We need a new banner.
i like 'em both
The last few months and particularly the last few days have been stressful for the average Michigan fan. As the creator and primary contributor of MGoBlog you lived and breathed every twist and turn of the coaching change so I can only imagine what it has been like for you. Your passion and frustration about what has transpired is undeniable.
Few if any of us are completely satisfied with the process that lead to the hiring of our new coach. Some have said that the players have gone through a grieving process since Coach Rodriguez was let go - it stands to reason that we, the fans of Michigan football, would do the same. No matter what our individual opinions are of Rich Rodriguez and his staff there is no debate that they gave maximum effort to build a winning football team. We need to honor them by reminding people of the positives and not dwelling on the negatives.
I respect your honestly and integrity in reporting the full story of the coaching change - please keep it up. However, based on public comments from some players today it sounds like they are turning the page and are prepared to embrace their new coach. I'm hoping you will continue to lead the MGoCommunity in that direction as well. If we want Michigan football to succeed in the near term Brady Hoke needs our support.
Thanks again for creating MGoBlog,
We need a new banner.
To wage a war like the Freep.
Actually, I don't know a thing about him.
Hey, that was quick...telepathic!
Not a fan. I dearly appreciate Brian's opinions on things.... but holy crap man, get a grip. You've got a big pile of data. Form your own conclusions. Don't beg someone else to make decisions for you.
I feel like brian (all the mgowriters really) do this anyway. Of course they'll have opinions on whatever news comes up, but most of the content on this site is devoid of bias. Like one post said before, regardless of who the coach is, we all want michigan to win (unlike FREEP etc)
(okay, there's a slight maize and blue tint of bias but whatever)
We need Brian, DG, Magnus, Zone, aaa, VH, Don, Profit, etc...to lead the way. For the most part (not everybody) people seem to be smoking what they're rolling!
Let's keep things positive. People should be able to express their opinion, but the bashing and outright ill informed, ignorant rhetoric is detrimental to morale!
I mean, if the guy is breaking rules, locking players in closets, ignoring bad behavior etc…then by all means, go at him. But when the guy hasn’t even started and he is getting slammed, well that is just straight up, unfair.
Nice post. Thanks for reaching out. Go Blue. Go Hoke. Go Team! And here are a couple more exclamation points for DB!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
We need Brian, DG, Magnus, Zone, aaa, VH, Don, Profit, etc...to lead the way
No you don't. Feel free to form your own opinions.
you have the urge to say something negative...just throw in FreeP prior to your typed out thought! It may help a bit plus we all hate the FreeP.
Here, I'll start...FreeP sucks balls!
I appreciate that many on here supported our coach when his name was Rich Rodriguez, even though it was apparent to most people that his ship was sinking and not worth salvaging. Now our coach is named Brady Hoke, and whether he was your first choice or not even on your list, it's time to get behind him. Brian, like it or not you set a tone for a lot of youngish Michigan fans. Now's a great time to set the tone that we fully support our coach. If he goes 3-9 next season, you may commence bashing.
saying "Hold Me Tom VH" up there.
in an odd situation. While I'm deeply disappointed by the hire (that I knew was coming in early December; just ask my wife), I am inexplicably EXPECTING to end up loving it. Something tells me that I'll end up loving having Hoke as head coach. It may not be today, and it may not be next year, but something tells me that this WAS the right hire, and that Hoke will go down as one of the great coaches at Michigan.
what's your wife's number? And can I ask her anything else?
The more I learn about Brady Hoke, the more excited I am about him as the new head football coach at the University of Michigan. I cannot tell a lie – I struggled to get excited about him as a candidate initially and didn’t feel much elation when the announcement was made yesterday. I was relieved that the process was over, and vowed to be supportive either way, but I wasn’t really happy. It’s not that I didn’t think he was a good guy or potentially a good coach, it just felt like, after the past three years and the past few weeks in particular, we needed a bigger buzz. There was clearly some disappointment that he wasn’t Jim Harbaugh. Many were enamored at the thought of Les Miles and his 62-17 record at LSU. With Hoke, it appeared on the surface as if we were “settling”. Frankly, there was also frustration that, if Hoke was our guy, we should have hired him 24 hours after the OSU game (not three weeks before National Signing Day for the 2011 recruiting class). That is water under the bridge at this point. Nobody but Dave Brandon really knows what happened at each stage during the process – and there isn’t a truth serum on the planet that will get him to talk. However, let me say this, after seeing Brady Hoke in today’s press conference, I wouldn’t trade him for any coach in America (including Les Miles or Jim Harbaugh). I’m serious. If you didn’t see his press conference – please watch it now – in its entirety. Have a Kleenex handy – and get ready to strap on your pads! http://www.mgoblue.com/allaccess/?media=221155
I understand why the majority of fans were underwhelmed (or even concerned) initially:
So why the change of heart?
