Student Section needs to be reduced

Submitted by bassmaster on

I know it's their school now, but god damn, this has been going on for too long. Just reduce it by a section let people who will show up get those seats. Today it looked like 5,000 seats were empty through the first quarter. 

Owl

November 10th, 2012 at 10:35 PM ^

I would agree with you that yes they should if what you were suggesting made sense to me. It's very difficult to tell the difference between a ticket request form sent in by someone that will show up for every game and a ticket request form sent in by someone who wont. Demand is demand. Reducing the size of the student section does nothing to change the information asymmetry inherent to this situation. For all you know you could be eliminating the seats of students that will show up. Also, there's the difficulty of choosing which requests to grant and which to deny. And proposed systems to determine who shows up and who doesn't sound like logistical nightmares. 

snarling wolverine

November 10th, 2012 at 10:42 PM ^

Except that - unlike track and field - everyone here cares about football.  We have pretty much shared priorities on this one.

It helps our stadium atmosphere, and homefield advantage, to have everyone there on time.  If alumni start showing up right at kickoff or later (which was the case at Purdue a few weeks ago), they deserve criticism too.  But at Michigan the problem is chiefly localized in the student section. 

 

snarling wolverine

November 10th, 2012 at 10:53 PM ^

That's what I meant by "here".  A poster above was arguing that getting to the games early was just some oddball priority, like going to obscure sporting events.

If you care about football (and I think everyone on MGoBlog does), there shouldn't be any disagreement about this - it's a problem when our stadium has lots of people not showing up on time (if at all).  I'm surprised there are posters on this site making excuses for it.

OMG Shirtless

November 10th, 2012 at 10:59 PM ^

I believe that students should have the right/privilege/ability (whatever you want to call it) to purchase season tickets regardless of whether or not they have any intention of attending a single game.  It's one of the perks of going to Michigan.  If you want season tickets, you can get them.  You can get them and light them on fire for all I care.

GetSumBlue

November 10th, 2012 at 10:27 PM ^

Let's face it, the student section has been turrible for a while now. I saw it from '04-'08 while I was there and I remember thinking the same thing. I rarely ever showed up after kickoff. Most of these people would rather drink beer at "insert random frat here" instead of showing up for the team. Pathetic.

Don

November 10th, 2012 at 10:28 PM ^

and go into the dorms at 11am, choose students at random, dressed or not, and march them to the stadium at gunpoint. If they resist, shoot them in the kneecaps and then rifle-butt them in the chops.

aaamichfan

November 10th, 2012 at 10:30 PM ^

It's definitely time to reduce the student area by at least one full section. I fully support students getting blackout wasted and getting all kinds of strange ass before/during the games, but still those empty seats should go to people who actually want them.

eamus_caeruli (not verified)

November 10th, 2012 at 10:40 PM ^

After reading more and more posts on this topic, from a recent former teacher who left the profession for greenery pastures, this is a generational thing. This is a generation of instant gratification, "being cool" and can't handle being told to be somewhere on time. I mean we used to fight for our rights on campus, now we fight for the right to not write.

It's Michigan's fault for having a game time that's doesn't fit people's social schedules, studying or partying habits on Saturday. That needs to be thwatted or fb or texted to the ad five mins prior to them changin their mind after seeing someone cute, or having a hunger tickle or needin to find a bathroom. I mean who wants to commit to a noon kickoff anyways. We should just chill bro, and gangham style a solution when 20 somethings are ready for kickoff. Shit even the army won't seven generation to fight!

Nothing.But.10ve

November 10th, 2012 at 10:40 PM ^

You are all missing the point.

First off, the student section is not half empty.  It's only those nosebleeds up top.  Do you ever wonder why it's only the nosebleeds?  It's because us students do whatever we can to get closer to the field.  Typically it's the freshmen who get seated up top.  A lot of freshmen don't like being seen as freshmen based on where they sit, so they move.  It's retarded, I know, but it's the way it is.  I can guarantee that rows 1-80 are far more densely populated in the student section than anywhere else in the stadium.  

And yes, there are a good portion of students who get too drunk before the games and don't make it.  Some of you consider that I crime, I consider that being in college.  Pregames are the best days of the year, so if you miss a NW or Illinois game once in a while and wake up somewhere in Ypsi, it is not disappointing.

