Logic says that you're correct--we shouldn't rush to hasty conclusions, yet I'm very encouraged by Hoke's intial efforts. I believe that you can learn something about a person's character when he is put in a tough situation. With Brady Hoke, all my impressions to date tell me that he gets stronger under pressure. I think you're right that Hoke's hiring Mattison was a great decision.
further adventures in Jed York being unsuited for his position