Home
i'm an actor, not a reactor

Primary links

  • About
    • $upport (lol)
    • Ethics
    • FAQ
    • Glossary
    • Privacy Policy
  • Contact
  • MGoStore
    • Hail to Old Blue
  • MGoBoard
    • MGoBoard FAQ
    • Michigan bar locator
    • Moderator Action Sticky
  • Useful Stuff
    • Depth Chart By Class
    • Hoops Depth Chart by Class
    • 2017 Recruiting Board
    • Unofficial Two Deep
    • MGoFlickr
    • Diaries, Windows Live Writer, And You
    • User-Curated HOF
    • Where To Eat In Ann Arbor
  • Schedule/Tix
    • Future Schedules (wiki)
    • Ticket spreadsheet
Home Forums MGoBoard

Navigation

  • Forums
  • Recent posts

User login

  • Create new account
  • Request new password

MGoElsewhere

  • @MGoBlog (Brian)
  • @aceanbender
  • @Misopogon (Seth)
  • @Aeschnepp (Adam)
  • @BISB
  • @EUpchurchPhoto
  • @FullOfTwitt (Fuller)
  • Hail to the Victors 2016
  • MGoFacebook
  • MGoPodcast
  • WTKA
  • Instagram

Michigan Blogs

  • Big House Blog
  • Burgeoning Wolverine Star
  • Genuinely Sarcastic
  • Go Blue Michigan Wolverine
  • Holdin' The Rope
  • MVictors
  • Maize 'n' Blue Nation
  • Maize 'n' Brew
  • Maize And Go Blue
  • Michigan Hockey Net
  • MMMGoBlueBBQ
  • The Blog That Yost Built
  • The Hoover Street Rag
  • The M Zone
  • Touch The Banner
  • UMGoBlog
  • UMHoops
  • UMTailgate
  • Wolverine Liberation Army

M On The Net

  • mgovideo
  • MGoBlue.com
  • Mike DeSimone
  • Recruiting Planet
  • The Wolverine
  • Go Blue Wolverine
  • Winged Helmet
  • UMGoBlue.com
  • MaizeRage.org
  • Puckhead
  • The M Den
  • True Blue Fan Forum

Big Ten Blogs

  • Illinois
    • Illinois Loyalty
    • Illinois Baseball Report
  • Indiana
    • Inside The Hall
    • The Crimson Quarry
  • Iowa
    • Black Heart, Gold Pants
    • Fight For Iowa
  • Michigan State
    • The Only Colors
  • Minnesota
    • GopherHole.com
    • The Daily Gopher
  • Nebraska
    • Corn Nation
    • Husker Max
    • Husker Mike's Blasphemy
    • Husker Gameday
  • Northwestern
    • Sippin' On Purple
    • Lake The Posts
  • Notre Dame
    • The House Rock Built
    • One Foot Down
  • Ohio State
    • Eleven Warriors
    • Buckeye Commentary
    • Men of the Scarlet and Gray
    • Our Honor Defend
    • The Buckeye Nine
  • Penn State
    • Slow States
    • Black Shoe Diaries
    • Happy Valley Hardball
    • Penn State Clips
    • Linebacker U
    • Nittany White Out
  • Purdue
    • Boiled Sports
    • Hammer and Rails
  • Wisconsin
    • Bruce Ciskie

Links of Note

  • Baseball
    • College Baseball Today
    • The College Baseball Blog
  • Basketball
    • Ken Pomeroy
    • Hoop Math
    • John Gasaway
    • Luke Winn/Sports Illustrated
  • College Hockey
    • Chris Heisenberg (Class of 2016)
    • College Hockey Stats
    • Michigan College Hockey
    • Hockey's Future
    • Sioux Sports
    • USCHO
  • Football
    • Smart Football
    • Every Day Should Be Saturday
    • Matt Hinton/Grantland
    • Football Study Hall
    • Football Outsiders
    • Harold Stassen
    • NCAA D-I Stats Page
    • The Wizard Of Odds
    • CFB Stats
  • General
    • Sports Central
  • Local Interest
    • The Ann Arbor Chronicle
    • Arborwiki
    • Arbor Update
    • Ann Arbor Observer
    • Teeter Talk
    • Vacuum
  • Teams Of The D
    • Lions
      • Pride of Detroit
    • Pistons
      • Detroit Bad Boys
      • Need4Sheed
    • Tigers
      • Roar Of The Tigers
      • Bless You Boys
      • The Daily Fungo
      • The Detroit Tigers Weblog
    • Red Wings
      • Winging It In Motown
      • On The Wings
    • Michigan Sports Forum

