Wings fan here.
Pittsburg ices as much talent as any team in the league. Crosby and Malkin have both taken their game to another level this year. Fluery(sp) is an incredible talent in net. If this years final turns out to be a rematch I can honestly say I don't know who would win. Emotions would be running high. Hossa would be the focus whether he wins or loses. If he wins and against his old team, it would turn the screw a little tighter. If he loses...then every fan of the Pens can taunt him with "HAAAA! you picked the wrong team to win a Stanley Cup with. Dumass!"
A rematch would be intense. For me, comparable to the intensity of the 97' WCF.