With that said, the student section could be half full and we would still be the loudest section in the stadium.  The fuckers who sit to our right either think we're on offense the entire game or don't have vocal cords.  It's pathetic.  When they do the 'M-I-C-H-I-G-A-N' chant, I have never once heard the I or C.  

You can take a section away from us if you so desire, but those empty rows up top will never change.  If you want some actual football student attendence issues, go to East Lansing.  

jmblue

November 10th, 2012 at 11:08 PM ^

Freshmen sit in the top rows now?  I thought they were in the endzones.  

I disagree with the idea that nothing can be done to stop this, because it wasn't that long ago that we didn't have these huge empty swathes in the student section (and people used to move  down to better seats back then, too).

I fully agree that the students are the loudest fans at the games - but that's what's frustrating about this.  They could be better.  A lot of us complaining are former students who got to the games on time when we were in school and screamed our heads off for four quarters.  We see the current students, who are supposed to be carrying that torch now, not doing all they can to keep it going.  I don't know if the student section should be shrunk, but I think going to general admission might help.

 

Sambojangles

November 10th, 2012 at 10:40 PM ^

For a lot of students, getting to the game on time is not a priority. Just because you diagree with their choices does not mean they are wrong. If anything, blame the athletic department. Give the students a compelling reason to show up early, and more probably will. I would start with general admission--if you show up early, you can sit wherever you want. That might encourage earlier seating. Second, come up with a more exciting pregame routine. The tradition of the band is unfortunately lost on the students, and nothing else that is going on is providing enough of a wow experience to get people there early. Flyovers and Jetpack guy last year were both really cool, but they need to get the word out about them better (nobody reads the stupid emails they send out on Thursday night about the game). Giveaways might help too, but it has to be more than throwaway value. A hat or $20 gift card for the first 10,000 students into the student section might me enough to convince people to come early. In general, I believe the culture needs to be changed. This is my fifth season as a student, and it does appear to have gotten worse every year. Maybe the Rodriguez years hurt enthusiasm, maybe college students are more apathetic in general. Whatever the reason, it's true that students are not showing up on time, and don't really care. Part of the problem with the culture is that the slow people--girlfriends, friends from other schools, students who aren't die-hard football fans--keep the friends who actually want to go early back, since they have to wait for one last drink, or to meet at another party, or just because they walk down Hoover slowly. And once it's okay for some people to show up late, it becomes okay for everyone. If there can be some more momentum for showing up on time, I think it will snowball as students see others on their way toward the stadium early. Making it culturally unacceptable to show up late will help start to solve the problem. By the way, there will always be out of state students, people that really don't care about football that much, and hard partiers who will never sacrifice drinking to watch the pregame and kickoff. The key is to get the Median 50% in sooner than they are arriving now.

eamus_caeruli (not verified)

November 10th, 2012 at 10:45 PM ^

It's called tradition!! Try some! When you are 40 and perhaps married and have kids, or not, you will never have the memories or appreciation for how truly blessed you are to have gone to UofM. I have lived on the east coast and met so many different kinds if peopel. ivy league, liberal arts colleges, big schools and their traditions both football and all other sports experiences pale in comparisons to what you get very fall and year. Even just cultural and student life...

Wake up young padawan!!! Wake up! You will never get this time back!

Sambojangles

November 10th, 2012 at 11:20 PM ^

I understand, and I appreciate the tradition. All I'm saying is that others don't share that, and it's not a poor reflection on them. Also, I mentioned it on my post above, but my experience today was basically this: I wanted to leave my pregame at about 11:30. I got everyone together in my group, and about 10 minutes later we were gone. But then we had to pick up someone else down the street, then eventually I left the group behind as they were walking too slow. I had to wait in line at the gate so I missed kickoff and the first drive. So what? If I were alone I could have made it, but friends are important too. There is almost no point in attending an event like a football game if there is no one to share it with.

eamus_caeruli (not verified)

November 10th, 2012 at 11:31 PM ^

I am not slamming you specifically, more a generalization which isn't always the best observation, but I pretty much used to say peace out rather than follow the crowd. My fandom is a lifetime, one more beer is a pisser.

HarBooYa

November 11th, 2012 at 9:25 AM ^

Part of the "tradition" as a student is to pre party and then show up late, no? I think pre game experiences are the reason many kids go to school in a2 and remember it fondly along with the games. Not everyone of the 110k plus needs to be a purist and kids should be kids.

