OT: Sad Story

Submitted by Mr Noodle on
http://www.mlive.com/news/muskegon/index.ssf/2010/01/post_29.html This story bothered me. I thought that I would share it with this community in light of all of the coaching/player bashing that goes on in today's sports world. Although it is not directly related to athletics, I think it is relevant in that it illustrates the need for structure, direction and hope that are necessary and many times desperately lacking in adolescent development. Often, sports serves this purpose. In this win-at-all-costs world that we live in, it is often easy to forget the impact teachers and coaches have on kids. And, on the flip side, as teachers and coaches we can sometimes forget the tremendous amount of baggage and angst that kids carry with them as they enter our classrooms or drills. Circumstances have forced many of them to become great actors. Unfortunately, this young man could not be saved. The reality of it is that we probably lose more kids than we like to admit.

Tater

January 25th, 2010 at 11:52 PM ^

..is that the family member who could have done something with his life is gone, while his wrteched stain of a mother is still here. I hope that isn't too extreme, but this story really pisses me off. And I agree that she should have her other children taken away from her immediately. Foster care might suck, but it can't be any worse than this pathetic excuse for a "parent."

Louie C

January 25th, 2010 at 10:35 PM ^

This is absolutely terrible. I hate to be judgmental towards people, but I have a four letter word set aside for the poor excuse of a parent. Sounds like she had her priorities waaaay off track. That also says a lot about her seeing that this kid seems like he was the adult of the household. Her child was arguing with her about WANTING to go to school!? Are you f'ing kidding me!? I can't think of too many kids that age that are that passionate about school. He seemed to have a good head on his shoulders, and now all that potential is gone. How sad.

scottcha

January 25th, 2010 at 10:39 PM ^

Yes, this story is far beyond sad and not as close to unique as we might all like to believe. I completely agree that the structure that is inherent to sports, or in this particular case ROTC, is extraordinarily important to personal development. We talk all the time about player development and are quick to judge someone for throwing an INT or muffing a punt in the heat of the moment (I know I do) and it's stories like these that help to illuminate that these kids are just that, and many depend on the structure of the team--coaches and players--off the field to an incredibly personal extent.

GVBlue86

January 25th, 2010 at 10:55 PM ^

How is that mother allowed custody of her other children at this point? You just don't imagine this stuff happening to the most undeserving and innocent people around you until this stuff comes out, and it is just terrible.

bouje

January 25th, 2010 at 10:56 PM ^

These are the kids that we should be helping, be giving money to, and getting them out of tragic situations. This kid just wanted to go to school more than anything else in the whole world, whereas most kids just want to find a way to ditch school. It's a sad, disgusting, disgraceful parent behind this story. She's a piece of shit and people like her should be neutered so that they cannot reproduce. IMO this is much sadder than any kid who turns to gangs, drugs, or anything like that and this is truly a life that was squandered. My condolences to the poor children who are left behind to live with that awful woman (I didn't finish reading the article) but I hope that they find a different home to a family that will actually love them.

Mr Noodle

January 25th, 2010 at 11:30 PM ^

Guilty. I did shorten the name for the sake of expediency. My apologies. Like many of you I couldn't read the entire story the first time. I have not an emotional reaction to a story like this in a very long time. I deleted my original post because it was full of rage and swear words. Instead, I tired to make the connection to the importance of extracurricular activities and those who commit themselves to helping kids. I have to say most of your responses have been stated much better than I could have written.

mattkast

January 25th, 2010 at 11:08 PM ^

What a tragedy. The mother should be in jail - those kids someone who actually, you know, gives a shit about them to take care of them. I had a friend who committed suicide in an eerily similar manner, after an argument with her father. How terrible it is that a child did not receive the care and attention he deserved. a whole life extinguished for nothing.

Beavis

January 25th, 2010 at 11:09 PM ^

Story is a tough one to read. Over the last year I have personally known three people who have lost their mothers (yes, mothers) to suicide.

Rescue_Dawn

January 25th, 2010 at 11:10 PM ^

I am sure a lot of you have seen this, but it just seems appropriate...how important it is to mentor and teach & challenge children and build character.....this is a great video if you haven't seen it.

Big Boutros

January 25th, 2010 at 11:15 PM ^

Allan’s mother said she has come to terms with her son’s death, and that Christmas, which would have been Allan’s 15th birthday, wasn’t as difficult for her as others expected it would be. “It’s OK,” she said. “I’m fine. I’ve dealt with it.”
Three months removed. No exaggeration: this woman is evil. Your son fucking killed himself 12 weeks ago because you made him live in shit and skip school to run the household and you're fine, you've dealt with it. You need to go. All the way away.

