Gulo Gulo Luscus
- Member for
- 6 years 51 weeks
- View recent blog entries
|6 days 22 hours ago||"Ranking football teams is an art, not a science.||
"Ranking football teams is an art, not a science. Football is popular in some measure because the outcome
|1 week 2 days ago||Colorado @ Bama, PSU @ OSU, Wisconsin @ Clemson,||
Colorado @ Bama, PSU @ OSU, Wisconsin @ Clemson, Michigan @ Washington... not bad!
|1 week 2 days ago||ok stop. now i'm genuinely||
ok stop. now i'm genuinely pissed at jim for not having that trick in the bag vs MSU.
|1 week 2 days ago||that i understand. but the||
that i understand. but the ball crossed the plane for evans way before his foot landed out of bounds. if we imagine the goal line is instead the 50 in the screenshot below, does the ball get spotted shy of the 50 (wherever it was when it crossed the sideline)? i think so, but what if the players body has not crossed the sideline yet? and doesn't the "plane of the goal line extends infinitely" concept make this unique? football rules are complicated.
harbaugh asked whether that's a TD if his foot had hit the pylon. i think the answer is "yes" since that is equivalent to his toe touching the field in the end zone. chris should have just stuck the ball out a bit but seems like this should be ruled a TD.
|1 week 2 days ago||wow. i hadn't even considered||
wow. i hadn't even considered that and now i'm infuriated all over again.
|1 week 2 days ago||right call. bad rule.another||
right call. bad rule.
another bad rule that needs to be addressed is that you can end the game with an intentional offensive penalty. in a just rulebook, the refs giving CMU a hail mary shot would have been the right call. same can be said for the recent illinois high school controversy where the refs also misapplied the same untimed down rule. and now jim's brother is taunting the football gods with this one!
|1 week 3 days ago||Generous||
Good on ya! I put in for $50.
You raised the fundraiser total to: !
|1 week 4 days ago||Thank you for the correction||
Thank you for the correction - no excuse for whiffing that one.
|1 week 4 days ago||I don't see depth at OL, especially since Newsome||
I'm not worried about next year, I think we can be very good and in the hunt again. But your OP doesn't really line up with this comment.
Hard to see depth at OL, especially since Newsome is totally up in the air. That leaves Cole as the only one with any experience (JBB and Kugler maybe had one start each this year?) and a distinct possibility of playing freshmen. I'll reserve judgment until Spring/Fall but the caveat "young depth" is sugar coating the uncertainty with this position group.
The secondary is "better with Clark" than without but won't be better than this year. I could see our young WR prospects turning out a plus but as of today seems like another group that takes a step back. We will like what we see in 2017 but our starting DBs and WRs will be hard to replace. Realistically, Peppers is gone; Hurst likely as well.
I do agree that having MSU/OSU at home is huge and really look forward to seeing the development from Gary and Speight. It's not that I'm even concerned about our ability to compete, just reacting to what I see on your depth chart versus what this comment says.
|1 week 5 days ago||Wait... OSU has 4 top 10 wins with two being||
Wait... OSU has 4 top 10 wins with two being blowouts?
- Blowout vs Oklahoma
- Beat Wisconsin in OT
- Lost to PSU
- Beat Michigan in 2OT
Or are you counting Nebraska because they were #10 at the time? And if so, why are you including Oklahoma? They were #14 in week 3, having already lost to Houston.
|1 week 6 days ago||i think that 3 and out ended with a bad pass from||
i think that 3 and out ended with a bad pass from Speight, thrown behind Darboh on an open slant? conservative call, sure, but that one was on the QB.
|2 weeks 10 hours ago||I think coaches, as a herd, should be more||
I have engaged with Craig many times in his search for the Unified Theory of Football. When he first shared Romer's work, it became clear to me that coaches, as a herd, should be more aggressive on fourth. Dramatically so, even. But it's hard for me to accept the premise the 4th down chart is as context-independent as theorized. Elaborating a bit on the author's examples...
Scenario A: 4th and 3 from the opponent 35. Your Freshman punter hasn't coffin-cornered one all year; your swiss-cheese defense lost its starting safety to a rolled ankle on the last drive; RB has been punishing opponents in short yardage all game; game is tied 45-45 with 8 minutes left in the 4th.
Scenario B: 4th and 3 from the opponent 35. Your All-American punter has pinned the ball inside the 10 all year; your offense has picked up just 5 first downs all game; your DBs have been blanketing WRs all day; game is tied 6-6 with 8 minutes left in the 4th.
