Unverified Voracity Watches Paint Dissasemble Comment Count

Brian

Good news for people who like boring news. There is a webcam of Michigan taking down their new scoreboards. You can watch it, or you can look at this picture. They are basically equivalent:

image

Yes, they left the Big Chill lingo up.

Womp-rats? Yesterday at about 7 PM Yahoo released its latest article that terrifies and thrills, and it's a doozy:

Tressel knew of gear scheme last April

If true, that would expose Ohio State to the worst kind of NCAA justice. Cover-ups are very bad. They got SMU the death penalty and are soon to terminate the job of Bruce Pearl.

Can Yahoo/the NCAA prove it, though? The Robinson/Wetzel piece relies on one anonymous source who said Tressel was "troubled by the information" and promised to investigate. I don't think OSU can reasonably suggest they investigated and found nothing since it didn't take the NCAA long to confirm the story, but previous Yahoo gotchas came with paper trails—as of now there isn't one.

The worst-case scenario here is that this gets rolled into an investigation of Terrelle Pryor's perpetual loaner and it turns out that—surprise—zealous OSU boosters are funneling massive amounts of impermissible benefits to players. It's getting to the point where it's hard to downplay everything that comes to light as an isolated incident, especially when Antonio Pittman tweets that cats have been getting hookups on tats since 2001.

I don't think anyone knows where this is going but if Yahoo can produce paper a major violation, an actual one not about stretching, is in the offing. Eleven Warriors just tweeted that they are hearing Tressel will admit wrongdoing(!) and sanctions/suspensions are "possible."

No serious harm done. According to Mike Spath, Carl Hagelin and Billy Powers expect Louie Caporusso to return for next weekend's CCHA finals at the Joe. Presuming Michigan can get by Bowling Green, by far the worst team in the league this season, without him they won't be short in their quest for a one-seed.

Word. Best NFL draft evaluation ever on one Justin Boren:

Plays angry on the field but his mental makeup is in question after a transfer from Michigan. Day 3 prospect.

Love to bits. The SBN Oilers blog goes off on semi-regular rants about how numbers are just not understood, man, that I love to tiny bits. Their latest is about the Avalanche and their fluky run last year. According to hockey's advanced metrics last year, the Avs were a terrible team. According to the standings midway through the year they were pretty good. They managed to survive a massive late slump to squeeze into the playoffs and fans thought this was sustainable and numbers were stupid. This year they're pretty much the same team except they're not nearly as lucky, so they're just above the Oilers in the standings and fans are discussing whether they should fire the coach they were pumping for the Jack Adams last year.

Key section:

Avalanche fans are not alone in ignoring, even denying the evidence behind the performance of the team. In an article entitled "When the scientific evidence is unwelcome, people try to reason it away" in The Guardian, author Ben Goldacre explores what happens when people are "...confronted with scientific evidence that challenges their pre-existing view." His conclusion? "Often they will try to ignore it, intimidate it, buy it off, sue it for libel or reason it away." Goldacre references a 1979 paper from Lord, Ross and Lepper. From the paper's abstract:

People who hold strong opinions on complex social issues are likely to examine relevant empirical evidence in a biased manner. They are apt to accept "confirming" evidence at face value while subjecting "disconfirming" evidence to critical evaluation, and, as a result, draw undue support for their initial positions from mixed or random empirical findings.

Goldacre goes on to discuss a second group of people - those who attack the science behind the evidence presented to them.

When presented with unwelcome scientific evidence, it seems, in a desperate attempt to retain some consistency in their world view, people would rather conclude that science in general is broken.

This line of thinking is similar to that used by fans who argue in favor of shot quality. Shot quality has become the great foil used by those arguing against possession metrics as a basis of hockey analytics. The ever-increasing mountain of possession data, evidence and studies means little to the shot quality folks. Arguments abound in favor of shot quality with no evidence to back it up, so lacking so Desjardins challenged the world to prove the existence of shot quality. There were no takers.

