little leverage.
A lot of dysfunction in the NFL comes from this, SF, Dallas, Washington, Miami, ... all great examples of coach wanna be rich guys meddling too much with the team and running coaches through revolving doors.
Do we really think a Saban or a Meyer would want to subject themselves to that? I am hoping Jim Harbaugh has decided he's done with it too.
|11 weeks 3 days ago||Hey have you suffered through back pain ....||
it was medicinal man ....
|11 weeks 3 days ago||We miss ya||
big guy ...
|11 weeks 6 days ago||It's the power of the Block M||
not what is behind it that is captivating your attention.
|11 weeks 6 days ago||I don't understand why they feel the need||
to entertain us. We have been on waiting lists and coming to games for years in 100000+ droves, cheered the team, watched the band warm up, or the drum line perform on the steps, etc. All of that plus the tailgating experience with friends and family or the lawn parties on the way, the band before the game and during the half, the banner, and a really good football game played by a great home football team - that is what we want.
That is why people come back to Michigan to watch football - emotionally they can not get the same connection anywhere else.
If Brandon's crack team of geniuses keep it up, I'll be able to get the same exact entertainment I get at a Hurrcane's game, or a Durham Bull's game, or an NC State game, or a Panther's game. Heck our high school football team plays the same music. They don't understand what the golden goose is made of.
|11 weeks 6 days ago||The results depend||
on the objectives set forth. I am sure Dave and Brady met the objectives at the time.
|11 weeks 6 days ago||The linemen||
have been young. Next year they should be (maybe except Cole) close their "mature" playing weight.
So looking at them this year or last, is not an accurate look.
|11 weeks 6 days ago||My view||
either research it before you say something, or don't say something about what you don't know.
His whole point was we haven't had a lot of people drafted, which is a trailing measure of the exact hole we have been wading through. But his error was using the trailing measure as a leading measure for the current roster talent.
|12 weeks 11 hours ago||Sorta like Bo and Woody||
Great competitors like great competition ...
|12 weeks 11 hours ago||This would be hilarious||
And a great fit.
They ought to take a pass at Brady Hoke as well.
|12 weeks 1 day ago||Yep||
Guess I'll stand by my initial "toddler" response, agree with BiSB, and be done with it.
|12 weeks 1 day ago||Yeah - I missed it||
and then I got it when you edited my initial post.
You are right, these are internet message boards, and attempts to discuss hot button social issues will likely devolve. For Monocle - my intent was to initiate a discussion based on the description of a problem written by a psychotherapist (granted his opinions were not acceptable) and a Time article, not a flame war.
All that said, if we in society do not discuss these issues - instead simply avoid discourse because we are afraid of it getting out of control - then how do we resolve them?
FWIW - I think the whole thread should be locked or removed because there are several jests made at the expense of a rival in a situation that shouldn't be made light of . It reflects badly, particularly given Michigan's own recent incidents.
|12 weeks 1 day ago||Just never mind||
No one is big enough to rationally discuss
|12 weeks 1 day ago||Never mind||
[Edit: never mind]
|12 weeks 1 day ago||A counterpoint worth discussion||
[ED:BISB - Nope. Not a counterpoint worth discussing. Not a counterpoint at all. Just some amazingly convoluted stuff that we AREN'T GONNA DISCUSS HERE]
|12 weeks 1 day ago||Which headline do you run with?||
Oh yeah, Michigan reached out to David Cutliffe to gauge his interest in being considered for the Michigan job, and had said he was happy at Duke thank you
- or -
OMG! MICHIGAN OFFERED DUKE (YES DUKE) HEAD COACH THE JOB AND HE TURNED THEM DOWN!
|12 weeks 1 day ago||Or Stoops||
or Mullen, or even Les
we need a big hit hire to shut everyone up.
|12 weeks 1 day ago||Yeah - this was an interest gauge||
I have met Coach Cutliffe. He is a Southern Brady Hoke. His objective is to build Duke to a Stanford like relevance the right way. My impression is he's happy here because there isn't a lot of pressure, and he can take a long term approach.
Knew his answer would be no. Also, given Michigan's definition of ideal candidates, I am not surprised they asked if he is interested. Shows the search firm is doing diligence.
Meanwhile, hey everybody look at my hand waving in the Southeast over this way ...
|12 weeks 2 days ago||Les is due for a contract extension right?||
About that time?
|12 weeks 3 days ago||Seems like Sam's arms are really being twisted||
behind his back. He knows too much, and is being forced to act out to keep the smoke out there or be cut off.
