Why We Fight Comment Count

Seth

IMG_2365

I'm sitting with my mother and her three sisters, and we're watching the rockets attacking Israel. One aunt is on Skype with her daughter who just picked a really bad week to move to Tel Aviv. My cousin has a tendency toward fearlessness—when living in Sendai, Japan, during that earthquake/tidal wave/nuclear plant disaster she passed up offers from the U.S. consulate to get her out of there, instead organizing the evacuation of her schoolchildren. Now she's brushing aside her mother's terror: we have an Iron Dome; can I show you the floor of the apartment?

The American TV news is showing people fleeing the beach and she jokes that all those moving at a walking pace are the Israelis. The aunts don't see the humor; these are minutes carefully constructed—including the Skype call—to properly experience the horror of warfare. And when it's interrupted by the news shifting to Wimbledon the women lament, and complain of Western Civilization's warped priorities: here's civilians being shot at with rockets; now let's go to sport.

Here's sport. The reason that TV news can seamlessly shift from Hamas lobbing rockets to Roger Federer smashing lobs is because TV news turned news coverage into sports coverage. Here's the teams, here's the scores, here's a highlight reel, here's the day's-end results. You are welcome to lament this development; my point here is there's something so innately gratifying about sports that they turned news into it.

Getting in. I can't remember my first interactions with sports. There's a photo of me as an infant between my dad and my grandpas on a couch, and given the setup and the expressions (sleeping, discussing something else, WHAT THE HELL WAS THAT?)  it's a good bet a game was on. I was just four months old the first time I was on a sailboat—my dad was a serious racer back then and had use of his captain's boat because he was the only crewman who knew how to fix it. I've been told I went to an '84 Tigers playoff game but I don't remember it. I don't remember my first Michigan game either—just the familiarity of going to Michigan games in later memories.

I remember going hours early to my great aunt's house for Thanksgiving, and sitting on the floor of the living room for the Lions game. I remember at the end of a morning ski lesson at Nub's Nob my dad coming to pick us up and all afternoon us showing him what we'd learned of pizza pies and french fries. I remember wearing space pajamas while watching March Madness on my parents' bed, and my dad getting in trouble for me being up. And I remember my dad instructing me on the proper breaking-in technique of my first baseball glove, and unwrapping the greasy twine early because I meant to take the glove to tailgate, and that my dad fished his out of the chaos of his garage shelves, and that I spent the drive to Ann Arbor admiring the old leather, the Rocky Colavito signature, and the bull's head brand in the palm that matched my own glove.

I don't remember when I started liking sports. I just remember my Dad was there.

The Men

From left: WWII vet, blogger, WWII vet, draft dodger

Distraction. My favorite MGoBlog piece is "Eleven Swans," when Brian felt, in the hours leading up to Football Armageddon (The Game 2006), that he needed to justify how such a thing could have importance in a world with an Israeli-Palestinian conflict in it:

And then you try to figure out why the stakes are so high in the first place. Why this entire week you haven't been able to concentrate on anything by war by proxy. Fake war by proxy. Meaningless war by proxy. You will suffer humiliation when the team from my area defeats the team from your area. It's ridiculous. Intelligent people do not spend a goodly swath of their life pouring emotion and precious time into a contest that affects no one and changes nothing except some inky scribbles in media guides.

The analogy that Kellen Winslow Jr. badly articulated in reference to a brutal injury he inflicted that one time is, in fact, true: sports is warfare. Our regional tribe shall fight theirs, and will do so in the manner that we all wish war was conducted: hardfast rules, individual heroics, minimal casualties, clear victories, and done by somebody else on our behalf.

My father was the first in his paternal lineage not to go to war. The first Fisher, according to the family history, deserted a British ship for an American one near Sault Ste. Marie in 1813. There was a Harry Fisher who distinguished himself in the Civil War. And there was Great Grandpa Prenzlauer, who for a drunken promise named a son for his war buddy Colonel Leonard Wood, whom everyone called "Colonel." Both of my grandpas fought against real Nazis in The War, as did my dad's great uncle Colonel Leonard Wood Prenzlauer, a corporal (family members, almost certainly apocryphally, claim he was Joseph Heller's inspiration for Major-Major). The horrors of it made them old men before their thirties; Colonel died only a few years afterward.

Because you're supposed to name kids for a loved one who recently passed, my dad's name was to be Colonel, until my grandma awoke from the drugs they used back then and promptly changed it to Robert Leonard. He played football at Cass Tech and his coach—perhaps every coach in the mid-'60s—was a vet who coached like it was a war.

My dad's distaste for warfare started a rift with him and his father that wouldn't be repaired until I was born. My dad spent the bulk of his twenties avoiding Vietnam by any means. He had a low draft number and after his first two years at MSU they got rid of student deferments. He and his best friend, who'd been at Michigan, transferred to Oakland University to keep their parents mollified while really doing nothing but play handball and researching ways of getting around the draft. Eventually they came upon agricultural deferments, which is how two Jewish city boys became farmers. The New Deal system of the federal government buying up unplanted crops to keep food prices high enough to support farming was still in effect, so the years they were not-growing corn were able to offset the years they were growing corn badly.