Here is the deal. Brady Hoke is facing an extraordinary set of challenges in the next few weeks – and he needs our help. We need to back this guy 100%+ with all of our maize & blue hearts. No more whining about our former coach or other candidates or this scheme or that. We have our guy and he’s going to be here a LONG time. Hopefully, as Michigan fans, you don’t need convincing. If you do, hopefully this and similar notes, articles, emails and Blogs have helped. If you are still not there – that’s too bad – suck it up. We need to make his job easier not harder. Here are just a few of the things he must do:
What can we do? Embracing this guy whole heartedly at tonight’s Michigan versus OSU basketball game would be a good start (the “Maize Rage” has it covered). Support him amongst friends, fans, websites, blogs and Twitter. Forward this note (or others like it) to Michigan graduates and fans everywhere. We can no longer tolerate differing factions. A House Divided Cannot Stand. If you remain angry about something, send a note to Dave Brandon, but don’t take it out on Brady Hoke (and certainly don’t post it for opposing coaches to use against us in recruiting). Our Athletic Director has taken some heat during this process, and initially after this hire, but nobody was more relieved than Dave Brandon during & after today’s press conference. He knows he made an outstanding hire.
p.s. My dogs are named Bo and Brady (ok, so my Brady was named after Tom, but this gives me some flexibility)… At least I don’t have to get another dog!
p.s.s. Could Jared Sullinger enter a mid-year NBA draft of some sort? He’s a beast and the Cavs could use him NOW (plus I’d rather not see him in scarlet & gray again anytime soon).
p.s.s.s. Is there is a bigger moron in the world than Drew Sharp? If so, I have no interest in ever meeting him. How does that guy still have a job?
Is that you?
i'll bet it's somebody in the AD who realizes mgoblog's influence.
... who happens to be a very BIG Michigan fan. I grew up in Clarkston. My parents haven't missed a home game in 50+ years. I live in CT and run a HF in NYC. My kids (aged 13, 11 and 9) have been brainwashed since birth. and BTW - this site DOES have influence...
I write a ~weekly email (similar to my post above) which I send to friends (surprisingly, my recipient list continues to grow). I scan the noise and distill into a detailed summary in an easy to read format. I've visited this site MANY times over the years but never posted until yesterday. I don't know Brian but appreciate the effort he puts forth to run this site. That being said, for better or worse, it's a pretty influential site and can sway the opinions of certain fans, recruits and our competition. The previous support for RR was commendable (to a point) as he was our coach. But he's no longer our coach and nothing anyone says/does is going to change that. Brady Hoke is our coach and anyone who saw the press conference or knows anything about Michigan football can see why. We are seriously lucky to have him. So, if you love Michigan football and what it stands for, it's time to embrace him whole heartedly 100%. If you can't do that, please don't do anything to sabatoge his chances. The Banner on this site is what Jon Stewart does to George Bush, not what Michigan fans do to their coach (who, by the way, is going to be here a LONG time). Someone said Brian was continuing to bad mouth Hoke on the radio today!? I have a hard time believing that but, if true, SHAME ON HIM. Shame on any Michigan fan who is trying to create yet another division. Brian backed himself into a corner by foolishly going ballistic on a guy who was a serious candidate to be our next coach (and has become our coach). I'm willing to forgive and forget - it's time to move forward. I'm not telling anyone how to think, but I'm asking people to be less spiteful to a guy who has been on the job for less than 24 hours. Another life lesson from kindergarten "If you can't say something nice, don't say it all". Or, at a minimum, please don't post it on Michigan website.
I haven't seen Jason Whitlock kiss so much ass since the last time I heard him go off about Jeff George! Good to see that he's behind our coach though!