Goldacre concludes:

When presented with unwelcome scientific evidence, it seems, in a desperate attempt to retain some consistency in their world view, people would rather conclude that science in general is broken.

What's that on the horizon? It's getting closer! It's getting closer very fast!Joe-Morgan

This is why numbers are important—they at least force you to consider things that conventional wisdom holds are ridiculous, like Derek Jeter being a pretty crappy defensive shortstop. The advanced metrics said the Avs were due to regress badly and they did. This would be just another guy who loves numbers accepting confirming evidence while some other team that defied the numbers would be seized upon by the Joe Morgans of the world as their confirming evidence… except for the fact that you can collect big sets of numbers and show they are accurate more often than not. We had a discussion about this before college football season when I predicted Iowa wouldn't do so hot and Iowa fans were like "numbers are stupid."

The other end of the spectrum from Joe Morgan is David Berri, who's just as wrong as Morgan and relies on a just-as-irrelevant credential ("I was the greatest second baseman of all time"/"I went to Princeton") in his quest to reduce everything in sports to a regression. I'm not arguing for that, either. The numbers gathered by football and basketball box scores are witheringly insufficient to hope to explain anything.

In reality, numbers are insufficient to fully explain anything but baseball for a lot of reasons. Baseball's easier and there are orders of magnitude more data—Pitch FX is insane. But in all sports advanced metrics can at least provide a much better answer for "what," if not how and why. An example: about a week ago LaVall Jordan tweeted that Michigan had the fourth best defense in the Big Ten. That's true on a pure counting number basis but if you do something like divide they were ninth*. That's a huge difference and the tempo-free number is indisputably better. There's a huge difference between talking about why Michigan has an above average defense or why they have a below-average one, and anyone who would prefer to talk about the former is just wasting people's time.

*[The MSU game moved them up to seventh.]

Hardaway explosion. Rod Beard's latest in the News has a wide array of quotes on the emergence of Tim Hardaway Jr. Vitale is involved, but don't let that phase you. Here's the most interesting bit on his recent blowup:

"When he was shooting a lower percentage earlier in the year, I called him in and we just talked a little about getting a better shot than he was taking," Beilein said. "(I told him) you're probably going to take just as many shots, but the ball will come back to you again.

"He did it immediately and his shooting percentage has gone way up."

Beilein has repeatedly praised Hardaway's coachability, which suggests he will continue to improve over the duration of his career at Michigan. Dad is also impressed:

"He's developed very well and the whole team has, from November to today," Tim Sr. said. "You can see a lot of confidence in them and you can see their swagger. They're playing well, they believe in the system and they believe in the coach."

Random offer thought. Michigan continues to litter the nation with offers, but a Q: could this be a more general pattern? The NCAA just implemented a rule that prohibits schools from sending written offers until August. In the past there was the verbal offer, which was more of an indication of interest, and the written offer, which was as close to official as something that says "we can revoke this at any time" gets. Now there are no written offers, nothing to distinguish between the two, and kids who may have waited to declare they had an offer until they had the actual paper in their hands now have nothing else do go on.

In any case, the universal predictions that this rule would lead to confusion and would do nothing to slow down the breakneck pace of recruiting have come true, like it was obvious they would.

Etc.: Posnanski writes something about the "joy of rooting against Lebron" that expands on yesterday's trash-talk assertions. According to Ira at WTKA via Brandon, Michigan's club seats and suites are sold out. Evolving Evan Smotrycz. Big Ten wrestling details.

Comments

michgoblue

March 8th, 2011 at 3:29 PM ^

I don't want him gone - then we never have the joy of kicking his ass, and man, does he have it coming. 

Rather, I want to see a STONG penalty, and I want the NCAA to put his program under a microscope.  Let's see how well he can recruit and coach if he is playing by the same rules that we play by.

/indignation

Cavalry21

March 8th, 2011 at 4:19 PM ^

As much as part of me wants this to be true, I can't help but think of the anonymous sources cited during the jihad. 

