OT: More Trouble For Butch Jones And UT

Submitted by Sac Fly on

News breaking out of Tennessee today.

Hours after an alleged rape occurred Knoxville police notified Butch Jones that two of his players, AJ Johnson and Michael Williams, were going to be investigated. Jones immediately called his players and the lawyer who is currently defending them. That gave the two players four hours between when Jones contacted them and when the police questioned them.

Now KPD is in some big trouble here. This goes all the way up to the chief who called Jones four times that day and then made over 15 calls to Jones in the next 3 days.

I doubt anyone down there has the balls to go after Butch Jones but he could also be in serious trouble for obstructing an investigation.

The deeper they dig into this story the worse it gets.

Here's the article from the Tennessean

PopeLando

April 13th, 2016 at 7:25 PM ^

I'm more concerned that the police chief has Jones' phone number ready and at hand. There's really nothing wrong with telling your players that the cops are coming and that they need a lawyer. Any insinuation of destroying evidence or concocting a lie is REALLY wrong. But again, if the police chief has Butch Jones on speed dial, who's going to prosecute...?

TdK71

April 14th, 2016 at 10:49 AM ^

The prosecutor is going to prosecute. Sometimes for college kid crap it's better to let the coach know so that he can handle discipline without destroying the person.

Back in my youth I knew a couple of guys that worked out at the same gym as I did in the off season.. ('mid '80's) ... For them the worst punishment was being taken to Bo's house by the police in the middle of the night and having him open the door to see them standing in front of him.

FWIW they both said it was probably much worse than doing 30days...

That being said I'm not condoning any type of cover-up that may have been perpatrated by KPD and the Tennesee Head Coach. If that kind of crap was going on they both need to lose their jobs. 

Yeoman

April 14th, 2016 at 5:16 PM ^

...is between sexual assault and the kind of misdemeanor that might get you 30 days and a summer of stair running.

And between an athletic department that's being sued over its past handling of alleged sex crimes and Bo-era Michigan football.

That the local police chief has the football coach's phone number isn't that much of a surprise, and if he wants to use it to give a heads up after a minor altercation in a bar or something, so be it. That he chose to use it now, for this, is a different kettle of fish.

Canadian

April 13th, 2016 at 6:20 PM ^

I can understand calling him after you have the players in custody but why are you "tipping him off"?? Just gives the accused time to destroy any incriminating evidence and or flee. Fucked up

stephenrjking

April 13th, 2016 at 6:59 PM ^

That's a biiiiiig leap from Butch telling them they're under investigation. And while this stinks that is a whole different level of stink that would be way worse. I don't think it's fair to make that assumption. Honestly this sounds like an issue with Knoxville police. It's the chief's action that's the issue here.

Oregon Wolverine

April 13th, 2016 at 7:17 PM ^

It depends on the law of Tennessee and the ways in which the law is construed.  

I'm a criminal defense lawyer in Oregon, not Tennessee.  Telling someone to destroy evidence is most likely Solicitation of Obstruction (or similar offense like Hindering Prosecution).  Telling someone to "get your stories straight" may be the same (or similar crime like Hindering Prosecution, or Solicitation of Perjury) if it is inferred you are telling one (or both) to lie.  Telling a witness/accused not to speak with police could also be obstruction (or similar) depending on the manner in which the law is written.

Coach telling player that the police want to interview, you should "lawyer up" is undoubtedly ok (and generally very good advice).

Coach telling player that police are coming, you should flee, is problematic.  Providing material support for player who is fleeing or facing charges, such as "here's money for a bus ticket" or harboring, such as lying to the police "he's not here" is a federal offense but seldom charged, at least in my jurisdiction.

 

Everyone Murders

April 13th, 2016 at 6:57 PM ^

Well, I suppose if you subscribe to James Carville's view of Pennsylvania - "Philadelphia and Pittsburgh with Alabama inbetween" - this may be correct.  PSU and child rape coverups and all that.

Not that this stuff doesn't happen more frequently in the South.  It does.  But it's hard to determine whether it's a "Southern thang" or a result of so many prominent football programs being in the South, and so many cops and politicians loving the rich smell of jockstrap.

Everyone Murders

April 13th, 2016 at 7:05 PM ^

But if I have to choose who to defend (solely based on a desire to have a successful defense), I'd rather choose the football coach.  The chief of police spends all day in ... criminal law enforcement.  At least Butch Jones could plead ignorance (not that it's necessarily a defense, but for sentencing and plea purposes it's a mitigating factor).  And in fact, the chief of police put Jones in a difficult position - you shouldn't tip someone off, but it has to be mighty tempting to do just that.

Moreover, Jones could argue that he thought it was OK to tell the players because the local law enforcement endorsed him doing just that.  To be clear, I don't think anyone here thinks that Jones did the right thing (assuming he tipped off the players), or that it was legal. 

Anyway, if true, both Jones and the chief of police look like dirtbags here.

Wolvie3758

April 13th, 2016 at 6:41 PM ^

special treatment for UT athletes from the police and Jones USING the police for specail treatment of his players...Guity and Guilty  and at the least obstructing a investigation albeit a rigged investigation

panthera leo fututio

April 13th, 2016 at 6:44 PM ^

Maybe in the sense of an actual commission of a crime (though I'm really out of my legal depth here), but Butch's actions go way beyond what I'd consider a fireable offense. Basically what he did was demonstrate in the clearest possible way that he didn't care to know whether two of his players are rapists, or to help a grave legal and moral matter progress toward its best possible outcome. It's a travesty if this guy stays on at Tennessee or gets a head coaching job anywhere else, as he's clearly unfit for the position.

Ty Butterfield

April 13th, 2016 at 6:31 PM ^

Harbaugh has more wins over Florida than Butch Jones. Not sure why people cover for this guy.