This is a none issue. Leave the kids alone you ol curmudgeons. I personally think Kovacs saying "that end" at the OT coin flip and crowd performance during OT should have preempted such a strange post. He didn't pick the "traditionally" alum section did he?

jmblue

November 10th, 2012 at 11:16 PM ^

Honestly, I don't think positive incentives work that often in these cases.  A half-drunk student is probably not going to forego that last drink just to get the freebie of the week.

There simply needs to be more pressure to get to the games on time - more fear of being late. When I was in school (a decade ago), I knew that if I didn't get there on time, I would not be able to sit in my actual seat.  I'd be stuck in a crappier seat somewhere - maybe not even in my section.  Apparently that fear of being late is gone now.  The AD can bring it back by either giving seat priority to those who show up on time or simply going to straight-up general admission.

eamus_caeruli (not verified)

November 10th, 2012 at 11:40 PM ^

I think I am in favor of ga for students. I guess I am weirdo, but I would have showed up at 8am to get the best seat for game day. Just sayin!

All this squeeze down crap has always happened but people used to bring bottles in with them, now people drink till 1 and then sashe into the "student section. I just started early and watched the clock.

Doc Brown

November 11th, 2012 at 11:24 AM ^

hey look jmblue is talking down to people with blanket statements. Junior I showed to Michigan games 2 hours early when I was working on my PhD at Michigan. When I was using my parents tickets, I would show up 2 hours early. This year, my first year as a victors club member and season ticket holder, I show up 2 hours early. However, not everyone is as hardcore as I am. Some of my friends show up late because they have numerous other commitments such as rehearsels with the music theater department on Saturday mornings or they just don't care as much as I do. Yet they pull with Michigan with all of their heart.  When I say all I read in this thread is bitch bitch bitch and whine whine whine, that is all this thread is. One GIANT bitchfest from those individuals who only see the world in black and white. Get over yourself. 

da shiz

November 10th, 2012 at 10:41 PM ^

Its pretty sad. I was in the student section today and the frat guys standing in front of me were more interesting in the beach balls being hit around then the actual game.

Doc Brown

November 11th, 2012 at 11:17 AM ^

here we go again...Just becuase I chose to go to another school that has a higher ranked physics department while I still rooted against Purdue and pulled for Michigan, then earned two degrees from Michigan and now am I season ticket holder for Michigan, I am some how don't understand. Junior, just don't. I have more Michigan blood in me then you will ever have. I don't see you planning trips to the UP to follow the hockey team on their last UP road trip. this is a fight you will NOT win.

Doc Brown

November 11th, 2012 at 11:28 AM ^

except now I teach physics and I know my students follow me on this blog and on twitter. I watch my language and what I say now. Yes, this is a battle I will win. As long as we are wipping it out. The money I donate to Michigan and the trips across the country, prove I BLEED michigan. but somehow I don't understand after 7 years of student tickets at Michigan. 

By the way your gif in that lame sec 1 thread is hilarious. 

MQTBlue

November 10th, 2012 at 10:54 PM ^

I was near row 30 by kick off and I haven't felt like it was that packed in a long time. We all had to stand sideways although it may have been better in other places. That said the top rows seemed very spaced out.

Wolverine Devotee

November 10th, 2012 at 10:56 PM ^

I can't even imagine being late for a game ever. That's almost as bad as missing a game.

My crazy ass went in at 10am today. That's what I usually do for Noon starts to stand by the tunnel for warmups.

First one in, last one out. Want to spend all the time I can in the greatest place on earth.

SCS100

November 10th, 2012 at 10:57 PM ^

The one thing that really irked me as a current student was the numerous times that students in the endzone tried to start the wave. When we were losing. Come on guys, use your heads and focus on the game.

Owl

November 10th, 2012 at 11:06 PM ^

I'm pretty sure they tried to start it when Colter went down with an injury as well. Also during an injury against Airforce. The really bad part is when the rest of the stadium doesn't do it as well they start booing. So they boo during an injury timeout. That REALLY upset me and embarrassed me as a student. 

uminks

November 10th, 2012 at 10:59 PM ^

But during the early and mid 80s there were always late students. Me and my friends would do morning tail gating. Nothing like drinking at 800 AM for a noon game, especially when you were out getting hammered on Friday Night!  We always wanted to see the player touch the banner running out onto the field!