(For many reasons I read Catch 22 at an early age)

The way the WWII generation watched sports was different from my dad's generation, and different from mine. My grandpa treated it like an intense escape. He and his brothers-in-law went to the 1950 game—the one with all the snow—and he said ever after it was his favorite because it was too cold for anybody to interrupt the game with talking. He wouldn't talk about the war much, except to bring up the fact that he fought it so that he could watch the damn game in peace.

My dad watched Michigan games in the stands, or at his best friend's house, or if neither were available from his bed; either way it was a background piece to a conversation that alternated between mutterings over the incompetence of the coaches and the other things in life.

He had little of the seriousness for sports that I developed. I'd complain to him of battles with the internet Nazis and the relativity of program goodness, and he'd shrug at these things then go back to the two great questions of our age: Why haven't they pulled this pitcher?, and Why are they running left again?. A few things were important and everything else was irrelevant, and nobody could bring irreverence to bear like my father. He was off-the-charts intelligent. He was unflinchingly ethical. He could mock anything because he had the mind and the desire to understand everything.

The things that are important. My aunts were all in town last week because on July 4th my dad suddenly passed away. He'd been a little sick with that cold everyone had that turned into mild bronchitis and pneumonia, but the antibiotics and pills had him feeling better by that Friday. He was gardening, and planning to sail in the afternoon, and when he collapsed I was on the phone with my Mom to invite them, conditional on my dad's state of health after sailing, to barbecue at our new house with all the kids and his two grandkids.

When I was 16 I got fired from a summer camp—I accidentally ran into a kid while refereeing ultimate frisbee and it just happened to be the kid who had a lawsuit going against the camp for the last time he and his parents imagined he was damaged, and rather than compound their situation they let me go. Then my car wouldn't start and I was stranded at the bus depot at Lahser and 11-mile, and I called my dad and said it was the worst day of my life, and he said "No, the worst day of your life is the day I die."

I've never a fought a war, never been in a position where I'd been expected to, or had to face the prospect of one. Lacking something so serious I developed a tendency—as I'm sure many of my generation did—to stage pitched battles over less relevant things. You've witnessed this as I've railed on this blog and in HTTV etc. about the Superbowlization of Michigan sports.

Today is my first official day "back" to blogging since July 4, and there's fireworks to mock, new plays to scribble, and an interview with former Michigan cornerbacks in re: what to expect from Peppers that are coming up. But I couldn't bring myself to put any of those together because the worst day of my life still envelopes all the thoughts.

So I want to say for the record, in lieu of all the complaints and nitpicks and devastations and hypocrisies that I typically point out, that these things are of just a relative importance to a thing of actual little importance. If it costs way more than it should to sit in a stadium that's become way too chintzy for a team that isn't nearly as good as it ought to be, that's 5% of an experience that's 95% spending some of a truly finite amount of breaths with the person you came with. I can't remember how sports became such a part of my life any more than I remember how my dad entered it. Sports were just something that my dad and I did with the 34 years of peace and good life afforded to us. And it was the most important thing in the world.

Comments

LSAClassOf2000

July 15th, 2014 at 1:50 PM ^

Very well done, moving piece, Seth. Once again, let me express my deepest condolences for your loss. 

It stirred a lot of feelings for me because while I have not experienced this yet, I am in the process of watching my father slowly lose control of his life to Parkinson's and a few other things which, in combination, now visibly drag him down. As someone above said, the thought of the day when I can't call him and complain about strategy in a game is a thought I dread.

Thanks for sharing this wonderful and insightful entry with us.

champswest

July 15th, 2014 at 2:16 PM ^

I found out about my father's death on the day he collapsed and died.  My mother died 6 years later.  She was in in the hospital surrounded by her children and grand children.  It is the only time I have seen someone take their last breath.  Maybe that is why her passing was even harder on me than my father's.  In both cases, it is a deep sadness that gets better over time, but never fully goes away.  Be thankful for all of the great memories.

dmakian

July 15th, 2014 at 2:24 PM ^

Didn't expect to have a tear jerked up at work today, but I'm glad I did.  Great piece, I'll be calling my dad in a bit to hear his voice.  Thanks for everything you do.

mvp

July 15th, 2014 at 2:26 PM ^

Seth,

I am deeply moved by this piece.  It is a testament to your writing and what you choose to do with your talents that these responses are what they are. 

By itself, this would be a situation where this community comes together to express our condolences in this difficult time.

What you've done, though, is to take your own tragedy and use it as a way to make others realize the blessings in their lives and cause them to remember their own journeys.  I know I'll hug my parents a little tighter the next time I see them.  I'm truly sorry for your loss and truly appreciative that you chose this way to share with us.  God bless you and your family.

Prince Lover

July 15th, 2014 at 2:27 PM ^

I still have my dad who also taught me all things sports and competition. To make a long story short, I was hospitalized from the 4th til the 9th. I am now on blood thinners for the next 6 ish months. My dad has been on blood thinners for 7 ish years for his a-fib. Twice a week we have to have our InR checked. We've made a game of who can stay at our target levels. It's silly, but it's what my dad and I have always done, make up silly competitions. Thank you Seth, for sharing and making those of us still with our parents to take a step back and cherish what we have.