Might be appropriate after a season of utter failure but right now it comes across as bitter and childish. But it's your blog, and if you don't want to play nice with the new kid that's obviously your right. my F5 key still won't be getting much rest (sidenote: it's also been to 5 cities in 6 days)
He can follow, or get the fuck out of the way. It's all good.
you need to calm down.
If he wants to take his ball and go home. He can come around eventually, and follow everyone else, and support the program. Or he can not, be passive-aggressive hostile, and be a detriment to Michigan Football. It's his readership, his call whether he thinks that will increase or decrease his hits. He's entitled to his opinion, and has a forum to print it. I just think it's silly that Brian has to think for us. And if his "leading" is going to consist of Emo whining, that's not the kind of "leadership" we need. I mean, when your buddies like JamieMac are calling you out, maybe it's time to take a second look.
But I actually like Brian's unmitigated fandom. Whether you like it or not, people want to know what he thinks, and its refreshing to me that he's not bashful about expressing his disappointment. I relate to that 100% and others do, too. There's nothing wrong with that.
I think he's been much less unbalanced than you give him credit for. Yes, he's been off-center, but I don't mind that. I can make my own mind up, even though you've accused me of not being able to in the past.
Whether you approve or not, Brian's voice has its own gravity in ways that yours can not and, no offense intended, will not. Every time I hear "blogs" in the context of Michigan football, I think of mgoblog and Brian Cook. Dude has built a brand out of nothing with no apparent overt marketing to begin with. That's no small potatoes, man.
Brian's opinions are heard nationally, and he represents the Michigan fanbase to a large degree. OP's just asking him to bring it around a little more cleanly. Making the OP, and anyone who respects Brian's opinions, out to be sheep is bullshit.
Cry about where we are, complain about the process. But the childish jabs at Hoke (be basically characterized him as a chubby tickle me elmo doll today) doesn't do him or anyone else any good. He's welcome to give us more data and charts about how awful it going to be after 3 years of charts on how great it's going to be.
And my opinion may not mean much as much as Brian's, and it's nice he's cited on ESPN or whatever, but if he really had that much influence, We wouldn't be going through this coaching chance. So there are limits off this site (you think of blogs, you think of MGoBlog....most people think of blogs, and they go...huh? What's that?)
And really, it could be an interesting take if it continues. He has built a wonderful business for himself by being an innovator. I'm just curious how a college football blog negative about the team works. I mean, if it's like this in JANUARY, it should be fun after we lose our first game...
Again, I see where you're coming from. That's fine. But you're whipping yourself (and others) into a frenzy that just isn't necessary. Brian hates subversive douche-bags. I doubt that he would turn into one. Calm down.
As for the coaching change, only one opinion actually matters; David Brandon's. That says nothing of people's interest in other people's opinion; namely Brian in this case. Anyway, he's a big boy. I don't need to defend him.
about making a list of people consistently negative about hoke, who seemed like they would not stop hating him until he was gone because he is not rr, and brian seems like he would have needed to have been on the list. It's time to suck it up and see if hoke can be successful, even if rr was fired a little prematurely.
where Brian was coming from RE BH three years ago (last search).
BH has won a few more games than he lost in the years since, but not enough to lead us to expect Brian to do a 180.
I don't know what you're looking for from Brian, but if it's political correctness, I don't think that's how he built the site in the first place.
Maybe the old saying "lead, follow, or get the fuck out of the way" seemed unnecessarily hostile. I thought it was more cliche'.
but it's your overall tenor for a long stretch of time (call it a month). I don't have beef with speaking your mind or whatever, but you've been kind of a jerk about it. Just two cents from some dude on the internet to some other dude on the internet.
Hoke is the guy, deal with it. [insert GIF here].
He wasn't my second choice (Harbaugh, everyone else) but I believe he was Brandon's. His ascension to the job clearly communicates what DB's priorities were when assessing candidates. That's his job; I'm over it.
Given those assumed priorities, Hoke is the right hire. I was dreading trying to muster the wherewithal to root for Les Miles and I'm grateful that I don't have to even though I would have made a good faith effort to do so.
My only question was, I think I'm over it now, why did it take so long for Brandon to make this announcement? After JH took the SF job, Hoke could've been announced the same day with, I think, more credibility with respect to the process. Everything that happened since JH bolted seems like a charade. That's limp.