The chart is an indispensible reference point, but says "go for it" with equal gusto in both scenarios. I would interpret a decision to punt justifiable in B and abhorrent in A. And the situational context differences here don't even fet into the "human element" that coaches are paid in part to understand with a group of 18-22 year olds. Even if the coach can remain dispassionate when the outcome is unfavorable, he's playing chess with sentient pieces.
|2 weeks 2 days ago||Dude was fighting so hard to maintain eye||
Dude was fighting so hard to maintain eye contact
|3 weeks 3 days ago||Are the wins over top 10/25||
Are the wins over top 10/25 based on ranking at time of the game or as of today? For example, do we get +4 for the win over PSU because they are top 10 now? Or was that worth less because they weren't at the time?
|3 weeks 4 days ago||I'm not sure I understand his explanation here. It||
I'm not sure I understand his explanation here. It wasn't asked directly but felt like he was dodging answering "why did we need to take a TO before 1st down?" That is what happened, right?
|3 weeks 5 days ago||RPS numbers won't be good. Iowa offense was||
RPS numbers won't be good. Iowa offense was actually moving it with good old rock and hit us with a few timely scissors. Defensively they positioned to contain the edge well and stuffed a couple head-scratching runs we sent outside the tackle anyway.
It is beyond my pay grade to say if we got outcoached. I just know we have the better one and still lost. Harbaugh has proven brilliant and this is what he means that every game is a championship game. Every opponent is to be respected. Even Ferentz, target of much mockery here (and for good reason), can rise to the occasion against a superior opponent.
On the fuield the Jimmys and Joes followed suit. Iowa couldn't pass but was solid in the trenches against our monster DL and Wadley was fantastic. Their defense was fine but we had chances. The game was lost on Wilton missing a couple likely TD deep balls and receivers failing to bring in a couple challenging but critical catches.
Positive takeaway: Kenny Allen hits a clutch 51yd FG on the road. At the time I thought he'd miss and was bitching about four down territory and the previous play call.
|4 weeks 14 hours ago||While that last drive never presented a realistic||
While that last drive never presented a realistic threat, I did some nail-biting during MSU.
|4 weeks 5 days ago||evident is the evidence he deserves him a||
evident is the evidence he deserves him a championship
|6 weeks 2 days ago||Methinks he's cracking a beer or two in the car.||
Methinks he's cracking a beer or two in the car. Hopefully for passengers only.
|7 weeks 5 days ago||cover -34 means he's betting on michigan||
cover -34 means he's betting on michigan
|11 weeks 2 days ago||i'd flip rutgers and purdue||
i'd flip rutgers and purdue but otherwise nailed it
|15 weeks 3 days ago||offing them?||
whoa whoa whoa let's not get hasty and start murdering anyone
|19 weeks 3 days ago||Corona, Labatt and Coors||
That's only 3 beers ya drunk!
But seriously, those beers are low quality. It's summer in Michigan, drink some Bell's Oberon.
|22 weeks 10 hours ago||René Auberjonois||
René Auberjonois? #StarTrek
|22 weeks 10 hours ago||I enjoy the stuff myself, but||
I enjoy the stuff myself, but if it's hurting his game then it's a problem. He looked good in Summer League the other night but these bits from a recent NBA.com article are concerning.
|22 weeks 11 hours ago||Good luck young man||
Hoping he has a successful year and is in a position to enroll for 2017
|24 weeks 1 day ago||Fucking brilliant||
Choice bit from your first link:
"As any intelligible American English taboo word or phrase was considered fair game, the participants ended up generating a total of 533 taboo words, including the rather obscure 'cum dumpster' and 'ass pirate'."
|25 weeks 15 hours ago||Thanks, Yo. I posted a few flyers on the block||
Thanks, Yo. I posted a few flyers on the block this morning and it didn't take long to get a call from a neighbor that she was huddled in the corner of his back porch. Definitely a pos bang worthy relief to have her back so quickly!!
|25 weeks 18 hours ago||my indoor cat escaped last night and hasn't||
my indoor cat escaped last night and hasn't returned yet. pos bang me good luck in her making it back home soon!
|25 weeks 5 days ago||I understand you are angry and hurt and this post||
I understand you are angry and hurt and this post felt like a way to respond to the gravity of this event. We are all reacting in our own way. For many of us that happens in private.