Beveled Guilt

Site Search

Diaries

  • New
  • Popular
  • Hot
  • This Month in MGoBlog History - April 2008: No Spring Game at the Big House! Hockey loses to ND in the Frozen Four!
    Maize.Blue Wagner - 4 days ago
  • Thirteen unlucky minutes (TL;DNR-This is a bit of rant about the refs)
    docwhoblocked - 2 weeks ago
  • Fan Satisfaction Index End of Season Bball Survey
    OneFootIn - 3 weeks ago
  • How likely are we to revert to the mean?
    Bo Glue - 3 weeks ago
  • It's time to avenge Villanova's 1985 NCAA tourney upset over Michigan
    Communist Football - 3 weeks ago
  •  
  • 1 of 2
  • ››
more
  • This Month in MGoBlog History - April 2008: No Spring Game at the Big House! Hockey loses to ND in the Frozen Four!
    Maize.Blue Wagner - 1,360 views
  • 14 Months Ago: The Fire Beilein Threads.
    stephenrjking - 237 comments
  • This Month in MGoBlog History - April 2008: No Spring Game at the Big House! Hockey loses to ND in the Frozen Four!
    Maize.Blue Wagner - 8 comments

MGoBoard

  • New
  • Recent
  • Hot
  • More MSU takes. From USA Today
    33 replies
  • OT: National Park Week; What's Your Favorite?
    111 replies
  • New Q&A with Cam McGrone, video
    1 replies
  • Rice Commission recommendations to be released today
    61 replies
  • MBB: Wake Forest grad transfer PG Keyshawn Woods commits to OSU
    19 replies
  • Harmoniously OT: UM Men's Glee Club in AZ
    17 replies
  • Coach B w Andy Katz podcast
    3 replies
  • Michigan Alumni Club Scholarship Golf Tournament featuring Honorary Chair Glen Rice - This Saturday in Miami!
    5 replies
  • Hello? Boring Tuesday POSbang Happy Hour Thread
    114 replies
  • OT: UCL Semi-final First Legs
    14 replies
  • More evidence of awful culture at MSU, volleyball this time
    61 replies
  • OT: Rick Pitino Rumored to be Candidate for Detroit Mercy Job
    79 replies
  • New Jersey DE Aeneas DiCosmo: Prospect we should all want at UM
    55 replies
  • In-state recruiting rankings update
    125 replies
  • A piece of U-M broadcast history ends tonight.
    29 replies
  •  
  • 1 of 6
  • ››
  • OT: National Park Week; What's Your Favorite?
    111 replies
  • MBB: Wake Forest grad transfer PG Keyshawn Woods commits to OSU
    19 replies
  • A piece of U-M broadcast history ends tonight.
    29 replies
  • Rice Commission recommendations to be released today
    61 replies
  • More MSU takes. From USA Today
    33 replies
  • New Q&A with Cam McGrone, video
    1 replies
  • Harmoniously OT: UM Men's Glee Club in AZ
    17 replies
  • Coach B w Andy Katz podcast
    3 replies
  • Hello? Boring Tuesday POSbang Happy Hour Thread
    114 replies
  • More evidence of awful culture at MSU, volleyball this time
    61 replies
  • In-state recruiting rankings update
    125 replies
  • Michigan Alumni Club Scholarship Golf Tournament featuring Honorary Chair Glen Rice - This Saturday in Miami!
    5 replies
  • OT: Rick Pitino Rumored to be Candidate for Detroit Mercy Job
    79 replies
  • New Jersey DE Aeneas DiCosmo: Prospect we should all want at UM
    55 replies
  • Pep and Partridge Pressers
    11 replies
  •  
  • 1 of 6
  • ››
  • Belleville coach Jermain Crowell mad at UM again
    244 replies
  • "Being Not-Rich at UM" Guide
    168 replies
  • The Evolution of Commerce - What Industries are Dying, What's Thriving?
    148 replies
  • Pep Hamilton on Shea: Can extend the play, make all the throws, plus other QB's
    129 replies
  • In-state recruiting rankings update
    125 replies
  • OT - Jalen Hurts possibly looking to transfer
    121 replies
  • Notre Dame Spring Game: analysis from M n B, video
    119 replies
  • Hello? Boring Tuesday POSbang Happy Hour Thread
    114 replies
  • No additional protest of Shea Patterson appeal by Ole Miss
    113 replies
  • OT: National Park Week; What's Your Favorite?
    108 replies
  • OT: MSU digs hole deeper, Engler adviser: Nassar survivor's claims of payout 'fake news'
    106 replies
  • Nebraska football
    105 replies
  • OT: Map of college stadiums that sell alcohol
    96 replies
  • Karsen Barnhart - did we cool on him?
    92 replies
  • OT: College Football video games coming back
    90 replies
  •  
  • 1 of 6
  • ››

