Lacrosse Wrapup: Oregon

Submitted by Tim on
laxlogo.gif

Weekend Wrap

The Wolverines faced some of the greatest adversity they've experienced all season, but managed to emerge from their game against Oregon with their 46-game win streak intact. The Ducks didn't go down without a fight, however, pushing the game to overtime before a Trevor Yealy goal gave Michigan a 5-4 victory.

The scene was Dallas for the 2010 Patriot Cup, benefitting the Wounded Warrior Project. The MCLA matchup between #1 Michigan and #7 Oregon was the headlining event of the weeklong, 18-game Patriot Cup. The weather, however, didn't get the memo, and the teams had to play through cold temperatures, snow, and high winds. It's understandable, considering the conditions, how low-scoring the game turned out to be.

The game never turned strongly in favor of either team, as the Ducks got on board first, but senior Jamie Goldberg scored for Michigan to tie the game up at the end of the first quarter. Svet Tintchev added a tally of his own shortly before halftime, and Michigan went into the locker room with a slim 2-1 lead. Michigan got third-quarter goals from junior Trevor Yealy and senior Josh Ein, and Oregon notched one of their own to make the margin 4-3 in favor of the Wolverines heading to the fourth. The quarter nearly passed scoreless, but Oregon managed to force the extra frame with just seconds left. In overtime, however, Michigan forced a turnover and Trevor Yealy buried the game-winner for the 5-4 victory.

Mark Stone got the start in net, and finished with nine saves. Faceoff specialist David Reinhard won 7 of his 12 draws, a somewhat subpar result given his exceptional play thus far in the season. Yealy was the only multi-goal scorer, but Jamie Goldeberg and Anthony Hrusovsky each tallied two points.

(Official site recap)

Moregonlax.jpg

Based on reports (and the @UmichLacrosse Twitter feed), both teams played sloppy, which is understandable given the conditions. However, the season will come to a point where the sloppy play (which happened in much better conditions on the Arizona/BYU road trip) has to be attributed to the team not being quite as dominant as they were last year. Who knows if that will eventually cost them a game.

Up Next

minnesota_duluth_96.pngMichigan will have its second consecutive one-game weekend, as this time they'll travel to Milwaukee to take on Minnesota-Duluth on Saturday. The Bulldogs were ranked #6 in last week's Prodigy Poll, and are the owners of a 6-1 record. Their one defeat came at Arizona State, where Michigan managed to pull out an 11-10 victory. Other than that, the strength of schedule is questionable, as they've defeated horrible Saint Cloud State (pounded by Eastern MIchigan!), unranked MSU-Mankato, Central Michigan, and Wisconsin Milwaukee, and fringe top-20 teams in Lindenwood and Cal. They've lost to the only competition they've played that's even close to Michigan's level.

minnesota_duluth_96.pngOffensively, Duluth is led by sophomore attack Alex McNamara, who averages 3.6 goals and 1.6 assists per game, and senior middie Daniel Pitzl (a 2009 2nd-Team All-American), who adds 2.6 goals and 1.4 assists of his own. Sophomores Drake Peterson and redshirt sophomore Kevin Gaydos also average more than three points in each contest. Benjamin Shandley and Andrew Madsen are both very good faceoff specialist, winning over 70% on the year, so there should be some entertaining battles with Michigan's David Reinhard. Redshirt sophomore Joey Slattery is the #1 goalie, allowing 3.2 goals per game, and saving just over 70% of shots faced.

minnesota_duluth_96.pngThe game is being played at a neutral site (Marquette University in Milwaukee, WI), and weather shouldn't play a huge factor, as it's projected to be in the mid-40s and sunny on Saturday. I encourage all MIchigan fans (and especially lacrosse fans) in the Milwaukee, CHicago, and Madison areas to make the trek out to see a championship-caliber Wolverine squad take on a ranked opponent.