None of that mattes anymore. Welcome, Coach Hoke. Now, let's strike down upon these mother-fuckers... ALL of them.
P.S. - Cosign, the banner thing. The tabloid flavor was excellent during the situation, but the situation has lapsed.
Everyone needs to sack up. Women included.
these balls swing kung fu
I think Brian is supporting him, but like me, he is skeptical and will remain so until proven wrong. Unfortunately that may take some time to see if he and I are either right or wrong.
I tend to agree. I expected to see a lot harsher things from Brian today than was posted. I took the lack of profanity laden tirades to be an indicator that he's accepted it's happened and will at least give him a chance to look like a viable coach.
to be bad in the character department; turns out that was MSM garbage. He put the kids first, often at the peril of W's. He took his community responsibilities to heart.
When he was fired, one of the things I was least looking forward to was hearing the MSM whitewash the iffy character of Harbaugh or Miles in order to buff the "return to self" meme after wrongly slandering RR for three years. It didn't happen, but I still get acid reflux thinking about it.
There is nothing to detest about BH. M is still holding out against the wholesale surrender to soul-less commercialism in CFB while he is around. I'm not affirmatively excited about the hire or the process that led to it (including dumping RR in the midst of a major rebuild, botched in many ways, but moving forward). But I'm not having to fight to swallow down anxieties about the character or concern for the kids in the new HC, or watch those who slandered the last coach whitewash the next one. In terms of integrity and concern for others, BH is in what I still think of as the M tradition.
If he should turn out a winner as well, I'll get positively excited then. Meanwhile, I'm glad I don't have to defend JH or LM. I'd rather have BH; in the character department, he's not a step down from RR.
Brian has his opinions, I have mine. They often tend to be coincidental, but not always. As long as I can freely express my opinion on this blog, and there is absolutely not one iota of anything to the contrary that I cannot, that is fine. If Brian is negative, will that impact recruiting? I don't know, but it is a concern that shouldn't be taken lightly.
As the very lengthy comment earlier in this thread noted, I found my feelings for Hoke changing massively during the presser. At the beginning, he sounded weak and unpolished, but by the end, it was impossible to not be caught up in the honest emotion that he conveyed. As for his love of the program, I never once felt that same emotion from Richrod, not once.
...he answered the question about "what will be his greatest challenge?". Instead of the standard coachspeak pap, he paused and then said (paraphrasing):
Nothing - I have to do X, Y and Z, but those things aren't challenges, they are my job and I love doing them, and will do them with passion and intensity like you have never seen before.
No one on earth can say how successful he will be...but at least I now know that I like (and REALLY repect) the guy.
Oh, and about the banner - yes, I think that its time has come and gone. I would vote for going back to the pre-CC banner until the Next Great Thing comes along.
Brian has a strong opinion on the matter and is sharing that. I think he reserves that right since, you know, this is his blog. He is not secretly hopinh that Hoke fails. Nor will he boo him or the team when they take the field. He's frustrated and he's venting, as are the rest of us.
Use your free will to form your own opinions.
... what Brian writes is going to be interpreted as feeling of a large faction of Michigan fans. If he seems to hate the hire, which is pretty clear when he makes statements like "this is a bad hire," then we're back to where we were during the RR years. We do not want to appear like a "Big House divided." I think it's fine to slam DB for a poor search process if you feel that way, but for general fan morale and enthusiasm, and for the sake of our team, I think it's important for a guy in Brian's position to accentuate the positives.
is you get to start your own website whenever you want. Perhaps that's a good place for you to start.
Brian is making an evaluation based on existing data, not on emotions, press conferences, or anything else. You have to admit that based on the data, it's a hire that doesn't jump out at you.
This doesn't mean that Hoke won't be a great coach, but absent knowing who Brandon actually interviewed and what they actually said we only have coaching resumes to go off of.
Now that he's had some actual exposure to Hoke. But this OP is pathetic (also -- a "letter to the editor" post is not a diary). I like reading Brian's take on things, but I don't need him to do anything -- I can think for myself.
I thought Brandon's explanation of how and why he chose Hoke was clear enough for a guy who hadn't slept in a week, and that's good enough for me. I feel the same anger as Brian toward segments of the Michigan community who actively worked to undermine Rodriguez, and similarly marvel at most of the news media's total lack of self-awareness. But, as Brian has already said, none of that is Brady Hoke's fault.