He needs a long vacation when this is done.
There seems like a lot of odd silence in general between the echo chamber reporting.
|12 weeks 3 days ago||First , it is interesting he thought about the question||
before asked, and chose to make an oblique leadership statement in response, rather than the run of the mill non-answer.
Second, Bo was less a military guy, but I am wondering if this is a Woody reference. A quick google didn't bring up a reference in lasting lessons, or in reference to Woody, but Woody frequently referenced the military, and Jim draws his lessons from both Bo and Woody.
|12 weeks 3 days ago||Funny - Panther Creek is where my son plays||
My son wasn't there in 2009, and none of the staff remains. We were 5-7 in 2009, but put a lot of points on the board for the most part.
Why does this write up not impress me very much?
|12 weeks 3 days ago||We need this thread why?||
|12 weeks 3 days ago||I was thinking we need to come up with a different name||
Snowflake threads started during the decline ...
|12 weeks 3 days ago||There are two points there||
1) Harbaugh does have faults - his intensity has clearly worn out in his current locker room, and has been the root of public incdents before. He's not Woody-unhinged, but definitely someone you have to make allowances for.
2) It appears the poster assumes Harbaugh is not coming this time. Honestly, if at the end of the day Harbaugh does turn us down this time, I think we need to be done with him. he'll have turned us down twice in our darkest hours.
Both points are reasonable points of view.
|12 weeks 3 days ago||Saban to Alabama||
Seem to recall that being a must get deal.
|12 weeks 3 days ago||I think there is an||
ECHO .... Echo .... echo
|12 weeks 3 days ago||The alternative would||
be worse for us.
|12 weeks 3 days ago||The difference is||
the Buckeyes got one more nationally televised game to prove the backup to the backup can ball too before the final decision was made.
|12 weeks 3 days ago||It goes farther back||
The Harbaughs put Hoke in place last coaching change and sent Mattison to build the recruiting up in advance of one Harbaugh taking over. Hoke was a fall guy from the start.
|12 weeks 4 days ago||As I recall||
Jimmy is confident enough in his own abilities that none of that is a significant stress to him.
|12 weeks 5 days ago||Different target users||
Android is for developers and self integrators and people who like to tinker and tweak.
The iPhone is for people who don't have time or interest and just want complex technology to simply work for them.
Both have their big brother aspects like when I phones slammed every user over to imessage and it took my wife two weeks to figure out I wasn't getting all of her messages.
|13 weeks 11 hours ago||And Miss Rita||
makes awesome nacho dip ya'll!
(Another reason Dave Brandon fired Rich, is Miss Rita refused to have her nacho dip sponsored by Rotel ...)
|13 weeks 15 hours ago||Stoops, Gundy||
or Mark Richt.
|13 weeks 18 hours ago||Took them 2-1/2 weeks||
So Hackett should know by Christmas, and depending on where from, we should know by January 4th or so?
|13 weeks 1 day ago||So is the a silver lever on the left side for that||
and does the data swirl to the right or the left as it is flushed out
|13 weeks 1 day ago||This is a boss I'd like to work for||
|13 weeks 1 day ago||Yeah - that was interesting||
especially since there was a tweet yesterday that Mattison's office was already cleaned out.
|13 weeks 2 days ago||Double Manhattan||
Father and step mother in laws coming tomorrow ...
|13 weeks 2 days ago||Jack Miller||
|13 weeks 2 days ago||That was impressive||
very well done by Hackett. Wojo's questions were very well asked too. Like a mirco chess match there.
|13 weeks 2 days ago||Oh come on you guys||
WTF else are we going to do besides hit F5 all day?
|13 weeks 2 days ago||Where is||
George Smiley when you need him.
|13 weeks 2 days ago||Rich Rod tried that||
they brought down an NCAA investigation on his ass
|13 weeks 3 days ago||I upvoted State Street and down voted you||
because you have no sense of humor - especially gallows humor.
|13 weeks 3 days ago||The End|
|13 weeks 3 days ago||To me it is quite simple||
you are either a team with cache that can oversign with impugnity and run any damned offense you choose, clubbing all those before you,
- OR -
you'd better be damned ready to put a ton of points on the board quickly when you come up against a better spread team (like Oregon, either OSU, 2007 Florida or WVU, etc.). One only has to look at Troy Smith led OSU, App State I, and Oregon after it, versus say the Cap One Bowl to know why - and that situation has gotten worse, not better.