Blazefire

January 27th, 2010 at 8:23 AM ^

It's a fact. My thought when I read that quote from her was, "I don't want you to be fine. I want you put to work as slave labor with your every desire squashed, forced to live with and work for strangers, sleeping in other people's crap, until you rip your own tongue out of your head just so you don't have to taste the foulness in the air anymore." JACKHOLES OF THE WORLD: Your children are not slave labor. In fact, to some greater or lesser extent, you are THEIR slave labor. Get used to it.

Mgobowl

January 25th, 2010 at 11:51 PM ^

Sent chills up my spine when I read that article. I cannot even fathom growing up in a household like that. What is even more concerning, is that this woman has 4 other children and it frightens me to think there are other people like this women in this world.

goblueritzy92

January 26th, 2010 at 12:45 AM ^

This is terrible. He went to Muskegon High, which isn't exactly the pinnacle of public schools, and was just trying to make something of his life, which is better than many kids there can say.

Tim Waymen

January 26th, 2010 at 1:50 AM ^

One thing I noticed was that the mother said that she put all that responsibility on Allen because she didn't want him to turn out like his father. Yeah, good thing she kept him out of school and taking care of her home so that he wouldn't become a murdering drug dealer. To me, this is very telling of her selfishness. I am no expert on teen suicide, but one thing that seems unusual in this case is that the boy didn't seem to be unpopular, bullied, a loner, etc. He seemed to be well liked at school and he had activities and goals. One can only wonder just how bad his home life had to be for him to choose suicide as a way out.

scottcha

January 26th, 2010 at 1:50 PM ^

I am no expert on teen suicide, but one thing that seems unusual in this case is that the boy didn't seem to be unpopular, bullied, a loner, etc. He seemed to be well liked at school and he had activities and goals.
While it can seem to make perfect sense, it's not only the unpopular, bullied, loner kids that fit the mold. Any factor can prove to be the tipping point with a fragile adolescent from a clearly hostile home life as in this case, to clinical depression, to even the pressure to succeed imparted by what we could call "good" parents. The scariest part of this particular illness is that it can be very hard to identify, especially when it's being hidden and suppressed--further emphasizing everyone's need for an institution where they can let their guard down and be mentored.

Blue in Yarmouth

January 26th, 2010 at 7:59 AM ^

It is a tragedy when a person feels as though their only alternative is to take their own life. I can't judge the boy or his mother as I have only a story to go on and really don't know all the details. Honestly, judging anyone in any circumstance is fruitless as it accomplishes nothing (I really don't envy people who have to sit on a jury and do it). The only thing I can do is wonder what this poor child was thinking, what he was feeling and what he had endured to this point in his life that lead him to this point. RIP young man, and whether your mother was the monster she is portrayed to be or not, she was right about one thing.....you are in a far better place now (especially if the details of this story are accurate).

MinorforPresident

January 27th, 2010 at 3:35 AM ^

This story was one of the saddest ones I've ever read. Being a parent myself I can't even fathom if something happened to my son. I would be devastated and not for any time period, for eternity. The fact that she was more or less non-chalant about his death and has managed to get the remaining children back is sickening. Some things in society will never make sense. You have parents like this who cannot provide a good or stable life for their children yet the kids, who are innocent victims, cannot escape. While on the other hand there are couples out there who cannot have children and go through hell trying to adopt, being forced to spend countless dollars to make it happen, and they CAN provide a good and loving home. Something is wrong with that picture and always will be.

MWW6T7

January 27th, 2010 at 8:18 AM ^

That story is sickening. It brought tears to my eyes. The sad part is that even if the kids were to be taken and put into loving homes, the psychological damage in the older kids is more than likely far beyond repair. It is one thing to be abused and bullied by your peers (which is horrible in its own sense) but to suffer this from the one person who you look to in times of need is un-repairable. My mother in-law adopted 4 children from a drug using worthless piece of shit here locally after the kids were put into foster care. They are all siblings and the 2 youngest are growing up great. It has been 4 years now and they show no signs of psychological set-backs. The two older ones are very insecure and emotionally unstable. We , as a family, try to show them as much love as possible but it hurts every time I am around them to know what they had to go through. They suffered some of the same abuse as in this story but hopefully, with all of us supporting them and treating them as they were born into our lives instead of adopted, we can help them.

Blazefire

January 27th, 2010 at 8:36 AM ^

It's interesting that you should say that being bullied by ones peers is terrible, but not even close to being treated so horribly by parents. In school, I was the SECOND most bullied kid. (The most bullied, by the way, did attempt to commit suicide, but thankfully failed). In Junior High, I used to get physically sick every monday morning from fear. This unfortunately kept me out of a lot of extracarriculars - boy scouts got me bullied and teased, sports did, since I was lousy, etc. But, I had wonderful parents, so as awful as school was, I never even once vaguely thought about suicide. Ugh.