So lets see who would win the Heisman Trophy with the MGoBlog community doing the voting. Place a reply with your ballots 1st, 2nd, 3rd, 4th, and 5th.
1st- Toby Gerhart
2nd- Ndamukong Suh
3rd- Mark Ingram
4th- Colt McCoy
5th- Tim Tebow
EDIT: I actually think i would take out Tebow and add either CJ Spiller or BG
1. McCoy
2. Suh
3. Gerhart
4.
Interesting
Interesting for some reason i like the non power team guys this year. Plus Colt was my preseason favorite but he didnt impress me much this season
Yeah I see what you mean
Yeah I see what you mean about McCoy. But if I had to vote, I would probably have the entire career in the back of my mind (even though this is a yearly award).
GO BLUE
Good Point
Good point I didnt really consider that but it still doesn't change my ballot just because it is his senior season and IMO his senior season should be his best.
I can't wait til Tate gets to go to NY
1) Suh
2) Gerhart
3) Ingram
4) McCoy
5) Tebow
You'll be better and you'll be smarter and more grown-up and a better daughter. . .
Ballot:
1. Suh
2. Gerhart
3. McCoy
4. Ingram
5. Brandon Graham
"A house divided against itself cannot stand"
No, no, no
No, no, no BG gets on the MVP ballot in the top 5 but heisman is about stats and its kinda hard to get stats like Suh when you're the only player worth blocking on the entire D
1. Gerhart
2. Suh
3. McCoy
4.
1. Gerhart
2. Suh
3. McCoy
4. Ingram
5. Spiller
6. Tebow
1. Suh
2. Gerhart
3.
1. Suh
2. Gerhart
3. Spiller
4. McClain
5. Ingram
I would love
I would love to see Suh win it but he is a DL and thats not exactly the most glamorous position to win the Heisman
shouldn't matter...
in an ideal world, the Heisman should go to most outstanding football player, regardless of whether they touch the ball on every play or not... Suh was the best player on the field in every game he played in... can't ask for anything more
Yes I realize that
Yes I realize that but who do you think the voters are going to pick? The best RB or the best DL even if the DL is better
good point
I would hope the DL especially when it is this dominant of a DL, but I may be too optimistic.
EDIT-- Maybe I'd flip Spiller
EDIT-- Maybe I'd flip Spiller and McClain around.
really...
really 2 Bama' players and 2 defensive players that is a peculiar list
Those are the five best
Those are the five best players in the country IMHE, so there they are.
1st- Ndamukong Suh
2nd- Toby
1st- Ndamukong Suh
2nd- Toby Gerhart
3rd- Mark Ingram
4th- Colt McCoy
5th- C.J. Spiller
Sorry but I don't think Tebow deserves to be on the list after this season and this season only.
"I figure if I can get two degrees from Ohio State, it might be close to Elliott’s undergraduate degree" - Brock Mealer
Why are you
Why are you sorry I really don't either but it is kind of hard to deny that he is a great player so I put him at 5
I am not sorry. Bad choice
I am not sorry. Bad choice of how to start the sentence. I understand what you are saying and Tebow is a great player and leader and I was actually a fan of his. However the Heisman should be about the current season and Tebow didn't have Heisman type numbers or Heisman type moments this season.
"I figure if I can get two degrees from Ohio State, it might be close to Elliott’s undergraduate degree" - Brock Mealer
1) Suh
2) Ingram
3)
1) Suh
2) Ingram
3) Gerhart
4) Spiller
5) McCoy
"Well, I think I made my position clear there."
- L.C.
I'm watching the
I'm watching the interview on Suh that is like 2 months old but with new highlights he is easily the best Defensive player this year. He is athletic and strong, plus he has great hand eye coordination.
1. Suh
2. Gerhart
3.
1. Suh
2. Gerhart
3. Spiller
4. Ingram
5. Dalton
There is a name
There is a name I haven't seen mentioned yet
1) Gerhart
2) Suh
3) McCoy
4)
1) Gerhart
2) Suh
3) McCoy
4) Spiller
5) Ingram
Without Percy Harvin, Tim Tebow is a "very good" QB, not the greatest college football player evarrr like everyone thinks he is.
It ain't easy being cheesy
1) Suh
2) Spiller
3)
1) Suh
2) Spiller
3) Gerhart
4) Ingram
5) Graham
1. Toby Gerhart
2. Ndamukong
1. Toby Gerhart
2. Ndamukong Suh
3. Mark Ingram
4. Colt McCoy
5. Tim Tebow
But the lows are so extreme that the good seems fucking cheap.
Ballot
1. Gerhart
2. Suh
3. Ingram
4. McCoy
5. Tebow
I'm hoping the SEC and Big 12 voters splilt their votes between the two candidates representing each of their respecitive conferences and that Gerhart emerges as the winner.