Beating The Varsity Drum

It's no secret that the Michigan Lacrosse team very much wants to earn varsity status from the Athletic Department (and I've made it no secret that I support such a move). I asked a former Michigan Lacrosse player a few questions about why the team deserves to be a varsity sport, and how this should happen. Greatest hits:

On why the Michigan Lacrosse team deserves varsity status:

If you want to know what makes them worthy, the short answer is that they have already gotten most of the way there without varsity status, and now want a chance to be the best of the best. What more can you ask for in sports besides a shot at being the best?
What makes this situation unique is the fact that the organizational structure currently in place is a highly capable group, and has been operating as a “virtual varsity” program for many years now. When varsity teams are added to any university, a typical process would be to hire the staff a year or two ahead of the target inaugural season for planning and recruiting purposes. This team is good to go tomorrow given the chance.

...Which provides a perfect segue into how long it would take for the team to be competitive on the D-1 level, should they be promoted:

There are several reasons that the transition to varsity competition will be much smoother for Michigan than some might think. First of all, the current club team has beaten several Division I programs in exhibition play. The current talent on the team consists of more than a handful of players that either turned down the chance to play for Division I teams to come to Michigan, or would be significant contributors in a Division I program. Another reason is the number of students from the east coast that come to Michigan. Even though the sport is growing across the country, the bulk of blue chip recruits still come from Atlantic states like New York and Maryland. The Michigan brand already draws a relatively large percentage of the student body from these areas, which would enable the rapid expansion of the team’s recruiting footprint into traditional hotbeds. Finally, the planned facilities featured in an earlier post would be bar none the best in the country.

He also points out that the infallible Transitive Rule of Sports Victory show MIchigan has beaten opponents in the past several years that have gone on to make the NCAA tournament in subsequent years, or themselves beaten an opponent that ultimately made the tournament. Assuming a boost from moving up to the D-1 level, they could step in and be competitive right away.

The final question I asked regarded why now is the right time for the team to earn varsity status, when it hasn't been for the past several years:

[T]he program has reached critical mass at the club level. While there are still many good teams in the MCLA, Michigan has asserted its dominance over the past several years and now only plays a few competitive games each season. In order to find good competition, the team has to travel to places like California, Utah, and Arizona, which is not easy to pull off on a club budget. The truth is that the current level of operations is only made possible by the level of private support that the team receives, which is not sustainable in the long run nor worthwhile if the team is never elevated to varsity status.

The change in athletic director played a role in spawning the effort by providing a timeline for taking a proposal to the university. When Bill Martin announced his retirement, Coach Paul initiated several conversations about what we would need to do to ensure that lacrosse was on the new athletic director’s agenda from day one. Unfortunately, our departing AD was not a supporter of elevating lacrosse to NCAA Division I during his tenure.

It seems as though positive steps are being taken toward varsity status, something that certainly sounds long overdue. The change in AD seems to be a major benefit, if only because there's at least the chance he's listening. David Brandon can do no wrong, man. So far, he's been a home run pick.

In the name of this post running too long, I'll cut off the varsity talk there this week, but make no mistake, I'll be hitting this topic in nearly every update.

Women!

The men aren't Michigan's only club lacrosse team, as the women's club team has the coveted "Varsity Club" distinction as well. While they haven't reached the same level of success as the men (but who has, really? Penn State club hockey?), they are a strong program in their own right. If a varsity push for the men's lacrosse team happens, it's likely that the women's lacrosse squad might be the program promoted at the same time, to satisfy Title IX requirements.

The women earned a 3-game sweep over the weekend, beating Michigan State 12-2, Pitt 13-10, and Miami (Not That Miami Unless You're Talking About Hockey, In Which Case Yes That Miami) 18-10. Thanks to their media contact Stuart Zaas for keeping me updated, and if you're interested in learning more about the women's lacrosse team, check out their website.

