I suggest you download the demo from either PSN or Live and judge for yourself.
OT - Madden 13 or NCAA 13 - which do I buy
Neither. Buy NCAA 04 and you'll be be getting the same (if not a better) game.
NCAA 13. Last chance to utilize Denard.
I'd go with NCAA but that is my opinion. I usually get NCAA every 2 or 3 years. I like the selection of 120+ teams and love dynasty mode.
Personally, I like turning awful teams like Eastern Michigan into superpowers. Last dynasty I took Eastern to the Big Ten, jumped to New Mexico State and got them into the Big XII before jumping ship once again for Kentucky, taking 10 years to make them good and finally win a national title.
Can't do that in Madden.