All of your Vlad Emilien jerseys are instantly converted to Tate Forcier jerseys!
Hey, wait a minute...
time for an update
Well-played, Angry Michigan Secondary-Hating God: Scout is reporting that Vlad Emilien is leaving Michigan. This is their Ohio recruiting analyst, FWIW, so it's not someone super-close to the program but he's not a random guy on the internet or bikini model. Details in the header:
Sophomore safety Vlad Emilien has left the Michigan football team, Scout.com learned Wednesday morning. Emilien, out of Plantation, Florida, requested, and was granted, his release Tuesday in a meeting with head coach Rich Rodriguez.
Emilien got some playing time against UConn on their final drive when Michigan went to a prevent package but did not play before that and may not have played at all if Jared Van Slyke had been healthy.
When you're on the depth chart behind a walk-on the writing is on the wall, I guess, but that walk-on is now out for the season, so the depth chart at free safety now reads
Realistically, it means any injury to a safety will see Marvin Robinson move into the starting lineup either at FS or bandit, with Kovacs moving to the deep safety spot that was not such a good idea a year ago. This may have already been the case, but losing Emilien just makes the secondary even flimsier than it is right now.
If I had to guess, this was just an injury/playing time washout. I'd heard persistent rumors that the knee injury never healed right and the Roundtree/Emilien/Jones sprint in the spring game was an eye opener. Hard to believe Michigan's secondary can suffer a PT transfer, but behind a walk-on and all that.
In addition: ARGH.
UPDATE: Tom confirms.
All of your Vlad Emilien jerseys are instantly converted to Tate Forcier jerseys!
Hey, wait a minute...
...runs counter to his recent action of vacating the team:
“I got to work my way back up,” (Vlad) said. “I got to prove to (coaches) that I’m the best. I got to prove to (coaches) that I’m worthy of playing, you can win with me.”
Listing a player as third string behind a player out for the year is a message from the coaches that the third stringer is not the second option. Regardless of why, Vlad was not presently ready to contribute and, perhaps, never would have been. I doubt RR tries to keep players for appearances sake. Nor should he. If Vlad is not an option this year, and is unwilling to compete to become one, then I can hardly fault him for not begging him to stay.
|Guy||Left because||Fishiness (1-5)|
|Artis Chambers||Carr guy way down the depth chart, transferred for PT||1|
|Adrian Witty||Couldn't get eligible||1|
|Boubacar Cissoko||Personal problems uncovered after loosed from prison-like home life||2|
|Brandon Smith||Carr recruit who hung on for awhile???||3|
|Donovan Warren||Got bad advice about NFL draft position, but was leaning that way regardless||3|
|Demar Dorsey||Shouldn't have been offered||4|
|Justin Turner||Not committed enough, fell down depth chart???||5|
|Vlad Emilien||Injury never healed, fell down depth chart???||5|
Vlad Emilien didn't have an effort problem. His knee hasn't healed, but I thought there was a strong bond here due to Michigan keeping in contact when everyone else saw the horrible knee pop, realized it would be three years until he was useful, if ever, and backed off.
All of these guys had reasons to leave -- known and unknown -- but I am starting to see a pattern here of players departing at the first sign that there's reason to do so. I would like to see this investigated. If it turns out it's just horrible luck, I would accept that. But I have very tangible willies now that Tony Gibson is doing something wrong, and this is making our secondary not as nice of a place to play.
Yep. I agree 100%. You did a diary recently asking if it's possible the staff is doing something wrong that's running kids off (granted that's a simplistic summary of it) and were basically hoping people would convince you otherwise... Well, I think it's time to start asking this question now.
As I said above, where there's smoke, there's fire. At this point it seems like it's just too much to be coincidence. I hope it's not, but the volume of this suggests otherwise. :-/
I wonder if part of it is the fact that most of these kids came to UM, at least in part, because they figured they would get some early playing time considering the depth chart. When guys like Turner and Vlad saw that they were being passed over by walk-ons and the like, it must have been a rude reality check and led a couple of them to walk away. Pure conjecture on my part, but at big-name programs kids expect to play early on, and it must sting when they are passed over.
But as others have said, with Vlad... Van Slyke is out for the year. He's gonna get playing time.
Out of the schools he's considering... the only places he's looking at getting PT right away are Duke and Virginia. Yet, he's also looking at getting PT here at M - a place he says he loves, yet is leaving. It really doesn't add up.
I agree with the trend. While I doubt Gibson is actively driving kids away, the fact remains that the thinnest position on the roster has also undergone the most upheaval. Some of those guys on the chart were outside of anybody's control - Cissoko, Warren, even Dorsey to an extent), while other guys were going to leave irrespective because of PT.
I am surprised that Vlad is out, but then again it sounds like he never fully recovered from the injury and, at some point, the coaches are going to treat you as damaged goods. That is obviously not an outcome you want to see, but coaches are paid to win and to maximize the talent around them, and with such limited practice hours they are going to focus on the guys who can help them win now, not the kid who is significantly slower than everyone else. I feel horrible for Vlad, but maybe this is the best.
I wish Vlad the best, and hopefully he'll find a better fit somewhere else.
