Michigan is Over! [Moderated: No More Henson]

Submitted by MichiganSports on

[ed-S: Adding Gregg Henson to the list of asshats (with Valenti, Foster, Sharp and Ace Williams) you are best left ignoring. Guy has no established credibility, as best as I can determine he gets emails from a pissed off former player with content alluding to things other pissed off former players are saying. Also demonstrated he doesn't understand most basic tenets of responsible journalism, getting into a twitter argument w/ me and BiSB on sourcing. Now he's trying to appoint himself the MC of Michigan's downfall. Please keep all trolls off this site.]

Jevablue

September 27th, 2014 at 11:27 PM ^

How a BS call could be the equivalent of the flapping of a Butterfly's wings starting a hurricane.

At game speed that call could only be made by a total asshole ref.  There was utterly no way or time for Crable to line Smith up for such a hit, Smith had been Houdini all night, no one hit him squarely except perhaps for that one time. But, total agreement, if you graphed the fortunes of the team since that BS call, the downward trend is undeniable.

schreibee

September 28th, 2014 at 12:37 AM ^

I remember that 06 game far more clearly than today's, and as painful as it was in the moment, it has only grown more so over time: That was a stupid & unnecessary hit by Crable, just as we were exerting control in the game. It's not even a valid debate whether it was a good call or not. But didn't the date quoted refer to Bo's passing rather than the game itself?

markusr2007

September 27th, 2014 at 11:23 PM ^

Sees his quarterback hurt and stumbling and then lets him go back in? In college and pro football, players play hurt. I get that. But wtf. The QB go hit pretty damn hard. Bellamy should have gone in if need be.
That was a horrible decision. It could have been an error or not knowing, but goddammit.

Wolverine Devotee

September 27th, 2014 at 11:04 PM ^

I just feel heartbroken. It's painful to watch these games. At least there was hope in 2008 that things would get better because the right style of players were on the way. 

Mr. Yost

September 27th, 2014 at 11:17 PM ^

When we had those players and Mississippi state was ass ramming us over and over?

It's literally the exact same thing.

People need to stop using this to justify Rich Rod.

Rich Rod was shitty, this is shitty. It's the same. Shitty is shitty. We deserve better than shitty. The end.

What is it with this constant urge to compare everything? Sometimes it just is what it is and it doesn't make the past better or worse.

7-5 with Rich Rod and struggling through the B1G yet again was just as painful as this bullshit. I was over it then, I'm over it now.

Fire Rich Rod then. Fire Hoke now.

Wolverine Devotee

September 27th, 2014 at 11:26 PM ^

Funny how the AD gave Hoke whatever amount of $ needed to get a good coordinator.

We fired a fucking offensive genius for a MAC-level coach because he knew the fight song and was an assistant here. 

At least RR was improving in wins, unlike Hoke, who won with RR's players. Yeah, the defense was bad. Maybe if RR had a DC he actually wanted, things would've been better. 

It's all over with. Can't go back. But there are a million reasons things are the way they are. 

 

snarling wolverine

September 27th, 2014 at 11:43 PM ^

The problem with RR was just that - a "DC he wanted" was a 3-3-5 guru and nothing else.  He had a good DC in Shafer and ran him out because he didn't want to run that defense.

Both RR and Hoke are failures here.  I'm not pining for either one.  I want a coach who doesn't have a giant blind spot on one side of the ball. 

 

ilah17

September 27th, 2014 at 11:47 PM ^

RichRod's teams "improved" because he started out with a losing record. He couldn't even win the gimmes at first. Until this season, Coach Hoke usually did. 

I don't understand why some people want to go back and say we should have kept RichRod, just because Coach Hoke hasn't worked out. Maybe it's possible that neither one was right for the program??

Wolverine Devotee

September 28th, 2014 at 12:04 AM ^

Never did I say Michigan should go back. It's a shame they can't turn back time, but there was no choice but to fire RR.

That whole thing was FUBAR from the beginning. It was like building a bicycle without putting pedals on it.

If they just didn't dick around in the beginning and went (sorry for the pun) all in from the start, I'm willing to bet a large amount of money that he'd still be here and Michigan would be good.

But, what's done is done. And now we're in our own present-day version of the 50s and 60s in terms of humiliating losses.

Reader71

September 28th, 2014 at 12:34 AM ^

Coach Rod was not fired to make room for Brady Hoke. He was fired because his record was shit. As bad as you think Hoke is (and you're justified in thinking he's pretty fucking bad), he can lose out and still end up with a winning percentage 13 points higher than Coach Rod. Yours is a nonsensical sentiment. It is the exact opposite of the Michigan Man thing we all hate. There is no reason to look back fondly on that era. Hoke might be bad. That does not magically make Rodriguez good. Lets hope the next guy is better.

TheSacko221

September 28th, 2014 at 1:01 AM ^

Rodriguez wasn't supported by a large margin of alumni and former players because he had no ties to Michigan. He was doomed from the start and some would say sabotaged from the start. Hoke has always had 100% support and his teams have gotten worse while having more talent then Rodriguez teams.

atom evolootion

September 27th, 2014 at 11:30 PM ^

The difference between the two coaches is 11-2 and the Sugar Bowl. Rich Rod was trending upward. Hoke took his shine and made us love him. Now, he is trending miserably--hellishly. Can you honestly say this year feels the same as Rich Rod's 7-5? If Hoke even makes a bowl this year, imagine that it could be far worse than 52-14, or at least far worse looking...

jmblue

September 28th, 2014 at 12:05 AM ^

This is like comparing Amaker vs. Ellerbe. One might be better than the other but neither was the right guy to lead the program. Basketball got it right on the third try. Hopefully football will as well.

atom evolootion

September 28th, 2014 at 12:15 AM ^

Not quite... If Rich Rod would've gotten a fourth year, I'm thinking he would've completely owned that Sugar Bowl season, and that probably would've gotten everybody who is somebody in the Michigan community behind him. Amaker and Ellerbe were just bad for Michigan. Neither was building anything. The evidence shows that Rich Rod was definitely building something; Hoke simply put the roof on it. Then he went and did some tinkering with the foundation and the whole house is falling in on him.

jmblue

September 28th, 2014 at 12:44 AM ^

RR's third season ended with losses of 20, 30, and 38 points.  The team quit on him, the fans quit on him, and the recruits were turning him down.  

There were two huge factors behind the turnaround in 2011: the hiring of a competent defensive staff, and the elimination of media pressure over the coach's job status.  Those two things don't happen if RR stays.  Another year of him means the players have to spend another 12 months in a negative media environment, hearing about how their coach will get fired if they don't win, and they almost certainly won't have a DC of Mattison's caliber coaching them because 1) RR is a dead man walking (so why work with him?) and 2) Gibson and the other position coaches need someone they're "compatible" with, anyway.

The 2011 season was the perfect transition from one failed regime that knew how to coach only offense with another that knew how to coach only defense.  Neither staff could have put 2011 together by themselves.

RobGoBlue

September 27th, 2014 at 11:09 PM ^

I am SHOCKED... SHOCKED, I tell you... that hiring a head coach with a sub-.500 record at Ball State and San Diego State has led us to anything short of the promised land!

GoneBlue83

September 27th, 2014 at 11:13 PM ^

Money not Michigan.  Hoke and Brandon need to respect the program and hand in their keys.  This program has to realize that in this day and age no team can walk on the field and win games simply because of the name on their jersery, not even Alabama.  This is not a talent issue, a recruiting issue, it is a program issue.  I will continue to watch and route for the team but quite honestly I no longer have an emotional or finacial interest unitl both Brandon and Hoke are GONE. 

 

so freakin frustrated