The call was "hitting a
Were you at the game? I'm
Were you at the game? I'm pretty sure he said defensive player...i knew he meant defenseless, but it REALLY sounded like defensive at the game.
Defenseless - at the game
I was at the game and I definitely heard him say defenseless.
From where I was sitting, it
From where I was sitting, it sounded at first like "spitting on" a defensive player. We figured we'd misheard, and that the call was "sitting on" . . .
It's not a big deal, but the refs were awfully indecisive: flags long after the end of e play, confusing calls, ambiguous resolutions of long discussions (especially on th re- punt call, and on the punt return penalty that put M back on the nine -- these may have been back-to-back).
Can't really blame them
They were EXHAUSTED running up and down that field.
i like the teamwork on the
i like the teamwork on the Shaw carry at the 40 second mark. Shilling gives him a nice little shove to get the first down!! the oline helps out even at the end of runs too!!
Forget about the curveball Ricky. Give him the heater...
I'm glad you started another thread for this!
http://mgoblog.com/mgoboard/ot-bad-refs
http://mgoblog.com/mgoboard/bw3-officiating-where-commercials-become-rea...
I put up a tough front, but deep down I just want to be held.
How do these idiots get to
How do these idiots get to start threads?
“I am going to treat you all the same. Like Dogs.” - Bo Schembechler
Brian only puts minimum point
Brian only puts minimum point levels for posting up after losses, which is a mistake IMO. You're going to have just as many morons/trolls after a win as you would after a loss.
Twitter // Recruiting Work// Email
I know, my statement was more
I know, my statement was more a rebuttal to the OP's statement referring to how the refs are idiots and he doesn't know how they get certified.
I am more just grumpy about all the dumb threads on officiating. When has it ever been good? I don't know why people constantly complain about it.
“I am going to treat you all the same. Like Dogs.” - Bo Schembechler
You're going to have just as
You're going to have just as many morons/trolls after a win as you would after a loss.
I'm thinking you might want to reevaluate this statement after we lose a game.
Not necessarily
the further the season moves on without a loss, the less you are going to see the morons/trolls, IME. Of course I suspect the numbers of losses and the numbers of morons/trolls are directly proportional...
You have to play this game like somebody just hit your mother with a two-by-four. ~Dan Birdwell
It's gonna be bad after our
It's gonna be bad after our first loss. There is still so much distrust/hatred/ignorance about RR that those douche bags will look for any reason to trash him and the program. The perceived let down of the first loss after a winning streak will make it that much worse. Remember, we WON last week and the trolls were having a field day. Hell, after the ND game tons of folks were bitching about running Denard too much.
There are no corners in space.
Maybe the guy in the stands a couple of rows will post
He was bitching about RR not trying a FG on the 4th down play where DG got his first rushing TD. Then again maybe he wanted to see Hagerup punt I'm not sure. I don't think I'll be complaining if we don't have to punt or attempt a FG the rest of the season unless..
This is the third straight
This is the third straight game this board has complained about officiating. This isn't Notre Dame. Shut up.
Galileo was also chastised.
Did you see the game? There
Did you see the game? There were several calls they botched that they announced and several more that were just absurd.
...But we won. What's the
...But we won. What's the point of complaining about the officials now? Can we do anything about it? Did the officiating affect the outcome of the game? IMO, both of these questions can be answered with a swift, no.
Twitter // Recruiting Work// Email
Can we do anything about recruiting?
Can we do anything about who starts? Can we do anything about injuries? Can we do anything about schedules?
We talk about officiating, win or lose because, as fans, we talk about all components of football, not just the components that DGDestroys, or anyone else pre-approves.
With all of the ridiculous posts we see every day, you choose to ride the OP for opening a discussion about the officiaitng of Michigan's game saturday? You're right. Maybe we should discuss the decision to burn Gardner's redshirt instead..........
All right Lemmings. Bring the heat.
