B-Nut-GoBlue

December 14th, 2013 at 9:09 PM ^

Congrats to him.  Very good season by that young, young man.  I hope he's innocent of any wrongdoings he's been "accused" of as he seems like a very decent and respectable person.  They all seem like good, young men.  And I agree with Jordan, Chicago style is the way to go!

JHendo

December 14th, 2013 at 10:53 PM ^

For now, until everything surrounding his situation is answered, I only have one opinion of him: The kid is a damn fine football player.  When the truth about what he did or didn't do comes out, then I can form an educated opinion of him as a person, but whatever that opinion may end up being, it won't have any effect whatsoever on my aforementioned one above.

a2_electricboogaloo

December 14th, 2013 at 9:30 PM ^

I went through the last 7 winners

Winner/year Year (college) Years starting
Jameis Winston (2013) RS Fr. 1st year
Johnny Manziel (2012) RS Fr. 1st year
RGIII  (2011) Jr. 3rd year
Cam Newton (2010) Jr. 1st year (complicated)
Mark Ingram (2009) So. 1st year
Sam Bradford (2008) So. 2nd year
Tim Tebow (2007) So. 1st year

5 of last 7 winners were first year starters (although Ingram and Tebow got some playing time during their freshman years and Cam Newton had a complicated history before coming to Auburn).

LSAClassOf2000

December 14th, 2013 at 9:20 PM ^

The margin was considerable. Here are the top five this year - 

Jameis Winston - 2,205 votes

AJ McCarron - 704 votes

Jordan Lynch - 558 votes

Andre Williams - 480 votes

Johnny Manziel - 441 votes

There was one tweet, I believe, that said this would be the seventh largest margin in Heisman history. 

Victor Valiant

December 14th, 2013 at 9:23 PM ^

Agree with turd ferguson, so hard to decide whether to root for him or not. He very well may have raped a woman. Tough to tell. I'll stay indifferent for now.

P.S. - Shot in the dark, but are you the turd ferguson from the FCP site?

turd ferguson

December 14th, 2013 at 9:28 PM ^

No, I'm only a turd here.

The crappy thing about staying indifferent with someone like Winston is that you essentially know you're wrong. While there's a lot of possible middle ground, chances are that he's either a victim (deserving of sympathy) or a rapist (deserving of scorn). Playing the middle is unsatisfying to me - even if it's the most reasonable perspective - because it almost certainly is wrong.

Princetonwolverine

December 14th, 2013 at 9:28 PM ^

I've always felt McCarron's significance to Alabama's success was underrated. The guy was clutch.

bronxblue

December 14th, 2013 at 10:31 PM ^

His problem has always been that guys before him at Alabama have done reasonably well, and with all the talent they have it doesn't feel like he has had to "earn" it like other guys.  I agree it is unfair, since it's not like Winston is playing with a bunch of MAC guys out there.  

 

Cheesecake Wizard

December 14th, 2013 at 10:02 PM ^

If anything, it gives it more credibiltiy.  If it turns out Winston did rape the girl, I would feel bad for whoever did not win the award.  If this was the case and he if he was honest from the beginning, one of the other finalists would have been very deserving, and would miss out on the award because of something totally unrelated to them.

Princetonwolverine

December 14th, 2013 at 9:54 PM ^

How can the Heisman committee be criticized since they made their decision AFTER the prosecutor said there was not enough evidence of a crime being committed ?

Should they have launched their own investigation?

aplatypus

December 15th, 2013 at 10:43 AM ^

You have Cam, whom even if you don't believe knew his dad was taking money (hah!), still stole a laptop and was going to get kicked out of Florida for cheating. 

Manziel, who also almost definitely took some money for the autographs, has had multiple DUI type incidents and bar fights, was almost kicked out of Texas A&M before his game. 

And then Winston, who should have probably been tried for rape a year ago (note I said tried, not convicted). It's really hard to judge him, but all the official reports made it sond a heck of a lot like date rape since the girl was too intoxicated to even know where she was. But his local police squashed the case for a year and hey Heisman!

They were all most likely the best player each year, but they just need to get the 'off the field excellence and integrity' or whatever line out of the Heisman criteria and call it the "best, most popular player award" like it really is.