From great, to good. Is Urban Meyer losing prestige? Why the Buckeyes need to win the Big Ten.

Submitted by Brandon_L on
On the eve of the Big Ten Championship I find myself thinking about the Big Ten conference, and all its wonderful mediocrity over the last decade in football. The Buckeyes have dominated the conference. They have won either a share, or an outright conference title six times since 2002. All six of these titles are Jim Tressel coached teams. During the tress era, Ohio State football competed against better competition than the Current Buckeyes have seen. For example, the Buckeyes won the Big Ten title five consecutive times from 2005-2009. After evaluating their strength of schedule on (http://www.teamrankings.com), the average strength of schedule from 2005-2009 was eleventh. Tress's Buckeyes had only one year that they faced a strength of schedule out side the top ten and that was in his last season at the helm. So how about Urban's Bucks? Since Urban has taken over the Buckeyes they have sleep walked through the regular season only losing three games in three years. They have dominated Big Ten regular season play, but they have nothing to show for their efforts other than Rings that were provided by the athletic department in 2012. Everyone gets a trophy right Urbz? (http://www.cleveland.com/osu/index.ssf/2013/04/ohio_state_buckeyes_get_rings.html), yes they got rings the year they went 12-0, and were on probation. Now how does Urbz Bucks, compare to Tress's dominate version? Lets compare strength of schedule. From 2012 to current the Buckeyes average strength of schedule is thirty second. This season it is forty second and dropping. Last year was the anomaly as the schedule strength beefed up to 21st because of Sparty, and Clemson. The two biggest test of the Urban Meyer era at Ohio State were failures. This year was supposed to be different. Then the unexpected happens with Braxton Miller's injured shoulder, then they tripped over themselves vs. Va Tech at home, but out of nowhere J.T. Barrett develops and makes a run for the Heisman breaking records along the way. Then tragedy struck when Barrett broke his ankle against Michigan, and is now done for the season. Here comes Cardale (I ain't here to play school) Jones. Hopefully he lives up to his famous tweet (see the link for entertaining reminder), (http://m.espn.go.com/ncf/story?storyId=8466428&src=desktop). If he truly is only at Ohio State to play football he should be prepared for the biggest game of his life and of the Urban Meyer era.At least the Buckeye faithful hope so. This Big Ten Title game is important on so many levels for Urban Meyer, who did not receive a contract extension for his performance thus far. It's been three years of falling short for some reason, or another. You had probation in 2012, the best Michigan State football team in its history in 2013, and now you are down to your third string QB, and are facing a Classic pound the football, play action Wisconsin football team. The Buckeyes should honestly be favored in this game. why should they be favored you ask? The reason I feel they should be favored is that the Badgers have fed off of a weaker schedule than the Buckeyes this year ranking at number fifty three in the nation. Wisky did nearly beat LSU to open the year, but eventually were exposed for what they are, a one dimensional football team. Joel Stave would be fourth on the Buckeyes depth chart. Melvin Gordon is the centerpiece of the Badger attack, and with a big game he could win the Heisman. The Buckeyes will certainly key on Gordon Saturday Night. If the Buckeyes struggle to stop Gordon, Wisky will play keep away all night. This will be the plan for Wisconsin and I think the plan can work. But Urban needs this one desperately. I had made a comment back in 2012 that Urban would not win a Big Ten Title before Brady Hoke. If the Badgers win I will be partially right about my guarantee from 2012. Hoke will obviously never win a BIg Ten Title, but I'm going to hedge my bet, and say that if Urban doesn't win this game Saturday, whoever coaches Michigan Next, (Insert the many Names here), will still win a title before Urban Meyer. So Urban, how important is this game to you? The Buckeyes are always so focused on National titles, but the truth of the matter is you have to win the Big Ten Title, and let the rest take care of itself. A Buckeye loss on Saturday means it was all for nothing again. Urban as of now remains the second best college coach next to Saban, but a loss on Saturday will prove Urban is just a good coach at this point, not a great coach, and the conversation of whether he can still win the big game at the highest level will become the topic of conversation in Columbus, and on the national level. A win will almost certainly get the Buckeyes in the College Football final four, and Gene Smith can finally extend Urban Meyer's contract because they actually won something.