Comments

phjhu89

March 22nd, 2010 at 12:07 PM ^

Tim - thanks for not only including game reports, but also program updates. Sounds like they would have had much better weather playing here, even on Elbel field. Weather can be a truly nasty equalizer for lax! Your source makes a lot of sense re: transition to D1. Those who are making the argument to The Powers That Be need to also emphasize that there is a narrow window here to enter D1 and be quite successful from the outset. Here's why: The explosion in High School lax means much more talent to go around - we are seeing the effect this season in the success of programs like Drexel, Stony Brook, and Lafayette (there are more who are having great seasons, but these three stand out as teams that have had no access to the dance, but are seriously threatening this year.) Michigan needs to get in on this trend NOW, while they would still be able to out-recruit some of these newly successful programs. If Michigan waits too long, schools like I named above will become more and more attractive, as they develop history and tradition, and by the time Michigan got into the game they would have to recruit not only against the old powers, but new powers as well. Things are really moving around right now - look at the current D1 coaches poll - Lafayette in the top 10, Drexel knocking on the door, Hopkins out of the top 10 for only the 13th time since 1973. 'Cuse and UVa are still favorites to win it all this year, but there are new players making noise. Michigan should be one of them.

TG7782

March 22nd, 2010 at 12:08 PM ^

As always thanks for keeping us lax fans up to date with all the goings on regarding their games and the topic of being a varsity sport.

weasel3216

March 22nd, 2010 at 12:25 PM ^

I was looking at the stats from this past weekend and Michigan was pretty dominate in all stats. From Laxpower article on the game, "U-M outshot the Ducks 41-26, and scooped up 46 groundballs compared to 22 by U-O. U-M was 7 of 12 on faceoffs, and cleared the ball at a of 21-30 while riding Oregon to 16-27 totals." The number that really stood out to me was the shots and ground-balls (GB). I know the game was played in horrible conditions so this just makes this differential even more impressive. At first i kind of freaked out that we only one by one in OT, but after thinking about the weather conditions and the fact that Oregon is a very good team i really saw this game as a huge relief for the team. I would much rather have a very close game in the regular season than face such adversary in the MCLA tourney. I am also glad to see that Michigan is still able to win defensive battles. Not sure how many of you are familiar with lacrosse, but Michigan scoring 20 goals a game is not a typical event to happen in lacrosse. Most games are played around 8-12 goals/team. Michigan has been scoring well above this level for the past few seasons that we have not really seen how good our defense truly is, we know they are good but we have not seen how good they really are until they play a 5-4 game. When we are able to pull out at low scoring win it really makes me feel confident in our defense and goalkeeping. I think the player you talked to brought up some goods points, some good points that we have been throwing around the last few years really. But i really agree with the competition point. Michigan will not have the funding to continue their competitive schedule without the jump to Varsity. Private donors would like to see advancements in the program rather than just Michigan dominating the same teams year in and year out. I believe a jump to Varsity will be the only way we will ever see anymore improvement out of the program, the have shown their dominance of the MCLA and therefore there is no room for improvement at this current level.

phjhu89

March 22nd, 2010 at 4:34 PM ^

If Michigan were a varsity program, they wouldn't be spending nearly as much on travel - the ridiculous travel schedule they need to have just so they can get a little competition would disappear with a varsity program. They would actually play fewer games/year, and while they would still have to fly more than a mid-Atlantic school, costs would be far less than now. I can't believe that the donors the team currently have really want to be funding airplane trips rather than scholarships!

L'Carpetron Do…

March 22nd, 2010 at 6:14 PM ^

You're right. I've been thinking about this lately. If Michigan were to play a D-1 schedule they would probably travel much less. They could take bus trips to places like ND, Ohio State, Penn State, Butler, Detroit Mercy and Bellarmine (I'm sure there are more teams in the region I can't think of). They can probably even bus to Syracuse. We used to bus to Bloomington and Champagn, play and come back the same day. Then, they can do what they have always done: take a spring break trip and play 3 or 4 games. However, the trip will be to the east coast to NY/NJ and DC. I would love to see Michigan field a Division 1 team WITHOUT scholarships, even just for a year or two. I think they would still be able to compete. Keep in mind that most lacrosse players, even at the big schools don't get scholarships, much less full scholarships. Michigan has an academic edge and overall reputation that surpasses most schools currently in Division 1. It's only a matter of time. But, Michigan is ready now.