Don't get me wrong, and I
Don't get me wrong, and I probably shouldn't have posted the previous comment either, but there's a fine line between discussing and complaining. What some of the people who have responded to the OP are doing, which is great, is discussing. However, the OP did nothing to add to the conversation, but complain. That's why I negged him. Also, his joke at the officials was off base, so I corrected him. I don't want to silence the conversation, and I totally agree that the officiating yesterday was dreadful, I just think we should be mindful of the difference between pointing out mistakes officials made, and complaining (like the Irish) that we were wronged in so many ways.
Twitter // Recruiting Work// Email
Referee?
I didn't know Brian appointed you to the post of MGoReferee, policeman of the blog . . .
Disgruntled former moderator. I got a lot of problems with you people!
I'm thrilled you are happy
I'm thrilled you are happy that we won, and so am I.But...the officiating at that game was horrible...seemed like the refs were totally out of it with their calls and their announcements.
As far as the game goes, after the first quarter, the game was a joke, another Delaware State, as was the OSU, Wisconsin and Iowa games. Playing these cream puffs should be done via scrimmages. I'll take a great game against a quality opponent, even if it is a loss, any day of the week. I, for one, will be much happier to see a nine game Big Ten schedule along with playing teams like Bama and ND, assuming that happens.
Every schedule needs a few
Every team needs a few games like this on their schedule. Did you notice the amount of different players that got into the game? Starters got a nice little rest right before conference play starts which is much needed. I understand how you as a fan may not like scheduling cream puffs but think about the team, the team , the team.
So what? That's football.
So what? That's football.
Galileo was also chastised.
I know I know. This isn't
I know I know. This isn't complaining as in, "OMW those refs might have cost us a touchdown!!!" More along the lines of, 'How do calls like that even get made?"
Fair enough. For the record,
Fair enough. For the record, the game didn't strike me as being particularly poorly officiated. I saw a few bad calls- the one on our receiver for blocking below the knees stands out- but nothing out of the ordinary.
Galileo was also chastised.
Inappropriate
No reason to tell people to "shut up" - they can say the same thing to you. The officiating has been horrible, plain and simple. It has nothing to do with Notre Dame or BGSU. There have been an amazing number of missed penalties in each game. I'm sure the other team would say the same. If you don't like the posts, don't respond.
Disgruntled former moderator. I got a lot of problems with you people!
Easy there
Obviously, no one is blaming the officials for anything, since we won big. But it was definitely a poorly-officiated game. The TV announcers themselves questioned a lot of the calls, more than usual. I am getting a little concerned about us getting flagged for illegal blocks on plays that look perfectly legal. It didn't matter yesterday, but against ND some of those were drive-killers. RR might want to contact the league office about us being unfairly targeted on our downfield blocks.
The principle is this:
The principle is this: complaining about officials is almost always annoying unless it was exceptionally egregious or altered the outcome of the game. The ND game I thought qualified, but the UMass/BGSU complaints have been pure whining and it's annoying.
Your concern about some of these calls continuing into the future is related, but separate from what I'm complaining about. FWIW I don't think your worry has much merit. If we've been getting relatively bad calls it's bad luck and there's no reason to expect it to continue. If we see some of these blocking calls continue into Big Ten play, it will probably be because officials interpret and apply the rules differently from how the mgocommunity would.
Galileo was also chastised.
Lets face it
The refs could call O holding every time Martin rushes the passer. Will they? NO! It will be a long season if we keep bitching about the refs. I think as the season rools along we will get our calls.
GMW
i was there
yesterday...and the officials took forever to figure out what the call was, who it was on; in addition they picked up 3-4 flags during the game...
I wonder what conference they officiate for....because they were god awful- I am guessing the Big East
"Those who stay will be champions"
It was a home game for Michigan
Michigan is in the Big 10. They were Big 10 officials.
"If they ever catch me, they can have 'em."
No they werent big ten
No they werent big ten officials, also, for non-conference games they can hire any crew or parts of crew are available.
Fuck Urban Meyer!
www.facebook.com/franklin.kaiser
"The credit belongs to the man who is actually in the arena...."
Yes they were B10
Yes, they were B10 officials. The same crew that made the controversial call in the NW-Vandy game earlier this year.
