Greg Robinson: A review

Submitted by Anonymous Coward (not verified) on
I have no idea if Greg Robinson is a serious candidate for the DC job, but some people seem to take him as one. Many claim that "his resume as a DC is excellent" and point out that "just because he wasn't a good HC, doesn't mean he won't be a good DC". Lets look at those two claims First, his resume (omitting time as an OC previously): 1 Year with the Jets. Defense ranked 14th in PPG. 6 Years in Denver w/ defenses ranked 17th, 7th, 6th, 6th, 11th, 23rd 3 Years in Kansas City, when their defense was the laughing stock of the NFL - ranked 23rd, 28th, 20th, and he was fired. 1 Year at University of Texas, where he posted decent numbers (28th ranked defense nationally) against a weak schedule (they played 2 teams that finished the season ranked). While Robinson did win 2 Super Bowls in Denver, his overall resume is what I would refer to as "checkered", and at no point has he coached a defense that could be referred to as "elite". Second, while the DC job and HC job require different skill-sets, there are some commonalities - like recruiting. He's demonstrated no ability to recruit at Syracuse (which, for the most part, never fared any worse than the rest of the Big East), and has begun to lose 2-star recruits to FCS schools. Finally, I don't think we should completely throw out his tenure as a head coach, as it was an epic disaster. Syracuse had 13 non-losing seasons in 14 years before his arrival, and had gone to 12 bowls in that time, including the BCS. Upon his arrival, Robinson turned a 6-6 team that returned 17 players into a 1-11 team. In the next 3 years he would reach a high-water mark of 4-8. This just isn't a "strong" resume. The peak of his career occurred 10 years ago, and it wasn't that staggering of a peak. Since that time, he has been associated with 2 staggering failures (the KC defense, and Syracuse). I know nothing of his X's and O's, and would be unqualified to comment on them, but this guy doesn't seem like "The" guy.

Comments

Ernis

January 20th, 2009 at 6:56 PM ^

One thing I would like to point out in regards to some of the splotches on GR's resume is simple, intuitive, yet often elusive to one's spontaneous sensibilities. Failure can be the best learning experience. And those low points in his career, including his job at Syracuse, are pretty durn appealing to me. He's bringing a real wealth of knowledge to the program. How that will translate onto the field is, right now, anyone's guess; but the future looks bright from where I'm standing.

Philly44

January 22nd, 2009 at 7:10 PM ^

First, my resume. SU BS '87, UM MHSA '92. Yes, I bleed Orange first and foremost, but I AM a Wolverine in every sense of the word. My assessment. GRob is a buffoon. Not only can't he recruit (immaterial now true, but of importance in the sense that he can't CONNECT with college kids, or so it appears), but his FAILURE to make half-time adjustments cost 'Cuse at least a dozen games during his tenure. Not alot by UM (historic) standards, but when you were sucking as much as SU was (is?), a dozen in 4 years goes a long way. No tactician, no strategist this man. The only enjoyment we got from him was his twisted syntax during interviews. This Orange Wolverine thought he had seen the last of Greggers. Alas...fate has dealt me one shitty hand.