"Prejudiced? Partial? You better believe I am. Michigan football is a religion and Saturday's the holy day of obligation." -Bob Ufer
BTW
BTW voting ends tonight at 8 and then i will count the votes
Thanks for doing this. Should
Thanks for doing this. Should be interesting to see the results.
A wise man speaks because he has something to say; a fool because he has to say something. - Plato
1) Suh
2) Gerhart
3)
1) Suh
2) Gerhart
3) Ingram
4) Spiller
5) Graham
" I want to win Big 10 titles. Multiply. Consecutively. I just made that word up (multiply). I'm like that. I'm good at Scrabble."
1) Suh
2) Gerhart
3) McCoy
4)
1) Suh
2) Gerhart
3) McCoy
4) Tebow
5) Ingram
Wow Tebow over Ingram? It is
Wow Tebow over Ingram? It is your ballot/opinion but I was surprised to see that. I would be interested to know why you feel this way.
"I figure if I can get two degrees from Ohio State, it might be close to Elliott’s undergraduate degree" - Brock Mealer
I think that
I think that we all would like to know why.
For a couple reasons. I never
For a couple reasons. I never really jumped onto the Tebow-hate bandwagon, even though I think he's pretty overrated. I saw both play a couple times this year, and Tebow simply impressed me more. The way I see it, if Ingram switched teams with say, C.J. Spiller, is there a doubt in anyones mind that Spiller would be on the ballot instead of Ingram? My ballot isn't so much me thinking Tebow is "best player evarrrr" (he's not) as much as it is thinking Ingram simply isn't that good.
Interesting. I am just glad
Interesting. I am just glad you have reasons behind how you ranked them other than Tebow has been awesome during his college career.
Just so you know I am a Tebow fan (I hate Urban Meyer) but I do like Tebow. I was just curious on your reasons.
"I figure if I can get two degrees from Ohio State, it might be close to Elliott’s undergraduate degree" - Brock Mealer
Heisman Ballot
1) Suh
2) Gerhart
3) Ingram
4) Spiller
5) McCoy
6) Lefevour*
*Had to throw in some Lefevour Love haha
A wise man speaks because he has something to say; a fool because he has to say something. - Plato
Kudos to Lefevour
Most touchdowns in NCAA history.
If he was on TV every Saturday, he'd be on the real Heisman ballot. What a shame.
1. Suh
2. Gerhart
3.
1. Suh
2. Gerhart
3. Graham
4. Dion Lewis
5. The mad scientist produced hybrid of Pike/Collaros
This has nothing to do with Michigan football.
What?
What? No Ingram but instead you have Dion Lewis and BG (well cant complain bout BG)
Ingram would be my real #5.
Ingram would be my real #5.
This has nothing to do with Michigan football.
Mine
1) Gerhart
2) Suh
3) Ingram
4) Mccoy
5) Kellen Moore
My ballot
1) Suh
2) BG
3) Gerhart
4) McCoy
5) Zoltan Mesko
1. Gerhart
2. Suh
3.
1. Gerhart
2. Suh
3. Ingram
4. McCoy
5. Tebow
1st- Ndamukong Suh
2nd- Toby
1. Suh
2. Gerhart
3.
1. Suh
2. Gerhart
3. Spiller
4. Ingram
5. Moore
Fucking magnets, how do they work?
1) Rolando McClain
2)
1) Rolando McClain
2) Ndamukong Suh
3) Toby Gerhardt
4) CJ Spiller
5) Case Keenum
Honorable Mentions: Ingram, Moore, Marty Gilyard (Cinci), Graham, McCoy, Masoli, (Ugh) Tate
Votes
1. Ndamukong
2. Gerhart
3. Ingram
4. McCoy
5. Spiller
They call me...Tater Salad
1) Zoltan
2) Zoltan!
3)
1) Zoltan
2) Zoltan!
3) ZOLTAN
4) ZOLTAN!
5) Suh
Wanting something to be true does not make it true.
1. Suh
2. Gerhart
3.
1. Suh
2. Gerhart
3. Ingram
4. Spiller
5. McCoy
Me fail english thats unpossible!
Fixed for SEC anyway...but here goes
1st- Ndamukong Suh
2nd- Toby Gerhart
3rd- Mark Ingram
4th- Colt McCoy
5th- Tim Tebow (I would have added BG but no way Spiller)
Prediction: SEC Media Mafia delivers for Mark Ingram.
If the haters don't hate you then you're doing something wrong. - David Cone
1. McCoy
2. Suh
3. Gerhart
4. Tebow
5. Ingram
GO BLUE