coldnjl

June 5th, 2014 at 10:12 AM ^

I used to love recruiting, but it seems more ther norm for top recruits to commit early, only to decommit from that school (normally dropping them from true contention) and explore new options. I can't get excited about a commit until he truly signs his NLOI. 

Magnus

June 5th, 2014 at 10:15 AM ^

It's certainly frustrating if you're the team being jilted (Damien Harris, George Campbell, etc.), but to me, it almost makes recruiting more interesting. It means that until National Signing Day 2015, you don't know whether kids will flip or not. You're never out of the fight.

I don't *like* the trend of going back on your word, but I think it does make things more intriguing.

Larry Appleton

June 5th, 2014 at 11:06 AM ^

"Committed" means virtually nothing anymore.  So many teens haven't the constitution to stand by their word.

Would an early signing period change this problem?  Honestly, I don't know.  We've seen in the past year or two "commits" trying to get out of their NLI after signing it.  I can't remember what happened with regards to the most recent one who I believed signed to FSU and then tried to get out of it months later claiming he was rushed into the decision.  What a joke.

Magnus

June 5th, 2014 at 10:16 AM ^

Staying out west won't affect Michigan much since he won't play against Michigan if he goes to Notre Dame. I guess if he went to ND and did well, that could help their recruiting efforts in the midwest. But frankly, I don't care if he goes to Notre Dame or not. If they don't get him, they'll get another solid QB prospect.

Anyway, yeah, I heard Barnett is likely going to choose Michigan.

BTW, Barnett was definitely on our radar, as he was one of the few quarterbacks with an offer from Michigan.

funkywolve

June 5th, 2014 at 11:14 AM ^

Taken from the linked article:

 

As for the Irish, senior Everett Golson is likely to lead Notre Dame in 2014, but the Irish's quarterback situation looks rather tenuous beyond this upcoming season. Landing Barnett would have helped secure the position for the foreseeable future, but now Kelly has more work ahead of him on the recruiting front. 

 

Is this Golsn's last year of eligibility?

superstringer

June 5th, 2014 at 2:16 PM ^

So, you're saying, the entire FCS can sue the SEC for "colluding" not to play any FCS teams anymore?

"Collusion" is illegal only among entities with market power.  ND has 200 scheduling options besides B1G teams, meaning every other FBS team and the entire FCS.  B1G does not have market power.  It is not illegal collusion.

Decatur Jack

June 5th, 2014 at 1:31 PM ^

I thought "Blake Barnett (CA QB) was IRISH!"

Totally saw this coming. Barnett is an NFL-style prototypical drop back passer and doesn't fit perfectly into Kelly's offense. Even if he were to be a non-turnover version of Tommy Rees, Kelly seems like he'd rather give the nod to a dual-threat guy like Golson or Zaire. The days of ND having guys like Crist, Clausen, Quinn, or Joe Montana under center are over.