Yes...and if he's such a superstar - one of the top 300 players in the country - you would think they could find a place for him in their 3-4 package.
I'm not saying Charlton is a bad player. All I'm saying is that if he were the absolute beast that many of you seem to think he is, then he would be on the field 100% of the time in every defensive package. He's not. Do you really think Pickerington Central is so stacked with talent that they could remove a truly elite player from their defense and be great? I doubt it. So maybe, just maybe, Charlton has some weaknesses that the coaches are trying to hide from opposing teams.