Support MGoBlog: buy stuff at Amazon

Go for it on 4th down

32 posts / 0 new
Login or register to post comments
Last post
November 16th, 2011 at 7:02 PM
#1
river-z
Joined: 09/19/2010
MGoPoints: 166
Go for it on 4th down

The article at the link makes 4 points about the hazards of decision-making in football.  The study used data from the NFL, but it's definitely relevant to the college game.  

In particular, it seems relevant discussion on MGoBlog about:

1. going for it on 4th down (do it!)

2. whether it helps the team to fire the coach (not really, but there needs to be a GERG exception, IMO)

3. winning with someone else's talent (WOO! go Brady, Borges, and Mattison)

http://www.theatlantic.com/business/archive/2011/11/4-things-the-nfl-can...

Top
  • Login or register to post comments
Tags:
  • MGoBoard
  • bad coaching
  • football
  • fourth down decisions
  • metrics
  • talent

Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.
November 16th, 2011 at 7:14 PM
#2
mGrowOld
mGrowOld's picture
Joined: 10/04/2010
MGoPoints: 111768
WTF?

WTF?

Top
  • Login or register to post comments
November 16th, 2011 at 7:12 PM
#3
LSAClassOf2000
LSAClassOf2000's picture
Joined: 01/07/2011
MGoPoints: 81402
Going For It On 4th And 1

Field position? The article fails to give specifics on field position, what sort of plays have succeeded in the game to date, etc...

Top
  • Login or register to post comments
November 16th, 2011 at 7:16 PM
(Reply to #3) #4
2plankr
Joined: 03/13/2009
MGoPoints: -433
???

Its a synopsis, but he does include

"If a team was on its own side of the field and needed four yards or less for a first down, going for it was the right move. At the opponent's five yard line, the chance of going for it and scoring a touchdown was more valuable than the guaranteed points from a field goal."

Top
  • Login or register to post comments
November 16th, 2011 at 7:21 PM
(Reply to #5) #5
LSAClassOf2000
LSAClassOf2000's picture
Joined: 01/07/2011
MGoPoints: 81402
Read It Again...

....and saw that. These are the sorts of things you miss when your kids suddenly want chicken nuggets. 

Top
  • Login or register to post comments
November 16th, 2011 at 9:23 PM
(Reply to #7) #6
ryebreadboy
ryebreadboy's picture
Joined: 12/02/2010
MGoPoints: 5894
I want chicken nuggets.

I want chicken nuggets.

