It is unlikely that you'll ever agree with everything a person iin position of power does. Deciding whether you think someone involves weighing the bad and the good. For me, the good greatly outweighs the bad.
Frankly the evidence that he is doing a good job is that the complaints that seem to have so many up in arms are generally about little things. Some schools are cutting sports, we're adding them. Some schools are losing lots of games, we're winning lots of games. If the biggest thing to complain about is special jerseys, our athletic department is in good hands.
Football and basketball programs - trending up
Revenue - trending up
Performance in non revenue sports - trending up
Facilities - trending up
I have trouble arguing against those results.