There are times when your defense will be unable to stop the opponent's offense enough.
|13 weeks 3 days ago||Jack Miller||
Frank Clark would have been in that mix.
|13 weeks 4 days ago||Season ticket sales||
timing of PSD payments. etc.
|13 weeks 4 days ago||I am confused by this||
would the 49ers PREFER Harbaugh coaching a college team over another NFL team?
If they were smart they'd fire him now so they don't get beat by him on Sundays every year hereafter.
|13 weeks 4 days ago||If we hire the right coach||
This team showed an offensive pulse in the last two games that looked like - we'll football.
Given MSU and OSS at home next year, I think a new coaching staff with a similar play book could contend for the Big Ten championship. The Rodriguez Hoke transition gap is behind us. The new staff just needs to get these guys to believe and execute (on game day apparently).
|13 weeks 5 days ago||Johnson runs with heart||
like Hart. Low, and keeps on going.
|13 weeks 6 days ago||You're right, we should just||
keep Hoke. Jim Harbaugh has no reason beyond those three other guys to be swayed to coach at Michigan. Their locker rooms and bosses totally want to get rid of them too. They all quote Bo as well. And having played here is no big deal.
|13 weeks 6 days ago||Watching that game last night||
it looked to me like his receivers were not playing full speed - always 3 steps from where they needed to be - and not blocking down field like Seattle's receivers.
It say whatever is going on in the locker room is spilling onto the field.
|14 weeks 2 days ago||Power 5||
How will recruiting be different for these guys in a Power 5 world, unless the Power 5 decide to allow more than 85 scholarships? I'm not getting how the Power 5 offering more benefits, impacts the non-Power 5 in football - the same number of recruits not signed with Power 5 schools will be available.
I think Power 5 impacts basketball more - same number of recruits limits yeah, but now there are many non-Power 5 basketball powerhouses that a top recruit would consider over a Power 5 school - that equation may change.
|14 weeks 2 days ago||I'm old and I feel the same way||
I appreciate the respect from the past but this game hasn't been what it was since 2006 and it is us (Michigan) who are stinking up the place including the Big Ten.
Saturday is going to be like going in for a colonoscopy or a root canal. No joy in a coming epic clash.
|14 weeks 3 days ago||whatever||
just whatever ...
|14 weeks 3 days ago||I think the butterfly we are looking for||
is Rodriguez firing all of Lloyd's staff - might be before that - but the division started then. Which led to practice-gate, which led to Brandon's hiring, which led to Rodriguez's firing, which led to a sub .500 Michigan-man who's staff down to the water boy breathed defense, and so on.
It doesn't matter though - what matters is what is done about it, and how the players and stakeholders around them respond.
|14 weeks 3 days ago||I confess - I am a corporate spreadsheet type||
but in our defense - we tend to tell our leadership the truth of the analysis, and then our leadership just goes and does what they want anyway. The other scenario is, when we get yelled at enough for telling them the truth - then we just shut up and let them believe what they want to believe. Oh wait - then the is the scenario where the yes men (and women) around the leadership find a wait to discredit the spreadsheet in support of whatever the leader believes.
Yes men (and women) get promoted and big raises. Spreadsheet jocks - not so much.
Net: I don't think the spreadsheet types are the problem here: all of this smacks of "this is what the Miami Dolphins do for a wow fan experience, so should we". (Check the link - a wow fan experience is something they pursue in Miami.)
|14 weeks 4 days ago||I like the added info||
that the board expects stability for several years after a coaching hire. Thanks for posting.
|14 weeks 5 days ago||I thought the female dinosaur laid an egg||
and then the male dinosaur fertilized the egg.
Did they recently discover something different?
|14 weeks 6 days ago||They totally should||
run with this. It has a chance of having legs much longer than the freedom trophy. Imagine how dodgy it will look in 50 years - perfect.
|14 weeks 6 days ago||I have thought about the Dan Mullen / Les Miles thing||
Wasn't the bag man article supposedly about Mississippi State recruiting (or was it Ole' Miss), and haven't some of their recruits posted the cash flash pictures? Les Miles is just as guity of oversigning and last minute greyshirting.
The thing is, the SEC operates on a different lens - oversigning is ok and above board - an accepted practice. These kids know if they sign with an SEC school, that is the risk they take (or they should). They still sign with SEC schools knowing the risk because they think it is their best change to get to the NFL. As a 3 star QB, you probably should have a backup plan - even if the bag man pays you not to.
As for the bag man part of it - not sure how connected it is to the coaching staff, or if it happens organically.