An Angelo's Addict

July 15th, 2014 at 2:48 PM ^

Thank you for sharing this with us Seth. It must have been difficult to put all of this in writing and get back to blogging. Probably one of the most powerful pieces I have read on the site. Welcome back.

getsome

July 15th, 2014 at 3:47 PM ^

always tough to lose someone unexpectedly, even more so when its a family member.  you def have my condolences, though sympathy of total strangers likely brings little comfort.  kudos for spilling some difficult emotion onto the page, i know it forced me to reflect a little.  hopefully the writing proves somewhat cathartic.  and great picture by the way, i really wish i had something similar.  i especially enjoyed the labels

jtblue

July 15th, 2014 at 3:51 PM ^

I haven't commented in two years, but I logged on to say thank you Seth. These words...

I can't remember how sports became such a part of my life any more than I remember how my dad entered it.

My sentiments exactly.

Thank you Seth for these words. I have also had my dad for 34 years and found out today he is now cancer free. 

May God grant you peace and people to carry you through. 

1.21 Jigawatts

July 15th, 2014 at 4:09 PM ^

Ovation to you sir. My favorite part:

He wouldn't talk about the war much, except to bring up the fact that he fought it so that he could watch the damn game in peace.


My condolences as well.

Danwillhor

July 15th, 2014 at 4:26 PM ^

I always go to the "do you remember the seven swans post before the game of the century?" question when gauging exactly how well/long one knows the blog.

pharker

July 15th, 2014 at 4:39 PM ^

What you've written here and who you are are a big part of your father's legacy. Maybe this is trite, but he did a good job with you, and you're doing a great job for him. 

Love and peace to you and yours, my friend. 

Michigasling

July 15th, 2014 at 7:48 PM ^

But, as you've so beautifully proven, they also live on in their stories.  And someday you'll surprise yourself when you find yourself telling the stories with a smile on your face, instead of the pain they must cause you today. 

Thanks for sharing these with us.

 

fatman_do

July 15th, 2014 at 8:09 PM ^

One day, maybe in the distant future, you will recall something that will reduce you to a sobbing mess. I live for those days. It reminds me of my loss, which brings me joy and sorrow. Joy for the memories, sorrow that there are conversations and memories that are still needed.

My family offers you our sincere condolences. I had my son read this, we had a moment.

PeteM

July 15th, 2014 at 8:16 PM ^

My uncle passed away not long ago, not the same as losing your father obviously, but your piece made me think about him a bit.  He was a huge fan of Boston's pro teams and BC, and I went to games with him when I was out there.  The day he died he was planning to go to a Bruins game, and his family put the ticket in the casket with him.  I guess my point is that I agree sports can be a huge bond within a family.

BlueAggie

July 15th, 2014 at 9:45 PM ^

This is really powerful and speaks tremendously of your father.  I unexpectedly lost my Dad last year and volunteered to speak at his memorial service.  The process of remembering my favorite times with him, picking a few and building a narrative around his life was significant in my grieving process.  

I hope that writing this has brought you some of that peace and helped begin the journey.  You don't ever stop missing your loved one, but you do gain some perspective as the shock becomes less acute.  One way or another we are reflections of those who raised us.  They live on as long as we continue to live out the lessons they imparted.

fatbastard

July 16th, 2014 at 12:23 AM ^

Great article/column, Seth.  I am moved.  I haven't logged into Mgoblog for at least a year, but I wanted to comment on this.  I am sorry for your loss. 

And, while I lament much of the same that you do about the current status of Michigan football, and the proposed fireworks, we're Michigan fergodsakes, it isn't even 5 percent of what is important.   

What is important about sports, and Michigan football in particular, as it passed from father to son, and to his son, is that it has brought you and your father together, and will (i hope) always bring me, my father, my brother, and my son and daughters (and hopefully their sons and daughters).  and my closest friends together. Whether it be in person or in spirit, or by phone.  Thank you for helping me, and all of us out here who still have their fathers, realize how important a discussion about recruits, about the defense, about the A.D., may be, not becuase of football, but because of whom the conversation is with and how much more the conversation means than the words that may be spoken. 

Thank you.

 

 

 

turd ferguson

July 16th, 2014 at 9:52 AM ^

Seth, I'm sorry just to get to this now, but this was beautifully done.  This MGoBlog entry might be to me what you said Eleven Swans is to you.  Obviously this will be little consolation, but I think your introspection and grace in the aftermath of personal tragedy has gotten a lot of us thinking about what's important.  Thank you.

JayMo4

July 16th, 2014 at 1:45 PM ^

A lot of similarities between your family history and my own. The line about your grandpa fighting the war so that he could watch the game in peace made me laugh for several minutes and then tear up.

Thank you for sharing your story with us. Sports may be trivial, but at least one sports blog is not.

Seth

August 25th, 2014 at 8:56 PM ^

If anyone gives a damn, somebody wanted to republish this and I patched up some of the mistakes I'd made in the family history, is why there was a recent update.