Top
  • Login or register to post comments
November 16th, 2011 at 7:13 PM
#7
turd ferguson
turd ferguson's picture
Joined: 12/09/2009
MGoPoints: 26489
posted from iPhone

I've felt bad for Mike Smith of the Falcons this week. IMHO, that was exactly the right decision and he just got burned by bad luck.

Top
  • Login or register to post comments
November 16th, 2011 at 7:18 PM
(Reply to #4) #8
2plankr
Joined: 03/13/2009
MGoPoints: -433
Unbelievable how all the

Unbelievable how all the talking heads say "i don't care what the statistics say"

Yeah, thats why youre in the studio and not on the sideline

Top
  • Login or register to post comments
November 16th, 2011 at 7:24 PM
(Reply to #6) #9
turd ferguson
turd ferguson's picture
Joined: 12/09/2009
MGoPoints: 26489
posted from iPhone

I share your frustration, but I'm not sure that mentality keeps guys off the sideline. Those views are par for the course.

Top
  • Login or register to post comments
November 16th, 2011 at 7:42 PM
(Reply to #6) #10
bo_lives
bo_lives's picture
Joined: 04/10/2011
MGoPoints: 4290
Judging by the number of statisticians on our sideline...

I really don't think having a good grasp of statsitics is a pre-requisite to coaching football. Les Miles doesn't really seem like a guy who took Stats 400 at U-M.

But this is an old point regarding a very tired old topic. Nothing new in this article at all.

Top
  • Login or register to post comments
November 16th, 2011 at 8:33 PM
(Reply to #10) #11
2plankr
Joined: 03/13/2009
MGoPoints: -433
I tend to disagree.  He may

I tend to disagree.  He may not know a thing about statistics, but his decisions tend to maximize expected value.

Now he may not know how to read a digital clock, but however he got his "feel" for when to go for it, it aligns pretty well with the statistics

Likewise I have no idea how much Hoke understands the numbers behind it, but he clearly seems to know what works in this regard

Top
  • Login or register to post comments
November 16th, 2011 at 8:38 PM
(Reply to #22) #12
turd ferguson
turd ferguson's picture
Joined: 12/09/2009
MGoPoints: 26489
posted from iPhone

Sometimes with Miles. There was a big-time game a few years ago (can't remember which one) in which I thought his timeout usage was the worst I've ever seen from a high-profile coach. He's a gambler, which tends to pay off, but he's still a disaster when there's actual thinking required.

Top
  • Login or register to post comments
November 16th, 2011 at 8:14 PM
(Reply to #6) #13
umchicago
umchicago's picture
Joined: 02/05/2009
MGoPoints: 16168
Disagree

in general, i like being aggressive on 4th down.  in the falcons case, though, it was sudden death OT and missing that conversion puts the opposition in FG range already.  if Atl was another 10 yds downfield, i wouldn't have a problem with that decision, as the opposition would need to get a first down to get into field goal range.

Top
  • Login or register to post comments
November 16th, 2011 at 8:22 PM
(Reply to #19) #14
BraveWolverine730
BraveWolverine730's picture
Joined: 09/21/2009
MGoPoints: 4122
How many times can you punt

How many times can you punt to Drew Brees with a below averge pass defense and expect to hold them? Especially since you have an above average rushing attack against a poor rush defese.  I feel statistically it would be backed up as close to 50-50, but the intangibles of the scenario in my opinion push it to going for it,. 

Top
  • Login or register to post comments
November 17th, 2011 at 12:25 AM
(Reply to #19) #15
treetown
Joined: 11/10/2010
MGoPoints: 2240
Exactly

It is always good to see smarter and better stats used in sports, but game context has to matter.

Why not analyze going for 4th down in the same "red zone" fashion as the regular offense?

The risk of turning over the ball on 4th down when there is at least 50 yards to your own goal line probably makes sense if your defense is pretty good. Most teams can't reliably drive 50 yards every time. Game context - time remaining, score and situation (OT) clearly all can affect these calculations.