Anwway, any coach or assistant you pull from the SEC will have been a part of this different lens - they had to, to compete.
So I guess the question I would have, is can that coach accept the Big Ten / Michigan lens, and operate competitively within in?
|15 weeks 1 day ago||Is that only for single MGoBlog users||
that hit 1000 points, or in-state users? That didn't happend back when I hit 1000 points.
|15 weeks 2 days ago||Yeah||
how could anyone forget GERG and his beaver
|15 weeks 2 days ago||I respectfully disagree||
while there may be the stereotypical drunken man who comes home and beats a woman, what I have read about or seen more often is a couple in a heated argument where the woman starts the physical violence and the man cracks. In our popular culture, a woman hitting a man upside the head with a frying pan is funny / he probably deserves it / it gets his attention. The problem is in the real world he could instinctively respond in defense and that response is likely going to be more signifincant - especially if he is a college or professional athlete - especially if they come from a background where instinctive defense is an everyday necessity. Both Ray Rice and this case are such cases.
They shouldn't happen, and they do, and it is sad.
|15 weeks 3 days ago||I can think of a few||
Forcier, and one other - who left due to real grade problems, and a few Carr and Rodriguez recruits who never were accepted to the University (which don't count - Dorsey the big name there), but for the most part I think the graduation and APR issue under Rodriguez was early departures to to coaching change related turnover. (e.g., Mallet, Arrington, Manningham, and Mr. Plow all counted against Rodriguez's APR even though they left early for Football issues, not grade issues).
This is where Hoke's 69 of 69 confuses me - he had some early departures as well didn't he? I know not nearly as many, which is why the APRs have climbed back up, but are we counting different stats? Certainly some players who would have been Seniors left Michigan before graduating.
|15 weeks 3 days ago||This makes no sense||
direclty - no. Hoke has handled this exactly the way he should have. Clark is dismissed.
indirectly - maybe. Frank was a defensive star starter who now needs to be replaced for the last two games of which one has to be won to be bowl eligible. It depends on how critical Frank was, and whether you believe an Ohio State miracle was possible, and enough to save Hoke's job. Those odds are lower now without Frank.
In Hoke's defense here, he has lowered his odds before, suspending Floyd and Hagerup for the Outback Bowl (which we lost by 5), dismissing Stonum, and suspending Toussant.
If he is fired - this isn't the last straw.
|15 weeks 3 days ago||I think given the timing||
the end of Clark's senior season - there is no opportunity for a extended suspension while the legal system processes - so in this case it is a dismissal.
And the decision is the right decision.
|15 weeks 4 days ago||He stole a laptop||
Sure, after he was found with it, but it was returned, and he paid the owner an amount equal to the value of the laptop.
Not OK sure, but not the end of the world either - and (according to Angelique) he appeared to have learned his lesson until now.
|15 weeks 6 days ago||I bought one of those rotorooter||
chimney sweeper dealies for dryer vents from Walmart. It works pretty well, but my dryer is on the second floor and I got covered in ash like dust standing on a ladder rotorooting out the vent. Suggestion, wear a hat, goggles and dust mask (or bandana).
The Committee won't let you back in the house until you've added your clothes to the random piles in the garage ...
|15 weeks 6 days ago||Do an Earle Bruce firing||
Fired effective the day after the bowl game / starting the coaching search now.
The hire the new coach in a way that they can put a recruiting staff in Ann Arbor while finishing out their existing season. (If their current employer chooses to let them go ASAP - a la Bo - then we at least tried to do this with integrity.)
|15 weeks 6 days ago||Yes - this us what I figure as well||
Sort of like Congrssional oversight: come into town for the beginning of basketball season. Hang out and eat a bunch of catered food while "reviewing" the work UNC's independent review team already did. Talk to a few people (not the people involved who were fired already).
Then announce a probation with annual follow-up reviews around the time Duke and UNC play at UNC.
Either that or UNC Pembroke loses their accreditation.
|15 weeks 6 days ago||Them or||
|16 weeks 11 hours ago||I think your last paragraph||
is a nicely put addendum to Brian's post.
I also think, even if a player chooses to get a degree in Football, there should still be core University requirements as well.
I suspect Art or Dance are similar examples to Music as well.
|16 weeks 17 hours ago||Uh - last I checked Hoke is in the top 10||
for coaching pay. So correcting your statement, we have a "steady hand that is not a big-name ... football coach" that is big-money.
|16 weeks 1 day ago||I am assuming the||
monitoring classes for more than 20% athletes comment that Schlissel made was directly related to the Independent Studies scandal.