Everyone screamed we had 5! major violations, and well, we know how that turned out.  So I really want to wait for the OSU or the NCAA on this, but then I see Cam w/ a Heisman and MNC ring and realize that doesn’t mean much either.

I guess for now I just hope Yahoo is more reliable than the Freep or ESPN (not that that's a great standard to shoot for, but you get the idea.)

mmangino

March 8th, 2011 at 4:30 PM ^

As a Buckeye fan who thought the media was likely making a mountain out of a mole hill during the NCAA inquiry, I appreciate your level-headed ness.

If he did know, we deserve to be punished. I really hope he didn't know.

BRCE

March 8th, 2011 at 5:32 PM ^

Dude, that is what Yahoo Sports is all about. Read the salacious crap that comes from Adrian Wojnarowski (NBA writer). The guy writes sexy copy with some seriously confrontational quotes -- NONE of it with names attached.

Without a doubt, the NCAA will be contacting those writers.

 

Vivz

March 8th, 2011 at 5:18 PM ^

i went over there when i first heard about this, and it linked to a page that was entitled 2011 coaching staff and was blank (you could get back to previous year staff with a link on that page)

now that page doesnt exist, but you are linked to a page that says 2010 coaching staff

MGoShoe

March 8th, 2011 at 3:45 PM ^

...when a coach knows something is rotten in Denmark and actively pretends that everything is hunky-dory in Norway. Or Columbus. Or something like that.

Whatever, I'll believe it when I see that Jim "Claudius" Tressel gets the axe.

Bodogblog

March 8th, 2011 at 5:01 PM ^

There were many during the season, open seats at games.  Horrors of Green during Sparty week. 

Selling all club seats and all suites, in this economy with this record over the last 3 years, is an astonishing statement on the health of the M football brand.  Locally. 

El Jeffe

March 8th, 2011 at 4:46 PM ^

I've read that paper by Lord, Ross, and (the unpopular as a child) Lepper. Parts of it I think they got exactly right, and I wouldn't change a thing. Other parts I disagreed with, so vehemently that it made me question the entire scientific endeavor altogether.

/ didyouseewhatididthere

/ fake HTML tags in this thread at least

maizenbluenc

March 8th, 2011 at 4:55 PM ^

Ha, haa, ha, ha! I love the comment. It is exactly what I would question: what about the way this kid left Michigan makes you feel comfortable about his loyalty, his work ethic, and for that matter his PR risk? If you are an NFL owner, are his skills worth the risk?

Tress

So a few months back there were hot rumors that Tress was suddenly retiring (ala Urban Meyer), and then OSU announced not true. Lately there has been the major news outlet (SI) has a smoking gun article coming out that is sure to bring down the wrath of the NCAA on a major D1 program you wouldn't expect ranked in the top 10 - 12 (the ranking throws us off the scent, and our ability to expect versus the rest of the country may be different ...)

Is this it, or is it Oregon???

CRex

March 8th, 2011 at 5:09 PM ^

Lets see, a renewed offensive by Brady Hoke to penetrate Ohio's talent pool at the same time the NCAA is talking about sanctions against tOSU?  Yes please.

A nice showing this year, a New Year's Day bowl (not BCS likely, but NYD) and Tressel getting questioned could lead to an excellent recruiting class next year. 

Of course AMHG does this right after I finish my interviews with the Korean government for a long term work visa.  Such is life though.

BRCE

March 8th, 2011 at 5:23 PM ^

I seriously wonder how effective negative recruiting against OSU will be in Ohio. That state has been almost totally indoctrinated to Buckeye Spin since Tressel took over.

Tressel survives EVERYTHING when it comes to this crap. We are just going to beat him by conventional means.

M-Wolverine

March 8th, 2011 at 6:50 PM ^

"They're going to get in trouble, don't go there", you're right, that won't work.

If it means "they have scholarship sanctions, already didn't have any, do you even want to play in The Game, and oh, they're banned from a bowl game too", then yeah, it could work. But it depends on the NCAA finally doing SOMETHING, and not just the threat of it.

