Your unpopular music opinions

Submitted by Monkey House on

Since the sports thread was really fun and interesting I thought a music one might be as well. There seems to be a wide age range on there so it should be pretty fun.

Blau

February 13th, 2015 at 5:39 PM ^

I still think Motown music is better than 50% of the crap on the radio.

 

Used to like ska/punk music until I was about 22. Still hit the Mustard Plug pretty hard on the way home from work sometimes.

 

Jimi Hendrix Blues Album is some of the best guitar work I've ever heard. 

 

Sufjan Stevens was great until he went all electronic. Please go back to your roots.

 

Tupac for lyrics, Biggie for beats. I would like Kanye a lot more if he just stopped acting like a douche to everyone else in the industry. His music is great imo.

 

All country musicians should have to take a class on Woody Guthrie. I find a lot of it is pandering, sappy crap. If people like it, good for them.

 

EDM isn't bad but the people who are diehard fans kinda suck to hang out with when they're all drugged out.

 

 

 

 

JHendo

February 13th, 2015 at 5:47 PM ^

The Doors and Jim Morrison:  They aren't just disgustingly overrated, they're just flat out not very good at making music.

Kanye West:  Greatest hip-hop artist of all time.  Yeah, he sometimes doesn't know when to shut up sometimes and has his moments that are musically questionable (his last album, arguably 808s and Heartbreaks too), but refuses to give in to what fans expect from him and still manages to come up with some of the greatest rap songs ever.  Also, his producing is undeniably amazing.  Would Jay-Z be as big as he is if he wasn't working with a lot of K-West beats early on?

Cher: I may be a 29 year-old, heterosexual male, but I dig her sound, past and present.

Blue24

February 13th, 2015 at 6:01 PM ^

Elliott Smith is the greatest song writer of my generation.

Robert Earl Keen is the best and only country artist I listen too. Thanks Texas for that find

Nitro

February 13th, 2015 at 6:19 PM ^

How about: Contemporary US rock music is overrated in the US because our rockist mainstream music media is racially biased and the industry wants to be able push music by people who look like white fans.

Like, for instance, consider hip-hop and college/indie rock.  Hip-hop, like jazz , funk, and disco music before it, has been embraced internationally, much more so than college rock.  But in the US, college rock is what's been more popular now -- a lot of that is because it gets pushed more as being things like "intellectual" and "emotionally deep," and people who want to feel smart about themselves and project a smart image of themselves get sold into artists promoted as embodying those concepts easily, especially if it's someone who looks like them since it makes it more comfortable for them to be fan.

So hate me now, Pitchfork devotees.

billybrown

February 14th, 2015 at 8:56 PM ^

"College rock" which isn't even a real thing anymore is certainly not more popular now and probably hasn't been more popular than hip hop in probably 25 years. Yours isn't an unpopular opinion it's just wrong. I think you vastly overestimate the amount of people who read pitchfork and pitchfork has reviewed (mostly positively) all kinds of rap and hip hop for years now.

Glen Masons Hot Wife

February 13th, 2015 at 6:48 PM ^

George Michael is one of the most talented artists of his generation.  Up there with the best.

There may be a lot of people who agree with me though.

Glen Masons Hot Wife

February 13th, 2015 at 6:49 PM ^

Bruno Mars sucks.

Aside from one song (Grenade) everything he comes up with sounds like a cheesy, generic ripoff of something that's been done before.

Jack Hammer

February 13th, 2015 at 6:54 PM ^

1.  Aerosmith

2.  Dave Matthews Band

3.  Led Zepplin

4.  Anything played on the Didgeridoo

5.  Country &/or Western Music

6.  Captain & Tennille

7.  Rob Zombie

8.  Aerosmith

9.  Aerosmith

10.  Aerosmith

mjv

February 13th, 2015 at 10:49 PM ^

Has any band during their run as a popular act, swung from so good to so awful to the extent Aerosmith has? Toys in the Attic is one of the great rock albums.

Then they get sober, release Permanent Vacation and become Steven Tyler's backup band with a pile of crap music to follow. Completely formulaic garbage. Their musical arc makes me sad.

Libertine

February 13th, 2015 at 7:13 PM ^

Give me Bonnie Raitt, Reba, Trisha, Wynonna, and LeAnn (with the exception being Shania Twain, she's beyond terrible) and keep your shitty ass Blake Shelton's wife, something about an Antebellum Era, and whatever other atrocious nonsense is out there.

Northville

February 13th, 2015 at 7:39 PM ^

If I find out someone is a rap or contemporary country fan, I immediately assume they're kinda dumb. Awful right? Can't help it.

Also, I like Rush without shame. Just listen to Subdivisions and tell me that isn't amazing art.

As I get older I listen more and more classical. Attitude and lyrics just don't interest me much anymore.

Check out Angel Olsen. For whatever reason I find her amazing.

m1jjb00

February 13th, 2015 at 7:58 PM ^

The Beatles nearly ruined rock music w/ Sgt. Pepper. 

Most rap music blows.  I like very little after NWA.

The best song ever is Blitzkrieg Bob.

The best album ever is Never Mind the Bollocks.

The best band ever is The Clash.

I have Hanson's Mmmbop on my Ipod.

Polkas are fun.

Nobody in the history of thw world is/was a worse live act than The Cars.

Dave Brubeck is a genius.   So was Dylan, but with 30 albums, yeah there are some stinkers.

Captain Beefheart is stupid.  Anyone paying money for that got played.

XM's Alt Nation is a waste.  Even then it's better than SiriusXMU.  Most of the songs Brian plays on the podcast other than the White Stripes are insipid.

I don't know what Springsteen album I hate more: Nebraska or the Seeger Sessions.

Metallica's Black album is much better than the earlier stuff.  I don't care what their fans say.

Nirvana saved the 90s.  The Hives saved the 00s, though the White Stripes are great too.

 

 

 

jmdblue

February 14th, 2015 at 12:41 PM ^

over rated album.  I love Pay Me My Money Down on the Seeger thing.  The Clash is truly outstanding.  The best song ever is Honky Tonk Women, but Thunder Road, 5:15 and Hallelujah are in the conversation.  The Cars are the worst live band I've seen.  Best show I've seen was James Cotton at the Pig around 1990 or so. 

Jack Hammer

February 14th, 2015 at 4:05 AM ^

True story.  I was putting my gigantic headphones on to run around Royal Oak in 1998ish and tuned in to 88.3FM detroit/Windsor and they introduced the local new hot music of "Eminem" and his self-appointed first song "Slim Shady."  Well, I ran with it.  Literally.  Listening to the song and running around Royal Oak.  I kind of liked the song at the time.  Happy "Slim Shady" caught on and had a decent career.  I heard "Eminem" on that run almost 20 years ago and thought "Eminem is a pretty stupid handle for an entertainer."  And here we are.......

pescadero

February 14th, 2015 at 1:10 PM ^

...and a boatload of other folks.

 

Mutt Lange has produced (and written songs for) about a billion hit albums in about a dozen different genres.

 

AC/DC - Highway to Hell, Back in Black, For Those about to Rock...

Def Lepard - High and Dry, Pyromania, Hysteria

Foreigner - 4

The Cars - Heartbeat City

Brian Adams  - Waking up the Neighbors,  18 til I die 

Nickleback - Dark Horse

Maroon 5 - Hands All Over

Muse - Drones

... and on and on.


 

Ike613

February 13th, 2015 at 9:46 PM ^

.. Mike Patton, one of the most original and creative musicians in the last couple decades.  Not everything he does is good, some is crap, but I appreciate that he tries new things and doesn't seem to care if people like it or not.