I also recall a story about a list of easy classes being provided to athletes at Stanford.
This is where I agree with Schlissel, and think that the NCAA needs to own UNC as an example of a broader problem that requires broader policy changes.
|16 weeks 2 days ago||If this is the case||
I predict we lose two recruiting classes (meaning the number and level of recruits are lower than they should have been) much like the last two classes of Rodriguez's time here, and a number of season ticket holders.
|16 weeks 2 days ago||There are two players||
who lead Clark in tackles this season.
|16 weeks 2 days ago||We all know what he is saying||
and you are trying to gloss it over.
|16 weeks 2 days ago||I agree Harbaugh is unlikely||
However neither of our opinions mean anything until Harbaughs agent is contacted with a whispered proposed offer
|16 weeks 2 days ago||Anyone else wonder if||
when they practice well, our high ranked defense is beating the snot out of our low ranked offense, further traumatizing our QBs (think how Simian felt last Saturday night 4 days a week), demoralizing our receivers, and confounding our RBs? I mean since the defense was killing our offense - in Brady ' s mind they worked hard in practice. Meanwhile morale on the opposite side is exasperated.
This is kind of how it looks in games. The O-line and in spurts the RBs seem to be the only ones with their heads on straight.
|16 weeks 2 days ago||We suck||
and there are less time slots at noon to back channel unwatchable football games to.
FWIW Dave Brandon said he preferred noon games, and probably tried to get noon starts - but the $dollahs$ drive the time.
|16 weeks 3 days ago||Where's the voting||
dongfumble has to take the cake.
|16 weeks 3 days ago||I think you could throw in||
staff change out as a reason to believe things could get better.
|16 weeks 3 days ago||Oh - it was even more nonsensical||
Marcus Ray thinks Michigan should keep Hoke to preserve the recruiting class. If Hoke doesn't turn the corner next year, then go after Harbaugh or Butch Jones and deal with the recruiting fall out then.
Our projected recruiting class this year is what 15? And the damage is already rampant. Add to that it seems Harbaugh may be in a poach-able state now.
So if we followed Marcus' logic: this year's class is weakened, we hold onto Hoke, Harbaugh gets a job somewhere else for sure, and if Hoke doesn't work out next year's larger class is a disaster too.
If we follow that route: waiting until 2015 ensures whoever is hired is facing the same exact dip down the road Rodriguez and Hoke faced - a recipe for continued suck.
There was also the bizarre comment that he didn't think spread was a good idea, but he thought Harbaugh - a pro-style coach - would get us competing for B1G championships, but not into the playoffs, however Butch Jones - a spread coach - would get us to the playoffs.
I really think the Hoke supporters are weaving the BS as fast as they can to try to buy one more year.
|16 weeks 3 days ago||It's like Ryan and Clark watched film all week||
and everyone else - not so much. Was it exam week or something?
|16 weeks 4 days ago||I think those people||
are getting their just dessert this year. I also suspect this next time around those people are being told to shut up and sit down.
|16 weeks 4 days ago||We could finally see||
the offense we've dreamed of and the defense in one game - both on the field at the same time.
|16 weeks 4 days ago||It's quite simple really||
we don't have a QB coach, and haven't since Rod Smith left (who himself developed a different skill set of QB).
When you have a QB coach, the QB coach can coach up the QBs on the side lines in games while the OC is in the booth, and the QB coach can coach up the QBs during practice, while the OC works on the overall strategy and tactics across the offensive players.
Our quarterbacks don't get dedicated coaching and counselling - this is why they haven't developed quickly enough (said particularly int he light of three OC changes).
|16 weeks 4 days ago||On this I disagree||
Marcus Ray talked in circles the other day, [like why would we retain Hoke this year to maintain a small recruiting class, and then evaluate him next year when an even larger recruiting class would be at risk?].
However, I agree with Marcus that one risk of Jim Harbaugh is old school football gets at a high level of competition that may not be enough to be at the very top. Especially when you run up against the oversigning Alabamas of the world.
Side note: remember 2006 when the Michigan - Ohio State game was the clash of titans like that Bama - LSU game last night? Sad state ....
|16 weeks 4 days ago||I said it in 2007 and I'll say it now||
Jim said something that was probably true - players were, and still are advised into paths where they can stay eligible and graduate. Vincent Smith said on this blog he regretted not being able to take some more advanced classes like calculus. Reality is: only the top 5-10% or so of students nationally can compete on the grading curve in the more rigorous subjects at Michigan. An even more narrow subset have the right physical make up and skills to play football. It later came out that at Stanford there was an official list of easier classes to take to balance you work load.
