OT: US Open Williams Sisters Showdown

Submitted by BornSinner on

Who ya got? 

I think Serena will win, but I want Venus to go out on top given her illness and fall from the top over the past few years. 

 

Adrian

September 8th, 2015 at 8:11 PM ^

Im glas to see there are other tennis fans on this site. Im thorn on the match. Would love to see venus win but would like to see serena cement her status as the best ever

BornSinner

September 8th, 2015 at 8:13 PM ^

Venus has been in form lately, but idk if she still has enough left. Serena's just been on another world lately with her play. 

The competitive side of Venus probably can't wait to beat her sister at a major again. 

meechiganman14

September 8th, 2015 at 8:33 PM ^

These Williams sister major matches almost never live up to the hype. If I remember right, there was a time when they were both winning everything (early 2000s) and people suspected their dad would dictate who would win when they met in Major finals because the matches were rarely tight. At this point with her illness, I doubt Venus has the physical stamina to win tonight and I'm sure it would be really difficult to be the one to deny her sister a shot at the historic grand slam.

wolverine1987

September 8th, 2015 at 9:01 PM ^

I'm saying this having not watched any. But Venus and Serena have never, not once, played a good match together. And Venus is 35 and past her prime. Serena will take it easy on her but win in two sets. Hope I'm wrong for those who are invrsted and watching,

JT4104

September 8th, 2015 at 9:58 PM ^

So...Serena got pissed off early in the 3rd and reality set in. When she takes it to that next level no one can stay with her.

Which is amazing considering for womens tennis she should be past her prime as well.

Mr. Yost

September 8th, 2015 at 10:12 PM ^

When other female tennis greats were winning the sport wasn't available to as many women around the world (not just the US)...so you can argue that the competition wasn't as good then either.

It's like with golf. There are many who say guys today would dominate way back when.

I choose to just say you have to beat who they throw in front of you and try to put a little context on the situation.

For example, I'd say the opposite about boxing. In the mid-1900's boxing was the premier sport in the country. Today it's football. I can't in good faith say that today's champions would be champions if some of these football players grew up wanting to box rather than play football.

I don't see such a contrast in women's tennis...while the sport probably isn't as popular as it once was (or maybe it still is, I don't know)...regardless, there are more people able to play it today, which I would think makes up for any loss in popularity.

Serena and Venus are beasts, they'd dominant any era and any time.

justingoblue

September 8th, 2015 at 10:32 PM ^

I won't bore you with Tom Brady's age or that Usain Bolt will be knocking on the door of 31 at Rio or that Phelps is thirty, or that LeBron turns 31 next season, but that must mean the quality on the men's side is even more worrying.

WTA top ten:

  1. Williams 33
  2. Halep 24
  3. Sharapova 28
  4. Kvitova 25
  5. Wozniacki 25
  6. Safarova 28
  7. Ivanovic 26
  8. Pliskova 23
  9. Muguruza 21
  10. Suarez Navarro 27

Mean age is 26

ATP top ten:

  1. Djokovic 28
  2. Federer 34
  3. Murray 28
  4. Nishikori 25
  5. Wawrinka 30
  6. Berdych 29
  7. Ferrer 33
  8. Nadal 29
  9. Cilic 26
  10. Raonic 24

Mean age is 28.6

justingoblue

September 8th, 2015 at 10:55 PM ^

I don't really want to break out the second grade math textbook again, but from looking at the basketball USWNT roster it looks very similar to the WTA distribution and the men's roster looks significantly younger than the ATP top ten, with Kobe being the only one over thirty on the London roster.

I doubt it's correlated with gender as much as sport. Baseball and hockey skew so much older than basketball and football because they're looking for different things (we see this in football with QB age vs. WR or RB age). I'd guess tennis falls in between baseball and basketball but slightly leaning towards baseball.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2012_United_States_men%27s_Olympic_basket…

http://www.usab.com/womens/national-team/roster.aspx

Mr. Yost

September 8th, 2015 at 10:18 PM ^

She'll be ahead of both.

Sidenote, let's not forget Jackie Joyner.

That said, I don't think it puts her in the top 5...but I think she'd be near the 10 with those gentlemen I mentioned all ahead of her.

Probably Jack Nicklaus, Joe Louis, Carl Lewis ahead of her...then I can't think of anyone else. Wilt? Jackie Robinson? Willie Mays? Hank Aaron? I see her and Babe Didrikson in that group.