Top
  • Login or register to post comments
November 16th, 2011 at 7:40 PM
(Reply to #4) #16
BraveWolverine730
BraveWolverine730's picture
Joined: 09/21/2009
MGoPoints: 4122
Falcons fan here

I absolutely loved that move and gives me even more confidence he'll give us the best chance to win in any given game. He also went for it on a 4th and 2 or 3 against the Lions that I thought was pretty big in us winning that game. 

Top
  • Login or register to post comments
November 16th, 2011 at 10:44 PM
(Reply to #12) #17
ATLWolverine
ATLWolverine's picture
Joined: 02/16/2009
MGoPoints: 1658
Agreed

It was risky, but given Brees' skill and perhaps other things we are not privy to (Smith feeling his defense was sagging, having used that same power play to success earlier or throughout the season, etc.) I don't see what the uproar is about.

Again, if Falcons convert, he's a genius-- but he didn't, so every forum-poster and sportswriter snipes at him until the next game or succesful gutsy call. Football!

Top
  • Login or register to post comments
November 16th, 2011 at 8:08 PM
(Reply to #4) #18
BiSB
BiSB's picture
Joined: 08/15/2009
MGoPoints: 44839
Well...

You can make a good decision to go, and still make a bad play call.

Top
  • Login or register to post comments
November 16th, 2011 at 8:11 PM
(Reply to #17) #19
LSAClassOf2000
LSAClassOf2000's picture
Joined: 01/07/2011
MGoPoints: 81402
Unless You're Ron Zook...

....in which case, it's, "BAHAMAS VACATION.....NO WHAMMIES....NO WHAMMIES......STOP!"

Top
  • Login or register to post comments
November 16th, 2011 at 10:46 PM
(Reply to #17) #20
ATLWolverine
ATLWolverine's picture
Joined: 02/16/2009
MGoPoints: 1658
What was bad about it?

Grantland has a good take on it, IMO

New Orleans has an abysmal power run defense, Atlanta had converted a 4th down on a Turner run earlier in the game, and was racking up yards on the ground at a fair clip throughout the game.

Power run with Turner seems reasonable to me, but I guess it's all about the wins, baby.

Top
  • Login or register to post comments
November 16th, 2011 at 7:27 PM
#21
orobs
Joined: 10/03/2010
MGoPoints: 3205
you felt compelled to share

you felt compelled to share this article because......?

Top
  • Login or register to post comments
November 16th, 2011 at 7:35 PM
#22
AAB
Joined: 01/14/2009
MGoPoints: 7940
I mean

Brian's been citing Romer for years now.  

Top
  • Login or register to post comments
November 16th, 2011 at 7:49 PM
(Reply to #11) #23
turd ferguson
turd ferguson's picture
Joined: 12/09/2009
MGoPoints: 26489
I think it tends to be

I think it tends to be misapplied around here.  The Romer paper - which, I think has problems, but that's for another day - is very good for telling us whether, across the board, coaches are too conservative, aggressive, etc.  It's not very useful in determining whether a particular decision in a particular game was right or wrong.

Around here, people will run some numbers and then declare a Michigan decision "right" or "wrong."  That's an inappropriate use of statistics.  The circumstances of the situation have massive effects on the relevant probabilities.  For example, quality of offense, quality of defense, weather, quality of plays available, injury/fatigue, and so many other context-specific things make it almost impossible to declare a decision right or wrong when it's relatively close in the expected value numbers.

I thought Mike Smith made the right move in that Falcons-Saints game.  If the same situation had arisen in the LSU-Alabama game, I probably would have felt differently.

Top
  • Login or register to post comments
November 16th, 2011 at 7:52 PM
(Reply to #13) #24
AAB
Joined: 01/14/2009
MGoPoints: 7940
I disagree

Coaches are departing so far from what EV would dictate that it would take a fairly extreme situation (say, Penn State against Alabama on a 3rd and 8 from its own 42, or something) for me to conclude that conventional wisdom is more correct than Romer.  