People don't like to bring up the fact that a lot of players were in General Studies, and later Kinesiology, etc. The worst part was Jim just happened to say it to the Ann Arbor News when they were trying expose a questionable course and broadening into a larger question of academic integrity.
At the end of the day, this is one of 3 places I think the NCAA has to change:
1) Improve the academic mission: Properly prepare the athletes for college level courses, continue to ethically support them through school, and give the athletes the opportunity to come back and pursue a second degree once their playing days are over.
2) Shift to the Olympic model: most of the athletes will never be successful at the professional level. Allow them to earn what they can through endorsements, and autographs, and sponsorships while they are in college. [Yes they already are economically benefiting from their ability, but if we brought all this stuff above board, the sport would be more ethical. Why should coaches and ADs officially get cars and not players if the free market supports it?]
3) Extend medical coverage for injuries sustained while playing college sports.
As for Jim, in his locker room speech before the 2009 Sun Bowl, Jim Harbaugh asked the Cardinals if they wanted "to be the conquering heroes?"
|16 weeks 4 days ago||No||
We fucking suck like shit damn it.
|16 weeks 6 days ago||Uh - NC State played||
Florida State close. I think we'd lose to them too.
|17 weeks 21 hours ago||I think there were complaints about||
RR's way of speaking from the beginning. He never got "he's such a dreamy Michigan Man".
But, yeah - every little thing gets critiqued. It's all part of the package deal in a death march season.
|17 weeks 21 hours ago||Yeah, only Dave's Uncle Vito||
got the injury updates
|17 weeks 1 day ago||Thanks for dropping by Mr. Smith||
We need the dialog. It helps rebuild the bridges.
And I agree - everyone is upset - and many are saying things that come out the wrong way on the spur of the moment.
|17 weeks 2 days ago||I think speed and comprehension of communication||
is a known issue as it is without the added complexity of last second signal stealing based adjustments.
|17 weeks 2 days ago||I didn't watch the video||
but my interpretation of Mattison's comments we're "eh - just another day at the office" in nature instead of whining. The press dug in on the subject, and asked more questions for details, but GMatt was like " business as usual - I would love to be Bama and telegraph what I am going to do because I know you can do nothing about it"
|17 weeks 2 days ago||OK - #2's comment was about offensive signals because:||
If Michigan decided to "steal" the opposing teams defensive signals like IU does, then our adjustment to offensive play call based on the intelligence gained from those "stolen" defensive signals would presummably have to be signaled into the offense in a timely manner.
#2 was saying we don't have time to make those adjustments the way we currently run our offense, so "stealing" the opponents defensive signals (like the OP is suggesting) wouldn't help.
|17 weeks 2 days ago||Hoke's guys||
have been on campus for 3 seasons and still are not good enough at blocking - a true freshman is the best choice at left tackle. Then there is Shane, and the RBs ....
Sorry - the youth excuse doesn't fly with me anymore.
|17 weeks 3 days ago||Don't want no more "wow"||
We fired "wow" last week. Let's get back to football being the primary entertainment. "Wow" is banned to Boliva.
|17 weeks 3 days ago||Yeah - I actually see this on the plus side for Harbaugh||
He is on record for stating UofM could do better on the student side of the balance, coached at Stanford where the recruits are held to a higher standard, and - less on the record - somewhere there was a story about a Woody quote about academics that Harbaugh posted at Stanford.
I didn't interpret Schlissel's comment to be so much about pay, more about mission.
|17 weeks 3 days ago||Well in '85||
we could carry in bags, thermoses, and seat cushions (toilet paper, beach balls, cow bells, etc.). As a student I didn't buy concessions very much at all. My seat location was based on my class year or the frat block location - and no one messed with it.
'85 is a bad comparison (we were 10-1-1), '84 was Bo's 6-6 year. We students did skip some games in '84. I don't know who the AD was, and whatever they were doing didn't piss me off. Yes the times were different because Bo had an established winning history, and everyone knew we sucked because of Harbaugh's broken collarbone.
So that is the different thing here - over 2005, 1984, etc.- Dave Brandon has managed to do a sufficient amount of things that pissed people off, that when enough became enough there were petitions, and letters to President Schlissel, and protests, and Fi-re Brandon chants.