phjhu89

March 22nd, 2010 at 6:49 PM ^

While it is fair to say that Michigan's academic rep surpasses most of the programs in some of the auto-bid conferences, the powers of the sport have academic reputations equal to or better than Michigan's. Schools with academic reputations better than Michigan have those 12.6 scholarships! Of course, Princeton and Cornell are doing it without scholarships. I think that point is moot, however, as I seriously doubt that Michigan would ever field a varsity team that is not fully funded. Going not fully funded is a MAAC sort of thing to do - not the way of a Big Ten school.

weasel3216

March 22nd, 2010 at 8:32 PM ^

I am not sure Michigan could hold their own without scholarships. Schools like John Hopkins, Maryland, North Carolina, and Syracuse are just filled with talent, talent that will be in the MLL and NLL in the future. If Michigan was to field a D1 team without scholarships then i think that they could hold their own, if not win, with the lower tier of D1 teams such as Detroit Mercy, Wagner, and VMI. I would be interested in seeing us compete against the middle tier teams like Ohio State (think we scrimmaged a few years ago), UMass, and Air Force.

Search4Meaning

March 22nd, 2010 at 11:58 PM ^

Walk before you run. I Michigan would go Varsity D-1, it would most likely start without scholarships. It is a huge jump from club to even mid-level D-1. Michigan would be at a disadvantage immediately. However, like many other varsity sports, supporters would be found to fund scholarships - it just takes time. The larger question is how would this affect Title IX? I believe that Michigan would need to move a Women's team to the Varsity status, or expanding athletic openings for women's participation. This then becomes an larger economic issue. All that being said, I would like to see Varsity Lacrosse at Michigan.

phjhu89

March 23rd, 2010 at 1:12 AM ^

field a varsity team in any sport that was not fully funded. Going D1 for lax when only partially funded is a path that a number of MAAC schools have taken (as well as a few other similar, non-football schools). These schools just don't have anything close to the resources of a school like Michigan, and did not have much of a choice but to only partially fund their lax programs. In fact, Michigan's club team already has more paid coaches on their staff than some of these partially funded D1 teams had when they went varsity. I just don't see partial funding of any varsity program being Michigan's style!

weasel3216

March 22nd, 2010 at 8:25 PM ^

I know that was my point, i guess i did not phrase it clearly. I was saying that private donors don't want to keep spending their money on a program that cannot get any better. Private donors would much rather spend their money on scholarships and travel to send Michigan out east as a Varsity program. They would much rather invest their money in program that was trying to gin something than a team just trying to keep at the top. I would also assume that private donors also get some enjoyment out of the knowledge that they are getting a student athlete one of the best educations in the world.

kw_hanna

March 23rd, 2010 at 2:16 AM ^

Anyone headed to Boulder or Fort Collins. I'm an alum living in Wyoming and am headed down to at least the CSU game on the 11th. Any tailgating going on? Maybe peeps from Denver looking to head north? Also will be in Commerce City for the championships, so we'll see you at LoDo's!

Old Blue

March 23rd, 2010 at 11:10 AM ^

Detroit Mercy just got their first win as a D1 program in their second year of existence. I agree with all that the time is now. I only hope that DB sees it that way as well. I truly see lacrosse growing at Michigan to at least the level of baseball and possibly even approaching hockey's status as a 2nd tier sport, just below football and basketball. There is a tremendous opportunity right now, and it sounds like the transition could be fairly painless given the success and organizational capabilities of the club team. I'm not saying this is a final four team right away, but certainly the team could compete at a fairly high level if given full support, including scholarships. Tim, Any chance we'll see lacrosse postings on the main page of the blog? There seems to be interest. Thanks for keeping the message out there.

Tim

March 23rd, 2010 at 12:11 PM ^

Tim, Any chance we'll see lacrosse postings on the main page of the blog? There seems to be interest. Thanks for keeping the message out there. Talk to Brian about it. He's not interested.