OT: Tigers acquire SS Alex Gonzalez

Submitted by Quailman on

Just a couple days after trading for Angels SS/Utility man Andrew Romine to compete in a SS platoon, the Tigers have acquired veteran SS Alex Gonzalez. Tigers traded away Steve Lombardozzi, who was acquired in the Fister trade.

Looks like the SS position in now in the hands of the 37-year old, 15 year veteran, and Romine will handle utility duties at 2B, SS and 3B. Bad news for Danny Worth fans.

M2GoBlue

March 24th, 2014 at 11:18 AM ^

They didn't trade Fister for Lombardozzi. They traded him for a young controllable left handed starting pitcher with high upside as well as a young left handed bullpen arm. I don't agree with the trade either, but trading a spare part of the Fister trade doesn't make it any less sensible.

rob f

March 24th, 2014 at 11:39 AM ^

Lombardozzi wasn't really even an option at SS.

As for Romine, he's a 27-yr old who never has hit much at any level.  I didn't think he was at all the answer when the Tigers announced his acquisition a few days ago.  When he does play, a huge hole in the batting lineup.

 

rob f

March 24th, 2014 at 11:57 AM ^

but an offensive threat in that Iggy is good-to-great at small-ball, his speed and base-running being a big plus.  Had a lot of infield hits, could bunt well (both in sac-bunt situations or for an occasional base hit), and when hot, is a good spray-hitter.  His complete offensive package translates well to being counted on for a BA of .275+ with good OBP. 

I was really looking forward to him being the long-term answer at SS.  Guess we'll have to wait 'til next year to see.

MGoBender

March 24th, 2014 at 2:27 PM ^

If you believe some of the rumors (and from what I've heard and from who, I definitely believe them), Fister may have been traded for the same reason Avisail Garcia was traded and Prince was traded.

To clean house of guys that didn't exactly "get along" in the clubhouse or outside of it.  I don't know if there's a link that actually names Fister, but I've heard his name thrown into the mix of guys that Prince Fielder has reason to be pissed at.

http://www.hallofverygood.com/2013-articles/december/wait-that-s-why-th…

http://diamondhoggers.com/2013/12/20/a-rumor-ill-print-about-prince-fie…

Bluemandew

March 24th, 2014 at 11:14 AM ^

This is a very strange trade. He is 37 was released last year in june and was only on a minor league  deal and may have been cut in a couple days by the orioles.... He only hit .211 last year.... There are reports that Baltimores scouts think he can't play ss anymore.  Its not like Lombardozi was a huge price tag but if Lombardozi is only worth Gonzalez this makes the Fister trade even more head scratching......

WMUgoblue

March 24th, 2014 at 11:16 AM ^

This seems like such a troll move, we essentially gave up a reasonable utility man for a 37 year old SS who hasn't gotten everyday AB's for a few years....what the hell DD?

French West Indian

March 24th, 2014 at 11:20 AM ^

Oh man, if only Peralta hadn't gotten busted last season.  Seems like the Tigers ahve been aplying one band-aid after another since that.

French West Indian

March 24th, 2014 at 1:22 PM ^

...but Peralta did have a good season and I'm not sure there were at lot of free-agent/trade option this past offseason either so Johny might well have returned.  Guess we'll just never know.

WolvinLA2

March 24th, 2014 at 12:13 PM ^

Exactly.  Not every trade is going to look good right away (or even be good in the long run) but the aggregate of DD's moves has made really good teams for a decade.  Let's see if he knows what he's doing.  I'm not saying he's above criticism, but he probably deserves the benefit of the doubt.

modabomb

March 24th, 2014 at 3:12 PM ^

could've been used to justify the Charlie Villanueva and Ben Gordon signings by Joe Dumars. This offseason has been horrible, save for the Kinsler trade and Ausmus signing. The bullpen is trash, the lineup has been severely downgraded, and the pitching staff is also worse in a season where the Tigers absolutely have to "win now". Dombrowski's made some good moves in the past, but those were widely lauded at the time too. These moves have, objectively, been horrible.

rob f

March 24th, 2014 at 11:41 AM ^

as the Tigers either couldn't pry Nick Franklin away from the Mariners or felt that he wasn't the answer/wasn't any more ready than anyone else already in the Tiger farm system.