Presumably today we'll see Brian's take on yesterday's events -- there were some interesting things to reflect on and joke about. I suspect the ban on talking about the things Drew Sharp says will be lifted momentarily, since I thought what he (Sharp) said was particularly instructive in understanding where he is coming from -- there are fools with the same point of view on this blog, for what it's worth.
The other thing I thought was important was the fact Hoke was a Criminal Justice major and got into coaching only as a way to help kids stay out of trouble. Maybe we should nickname him "Officer Hoke" or "Sarge" or something, although I have a feeling those former players already have nicknames for him.
co-sign. RR is gone, Hoke is in, and almost everyone I've talked to is moving on and getting excited to see what our new coach can do. As for needing a fearless leader, Hoke seems to be providing plenty of leadership and is getting people pumped for what's around the corner.
Re: Nicknames, Officer Hoke would be especially good considering we're bringing in a player named Justice. If nothing else, we can look forward to seeing what puns Brent Musberger comes up with using this raw material.
After yesterday, I'm starting to forget about everything Brian wrote. I wanted to hate Hoke, but I can't...
Hoke is pretty rough around the edges, but he seems like a high-character guy. I'd recommend watching his exchange with Drew Sharp if you haven't done so already. Strictly speaking, I didn't agree with Hoke's reasoning, but I love how he handled that DOOSHbag. It's not hard to imagine him motivating his own troops very well.
To the main point, I'm glad *someone* in SE Michigan is taking a dissenting viewpoint on Brady Hoke. Sure, I'd like the tone to by less whiny, but the groupthink that's been going on elsewhere (led, surely, by Corporate Guy Brandon) is embarrassing.
there is a lot that we don't know, and never will know. One possible, and very plausible scenario:
DB had some kind of back channel communication with Harbaugh, and #4 said "I will come to Michigan, it's my dream job, however there is no way I'm not coaching Stanford in the Orange Bowl."
DB thinks, "Well, that's fine. The timing will be awkward, but I'll get the guy everyone wants and save $1.5 on the buyout. Sweet." He then announces that he will wait until after bowl season to evaluate the season.
But then around bowl time, the NFL starts really throwing flowers at Harbaugh. Multiple teams are interested. He tells DB that he needs time to explore these options. Now DB is in a bind; Michigan's bowl has been played and he has to make a decision on Rodriguez but Harbaugh is backing off his verbal assurances. DB cannot publicly admit that there has been any kind of back channel communication. Swinging through the jungle, he has to let go of one vine in order to try and grab the next one. He does, and whiffs. When Harbaugh decides to go to the NFL, he has to scramble to find the next option.
A significant portion of the fan base -and, more significantly, the athletic department- wants Les Miles. On the surface of things, it's hard to argue against that based on the results he has had in Baton Rouge. However it's not the best fit for either side, especially for Miles. Whether the rumors about his personal behavior in Ann Arbor in the 90's are true or false, why on earth would his wife have any interest in returning to Ann Arbor and having people whisper behind their backs all the time? He must interview Miles, and he does. Then he hires a coach that not only did well at Michigan, but has the respect and even admiration of every player he ever coached and is a lights-out recruiter with national connections.
I wasn't thrilled with Hoke either, at first. I feel a lot better about him now, especially seeing how he spoke of Michigan and the rivalry with the Hideous Minions of Evil. That fact that he "gets it" is not something fuzzy and ephemeral - it will sell recruits on Michigan.
The question is not whether or not Hoke was the best coach in the country we could have gotten. The question is whether or not he was the best coach for our situation. More and more, as we learn more about him, I think he probably is. I can't wait for the fall to find out for sure.
Is that Hoke was DB's first choice all along, because Hoke fit Brandon's image of the Michigan football coach. I say that as a Hoke supporter, but Brandon did not want a 'big name' coach who would be bigger than the program. http://mgoblog.com/mgoboard/michigans-appetite-big-name-coach
given that Harbaugh and Miles are both loose-cannon sorts. When DB said that Hoke was his first choice I just assumed that he was lying and couldn't really publicly say that he had whiffed on his first two choices. But you may well be right.
The more I read about Hoke the better I feel. The apparently unanimous high opinion held of him by former players speaks volumes, and apparently he's a deadly recruiter. Maybe he can even do some magic in the time that's left before signing day...