Please stop putting Gardner in at QB

Submitted by Eye of the Tiger on

It's not working, it's disrupting any rhythm we get going.  The kid is talented, but he's not ready for prime time.  Denard may throw some ducks, but HE IS OUR BEST CHANCE TO WIN MORE THAN 8 GAMES THIS YEAR.  Let him play!

ARRRRRRRRRGGGGGGGGG...

kb

October 29th, 2011 at 2:18 PM ^

it's 29-7, Michigan is outgaining Purdue 424-192 in yards, and the Devin-Denard formations have clearly been unsuccessful.

allintime23

October 29th, 2011 at 3:54 PM ^

It's terrible. Please, it's not helping either player. Devin is clearly not ready. I realize it opens the run by forcing the D to focus on where Denard is lined up but it's only a matter of time before it's been figured out. If I can see the two plays coming I'm sure opposing coaches will too.

Tater

October 29th, 2011 at 4:05 PM ^

Why is anyone bitching about the coaches or the decisions they make?  Sometimes it seems like if Michigan won every game 75-0, someone would still find a reason to whine.  

Why not just trust and support your coaching staff?  We have been lucky that Denard hasn't missed a game yet, and that all he has sustained so far are "boo-boos."  Devin needs some playing time in case he is needed.  He is the backup, and needs to be ready to step in if anything bad happens.  

I trust the staff to make what they feel are the best decisions.  They are doing a pretty good job so far.

BigBlue4Life

October 29th, 2011 at 4:26 PM ^

Devin needs to be mixed in.  he clearly has the talent to play alot in a couple years as a starter.  The coaches know you have to get him snaps so a. he doesnt transfer, b. he is ready if Drob goes down, c. it obviously can confuse a defense if they can execute.   someday soon this kid is going to be dropping accurate long balls..you know the ones we havent seen in 3 1/2 season?  the kid has earned some time if you ask me.  Good luck and health to both our QB's.  GO BLUE

 

 

LB

October 29th, 2011 at 5:05 PM ^

Lets see, game was in hand at the half, it was homecoming, team is 7 -1 with most of the same players we watched in that bowl game last year. Damn these coaches!

Oh, and freshmen starting on defense - wow. They did a nice job and the experience should pay off in the future.

jwilkins3

October 29th, 2011 at 5:15 PM ^

Ii think the same thing but I can also see denard coming in motion against ohio state and the throwback to denard from devin for a td. I mean the throwback to smith today shouldve been a touchdown. Seems to work just fine to me, the problem is we have two talented QB's who love to compete and always want to make too big of a play sometimes instead of making better decisions. Thats the reason we have so many INT's.

joeysos33

October 29th, 2011 at 5:40 PM ^

yea wipe out an entire package that has been increasing in plays and in sucess. Different looks and options=more to plan for. A lot of good misdirection activity came from this today. That formation looked great today and Gardner didnt even throw from it.

LSAClassOf2000

October 29th, 2011 at 6:10 PM ^

He's not ready to be the featured QB, I think, but the misdirection plays in which he has been taking the snap are looking better and becoming more effective. We managed some pretty good yardage on a few of them today. Yeah, the turnover after the pass early on stung, but nothing came of it. With practice and game time, this is mitigated. 

rymgoblue11

October 29th, 2011 at 7:50 PM ^

tl;Dr/idc. denard throws that what ... 25yrd or so completion and Devin comes in... and throws a pick. that's dumb. denard throwing into a spy lb/safety with a man on the wr. bad decision.

I like the sweep options but don't have Devin throw without some quick rhythm short outs.

luvmesumblu

October 30th, 2011 at 9:40 AM ^

I like the fact that Gardner is getting snaps because it's helping him develop and it's making our offense more diverse.  You may not see it now but down the road you will also get a great play from Devin in the offense that will be one of the 6-8 plays that change the game.   In the future when Devin is the primary quarterback I will be happy knowing the young man has some valuable game experience to help him succeed early on.