M-Wolverine

March 8th, 2011 at 9:28 PM ^

I'm not sure it works that way in the Cult of Ohio, as many times as they've skated. (Might work on out of state recruits, but that would probably send them to Florida or Stanford or wherever, not here).

MGlobules

March 8th, 2011 at 5:36 PM ^

for practicing too much, I just hope (he said politely, swallowing several years' worth of bottled rage over Freepgate) that OSU is punished commensurately.  

blueloosh

March 8th, 2011 at 6:20 PM ^

Why does Brian always say Berri went to Princeton?  Here's what wiki says:

Berri graduated from Nebraska Wesleyan University with a B.A. in economics in 1991, and earned both his M.A. and Ph.D. from Colorado State University. He taught economics at Coe College and California State University-Bakersfield before accepting a position at Southern Utah in 2008.

I agree he's ill-advised and reckless.  But he doesn't have Princeton to cover his blemishes, he just has an active academic affiliation (which is enough for a lot of people).

zlionsfan

March 8th, 2011 at 7:06 PM ^

but I just saw this on the BTN page on Facebook:

Programming Note: the Big Ten Network will interrupt its regularly scheduled programming to carry the address to the media by Ohio State President E. Gordon Gee, Athletics Director Gene Smith and head coach Jim Tressel regarding the OSU football program. The briefing is scheduled to begin at approximately 7 PM ET. 

It could simply be Gee saying "blah blah blah cooperate blah blah".

Or it could be something else.

EDIT: Smith says that Tressel admits prior knowledge and will explain shortly why he did not bring up the emails that implied knowledge at the time. Smith is adamant that Tressel will not be let go.

dantejones

March 8th, 2011 at 8:56 PM ^

So my girlfriend and I were joking about the O$U scandal and one thing led to another and eventually her surprisingly strong MS Paint skills came into play:

 

bluesimage

March 8th, 2011 at 9:06 PM ^

A webcam of "Michigan taking down their new scoreboards"?  Wait a minute.  Shouldn't we be taking down our OLD scoreboards?  Anyway, the video after dark is awesome.  In a zen-go-blue kind of way.

 

Token_sparty

March 8th, 2011 at 9:07 PM ^

Okay, so the Vest is suspended for two games and fined $250,000. Why is this a problem? Because it's tantamount to admitting he committed a whole host of NCAA major violations, including unethical conduct, failure to monitor, failure to promote an atmosphere of compliance, of a level and gravity much more severe than anything Coach Rodriguez or the UM football program is accused of. If the NCAA has any fortitude at all, they will start digging, and keep doing it. They could well end up crucifying Tressel, if not Ohio State. Worst-case, if they dig up everything (including Pryor's magical car deal), penalties could and should be worse than USC. Yeah, it's that bad. The only good news- NCAA is slow enough that UM will probably get a chance to exact some revenge on the Vest before he leaves/is pushed out. Ball's in your court, Infractions Committee.

Zone Left

March 8th, 2011 at 9:31 PM ^

"The worst-case scenario here is that this gets rolled into an investigation of Terrelle Pryor's perpetual loaner and it turns out that—surprise—zealous OSU boosters are funneling massive amounts of impermissible benefits to players."

I fail to see how this is bad. Isn't that the ideal scenario?

mgoblue0970

March 8th, 2011 at 9:58 PM ^

Tressell != SMU

Not even close.

That was the epitome of hyperbole.

Oh... and being a Wings fan in Colorado, I have no problem with the decline of the Avs.  It's like Columbus Lite out here.

Sac Fly

March 8th, 2011 at 10:58 PM ^

is never good for an athletic department, but if tressel isn't fired they can survive. The good thing is that it is very specific in his contract that anything like this happens he will be terminated, if the follow their own rules. The bad thing is, kirk ferentz survived a huge cover up at iowa that was 10 times worse than this.