CC: The nuclear option

Submitted by Ron Utah on

With Hackett taking his sweet time in firing (or retaining!) Hoke, I have read a lot of material out there that says this search comes down to two names if neither Harbaugh wants the job: Les Miles and Greg Schiano.

To me, those are both unappealing options.  But if forced to choose one, whom would it be?

CLICK HERE  to take the survey.  I will post the results later.

UPDATE: With 100 votes in, it 96% Miles, 4% Schiano.  Actually, there are 857 votes in, but the percentages have been essentially the same all through the voting.

Part of the purpose of this poll was to give an unofficial voice to the fans...I knew Schiano would be unpopular, and I hope in some small way this helps the people in charge of things see how the fanbase views that hire.

I will post a few more polls in the next few days that should be more competitive.

WolvinLA2

December 1st, 2014 at 4:28 PM ^

Nobody does less with more?  I think RR and Hoke did.  Even if he is what you say he is, that's Lloyd Carr, and I think anyone would welcome those days back right about now.  

EDIT:  And he hasn't been there 15 years, this season was his 10th.  And although he only has 3 conference titles, that's pretty damn good considering he has had Urban Meyer's UF teams, Saban's Bama teams and those two really good Auburn teams to compete with.  

Brodie

December 1st, 2014 at 5:46 PM ^

You say this like LSU is at some kind of disadvantage to those schools. He's like Lloyd Carr there... sure he wins a lot, just never enough and he has all the talent and resources in the world.

Why don't you look into LSU fans' opinions on Les. They don't have the same rosy vision of a guy who's only made three BCS bowls in a decade while sending half his rosters to the NFL

WolvinLA2

December 1st, 2014 at 7:38 PM ^

I would welcome back Lloyd Carr in a heartbeat.  Always in contention for a league title, occasionally win it and one year put it all together and win it all.  Not many programs have it better than that.  

And I would say that LSU is at a disadvantage to UF (at least when Urban/Tebow were there) and Alabama.  But outside of those two, no coach has had as much success in the last decade as Les Miles.  If that's not good enough for us, then we're fucked.

Brodie

December 1st, 2014 at 8:45 PM ^

I don't really see how you can say that they're at a disadvantage... Louisiana is probably the 4th or 5th most talent rich state in the country and he has no in state competition. He doesn't have a spectacularly hard job... Gerry Dinardo had 2 SEC West titles there to Miles' 3, and DiNardo did it in half the time!

Bill in Birmingham

December 1st, 2014 at 9:38 PM ^

Prople do not want to hear the point you are making about Louisiana recruiting, but it is dead on. Most of those kids are going to LSU, not to Les Miles U. Between that and oversigning, cutting players and pulling scholarship offers to recruits who have accepted them, I do not think he is the right choice.

Brodie

December 1st, 2014 at 5:46 PM ^

You say this like LSU is at some kind of disadvantage to those schools. He's like Lloyd Carr there... sure he wins a lot, just never enough and he has all the talent and resources in the world.

Why don't you look into LSU fans' opinions on Les. They don't have the same rosy vision of a guy who's only made three BCS bowls in a decade while sending half his rosters to the NFL

Gobgoblue

December 1st, 2014 at 4:34 PM ^

The SEC West is brutal.  Since 2007, only 2008 Florida was the only team that caused an SEC West team to miss the National Championship game.  Every other year had one, and of course, LSU and Alabama were in it one year.  

Miles has had a great run at LSU, despite being in the best division of college football.  

Surveillance Doe

December 1st, 2014 at 2:59 PM ^

This shouldn't even be a question. One guy wins 80% of his games coaching in the SEC and has won a national championship. The other guy has accomplished what?

If Les Miles wasn't connected to Michigan, and there were rumors floating that there might be mutual interest, everyone on this board would be 100% behind it. I cannot understand the anti-Miles crowd. Even the argument that he won't have his fertile Louisiana recruiting ground is silly. Michigan has no trouble reeling in talent.

1464

December 1st, 2014 at 3:25 PM ^

You can't understand why there would be resistance to a guy who ate both boogers and grass on television?

I can't understand why you can't understand that.  Those of us against Miles are against him due to the fact we think he is an overgrown 5 year old who somehow has made a name for himself at LSU, but wouldn't be able to get lightning to strike a second time in Ann Arbor.

Aero01

December 1st, 2014 at 3:42 PM ^

As part of the anti-Miles crowd, my reason is that he seems like a sleazy guy:

1) he informed an incoming freshman that he was pulling his scholarship after the kid had moved into his dorm. This wasn't a discipline thing, it was an oversigning thing.

2) Rumor has it he allegedly, kinda, maybe banged Moeller's wife.

2 may or may not be true, but 1 is enough for me to not want him.




Sent from MGoBlog HD for iPhone & iPad

not TOM BRADY

December 1st, 2014 at 3:03 PM ^

I think Harbaugh still could come here. Over the past 2 days I've heard the media say. He is interested in michigan. He is going to the raiders. He is going to the jets. He could sign an extension with the 49ers. None of the these reports match up. I think it's safe to assume Harbaugh isn't talking to anyone who is talking.

ShadowStorm33

December 1st, 2014 at 3:20 PM ^

Harbaugh isn't going to the Raiders. Their management is a shitshow, and I'm confident Jim learned his lesson in SF about the importance of management given his style. The same goes for the Bears. The Jets or Giants are a possibility; their management might be better suited for him. Still, it's hard not to see the issue with the players repeating itself in a few years. That's not confined to the 49ers; the players are going to be divas at any NFL franchise. I just can't see Jim bouncing around the NFL every 4-5 years as his players get tired of him. It's readily apparent that he's much better suited to the college game; I just hope he recognizes that instead of trying to chase Super Bowls...

MGoGrendel

December 1st, 2014 at 4:37 PM ^

Jets will fire their GM this year - very poor drafts with him at the helm.

I liked Rob Lowe's tweet: "Please Lord, don't let the Raiders be the team moving to LA!"

To add to 'not TOM BRADY' - all those reports are floated so someone can say "told-ja"! Someone will be right, just like a blind squirrel finding a nut.



Sent from MGoBlog HD for iPhone & iPad

Needs

December 1st, 2014 at 6:16 PM ^

Harbaugh and the NYC media would be a total disaster. He's self-aware enough to know that. If he stays in the NFL, I expect it will be in a job no one is talking about because it will come open after a late season collapse. 

 

UMCoconut

December 1st, 2014 at 3:02 PM ^

I would be more interested in something like:

1. Les Miles

2. Dan Mullen

or something that has real trade-offs...but I'm way too lazy to take the 5 minutes to create that survey, so I'll stick to useless commentary instead.

The_Mad Hatter

December 1st, 2014 at 3:04 PM ^

This is a question?  Miles is a consistent winner with a NC ring.  Schiano has done what exactly?

I'll never be able to understand the anti-Miles sentiments here.  Is there a long line of NC winning coaches waiting to coach at Michigan that I'm not aware of?

He's still our 2nd best option after Harbaugh (either one).

bj-ask you

December 1st, 2014 at 3:07 PM ^

Definitely Les Miles. However I am bracing myself for the worst. . . kind of like getting ready to have drinks with Bill Cosby.