Gonzalez is nothing more than a stop-gap answer, a mediocre fielder close to the end of his career, a hitter with occasional pop that might be able to hit .260 but much more likely .220.  Until one of the youngsters in the minors catches fire, this looks like the best the Tigers can do without giving up too much from down on the farm.

Someone in the Tiger organization screwed up in their monitoring of Iglasias and his leg problems, which were already an issue last fall.  Hard to believe they didn't do a better job of evaluating him medically, when they put all their eggs in that basket, not having anyone as a capable backup in case of injury. 

French West Indian

March 24th, 2014 at 1:27 PM ^

...not that I know anything but the Iglesias injury situation almost makes me think the Red Sox pulled a fast one on the Tigers with last summer's trade.  Hopefully, Iggy eventually recovers and proves himself not to be a lemon.

denardogasm

March 24th, 2014 at 11:31 AM ^

The tigers have gotten so much worse this offseason. I'm just baffled by the whole thing. I don't know why they suddenly became concerned with the money situation when they're on the cusp of a championship. All they needed was a closer and a replacement for Fielder and instead they let a guaranteed great at bat go in Infante and a great starter in Fister. I'm not that upset about Peralta just because there wasn't really room for him, although in hindsight he'd be awesome to have now, but those other guys were very important to our success last year.

rainingmaize

March 24th, 2014 at 12:32 PM ^

Infante was an ok bat, not a "great" bat who hit at the bottom of the lineup. Although I liked him to, Kinsler is a massive upgrade who despite his declining skills. Legitimate leadoff candidate who hits in clutch and had a much higher WAR. There was no room for infante as the tigers are one of the four teams with elite young shortstops, and they are at their payroll limit. Fister was an underrated pitcher, however he is a replaceable one. And his deal may have brought in a Max's replacement. The Tigers were still pretty good, just you can't forcast, injuries.

rainingmaize

March 24th, 2014 at 12:32 PM ^

Infante was an ok bat, not a "great" bat who hit at the bottom of the lineup. Although I liked him to, Kinsler is a massive upgrade who despite his declining skills. Legitimate leadoff candidate who hits in clutch and had a much higher WAR. There was no room for infante as the tigers are one of the four teams with elite young shortstops, and they are at their payroll limit. Fister was an underrated pitcher, however he is a replaceable one. And his deal may have brought in a Max's replacement. The Tigers were still pretty good, just you can't forcast, injuries.

rainingmaize

March 24th, 2014 at 1:44 PM ^

Not sure how everyone is assuming this Ray guy sucks. I doubt anyone has seen him live. Scherzer was only the third or fourth best prospect in the Dbacks system when we acquired him and a fringe top 100 talent. No one is expecting Ray to be a CY Young, that is unfair. However solid pitching from Ray, along with expected improvements from Smyly, Porcello, Castelleanos, and Iglesias in 2015 will help us overcome the loss of Max. Fister was replaceable, and he netted us a young; talented lefty who more than likely will take Max's spot in the rotation

JamieH

March 24th, 2014 at 3:10 PM ^

Expected improvements from Smyly (a pitcher who has never gone 100 innings in the majors), Porcello (a pitcher with a career ERA of 4.51 and a WHIP near 1.4 who isn't that young anymore, Castelleanous (a player we already expected to contribute heavily) and Iglesias (a player currently out for the season with fractures in both legs) is going to make up for losing a Cy-Young winning pticher?  What planet are you living on?

 

I'll tell you what?  I'll sell you my house.  Expected improvements in the next year place the value around $10 million.  It's a steal.

JamieH

March 24th, 2014 at 6:53 PM ^

He had a tolerable season last year.  He pitched really well against righties but got absolutely lit up by lefties.  Lefties hit .300 .358 .448 against him.  He was basically lighter fluid for left-handed hitters.

He did dominate righties pretty well, which is cause for SOME encouragement.  However my personal guess is that his best season(s) will be worse than a Doug Fister average season.

 

CRISPed in the DIAG

March 24th, 2014 at 11:45 AM ^

There are no palatable options at SS in MLB right now.  Trading Lombardozzi for Alex Gonzales seems like a push, but the Tigers baseball ops are probably confident that he has a season of competent glove work left in the tank. Sometimes the devil you know, etc.

althegreat23

March 24th, 2014 at 11:52 AM ^

On the bright side, the Tigers may not have to give up their first round pick for Drew or at least can re-evaluate the SS position June 1st if Drew is still available.