Your unpopular sports opinions?

Submitted by DISCUSS Man on

I think the NHL should bring back ties instead of gimmicky shootouts. I also think the NBA should institute a 4 point line that was talked about not that long ago. Would shake up the game of basketball like it was when the 3 was instituted.

No politics or religion, please. This is a thread on your unpopular sports opinions.

DISCUSS

FatGuyTouchdown

February 13th, 2015 at 4:45 PM ^

1. I think John Beilein is one of the best coaches in the country, only behind Coach K, Bill Self, and Billy Donovan. I even have him ahead of Izzo, Matta, Ryan, Calipari, Roy Williams, and Boeheim. 

2. LeBron James is going to be viewed in 20 years as a better basketball player than Kobe and MJ.

3. Honestly breaking the color barrier kind of makes people forget how damn good Jackie Robinson was at Baseball.

4. This Patriots dynasty spanning from 2001-2014 is the most impressive feat in modern day sports. In the Salary Cap era, they won 4 Super Bowls, 6 Conference Championships, 12 Division titles, just incredible to think of.

 

MGoChippewa

February 13th, 2015 at 4:52 PM ^

the best run of the professional sports leagues in the United States.  It's the one league (we'll see on Manfred) that isn't run by a fucking idiot.  The league, especially under Silver, but under Stern as well, is generally responsive to the desires of its fans and more aware and alert of public perception than the NFL, MLB or NHL.  The fact that they might actually do something about the conference imbalance, as opposed to simply standing behind "tradition" in the name of not making changes, is Exhibit A in my argument.  The same goes for the discussions taking place to make changes so teams don't have incentive to tank.

The NBA may not make the most money, because people don't fawn over professional basketball the way people do over the NFL, but it's of better quality in terms of play and competition than people give it credit for.  The league's opponents have to resort to bullshit like "the players are thugs" or "they never call traveling" to try and criticize the game.  I don't know how it stacks up with the MLB in terms of international popularity, but I know the league does a good job of promoting itself overseas.  

I believe this will meet the "unpopular" qualification on this board, but if you really, truly hate the NBA, I'd like to hear your argument as to why the league isn't good, without citing the traveling/"players are divas' argument.

Vasav

February 13th, 2015 at 6:57 PM ^

I have three counters:

1) Basketball has international appeal - I feel like the NBA has stoked that to some extent, but I think a better run league would have seen an explosion in basketball around the world. It's an accessible, cheap game to play that doesn't require a lot of space or ice. It's everywhere, but why isn't it as popular as soccer?

2) Considering how popular basketball is in this country - I'd say there's more chance the average American has played basketball competitvely at some point than football or baseball - why is it in 3rd place on the American sports ranking? This kind of goes along with point one - but considering how great a product basketball is, and how appealing it is, I think it ought to be #1.

3) Franchise stablity in the NBA is lower than in the NFL or MLB. What happened to the Sonics was heartbreaking - and is probably the only reason I would say I hate the NBA.

MGoChippewa

February 13th, 2015 at 9:18 PM ^

1 - I'm not sure anything will take over soccer internationally.  However, the NBA's executives, Adam Silver in particular, have a profound understanding of how important the Chinese market is in terms of international expansion.  They've managed to take advantage of, among other things, the popularity of Asian (or Asian-American) players such as Yao Ming and Jeremy Lin, to the point where there are now over 100 million NBA fans in China.  I'd say that's a good start, especially considering the local time when most NBA games are on is around 9 or 10 am, loosely speaking.

2 - Basketball is a great product, but you can't force people to enjoy it.  People refuse to stop bowing at the NFL alter despite the shit they give us on and off the field.  For example, let me present this baffling statistic: 4.25 million people watched Thursday Night Football on December 18, 2014.  That was a 21-13 Jaguars win over the Titans.  That same night, only 2 million people tuned into TNT for a really good Warriors-Thunder game.  Why is this?  To sum it up simply, people make really bad decisions because of their loyalty to brands.  The amount of complaining about how meaningless the NBA regular season is gets to be really funny when you look at the viewership on that Thursday night.

3 - Can't answer you here.  I was 17 or 18 when Seattle lost the Sonics and I don't know enough about what went on there.  

KSmooth

February 13th, 2015 at 5:11 PM ^

I think the clock should stop when the ball goes out-of-bounds in soccer.  As it is, if the team with the lead has a throw in, they can waste close to a minute deciding who will take the throw-in.  That's cheesy. 