Blue Hokie

November 10th, 2012 at 11:11 PM ^

FWIW, I graduated from Virginia Tech this spring and we had the same issue in my four years.  It seemed to get worse each year even though VT has been consistently good, especially at home.  We also have a great team entrance with 'Enter Sandman', so I could never figure out why you would want to miss that.  I don't think there's any way around it.

CRex

November 10th, 2012 at 11:16 PM ^

I first had access to student tickets in 2003, when I was issued top row (98 or 99, I forget) tickets.  I could lean against the top wall and watch the game from the nosebleeds.  I never missed a kickoff.  In fact during the entire Lloyd Carr era I walked into one game late, a EMU blowout and I only missed half the first (and have a good excuse).

I graduated before the RR began, but thanks to a grad student friend who was happy to buy season tickets and sell them at face, I had a steady stream of tickets.  I actually still have unused tickets for that era, as in I didn't go and I was too disinterested to even scalp them.  After sitting through 2008, it just killed them.  

So first give the student body time to cycle in a new generation whose souls weren't crushed by the crap offense of 2008 and the crap defense of the rest of the RR tenture.  Going to games is like voting, it is a habit you need to get into.  With RR you pretty much had to stay at the tailgate drinking until midway through the second.  You didn't want to be capable of feeling pain come the end of the game.  

The other thing is the stadium atmosphere has steadily gone downhill.  In 2003 you could bring in an unopened water bottle and the gate workers tended to look the other way on snack food.  I remember cruising in fifteen to twenty minutes before the game, settling down, having some water, hitting the flask, and eating the snack I'd smuggled in.  

Now gate security is a lot tougher.  During the cold games you can smuggle in stuff under bulky jackets, but during the early months the options you can bring through security are limited.  So I can see why most students would stay at the tailgate for one last hotdog as opposed to entering early and paying through the nose for a stadium one.  They are broke ass college kids after all.  

Finally pregame has always been blue hair time.  All these weird cheers and stuff that I has a student had no interest in.  I remember sitting there with this cute blonde girl, sharing pulls off my flask and mocking our rich musical hertigage of songs from the 1920s.  Also how the old people all showed up an hour early.  

If we're going to do anything, I'd say go back to the circa 2003 rules for bringing stuff into the stadium.  I know the bottled water ban pissed a lot of people out and it just one symptom of the degrading stadium atmosphere.  We have a lot of cops on patrol than we used to and the ushers are much bitcher than they were in the past/

Secondly if you want the kids in early, throw them some bones in the pregame.  Varsity is not that great of a song and there isn't that much else going on.  

(The other issue I think that is overlooked is the AAPD is really cracking down hard on State Street and those environs.  These days it much harder to stage yourself at a party near the stadium around say 11 am.  They're pushing people back and increasing transit time of the drunks from their house party to the student section.  It used to be you could start walking at 11, hit six other parties, and then roll into the stadium about 11:45 or so.)

WolverineHistorian

November 10th, 2012 at 11:52 PM ^

Indeed.  Although 'Varsity' and 'Let's go blue,' are somewhat recent additions to the pregame lineup.  Varsity not being added until 1996 and Let's go blue being added just in the last several years. 

The pre-Varsity days, the band would break into a random formation and play a fun song where they usually danced during a percussion solo, like this...

 

 

It was fun to watch but I hardly think a dance number is going to get the students to the game on time.  Surely it's a generational thing.

Owl

November 10th, 2012 at 11:53 PM ^

There's this guy that's usually near me in the student section that wears maize football pants, a jersey, and receiver gloves to every game. In my mind I've started envisioning you as that guy. You're kind of ruining tht illusion for me with this additional information, though. 

Wolverine Devotee

November 11th, 2012 at 12:14 PM ^

I don't understand the point of wearing receiver gloves to games. That's like drinking out of my 1947 Western Conference champions glass. You just don't. You'll ruin it.

And leave the football pants to the actual football players. Eeesh.

lhglrkwg

November 10th, 2012 at 11:17 PM ^

Those jackwagons were trying to start it when we were down 24-21 in the 3rd quarter. You do the wave when we are winning by 14+ (generally)! Not when the team requires you to pay attention and yell.

And I'm not some crotchity old guy. I graduated 2 years ago and it used to be understood when the wave was done. Fortunately, all attempts died cruel deaths today