Why has Michigan struggled in night games under Harbaugh?

Submitted by Maizen on

Night Game W/L

L Utah 17-24

W Minnesota 29-26

W Rutgers 78-0

L Iowa 13-14

L FSU 32-33

L MSU 10-14

L PSU 13-42

Overall record: 2-5

Outside of the Rutgers game (who lets be honest is terrible) I don't think U-M has played one good game at night under Harbaugh. If not for some good fortune in Minneapolis they could be sitting at 1-6. Harbaugh is 24-3 in games that kickoff at 3:30PM or earlier, and could easily be 26-1 if not for "trouble with the snap" and "the spot." I get going on the road and playing in hostile environments under the lights is challenging, but there is a marked difference in U-M's play and execution at night. Might be time to change up how they prepare or the routine for night games? I'm at a loss.

slimj091

October 22nd, 2017 at 7:42 PM ^

It's not just night games. The team has struggled all season aside from the opener against Florida. And I know exactly why. The complete lack of Yips in the first row. Warde Manuel get on that shit, and move the Yips back to where they belong.

Some Call Me.... Tim

October 22nd, 2017 at 7:45 PM ^

Personally I believe it has everything to do with the fact that all the losses have been either an away game, a neutral site game without a first rounder and a Mackey award winner, or in a monsoon with an objectively mediocre offense.  Ignoring MSU and FSU for a second, the rest of the games have been away games.  Literally every university student LOVES night games and the crowds are usually far drunker and more rowdy, which creates a MUCH more hostile playing environment.  Not that hard to understand how this can cause people to underperform.  Calm down and be logical

FL_Steve

October 22nd, 2017 at 7:46 PM ^

To sum it up succinctly: Too much pressure. The pro system is too pro based. We play far too conservatively. The expectations are too high (in that it becomes a psychological detriment to the players and team). Maybe with the right talent and when talent has been "developed" (i.e. upper classmen) this will all work out (see Alabama). At the end of the day I am just disappointed we haven't utilized the talent we have better. I get there is a "system" and "trust in execution" by coaches, but we have the same talent Penn State has (if not better) sans a functional O-line (but fuck that excuse bc FSU last season) and we haven't adjusted to maximize it. Same old story though *sigh*

1VaBlue1

October 22nd, 2017 at 8:13 PM ^

Same talent, right?  Lets see...  PSU has an all upper-classmen OL, Hiesman finalist RB, NFL-lookin' QB, all upper-classmen WR's, and Mackey finalist TE.

UM has an under-class OL with first year starters (incl seniors from Hoke that couldn't ever get on the field), freshmen WRs, inexperienced under-class RBs, and a G5 backup QB.

Yeah, sure...  Same personnel!

MonkeyMan

October 22nd, 2017 at 8:19 PM ^

To sum it up succinctly: Too much pressure. The pro system is too pro based. We play far too conservatively. The expectations are too high (in that it becomes a psychological detriment to the players and team)."

Holy shit- you have some sort of excuse making super power- like Captain America

MIGHTYMOJO91

October 22nd, 2017 at 7:56 PM ^

Maybe its past JH bedtime. Good lord the absurdy of some of these posts is absolutely ludicrous. Geesh!!!! Next up for fellow mgobloggers.....The Michigan record of Oct 21st night games. Blah Blah Blah Blah Blah.......  Let us all over analyze every fucking thing and create a post about it. 

M-Dog

October 22nd, 2017 at 8:04 PM ^

Other than Iowa (who is tough at home at night and almost beat Penn State), we beat the teams we were better than, and lost to the teams that were better than us (yes including MSU this year).

Just like we would have done during the day.

It has almost nothing to do with nighttime.

 

MilkSteak

October 22nd, 2017 at 8:08 PM ^

I have it on good authority that Harbaugh has specifically trained this team to sleep at night (and to be awake during the day). How does he do this? Basically every team activity is scheduled for early in the morning, mid day, or early evening. Most players have naturally fallen into a regular rhythm of sleeping somewhere between the hours of 11PM - 7AM.

While that may seem unrelated because games rarely go as late as 11PM, most peoples' energy levels decrease throughout the course of the day. Think of it like your phone's battery: you start the day at 100%, and as you get closer to the end of the day you get closer to 0%. Back to the Michigan football players. They start their days at 7AM with 100% "charge" and due to Harbaugh's sleep conditioning, they're closer to needing another "charge" during night games, leading them to play a bit more sluggishly. Again they don't actually need a charge. I'm using "charging" as a comparison to the way humans have to sleep.

The upshot of all of this is that Harbaugh needs to vary the sleep schedule of his team. Any method in which he can disrupt players late at night should work. Bo used to sneak into West Quad every night and blow airhorns in the players' ears for 4 months prior to any night games in order to break up any undesirable sleep patterns. And it wasn't just Bo. Any good football coach does this. Whenever Fielding Yost's teams played in primetime ESPN games he would famously deny them hard tack for weeks on end, causing hunger pains which disrupted their sleep.

In both cases players were given a solid 8 hours the day of the game and then sent out onto the field, reminding the team "your batteries is now at 100% like your iPhones are in the morning." This is where that famous Michigan phrase comes from.

To see this aspect of the game overlooked really just shows the incompetence of this staff.

RedGreene

October 22nd, 2017 at 8:13 PM ^

Maizen needs some attention! He says he doesn't care about points and other people's opinions but still starts several posts a day. He's definitely an attention whore.