WhoopinStick

February 13th, 2015 at 5:31 PM ^

I don't think fumble recoveries should be decided based on who comes out of the bottom of the pile with the ball.  First guy the jumps on the ball and seems to have control of it should be the determining factor.  If he's on the ground is is down. 

champswest

February 13th, 2015 at 5:54 PM ^

The argument that a player wasn't great because his team didn't win a championship is false. College FB and BB are superior to the pro games. Televised golf is boring.

Gr1mlock

February 13th, 2015 at 5:57 PM ^

Soccer is the worst sport ever.  Period.  I don't deny the skill and athleticism necessary to be good at it (or even to play a full game and be bad at it), but it's boring as hell and goes through agonizingly long stretches of exactly nothing happening.  It's like watching a football game where neither side gets into the redzone, except there are no big hits or occasional long scores to shake things up.  Soccer = team jogging, with 3 cool things a game happening (with only half of those cool things actually resulting in a shot on goal, let alone a score).  Plus, the rules are deliberately and beligerantly anachronistic (stoppage time? GTFO), and allow for the stupidest tie breakers in any sport (shootouts suck, coin flip to decide winner actually happened in a women's world cup qualifier 10 or 15 years ago).  It's the worst.

 

 

chatster

February 14th, 2015 at 3:30 PM ^

If you live in the Metropolitan New York City area and don’t pay for Sirius/XM Radio, Colin Cowherd’s show is just about the only radio show that includes anything about college sports. They only broadcast the first two hours of his show on ESPN Radio in New York, but if I’m not listening to NPR, I’ll listen to Cowherd.
 
If I’m working from home in the morning, and I’m listening to internet radio, after listening to WTKA in Michigan, I’ll switch to ESPN Radio and listen to Colin Cowherd.
 
Cowherd’s honest about his role as an entertainer.  I’ve heard him say something to the effect that he doesn’t have to be right; he just has to entertain.
 
He’s a decent interviewer and seems to have well-researched opinions. He often discusses the business of sports and restricts his time spent on call-ins from listeners.  Though I have no interest in gambling, I don’t mind the time he devotes to the “wise guys in Vegas” whom he often relies on for his predictions.
 
He may come off to many as self-righteous, but he’s more thoughtful than most, if not all, of the NYC sports radio personalities; and he’s willing to state controversial opinions, without seeming to be mean-spirited. He also often admits when his opinions have been wrong.
 
To me, ten minutes of listening to Colin Cowherd is far superior to an infinite amount of time spent listening to Stephen A. Smith and Skip Bayless. (I still miss ESPN’s Cold Pizza/First Take with Dana Jacobson and Jay Crawford who kept the Michigan-Ohio State rivalry alive on air.)

M Go Cue

February 13th, 2015 at 6:22 PM ^

I'm sick and tired of people, especially about every blabbermouth on ESPN telling me every season what baseball needs to do to save itself.  They seem to think the only way to make baseball watchable is to turn it into football.

MLB had 73.7 million people visit a game last season (7th all time) with steady growth since 1950.  They have record tv contracts, the players have the most lucrative contracts in all of sports.  Baseball has worldwide appeal and far more diversity than the NFL.  The MLB stadium experience is far better and family friendly than the NFL. 

Finally, considering the NFL's recent issues regarding CTE and off field issues one could make the argument that Major League Baseball is in a far better long term position.

That being said, I would trade it all for an October Saturday at the Big House.

MBloGlue

February 13th, 2015 at 9:19 PM ^

In college basketball, if a team is in the bonus and they get fouled, they should have the option of shooting free throws or taking the ball out of bounds with a fresh shot clock.  I"m sick of the way basketball games drag at the end. 

 

Also, each team gets one "do over" per half.

slaunius

February 14th, 2015 at 5:32 PM ^

In some ways, the pitcher batting is the bigger gimmick. I hate the way the 9th spot in the batting order becomes a revolving door in the later innings of NL games.

Basically, the NL already uses DH's, they just wait until like the 6th inning to do it.

Wolverdog

February 14th, 2015 at 12:08 AM ^

Flopping in soccer or in basketball should result in a penalty, a stop to the game, and a forced game of ROSHAMBO. A second flop results in an immediate ejection.

HarBooYa

February 14th, 2015 at 4:30 PM ^

I would take out the pitching, catching and fielding, change the field dimensions to college football regulation and then implement all of college football rules...

..and fights song

...and coeds etc.

Neither that, or make all baseball players take a steroid injection before the game...

...on the field so he can cheat and not take it.