Unverified Voracity Says Nice Unfinished Hotel Comment Count

Brian

jacob-charest-hey-baby The rotate. Illinois will look to the future on Saturday by rotating in redshirt freshman Jacob Charest, who you can see making sweet love to your whole body with his mind to the right. Hey, baby, Jacob Charest would like to know if you like emo bangs and nonchalant poses from his trip to North Korea. Yeah, baby, Jacob Charest wore his Illini uniform to Pyongyang Stadium. Because Illini up, that's why.

Charest is a 6'4" pro-style QB out of North Carolina who was a middling three star a couple years back. When Juice got pulled (again) against Purdue, Charest came in and did this:

Charest made his debut Saturday, playing in three series while going 4 of 8 for 52 yards. Zook said he was impressed with the way Charest threw downfield.

Read: "Zook said he was impressed that Charest had better accuracy than a random number generator."

So… good or bad? I guess you'd always rather be going against a team that's trying to find a quarterback and is on their third attempt—Eddie McGee is now working at wide receiver—of the season. And Williams was beyond terrifying last year against Michigan. On the other hand: Michigan's clear weakness this year is the secondary, and anyone more capable of taking advantage of that secondary than Williams is bad.

It probably won't matter since Illinois's line is so terrible: the Illini are #112 in sacks allowed despite a below-average number of passes. (212; NCAA average is 228. So it's not a huge outlier or anything; the point is that their stats aren't distorted by a lot of late-game passing because they're bad.)

Bonus: Arrelious Benn has been fighting an ankle sprain since the first game of the year and played with a shoulder sprain against Purdue. He'll play this weekend but is not 100%.

Ortmann carries around a phonebooth on his back. Via Rittenberg, this table of woe from before the Penn State game:

Tate Forcier: Throws of 10+ yards, vs FBS teams
  In Pocket Out of Pocket
Comp-Att 4-25 15-26
Comp pct 16.0 57.7
Yds per att 6.8 12.7

Suboptimal, and probably worse after Forcier got little help from his receivers. The pocket stuff isn't quite that grim as the table implies since this only accounts for throw of over ten yards—I was in the midst of firing off an email suggesting those numbers had to be wrong when I finally understood the qualifier—but, yeah, pretty grim.

This is a confirmation of a number of this: Forcier's bad in the pocket, the receivers aren't helping out much, and so forth and so on. Michigan should really slant its playcalling towards Lloyd-style conservatism, which only maddens when you're running around with a senior Tom Brady, not sophomore John Navarre.

Mumble mumble bands thing. Michigan State may have lost Saturday, but they won the halftime show:

The Numa Numa song is kind of awesome arranged for marching band, isn't it?

I'm still not sure what the MMB played, as I couldn't hear 3/4ths of it. Was it supposed to be four different thematic versions of the Victors? The one I heard had some vague Victors-y parts but it didn't sound like the fight song itself. I was confused by it.

He descended on a cloud and grumbled out some grumbles for us, we used it to season the tacos. Lloyd Carr, perhaps prompted by Rick Leach's intemperate outburst on WTKA a week or two ago, has emerged from the Fortress of Solitude to deliver his benediction:

"Rich is a young guy, (and) he's got a great background for such a young guy," Carr said during his interview with Frank Beckmann and Jim Brandstatter. "What we're seeing here offensively throughout this season is a great thing for the future of Michigan football.

"The transition a year ago you could expect (the struggles) because what they were looking for in a quarterback. Certainly what we have here is exciting. I'm excited for the future." …

"I've had a lot of conversations with Rich Rodriguez down through the last 18, 20 months, and I told him from the beginning if he needed me for any reason, just call me," Carr said. "I did not want to be a coach who's at practice and hanging around and answering questions from the media about what I saw. I didn't think that was good for Rich or our program."

This will slightly staunch the internet paranoia, but only slightly. As always, I wish to avoid this topic as thoroughly as possible. I have zero credible information about it, and learned during the coaching search that different factions can have incredibly different versions of reality.

On the notice. Chengelis's article on the import of this notice Michigan received from the NCAA starts off by broaching the possibility of major infractions but the end of it puts the event that just transpired in context:

Experts said that might well not be a major development.

"I think this is just a natural sequence of events that should occur when you have numerous former and current players making allegations that there have been rule violations, in this case, practices too long," said Rick Karcher, a sports law expert at the Florida Coastal School of Law.

"It's just a first step."

The next step would either be a determination by the NCAA that the accusations are baseless, or a formal "Notice of Allegations" detailing precisely what is supported by evidence.

It appears this is something that was obviously going to happen, and since NCAA investigators have been working with Michigan the past couple months it seems like this is a letter telling Michigan what it already knows. Basically status quo.

lolfreep.

image

Just 40 more years and they'll get the hang of it.

Charts. A diarist at Black Shoe Diaries diarist is rivaling Misopogon with his charts and interesting research. His focus is on Big Ten passer efficiency over the last decade, with a special focus on Penn State that won't be surprising to anyone who's watched PSU play over the last decade. PSU QBs were consistently horrible except for that one year Mills had before his arm fell off until Darryl Clark broke all of our preconceived notions about JayPa. A couple more general takeaways:

  • The last few years Big Ten QBs have dropped off a cliff, with this year a bounce-back.
  • Passer efficiency continues to skyrocket. Check out some meh QBs of recent and not-so-recent vintage:
    casey-pryor_medium 
    Approximately same rank, 12 extra passer efficiency points for the guy slightly worse.