Great post. While the earlier losses can't be blamed on the coaches, it is disturbing to lose guys who with some motivation could have helped us out a lot. I realize that we don't know that VE lacked motivation, but still, this kind of leak needs to get plugged.
Thank you for putting this all together. You can't look at these departures in a vaccuum. It's not just about Vlad right now, it's about whats going on with this team.
Right now we're all on a UConn high, but this could have some major ramifications very soon. Ugh.
Where do Shazor, Mundy, Johnny Sears, Chris Richards, etc. fit on your list?
I seriously do love your work, but this seems to be a "pattern" that has been occurring with some frequency even in the late Carr years. I'm not sure that hanging it all on Gibson makes sense.
If you're looking for the one constant in all this, it's pretty obvious -- this is all Fred Jackson's fault. (In case it's not obvious, that previous sentence is /s).
is interesting because after a ho-hum career at UM, he went to play for Gibson/RR at WVU and had a decent year. Ended up getting drafted after it too.
Yeah, that's one of the main reasons I'm having trouble believing the RABBLEGIBSONRABBLE talk going on.
It's also the main reason I was excited for Gibson.
The Sears/Richards things brings up a thought though: perhaps this is an afteraffect of desperate recruiting....like the secondary got so bad that we were recruiting a lot on the promise of playing time, which may explain why the ongoing attrition from those not getting playing time.
I now need to come up with a new fantasy team name to replace "One in Emilien"
keep blaming God for this one. No doubt, our existing secondary is the work of none other than Lucifer himself.
"Look men, the season's off to a good start, but we face quite a few pass-centric teams this fall. The UM blogs and Detroit press are going into meltdown the last few weeks - they're really hammering home the whole deal about our thin depth chart in the secondary, and.... well, there's no easy way to say this, and I know you had different ideas when you agreed to come here with our infamous 4 and 5 wide sets, but starting tomorrow a good number of you men will be hitting the tackling dummies like whoa....I'm sorry, but there's no other way."
That #5 jersey I bought last year is looking like a great investment right now...
The whole goddamn secondary already left or got injured and the guy was still nowhere near seeing the field (which seeing his physical skills on display in the spring game makes understandable as a coaching decision) so he got pissed and decided to bail.
I don't see what is so tricky about this.
The coaching staff has put Williams, Gordon (who they had to move from WR), not one but two walk-ons, and probably a new true freshman or two ahead of Vlad on the depth chart over the last two years. If the coaching staff had any desire to put him on the field, they would have done it by now, but instead he continued to fall down the depth chart. From this we can make a pretty strong assumption that the guy was never going to see the field, for whatever reason, under this coaching staff. When a player realizes that to be the case, I don't think anybody can blame him for wanting to look elsewhere.
Except for the fact that he is second on the depth chart and played in the last game at free safety.
He probably didn't expect the loss of Warren, the loss of Witty, the Dorsey recruiting fiasco and then the ridiculous cracked ankle of his best player in the secondary group for 2010.
Honestly guys, imagine a similar progression of events happening at your work. With Crist, Cousins, Stanzi, Tolzien, Pryor and others up ahead, yeah, I would be shitting bricks right now. Wouldn't you? As a result I might not be "on top of my game" either.
Yeah, it might be all MY FAULT, but the "pattern", if there even was one, started with that freaking No. 2 ranked recruiting class of 2005 that disintegrated into quark particles, not when Tony Gibson showed up on the scene.
+1 for quark reference
Adam Braithwaite is the safeties coach anyway, not Gibson.
This is getting a bigger reaction than the stories of Warren, BSmith and Cissoko got combined.
That there have been so many of these stories that I actually FORGOT about Brandon Smith until I read your comment, how fucking ridiculous is that!?
How could any secondary recruit not have us in their top 3??? A verbal commitment alone would put them in the 2-deep.
i mean, NO SHIT RIGHT???
who wants to play as a freshman for a contender next year...step right up!
the Midwest is like kryptonite on his impaling abilities, as he is looking more towards the coasts.
Can he play safety?
/ too soon?
But I laughed
the other day even before this Vlad news. I really do wonder if Tate on defense could ever work.
I realize that it has probably been a long time since Tate has lined up on the other side of the ball (if ever), but I'm still intrigued. I could see where a QB thrust into the seconday could be very instinctive because they have so much experience studying and reading coverages.
Again, probably not realistic based on athleticism, but still a thought.
No doubt this sucks. But I'm with the marjoity of the board on this one. The kid seemed lost last year against Baby Seal U, can't get on the field until the end of a blowout, and it is obvious that his knee injury may have been a little more damaging then we all thought. I wish Vlad the best of luck wherever he decides to go. He worked hard while he was here and while he did not crack the starting line up he never complained or isolated himself from the team. This opens another spot for this incoming recruiting class and I'm sure we're going to get some nice players to fill the voids left by Angry Michigan Secondary Hating God.
Sooo maybe all of these transfer rumors about Tate were just mix ups over their mutual jersey number?
she is apparently comprised entirely of Spinal Tap drummers.
Michigan football is causing me to channel Camus. That is not right.
Damnit. My number 5 jersey is now pretty much obsolete.
Holy moses! Can we please get some commitment out of anyone besides the starters here? We pretty much need nothing but db's in the 2011 recruiting class