Yesterday's officials
Referee - Dennis Lipski, Umpire - Jim Krogstad, Head Linesman - Brent Durbin, Line Judge - Dave Chesney, Back Judge - Robert Smith, Field Judge - Al Terry, Side Judge - Steve Hassel.
Lipski and Hassel officiated the Indiana-Michigan game last year. Krogstad officiated the Ohio State-Michigan game last year. Durbin officiated the Penn State-Michigan game last year. Chesney and Terry officiated the Michigan-Iowa and Michigan-Purdue games last year. Smith officiated the Michigan-Illinois game last year.
This was a 100 percent Big Ten crew.
I stand corrected....i take
I stand corrected....i take it this was a "chopped up" crew then, they dont normaly work together, as they seemed really confused most of the time.
Fuck Urban Meyer!
www.facebook.com/franklin.kaiser
"The credit belongs to the man who is actually in the arena...."
Yes, please, how about a
Yes, please, how about a moratorium on officiating threads, barring some monumental, game-changing blunder by a zebra. Bitching about the officials is loser-talk.
Uh, right...
Sure. When it comes to zebras, let's use the ostrich approach and bury our heads in the sand. Let's just pretend the bad calls never happened.
That was a pretty common approach in the 1950's, but officials are now held accountable for their performances, too, just like players and coaches. Bad officiating, whether from bias, accident, luck, or just plain incompetence, affects a lot of games. It had no part in the outcome of the game, but the officials cornholed the team during one of DG's drives. They ignored a blatant PI on BGSU on one play and then called a chop block on Michigan on the next.
It's no accident that "working the officials" is now counted as a coaching skill.
Eh, officiating has been bad
Eh, officiating has been bad all year, but that is the nature of college football. UM got away with a couple of holds there, and I'm sure a PI could have been called on a couple of pass blocks by the defense. Stuff happens. I'm happy that the team won, and while everyone can recognize that there were missed calls, I'd rather the focus be on egregious penalties or missed calls. That said, the Molk penalty seemed somewhat legit if the focus is to protect the player from injury.
Odoms blocking below the knees
wasn't Odoms called for a bogus blocking below the knees penalty.
I really don't understand the guys complaining about posts. Simply don't read them.
6:16 in the video above
Just a terrible call. Horrible.
The play was already outside of Odoms and the defender well before Odoms threw the block, and the block wasn't below the waist. So, by rule, that was a "block."
All I know is that I am
All I know is that I am getting sick and tired of being called for all of these"illegal crack back blocks". I cant even count how many we have been called for now. That one on Odoms yesterday was not even close to being a foul.
Everybody agrees the refs
Everybody agrees the refs bungle too many calls. Everyone knows home teams have an edge. But the real implication, in threads such as this one, is that refs are aligned in some sort of broad anti-Michigan effort. I'm quite sure fans of M's could find just as many iffy calls to complain about. (Do you really think a tiny team like UMass gets the benefit of the doubt in the Big House? Please.) Every team's fans think the refs are out to get their team. It's ridiculous, and such complaint's make fans look defensive and paranoid. Which is the nature of fandom, I realize. But there ought to be limits.
I was at the game, and there
I was at the game, and there were some bad calls. Someone posted earlier about the holding calls. I watched through the binoculars and holding Martin is a regular occurance. It just isn't getting called.
I feel more like I do now than I did when I got here.
on the screen...
pass where BGSU scored, you can clearly see a BGSU player grab james rogers arm as he tries to take off after the player... there was a ref standing right there IIRC and he didn't even bother throwing a flag...
does anyone...
even know what molk did??? espn2 never showed a replay of the play and the live feed at the stadium didn't replay it either...
chill out people
I'm not complaining about the officials at all. I just simply thought it was funny. You guys jump all over people for being "idiots" and what not. Who gives a flying f*ck.... Chill out you michigan dousche bags, you guys are the reason people think Michigan fans are arrogant
We Will Be Back
The call was "hitting a defenseless player" not "defensive player"
5:03
Twitter // Recruiting Work// Email