That latter one is a reason to relax pass interference rules, I think. Another reason: right now they are arbitrary.

Etc.: Tempo-free stats make the NBA bigtime. Florida is the current possessor of a hypothetical college football title belt dating back to the first game ever played; Michigan is an eight-time hypothetical champ, most recently in 2004 when they beat… Purdue?

Comments

UMphd

October 27th, 2009 at 2:53 PM ^

The members of the MMB are PAYING students, not scholarship athletes. (I believe it's still a class through the School of Music, so those kids have to PAY to be out there). I would guess that the vast majority of them came to U-M to be in the Michigan Band and perpetuate its great tradition, just like the athletes. And if the athletes enjoy great careers at U-M, some of them can look forward to highly lucrative careers playing their sport. Even the greatest marching band member in the world will ever receive a cent for his/her efforts out there. This is it for them. I know I rarely touched my trumpet after graduating. What could top playing in 5 bowl games, marching in the Tournament of Roses, and travelling to 4 NCAA basketball tournaments. When coaches fail to put the players in a position to be successful, they are criticized along with the players. BUT, how much more influence does a U-M football player have over his individual success on the field than a marching band member? A helluva lot. Long way around, the kids in the MMB work hard. They sweat, they hurt, they run and they PAY for the chance to perform in Michigan Stadium. And for what? For Michigan. For the love of it. Certainly not for an ungrateful public that knows little (or nothing) about what goes in to what they do. I think criticism of the MMB needs to be directed at its leadership, the director, the School of Music and, to an extend the Athletic Department. Those are the people that need to put these kids in a position to succeed. If you've got issues with the Band, direct them where they will do some good. To say "the Band fucking sucks" just shows your own ignorance. Save it. (/rant)

MGoAndy

October 27th, 2009 at 3:07 PM ^

I'm pretty sure that almost all of the frustration with the band is directed towards the higher ups. I have a deep respect for the member of the MMB who are working extremely hard and just following orders. I do, however, have a problem with whoever is picking the songs and planning the halftime shows. Like I said earlier, I miss the creativity I'm used to with the band. I like laughing at how clever they are while enjoying the sound. This year has been a big, big letdown.

BlueVoix

October 27th, 2009 at 4:21 PM ^

Yeah, as said above this here comment, this isn't directed at the individual members of the MMB. This is directed at the directors and the admins that are in charge of the performance of the band. I think this here blog is presuming members of the band cannot or would not directly approach the admins/directors and note the concerns of fans for fear of reprisal or just them being uptight dicks. So this area becomes an open forum for how bad things have become. I'll say this much: the drop off from two years ago, to last year, to this year, has been very, very noticeable. I used to really think that the MMB was one of the best in the country. Now, I'm not really sure if we're in the top half of the Big Ten.

majoturc

October 27th, 2009 at 4:37 PM ^

Agreed. Some of the criticisms of the band I've seen on this blog and its messages board over the last few months are disgusting. This blog would be much better served by sticking to what made it great, quality sports coverage. At this point, the continued shots at the band are not accomplishing anything aside from exposing ignorance and stirring up unnecessary e-fights. I come to this site for quality sports discussion, not to see a bunch of ignorant parties throw around their opinions on something they have little to no knowledge about, and I'm sick of seeing that happen with the band. I'm sure I'm not the only one.

BlueVoix

October 27th, 2009 at 4:48 PM ^

"I come to this site for quality sports discussion, not to see a bunch of ignorant parties throw around their opinions on something they have little to no knowledge about, and I'm sick of seeing that happen with the band. I'm sure I'm not the only one." The MGoBoard may not be the right place for you then. I believe ignorant parties throwing around opinions is in the definition.

Jim Harbaugh S…

October 27th, 2009 at 3:09 PM ^

this Charest character runs a 4.6 40 yard dash. Looks like your typical, run of the mill, 3 star pro-style QB. If this guy starts running for 70 yards, we got bigger problems then I thought. Hopefully this means that the Illini have completly thrown in the towel and are looking to get youngsters playing time in building for next year.

Elno Lewis

October 27th, 2009 at 3:57 PM ^

do the band members have to pay their own way to the bowl games? And besides, band members always get the hawt girls. IMO Wisconsin Bannded is the best. I like a band that gets banned for bannable behavior. Now those are some serious nerds there. In conclusion, potato salad.

BlueinLansing

October 27th, 2009 at 4:14 PM ^

just makes me mad. Anyone want to guess what it would have been if it was Michigan. My shot...... "Rodriguez led Michigan continues slide with last second loss to unimpressive Iowa."

ajscipione

October 27th, 2009 at 5:45 PM ^

fallen off in the Illinois football program this year. They really seem to be groping for straws. As the season has worn on, things have gotten worse for them. Rotating Charest in the game this Saturday is just another sign of how desperate they are getting. This a good sign for Michigan. Zook will get the hook (after next year)!