Top
  • Login or register to post comments
November 16th, 2011 at 7:57 PM
(Reply to #14) #25
turd ferguson
turd ferguson's picture
Joined: 12/09/2009
MGoPoints: 26489
Our views are probably pretty

Our views are probably pretty close on this.  Here's where I'm at:

The starting point for what's the right decision should be something like what's in the Romer paper.  In other words, if you have a median offense against a median defense in median weather with median fatigue... go with Romer.  I think the starting point that people use (conventional wisdom) is much too conservative.  Still, there's enormous context-specific variation that needs to be accounted for in order to intelligently play the expected value game in a particular situation.  I think that people around here tend to be very good at understanding the starting point and not as good at understanding the relevance of context.  (Note that that means that "people around here" are just as likely to be too conservative, in my view, as too aggressive.)

I'm definitely not arguing that conventional wisdom > Romer.

Top
  • Login or register to post comments
November 16th, 2011 at 8:03 PM
(Reply to #15) #26
AAB
Joined: 01/14/2009
MGoPoints: 7940
I don't disagree with that

but here's where I'm at:

For the most part, people (including Brian) aren't really complaining about marginal decisions where, according to Romer, going for it on 4th and fairly long from your own 38 or whatever might be slightly +EV.  People are like "oh my god stop punting on 4th and 2 from your opponent's 45, especially when you're down a touchdown in the 4th quarter."  

To use a poker analogy, coaches, by and large, aren't being criticized for failing to make marginal but probably +EV calls with Q7 when their opponent is shoving all in with a really huge range of hands.  It's more like the vast majority of coaches are folding pocket Jacks when they have 10 big blinds.  There's basically no set of circumstances where that decision is the correct one.  

Top
  • Login or register to post comments
November 16th, 2011 at 8:14 PM
(Reply to #16) #27
turd ferguson
turd ferguson's picture
Joined: 12/09/2009
MGoPoints: 26489
No disagreement here.  The

No disagreement here.  The marginal cases are the more interesting ones to me, but you're right that most of the screaming is completely justified because the decisions are so outrageously conservative.

Top
  • Login or register to post comments
November 16th, 2011 at 9:26 PM
(Reply to #13) #28
ryebreadboy
ryebreadboy's picture
Joined: 12/02/2010
MGoPoints: 5894
Easy! It's the right

Easy!

It's the right decision if I agree with it.

It's not if I don't.

/99%ofsportsfans.

Top
  • Login or register to post comments
November 17th, 2011 at 1:07 PM
(Reply to #26) #29
jmblue
Joined: 11/07/2008
MGoPoints: 56299
If it works, it's

If it works, it's "gutsy."

If it doesn't work, it's "boneheaded."

Top
  • Login or register to post comments
November 16th, 2011 at 9:21 PM
#30
alanmfrench
alanmfrench's picture
Joined: 06/23/2010
MGoPoints: 1987
i would

love to see a div 1 program adopt a go for it on every 4th down no matter what philosophy. i think it would make for some really interesting games. youre offense would have to be good though or it would just be ridiculous.

Top
  • Login or register to post comments
November 16th, 2011 at 10:38 PM
(Reply to #24) #31
ATLWolverine
ATLWolverine's picture
Joined: 02/16/2009
MGoPoints: 1658
Interesting article about HS offensive guru

http://sportsillustrated.cnn.com/2011/writers/scorecasting/09/15/kelley.pulaski/index.html

He also refuses to return punts because the risk of getting stripped (in HS at least) is apparently too high to justify the sparse return yards generated.

Gus Malzahan started as a zany offensive-minded HS coach once  upon a time and a lot of his spread precepts are gaining traction in Div. 1. Who knows, your wish could come true sooner than you think

Top
  • Login or register to post comments
November 16th, 2011 at 10:16 PM
#32
LB
LB's picture
Joined: 09/26/2009
MGoPoints: 10451
If they were really football guru's, they would have

understood and related the MGoLiveBlog's ability to will interceptions. Any stats that do not take that into account can't possibly be taken seriously.

Top
  • Login or register to post comments
Powered by Drupal, an open source content management system
Theme provided by Roopletheme; sidebars adapted from Chris Murphy.