According to Sports by Brooks, OSU's freshman QB Braxton Miller was one of the additional two players in attendance at the infamous charity event where envelopes of cash were handed out. No evidence that Miller received any money, but for some reason OSU redacted his name from their NCAA filing that was released to the public:
The two “current student-athletes” referred to by Ohio State in its report to the NCAA - with the names redacted by the the school in its release of the report to the media - are Braxton Miller and current Buckeye football player Nathan Williams.
Williams also sat out of the Toledo game and will miss the Miami game due to a knee injury.
Though I cannot confirm Fickell didn’t play Miller against Toledo because the QB was named in the NCAA report - particularly after the NCAA’s last-second Toledo game blockade of Hall - you can’t help but wonder if it was a contributing factor.