Comments

Perkis-Size Me

December 6th, 2014 at 11:59 AM ^

You're outside your mind. Unless we grab Harbaugh, there's no way Michigan wins a Big Ten Title before Meyer does. And even with Harbaugh we never really know. We've got to clean up our dumpster fire first before we can even start remotely thinking about Big Ten titles.

I don't think people are really going to be complaining too much about Meyer if he can't win a conference title this year. They would've won it easily in 2012, lost a tough game last year to what is arguably the best team MSU has ever had, and have gotten honestly the worst luck with its QBs this year in terms of injuries. And yet, there they are in the title game for what should be the 3rd year in a row.

Meyer won't need a win tonight to legitimize himself. He's down to playing with a 3rd string QB after both of his starters have gone down with injuries. Both of whom have set multiple records at OSU. If Miller or Barrett were playing tonight and they lost, he'd probably get some flak about whether or not he'll ever get back to the level he was at with Florida. But I think unless they get blown out by Wisconsin tonight, I think he gets a free pass with whatever happens.

JTrain

December 6th, 2014 at 1:07 PM ^

As much as I say I hate urban for how he handled Florida, quit on his team, ran from Saban, sleezy recruiting tactics...etc., the guy is a great coach. A great game planner. A great evaluator and developer of talent. The other thing that really impresses me is how he handles himself on TV. I loved Brady Hoke, but let's face it...the guy didn't really do himself any favors in the eye of the public. I can appreciate Brady's meat head personality and responses at times but I'd rather have a guy like urban at press conferences dealing with shit in a more "sharp" or "concise" manner.
The smokescreen shot with Brady got old. Just say what it is and move on.
I don't see urban Meyer going anywhere anytime soon. Who's better than him for Ohio? Has he even lost a freekin' regular season conference game yet???

OccaM

December 7th, 2014 at 4:59 AM ^

I posted earlier that Urban Meyer just had a few bad breaks at his tenure at OSU... looks like I was right. 

It's OSU and everyone else in the B1G. Not even close... 

I was kind enough in the first post, but here's what I really think of your analysis. 

It's fucking stupid, and you should feel stupid for even writing such a stupid thing. 

Wake me up when we hire Greg Schiano for some fucking dumb reason b/c I got season tickets to cancel. 

Harbaugh/Stoops would be a godsend, but Michigan hasn't had that type of luck since 2003. Meanwhile in Columbus, Urban Meyer falls into OSU's lap. 

Fuck everything. 

You Only Live Twice

December 7th, 2014 at 9:34 AM ^

I wanted OSU to lose but it does make us our performance at the horseshoe look even better.  And, it brought home that Dantonio is no Meyer.

We need Harbaugh!

User -not THAT user

December 7th, 2014 at 2:57 PM ^

the worst thing written in the history of the English language, let alone sports blogging.

However, 59-0 and a berth in the playoffs should soothe your concern over poor Urbz somewhat.  Aaaaaaaaaand of course that strengthens further a recruiting advantage that he has over every other school in the damned conference since his health miraculously improved to the point of his feeling up to the challenge of taking the job in C-bus, as well.

Good lord, man.

Wmonette

December 7th, 2014 at 10:32 PM ^

Two national title rings... He must suck. /s

 

He didn't need to paste Wisky for me to think Ohio State hit a massive home-run with Urban Meyer. There are a couple of bucks here in graduate school with me and they are literally the happiest I have seen them since their National Title run. 

 

It just makes me want nice things...

Mo Better Blues

December 11th, 2014 at 11:37 AM ^

All I can say is that performance by the Buckeyes the other night, much as it pains me, is among the most remarkable things I've ever seen on a football field. A clinic. At full strength, that would have been impressive, but with a 3rd Stringer? Hat tip to you, Brutus. Credit where credit is due.